9th South Asia Conference - Culture as a Factor in Regional Cooperation in South Asia

Most states in South Asia are multi-cultural in character. In the post-colonial phase of their existence, they were confronted with the twin problems of state and nation building. While the former involved building institutions of governance the latter necessitated efforts to achieve unity in diversity. States seeking to construct a monolithic identity amalgamating diverse linguistic, religion and ethnic identities faced the challenge of integrating the minorities. In view of the overlapping cultural spaces cutting across state borders, such homogenization efforts led to spilling over of ethnic conflicts across states. The borders thus became new frontiers of such contested identities— national versus sub-national. It was natural, therefore, for discourses on interstate relations to be enmeshed in arguments in favour of, and against, pluri-cultural national identities. Recognition of plurality was often misconstrued as shedding of sovereignty to other states which housed same ethno-linguistic and cultural communities. While in many cases such geo-cultural continuity and commonality have led to inter-state tension and conflicts, there is distinct possibility of culture playing an integrative role and creating and propelling regional integration in South Asia or at least playing a positive role in contributing to bilateral relations.

As South Asian states are pushing for regional integration, culture has emerged as a force to connect, to build relations and heal the ruptures created by history and politics. As cultural actors challenge the territorial limits that nation-states impose on culture, they engender new possibilities of states caving in to their demands and using their borders as bridges rather than barriers. William Van Schendel in his path breaking work titled as The Bengal Borderland: Beyond State and Nation in South Asia identifies the beginnings of such a change when he argues that “territoriality is being re-scaled by states that should be seen as active partners in global restructuring and not as passive victims of deterritorialisation”. However, it may take a long time for such process to mature in the region as the nation states in South Asia continue to be apprehensive of cultural connectivity across states which is perceived to be ‘deterritorialising’ the process of construction of exclusive nation-states.

Nevertheless, there are several developments which signal a movement in that direction. The nation-states in South Asia in spite of their exclusive nation building projects, are succumbing to the process of globalisation and revolution in the information technology that has propelled emergence of the new media. Cultural contacts and social interactions no more require state sanctions and visas; rather the netizens have been able to dilute the exclusivity that they imbibed through their political socialisation and textbook education. Television channels, movies and visits by cultural troupes have contributed to the cultural connectivity even across ethno-cultural groups.

Even if culture has so far been used in South Asia sparingly and cautiously as a foreign policy tool, the use of culture as a connecting tool is quite noticeable in recent years. There are efforts today to jointly produce movies especially in the India Pakistan context; effort is also being made to make people to people contact part of bilateral as well as regional agenda.  Recently Tagore 150th birth centenary was celebrated by India, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka and Nazrul birth anniversary were jointly celebrated by India and Bangladesh. The old Buddhist tourism circuit is being revived to link up with Nepal, Sri Lanka, Bhutan and the wider world. Nepal, Bhutan, Bangladesh and India are taking steps to celebrate their common cultural heritages. There are many in Pakistan who are trying to revive, re-establish and reinvent their past socio-cultural connectivity with India. In the words of Yousef Lapid and Fredrich Kratochwil in their book The Return of Culture and identity in IR Theory write, “The forces disposing states towards particularism, however, sometimes confront others disposing them towards collectivism”. Therefore, it can be argued that “culture” is staging a comeback in inter-state and regional politics and it could help states to overcome years of mutual mistrust and push the process of regional integration forward.

The 9th South Asia Dialogue being hosted by IDSA in 2015 seeks to focus on how India and its South Asian neighbours perceive their common cultural heritage and to what extent inter-state cultural linkages will help the nation states establish a new of trust and understanding and help construct a new regional identity. Some of the questions this conference aims to look at are:

• Does culture play any role in international relations and does it matter as a tool of foreign policy?
• What role can culture play in the region in building trust and understanding?
• How do the South Asian countries look at the common historical and shared cultural experiences?
• How can cross-cultural ties be built across states?
• Can culture help in forging a regional identity and foster regional cooperation?

0930-1000hrs: Registration and Tea

1000-1030: Inauguration, 

Chair: Amb Jayant Prasad, Director General, IDSA

Keynote speaker: Dr Karan Singh, Member of Parliament, Rajya Sabha

1030-1045: Tea Break

1045-1300hrs - Session 1: Cultural Profile of South Asia and Foreign Policy

Chair: Amb Virendra Gupta

• Culture, Cultural Productions and South Asian Spaces -   Prof Partha S Ghosh, ICSSR Fellow, IDSA
• India-Nepal Relations: Has Cultural commonality Helped? - Dr Sudhindra Sharma, IDA, Kathmandu
• Culture as a Foreign Policy Tool: India’s Experience in South Asia - Dr Smruti S Pattanaik, IDSA
• Culture as a Foreign Policy Tool: Pakistani Perspective - Dr Rubina Saigol, Lahore, Pakistan

1300-1400hrs: Lunch

1400-1730hrs - Session 2: Culture as a Soft Power: Can it further Regional Cooperation?

Chair: Amb Suresh Goel, former DG, Indian Council of Cultural Relations

• Can the Cultural Commons be Harnessed to further Regional Cooperation? - HE Sayed Mossadeq Khalili, Deputy Minister of Culture, Afghanistan
• Using Cultural Commons in Regional cooperation: Bhutanese Perspective - Mr. Kunzang Delek, National Archives and Library, Bhutan
• Can Heritage further Regional Cooperation in South Asia? Sri Lanka’s Experience - Dr Sarala Fernando, Sri Lanka
• Role of Media in Promoting Soft Power in South Asia - Shyam Tekwani, Asia Pacific Centre for Security Studies, Hawaii
• Culture and Regional Cooperation in South Asia: Bangladesh’s Experience - Lt Gen. M Akbar Fazle, Bangladesh
• Culture and Regional Cooperation: Pakistani Perspective - Raza Rumi, Columnist and Writer, Scholar in Residence at Ithaca College

 Day II, November 27, 2015

0930-1000 hrs Tea and Registration

1000-1230 hrs - Session 3: Culture, Identity and Politics and its Impact on Bilateral Relations 

Chair: Amb P. Stobdan, Senior Fellow, IDSA

• Distant Neighbours: Could People and Culture Bridge Relations between Afghanistan and Pakistan - Mr. Aref Dostyar, Afghanistan
• Bhutan-India Relations: Does culture matter? - Mr. Sangay Chophel, Centre for Bhutanese Studies
• The Dilemmas of Relatedness: India and Sri Lanka - Dr Pradeep Jeganathan, Sri Lanka
• Folklore and Evolution of National Identity in the Maldives - Dr. Abdul Rasheed Ali, Dean, Maldives National University
• Cultural Symbols as Resistance and the Making of the Bengali Identity - Prof Sonia Nishat Amin, Dhaka University

1230-1345 hrs: Group photo & Lunch

1345-1600hrs - Session 4: Culture, Identity and Politics and its Impact on Bilateral Relations (continued)

Chair: Ms. Ajeet Cour, President, Foundation of SAARC Writers and Literature

• Civilisational and Cultural linkages in South Asia: Continuities and discontinuities - Prof S.D.Muni, Distinguished Fellow, IDSA
• New Constitution and Identity Politics in Nepal - Prof Krishna Hachhethu, Tribhuban University, Kathmandu
• Ethnic Diversity and Cultural Hegemony in Bangladesh: Imperatives for More Inclusive National and Regional Identities - Prof Prashanta Tripura, Department of Economics and Social Sciences, BRAC University, Bangladesh
• Does Religion Triumph Culture in Identity Formation? The Arabisation of Maldives and its Regional Implications - Dr. Azra Naseem, University of Dublin, Ireland
• Culture, Identity and Politics: Pakistan’s Experience - Dr Yaqoob Bangash, Pakistan

1600-1730 hours- Session 5: Roundtable discussion on Way Forward

Chair: Prof Muchkund Dubey

Speakers

• Ms. Ajeet Cour
• Amb Suresh Goel
• Dr Ashok K Behuria
• H.E. Sayed Mossadeq Khalili, Deputy Minister of Culture, Afghanistan
• Dr. Yaqoob Bangash, Pakistan
• Dr. Pradeep Jeganathan, Sri Lanka
• Dr. Sudhindra Sharma, Nepal
• Mr. Kunzang Delek, Bhutan
• Prof. Sonia Nishat Amin, Bangladesh
• Dr. Abdul Rasheed Ali, Maldives

1730-1735: Vote of Thanks by Dr Smruti Pattanaik, Research Fellow, IDSA and Coordinator of the Conference