BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20230101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240116T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240116T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T103736
CREATED:20240514T232052Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240514T232052Z
UID:81249-1705383000-1705383000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report on the Visit of Delegation from the Polish Centre for Eastern Studies (OSW)
DESCRIPTION:The Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised an interaction with the delegation from the Polish Centre for Eastern Studies (OSW) on 16 January 2024. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, chaired the session. \nExecutive Summary\nInternational developments in the last couple of years\, mainly the Russia-Ukraine war and the recent Israel-Hamas conflict have raised concerns over global peace and security. These issues have highlighted the inability of international organisations to cooperate on matters of growing relevance in the post-pandemic era. Two factors which are crucial to understanding these developments are – the relationship between the former superpowers and China’s growing influence. The interaction between the delegation from OSW and scholars from MP-IDSA facilitated a fruitful exchange of Indian and Polish views on such matters of importance\, providing valuable insights for both parties. \nDetailed Report\nIn the opening remarks\, the Chair\, Amb. Sujan Chinoy began by briefly addressing India’s perspective on the unfolding geopolitics around the globe\, identifying various divisions\, which for instance\, have led to weaponisation of trade and technology. The nature of power contestation in recent times and the inability of the United Nations (UN) to deliver on issues of development\, peace\, and security was also stressed upon. Further\, he highlighted the difficulties in international institutions like the World Bank\, the International Monetary Fund (IMF)\, and the World Trade Organization (WTO) working collectively to develop consensus on issues of greater significance in post-pandemic times. \nAmb. Chinoy also stated that the G20\, under the Indian Presidency in 2023\, was a “dream team”. He lauded the unanimous adoption of the G20 New Delhi Leaders’ Declaration. The grouping successfully focused on developmental\, financial\, and economic issues as it ought to\, rather than being hindered by political matters\, which do not fall in its ambit. It is also more inclusive in nature than the G7 as it comprises the members of the Quad\, BRICS\, IPSA and other such groupings. \nRegarding the Russia-Ukraine War\, the Chair referred to India’s special relations with Russia while also expressing India’s distress vis-à-vis the loss of lives since the start of the war. India has provided humanitarian assistance to the people of Ukraine and has engaged with both sides. Putting forth his viewpoint\, the Chair mentioned that this war is likely to last a while. \nConcerning recent developments in the Israel-Hamas conflict\, Amb. Chinoy stressed on India’s good relations with both Israel and Palestine and that it continues to send humanitarian aid to the Palestinians\, including through the United Nations Relief and Work Agency (UNRWA). Terrorism remains one of the key concerns for India\, as the country has been on its receiving end for a long time. The Chair also expressed India’s concern over the humanitarian catastrophe unfolding in the region\, which is unlikely to end soon. He further added that Hamas has got deep roots in the region and that there is a likelihood that the Houthis\, Hezbollah\, or other nation-states\, might get directly or indirectly embroiled in the conflict. \nWith growth and prosperity spreading to wider regions of Southeast Asia\, South Asia and the littoral countries in the Indian Ocean\, particularly the East Coast of Africa\, Amb. Chinoy indicated that the notion of Indo-Pacific has replaced the Asia-Pacific. The former is a much clearer reflection of today’s changing balance of power. It is more inclusive\, democratic\, and in tune with the growing aspirations of a much wider arc of geographical space. Thus\, the Indo-Pacific harbours the potential for a greater participatory and inclusive architecture. \nReflecting on the US-China tussle\, Amb. Chinoy highlighted that the dialogue has resumed for the sake of stability\, but relations will continue to manifest various tensions\, as some fundamental discrepancies and divergences may arise. He believes that the Chinese are mindful of the potential derailment of their own long-term plans\, were they to take any hasty decisions with regard to Taiwan or continue to exhibit the same level of unilateralism\, militarization and aggressive behaviour. \nHighlighting the growing engagement and a degree of mutual interdependence between Russia and China\, the Chair averred that the Russian Federation is not very happy to play the role of an underdog all the time\, to a country which has learnt virtually everything from the Russians in the past. He mentioned the difference in how Russia and China challenge the existing international order\, where China influences the world order more directly. China is trying to curate parallel orders – for example\, through the expansion of BRICS\, New Development Bank of BRICS\, or their own sovereign lending and banking institutions. \nWojciech Konończuk\, Director of OSW\, contributed to the discussion by highlighting Poland’s priorities in the European context. He mentioned that Poland’s viewpoint is different from India’s. This is mainly due to the difference in their geographical locations\, leading to a difference in how both countries percieve recent international developments. It is essential for Poland to focus on the evolution of Russia-China relations. He emphasised that the Poles view the Russian invasion against Ukraine as a war with far reaching global consequences and called it an existential issue for Poland. He noted that the outcome of this war will have a direct impact on the order in the European continent as Russian ambitions go far beyond Ukraine. It is aimed at recovering parts of the former Soviet Union territory and for that it wants to destroy the international order which created Eastern Europe from the collapse of the Soviet Union. Mr. Konończuk agreed that this war will not end soon\, even though the initial Russian plan was to end the war in a couple of weeks. \nMarek Menkiszak\, Head of Russian Department at OSW\, noted that Russian policies have a deep interlink between Russia’s internal system and its foreign security policy\, which are focused on regime survival. The Russian regime\, which went from half-democratic to the current neo-totalitarian\, believes that the increase of their sphere of influence in the post-Soviet region is a matter of regime survival. According to Mr. Menkiszak\, Russia believes that the West – led by the US – is an existential threat to the regime. Thus\, the former is trying to diminish the latter to develop a post-western world order\, and is trying to change the status quo using its military capabilities. In achieving this goal\, Russia sees China as a necessary ally and aims to avoid any conflict with China. Moscow also seems to believe that making it an indispensable partner to Beijing will create a situation wherein they will have strategic autonomy vis-à-vis Beijing; while enjoying the gains from US-China conflict. \nJakub Jakóbowski\, Deputy Director at OSW\, shared his insights on how the Chinese view their relationship with Russia\, since its full-scale invasion of Ukraine. According to him\, the Chinese believe that Russians can achieve their goals\, but at a much higher cost. This will lead to a diminished Russia in Russia-China relations and would establish a precedent to undermine the US based security system by force. In this\, Russia is ready to play second to China as it sees China as the lone partner in its fight against the West. He also highlighted that one must focus on China’s original plan of action and not get carried away by the opinion it voices on the world stage. He ended by putting forth the question of – how to engage with India in dialogue and what kind of strategic choices might India make in the Indo-Pacific and European theatre. \nResponding to some points raised by the speakers\, Amb. Chinoy highlighted that regime survival is not a characteristic of authoritarian states alone but that of democracies too. Any government can be called a regime. However\, in this discourse some identify regimes with what they think are more authoritarian states. He also mentioned that global orders cannot be created nor dismantled easily. It is not possible to forge a post-World War II world order\, which will be very different from what we have today. A new world order by Russia might not be possible without the destruction of all. \nIndia does not challenge the international order that has been in place since World War II. It is more concerned with the lack of reforms. According to Amb. Chinoy\, China is also not seeking the reversal of this order altogether\, as it has been a major beneficiary of the same. In his view\, Russians are in a reactive mode\, whereas the Chinese are in a proactive mode in terms of their actions and policies in international relations. He also urged that we must not forgo the possibility of a reset of US-Russia relations\, as there are greater structural similarities in US-Russia relations than Russia-China. In fact\, the chances of a post-Putin Russia turning democratic are statistically far greater than that of China\, owing to the Chinese Confucius thinking and the communist party. \nWith regard to India-China\, Amb. Chinoy mentioned that India has dealt with military threats to its sovereignty and territorial integrity on its own. It is also less likely to directly join in any conflicts in the Taiwan Strait or the South China Sea in the near future. \nWitold Rodkiewicz\, Senior Fellow at OSW\, pointed out that Russian elites have a completely different view of China. According to him\, the Russians admire China. They believe that China managed to do something that Russia failed at. Earlier we have seen Russia turn towards the west\, when it befriended the US and now it is turning towards the east\, befriending China. Russia cannot afford to have problems with its crucial ally\, like it did during the cold war times\, thereby deciding to make itself indispensable to China. In all of this\, we need to realise that in current