Leveraging Private Sector Innovation and MSME Participation in India’s Defence Industrial Ecosystem

Volume:20
Issue: 3
Focus

India’s defence ecosystem has undergone a significant transformation since the sector was opened for private participation in 2001. For decades, defence procurement and production was dominated by Defence Public Sector Undertakings (DPSUs), state-led research institutions, and Ordnance Factories, resulting in limited private sector participation, high import dependence, and comparatively weaker indigenous development. In response, the government introduced reforms such as ‘Make in India’, iDEX, defence corridors, Defence Procurement Procedures, and indigenous measures under ‘Atmanirbhar Bharat’ to expand the participation of private firms and micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) to promote selfreliance.

Traditionally, advanced defence capabilities in India have largely been developed through DRDO or acquired through technology transfer and procurement from technologically advanced countries. So defence innovation cannot be treated like innovation in a normal market. There is a fundamental connection between defence procurement and the ability to leverage innovation from MSMEs and the private sector. If India seeks to expand the role of private industry and MSMEs in defence innovation, there must also be a mechanism through which innovative technologies and products can progress from conception to testing, production, and eventual absorption into the defence ecosystem.

When a technological gap or requirement is clearly articulated and private industries, MSMEs are provided with an opportunity to develop a solution, a good procurement mechanism can provide the opportunities through which private firms are encouraged to invest in R&D, develop prototypes, undertake testing and ultimately scale successful technologies for defence use. It can also provide an important demand for private firms and MSMEs to invest in R&D, technology development, tooling, and manufacturing capacity. Where successful technologies or indigenous alternatives receive an opportunity for testing and production, the resulting demand can encourage further private sector investment and enable firms to scale from components and sub-systems to higher-value products and complete systems. It can further generate user feedback, contributing to subsequent technological improvement and innovation.

This article does not seek to examine defence procurement in its entirety, including all procurement of proven defence systems. It rather examines how the procurement framework can be leveraged to create more effective approaches for private firms and MSMEs to participate in defence innovation, including the development of new solutions and indigenisation of existing imported products, systems, sub-systems, and components.

The expansion of the role of private industry and MSMEs participation requires mechanisms to innovate, to win contracts, to produce, and to widen absorption. This involves addressing barriers in the procurement system, funding and integration. A well-designed procurement ecosystem can stimulate and leverage private investment in R&D, enable testing and support scale-up.

This article, therefore, examines the evolution of India’s defence industrial base and draws comparative analysis between India’s model and that of China, United States and Israel. It also recommends a shift from lowest-price procurement to best-value procurement and proposes a datadriven Vendor Performance Rating System integrated with Government e-Marketplace (GeM) and SRIJAN in order to reward performance, reliability and quality. In conclusion, it suggests India adopt a capabilitycentric approach to mobilise private sector innovation in defence.

Full Article