times\, Russia ties Europe with the US or the western theatre. \nQ&A\nThe interaction was followed by a Q&A session\, in which questions regarding Russia-China relations\, India-Russia relations\, polarisation of Europe\, Russian and Chinese role in Central Asia\, and the Polish Vs European debate on China\, were posed. \nThe Polish delegation members answered different questions\, based on their expertise. Theypointed out that the strategic interests of Russia and China are much bigger than any tensions between them. Initially the Russians tried to oppose the BRI but when they couldn’t anymore\, they joined it. The Russia-China partnership is based on the need of the hour and the European mindset sees this partnership as immune to any third-party intrusions. \nCentral Asia is a working condominium\, where Russia has accepted the growing economic influence of China. They also emphasised on Russia’s three strategic goals in Europe – to gain strategic control over the post-Soviet area\, to create a security buffer zone in Central Europe\, and to drastically reduce US influence in Europe. \nThe delegation members alsomentioned that Poland does not have an independent Indo-Pacific strategy. It actively contributes to European efforts in the region and wants to do as much as possible. The delegation emphasised on the need for India and Europe\, especially Poland\, to engage more actively\, given the Indo-Pacific theatre sees a convergence of interests of all the three parties.  \nReport has been prepared by Ms. Anusua Ganguly\, Intern\, Europe and Eurasia Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-on-the-visit-of-delegation-from-the-polish-centre-for-eastern-studies-osw-2
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240119T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240119T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T103736
CREATED:20240514T232233Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240514T232233Z
UID:81251-1705642200-1705642200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Interaction with Dr. Andreas Østhagen\, from Fridtjof Nansen Institute (FNI)\, Oslo\, Norway
DESCRIPTION:MP-IDSA organised an interaction with Dr. Andreas Østhagen\, Senior Researcher\, Arctic\, Ocean and Russia programme from Fridtjof Nansen Institute (FNI)\, Oslo\, Norway on Friday\, 19 January 2024. The theme of discussion was ‘Emerging Geopolitics in the Arctic’. The Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy chaired the Session. \nExecutive Summary\nThe session covered issues on the geopolitics of the Arctic\, highlighting Norway’s role. The Speaker explored various aspects\, including resources\, routes\, and climate change\, and discussed emerging players. Emphasis was placed on governance through the Law of the Sea and the Arctic Council\, with a mention of India’s role in the region. \nDetailed Report\nIn his opening remarks\, Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy welcomed Dr. Andreas Østhagen and Ms. Filippa Braarud\, Second Secretary from the Royal Norwegian Embassy\, New Delhi. Amb. Chinoy highlighted that India’s connection with the Arctic region dates back to 1920 with the signing of the Spitsbergen Treaty. He emphasised that India remains concerned regarding the geopolitical developments in the Arctic that have significantly impacted existing cooperation between states. He further mentioned that though the western states have terminated the existing cooperation with Russia\, it is important to note that Russia accounts for more than 50 percent of the coastal extent in the region. He mentioned that despite strong western pressures India maintains strong bilateral relations with Russia. He further highlighted that India’s interest in the Arctic remains primarily scientific\, unlike China that has larger economic and geostrategic objectives in the region. Ambassador Chinoy pointed out that India’s interests in the Arctic are in tandem with its partners and acknowledged Norway’s role in strengthening India’s scientific research in the Arctic. He mentioned that the Arctic offers multiple opportunities in the near future\, for both India and Norway to deepen their bilateral cooperation in the region.  \nDr. Østhagen highlighted that the primary purpose of his visit is to establish connections for future collaboration and gain a deeper understanding of India’s viewpoints and interests in the Arctic. He acknowledged India’s growing role in the region and on the global stage as a significant power. Examining regional complexities and nuances\, he pointed out that the Arctic extends beyond commonly considered factors like climate change\, shipping routes\, resources\, and territory. He mentioned that though climate change and scientific research remain major drivers of states’ engagements in the region\, there are several common myths about the Arctic that need to be noted. Dr. Østhagen mentioned that there are no territorial issues between states in the Arctic and the only issues existing are with regard to extended maritime claims of states in the region. He pointed out that the resources estimates in the Arctic are overexaggerated and extraction of hydrocarbons and other form of minerals from the region is difficult and expensive. Similarly\, he mentioned that despite Russia’s emphasis on the development of the Northern Sea Route (NSR) as a future shipping route\, there will remain several navigational challenges. \nIn the second part of his presentation Dr. Østhagen highlighted China’s increasing role in the Arctic\, and asserted that this remains a cause of concerns for all seven Arctic states. He highlighted that these concerns are further elevated by the Russia-China emerging partnership. He further stressed that Russia’s dependency on China is significantly increasing\, that further adds to western countries concerns. He talked about the US-Canada maritime disputes in the region and highlighted the recent US unilateral action of claiming extended continental shelf claims in the Bering Sea and central Arctic Ocean. Dr. Østhagen mentioned that there are no maritime issues between the US and Russia in the Arctic. He highlighted that the maritime borders between both these states remain demarcated by the 1990 US-Soviet Agreement. \nIn the final part of his presentation\, Dr. Østhagen gave an overview of the Arctic Council. He mentioned that though the Arctic Council is not the ‘only’ existing mechanism for Arctic governance\, Norway’s core concern under its chairship is to keep the Arctic Council alive and going. He highlighted Russia’s nuclear capabilities in the North and mentioned that Russia is undertaking large scale military exercises in the region. Dr. Østhagen emphasised that with the Russia-China emerging threat perception in the Bering Sea\, US is taking advanced measures to protect its interests in the region. \nAmb. Sujan Chinoy acknowledged China’s emerging geo-economic and geo-strategic interest in the Arctic. He emphasised that as India’s interests in the Polar Regions increase\, there is a serious need to focus on developing India’s independent infrastructure capabilities in these regions. \nDr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\, Senior Fellow and Coordinator\, Non- Traditional Security Centre underscored the need to look beyond Arctic politics and recognise the importance of scientific exploration. He asked a question about the future role that Norway intends to play in the Arctic Council under its chairship. \nQuestions and Comments\nMr. Bipandeep Sharma\, Research Analyst enquired about the implications of the United States unilateral action for making extended continental claims in the Arctic. He questioned the validity of these claims and highlighted that US despite not ratifying UNCLOS has made these claims\, that could have counter responses from Russia. He also asked a question regarding Norway’s parliamentary decision on opening up of the deep seabed mining in the Arctic and its implications from environmental perspectives. \nDr. Rajorshi Roy\, Associate Fellow\, enquired about the Arctic States response to transboundary resource management.  \nCommandant M. Srivastav\, Research Fellow\, discussed the prospects of opening up of the Central Passage in the Arctic. He raised questions regarding the rationale behind creating new shipping routes and its impact on climate change. Additionally\, he inquired about Norway’s view on China’s expanding interest\, particularly observed in its second Belt and Road Forum in 2019. He further asked about China’s emerging collaboration with Russia on the North Sea Route (NSR) within China’s Silk Road initiative. \nDr. Swasti Rao\, Associate Fellow\, inquired about Norway’s approach to addressing tensions in the Arctic while holding the Arctic Chair. She sought insights into Norway’s perception\, highlighting the need to sustain cooperation with Russia for the Council’s success\, alongside considerations of the region’s securitisation. \nDr. Jason Wahlang\, Research Analyst\, raised inquiries regarding the geopolitical complexities affecting countries like Kazakhstan\, especially in their attempts to diversify trade routes. \nMs. Filippa Braarud\, Second Secretary\, Royal Norwegian Embassy\, New Delhi\, stressed the importance of maintaining Arctic stability. She highlighted the extensive scientific cooperation with India\, particularly focusing on the research operations in the Arctic. Ms. Braarud also mentioned the common challenges with regard to the coastal management of Norway and India. Lastly\, she emphasised the significance of policy formulation through scientific cooperation in the region. \nDr. Østhagenresponded to the comments andquestions and stated that the Arctic Council will endure amid tensions. He highlighted Russia’s shift toward China due to diversification of Arctic interests. He highlighted that Norway is adopting a pragmatic approach in balancing relations with Russia and NATO. He mentioned that the recent US claim on the extended continental shelf raises concerns. He further elaborated that the collective Western presence driven by the US and UK\, is expected to increase military activity in the Arctic in response to Russia’s remilitarisation. He concluded by stating that the Arctic experiences short-term tensions but holds long-term strategic investment potential. \nThe report has been prepared by Ms. Simran Rathore\, Research Intern\, Non-Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/interaction-with-dr-andreas-osthagen-from-fridtjof-nansen-institute-fni-oslo-norway-2
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR