BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20140101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211208T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211208T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132606Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T131009Z
UID:63041-1638941400-1638941400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Talk by Professor Dr. Bharat H. Desai on “Taking International Law Seriously"
DESCRIPTION:Report \nTalk by Prof. Dr. Bharat Desai on “Taking  International Law Seriously” \n08 December  2021 \nEvent Report \n  The  Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised  a talk on “Taking International Law Seriously” by Prof. Dr. Bharat H. Desai\, Professor  of International Law\, Jawaharlal Nehru Chair in International Environmental  Law\, Chairman\, Centre for International Legal Studies\, School of International  Studies\, Jawaharlal Nehru University\, on  08 December 2021\, at 11am in Seminar Hall I. Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi\,  AVSM\, VSM\, (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA\, chaired the session. The  talk was attended by all scholars at MP-IDSA. \nExecutive  Summary \nThe talk drew attention to the negligence of  International Law by countries and the challenges in ensuring that it is taken  seriously by all players in the international arena. Prof. Desai reflected on  the general apathy towards International Law from all spheres – academic\,  scholarly as well as the government. Stating that the basis of conduct for  International Relations is International Law\, he argued that the concept can be  traced to ancient Indian history and indigenous texts. The speaker shed light  on the gradual shift seen in India’s growing emphasis on international law in  its bilateral and multilateral engagement. Underscoring the consequences of  neglecting International Law in dealing with international issues; Prof. Desai  emphasised on the diversity and applicability of International Law on a variety  of issues. He asserted that scholarship and domain knowledge would add  legitimacy and prestige to government officials representing India on  international forums \nDetailed  Report \n  The  chair\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA\,  began the session by welcoming the speaker and introduced the topic to the  attendees. He drew attention to the importance and relevance of International  Law in providing a stable just political order. Referring to the topical issue  on border tensions between Russia and Ukraine\, he highlighted the concerns  surrounding violation of international norms. The chair underlined that  nation-states cannot face challenges with outdated structures\, a message given  by Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his address at the United Nations. Maj.  Gen. (Dr.) Bakshi reflected on the effectiveness of International Law owing to  the fact that its validity depends on the will of the State. He shed light on  countries in the international community transitioning from rule takers to rule  shapers\, including India. The chair invited the speaker to further discuss  these issues and share insights on the theme. \n  The  speaker\, Prof. Dr. Bharat Desai\, began his talk by expressing his gratitude for  the opportunity to present at MP-IDSA. Remarking on the historical trajectory  of International Law architecture; he underscored the negligence of  International Law and the challenges faced in ensuring it is taken seriously.  Presenting an overview of the origins of the School of International Studies at  Jawaharlal Nehru University; he shared personal anecdotes of his efforts to  introduce International Law as a field of study in academic syllabus. Stating  the difficult working conditions to ensure recognition of International Law as  a serious field of study; he reflected on the general apathy towards  International Law from all spheres – academic\, scholarly as well as government.  \n  Prof.  Desai emphasised that the basis of conduct for International Relations is  International Law\, which is often taken for granted and neglected by nation-states.  Mentioning that the modern understanding of International Law is a product of  European civilization; he stated the concept itself is rooted in ancient Indian  history. He drew an outline of the rudimentary forms of International Law and  territorial sovereignty as was seen in ancient Indian states like the Ganarajyas. He drew parallels between  ancient norms like “a Shanthidoot (enemy’s envoy) cannot be punished” prevalent in Mahabharatha and Ramayana texts and; the current practices established in the Geneva Convention. He  underscored that the ‘Law of Dharma’  is similar to ‘international norms and laws’ and pre-dates to texts like the Arthashastra and Nitishastra. He remarked that these indigenous scriptures of India  also make references to the treatment of ‘Prisoners of War’.  \n  The  speaker explained the trajectory of India’s participation in the formation of  International Laws even during the colonial times. He stated that the Maharaja  of Bikaner had signed the Treaty of Versailles on behalf of India\, which implies  the value Britishers attached to their colonies. The speaker opined that  British rulers did not obliterate the identities of their colonies and instead  ensured their fair representation by encouraging them to sign international  treaties. Prof. Desai underscored that International Law refers to the law  governing official relations. He remarked on the initial efforts in developing  a law on the seas which eventually took the form of ‘United Nations Convention  on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS)’. The speaker shed light on the provisions in  the Indian Constitution which accord importance to International Law and  empower the Indian parliament to give effect to international agreements. \n  Giving  examples of some countries\, Prof. Desai remarked on the dichotomy of statements  by Heads of State arguing for adherence to International Law and their actions  which often violate established international norms. The speaker also reflected  on the changing dimension of use of force in the world. Opining that countries  often use International Law as a ‘trump card’; he stated that International Law  as a practice has been applied on various international issues. He explained  the same by providing examples of Operation Neptune Spear\, treaties like  International Solar Alliance\, security issues like border cross-firing and  surgical strikes; and post-conflict mechanisms as in the case of Taliban’s  takeover of Afghanistan. \n  Reflecting  on the rapidly changing world\, the speaker stressed that India needs to be  equipped effectively to understand and grasp the simmering ideas of  International Law. He stated that it is essential for India to prioritise  International Law in order to solidify her right to self-defense\, especially in  issues pertaining to the belligerent occupation of Jammu and Kashmir by  Pakistan. Remarking on the idea of gaining consensus for permanent membership  in the United Nations Security Council (UNSC)\, Prof. Desai opined that India  must instead focus on earning the right. This could be accomplished by building  efficient knowledge centres and ensuring that government officials representing  India are aided by a strong team of expert scholars.  \n  Stating  the example of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s speech at the recent ASEAN Summit  which underlined the importance of International Law; the speaker shed light on  the gradual shift seen in India’s growing emphasis on international law in its  bilateral and multilateral engagement. Prof. Desai underlined and strongly  stressed on the importance of actively pursuing and asserting International Law  as a foundation of diplomacy. He stated that countries must gain clarity on the  consequences of neglecting International Law in dealing with international  issues. Sharing some of his own published works\, the speaker remarked on the  diversity and applicability of International Law on a variety of issues. He  opined that International Law plays a vital role in the hard core issues of  national security and could be tool for policy implementation. The speaker  concluded by reiterating the importance of mutual cooperation and dialogue on  International Law for international peace and security.  \n  The  talk was followed by a lively Q/A session which brought out inputs on the  elections in Libya and role of International Criminal Court (ICC); issue of  refugees in India; underlying causes for earlier neglect of International Law  by the Government in India and the role of Supreme Court in invoking  international law conventions during its judgements on important issues. During  his response\, the speaker highlighted the dominance of African-related  incidents and undergoing investigations in the ICC; the responsible and  humanitarian role played by India in accommodating refugees from neighbor  states like Myanmar despite not ratifying the 1951 Refugee Convention; and the  dire need for Indian leaders to engage with scholars while dealing with  international issues. Prof. Desai underscored that efficient scholarship and  domain knowledge would add legitimacy and prestige to officials representing  India on international forums. The session concluded with the Chair  acknowledging and thanking the Speaker for his passionate and insightful  presentation. \nReport prepared by Ms. Sindhu Dinesh\, Research  Analyst\, ALACUN Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/talk-by-professor-dr-bharat-h-desai-on-taking-international-law-seriously
CATEGORIES:LECTURES,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211206T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211206T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132706Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130548Z
UID:63042-1638768600-1638768600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar on "Prospects of Maritime Cooperation between India and Russia in the Indian Ocean Region\, Arctic and Russian Far East”
DESCRIPTION:Monday Morning- Prospects of Maritime Cooperation  between India and Russia in the Indian Ocean Region\, Arctic and Russian Far  East \nCapt. Anurag Bisen (Indian Navy)\, Member Non-Traditional  Security Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses\, spoke on the “Prospects of Maritime Cooperation  between India and Russia in the Indian Ocean Region\, Arctic and Russian Far  East” at the Monday Morning Webinar held on 6th December\, 2021.  The webinar was chaired  by Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\, Centre Coordinator\, Non-Traditional Security Centre. Deputy Director General\, and scholars  of the institute participated in the webinar. \nExecutive Summary \n  India and Russia maintain a longstanding and time tested  partnership since the last 50 years. This bilateral partnership has increased  manifold and has been elevated to a “Special and Privileged Strategic  Partnership”. The Indian Ocean Region\, the Arctic and the Russian Far East  bring new opportunities for both the countries to further their bilateral  relationship. Deeper engagements between India and Russia in these regions  through trade\, investments\, connectivity\, energy projects and enhanced  cooperation over military\, scientific and strategic domains have immense  potential. \nDetailed Report \nDr. Uttam K.  Sinha\, the Chair introduced the audience to the  topic and highlighted the significance of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s  visit to India. In his opening remarks\, he mentioned that while there is mutual  respect and reciprocity between India and Russia\, there also is India’s growing  partnership with the United States. It presents an interesting dynamic\, he  observed.  \n  Capt. Bisen provided the backdrop of India-Russia relations  mentioning that the two countries have a time-tested and steady relationship  which since 2010 was elevated to “Special and Privileged Strategic Partnership”.  Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Russian President Vladimir Putin have  met 19 times since 2014\, which is the highest for any foreign leader PM Modi  has ever met. Defence\, energy\, nuclear\, space\, science and technology remains  to be the key drivers of the strategic partnership. 86 per cent of the  equipment\, weapon system and platforms in Indian military services is of  Russian origin. Capt. Bisen mentioned that trade remains a weak link between  the two countries where the targets by 2025 have been revised to USD 50 billion  for investment and USD 30 billion for trade. He mentioned that Foreign Direct  Investment (FDI) from Russia in the last 21 years account for just 0.24% of  equity FDI in the country. Similarly\, overseas direct investments (ODI) from  India account for just 3% over the same period. Capt. Bisen\, underlined that  there is unrealized potential in terms of trade and investments between the two  countries.  \n  The speaker highlighted the divergences between the two over  Russia’s growing alignments with China and India’s deepening ties with the US  and observed the need for identifying areas of convergences and prioritizing  them. There is\, therefore\, is a need to identify areas of cooperation that can  take the relationship forward. \n  Focusing on the Indian Ocean Region (IOR)\, Capt. Bisen explained  the military bases and the presence of foreign navies such as France\, Germany\,  Italy\, Spain\, Japan and the United States in the IOR via permanent bases.  Russia\, he commented\, is the only major power without a permanent base in IOR.  Supporting Russia’s recent inclusion as a dialogue partner in Indian Ocean Rim  Association (IORA) would strategically bolster relations.                \n  Commenting on Russia’s Indian Ocean strategy\, the speaker  commented that the 2015 Maritime Doctrine of the Russian Federation emphasises building  relations with India as the most important goal in the IOR. The updated  Russia’s National Security Strategy in 2021\, also lists India and China as key  priorities for Russia’s foreign policy in the region. Russia’s security  presence in IOR is gradually increasing and it is emerging as an active player  in anti-piracy operations. Russia is also planning on setting up a naval  facility in Sudan. \n  The presentation highlighted the importance of reciprocal  logistics agreements with the friendly nations in the region. India has signed  Reciprocal Military Logistic Agreement with all the Quad countries and with  France\, Singapore and South Korea. It is in the process of signing such an  agreement with UK and Vietnam and such an agreement is also expected to be  signed with Russia. The speaker pointed to the importance of the White Shipping  Information Sharing (WSIS) agreement and mentioned that India and Russia do not  have any WSIS agreement. Despite Russia being India’s primary source in the  maritime domain\, the operational interaction between the two navies is  comparatively low which has led to Russia seeking partners elsewhere in the  region. \n  The second part of the presentation focused on the  developments in the Russian Arctic. The speaker mentioned that “What Arctic is to  Russia\, the Indian Ocean is to India”. The Arctic has become the most important  arena of foreign\, military and economic policies since president Putin’s coming  to power. Russian Arctic accounts for 15 % of Russian GDP\, 20% of exports  including 80% of its gas and 17 % of its oil. He mentioned that the Russian  Arctic has the potential of addressing India’s energy security needs. He also pointed  out that due to US-led sanctions\, Russia has been significantly restricted in  its ability to access the capital and technology to develop its northern  territories. China has taken great advantage and has made huge investments in  the region. \n  Strategic minerals and rare earth materials in the Russian  Arctic were the other areas highlighted by the speaker.  The Russian Arctic holds vast amount of  strategic materials that can easily mitigate India’s critical deficiencies in  rare earth and strategic materials. Commenting on the prospects of the Northern  Sea Route (NSR)\, the speaker asserted that the NSR has the potential of cutting  the maritime distance by 4000 km from Shanghai to Rotterdam as compared to Suez  and Malacca routes. He further mentioned that India supports President Putin’s  vision of developing NSR for international trade and commerce. \n  The third and final part of the presentation focused on  Russian Far East (RFE). He mentioned that the RFE is also rich in natural  resources that accounts for producing 98% Russian diamonds\, 90% Borax materials\,  50% gold\, 14% of Tungsten\, and 40% of fish and seafood. There are plans to  attract 2 million people to the region in the next 15 years. India’s USD1  billion line of credit for developing the Russian Far East\, is the first time  that India has ever given to a particular region of the country. Similarly\, PM  Modi has announced India’s Act Far East Policy\, while speaking at Eurasian  Economic Forum in Vladivostok in 2019.  \n  \nCapt. Anurag Bisen’s policy recommendations were as follows: \n\nIndia needs to support Russia       in the Arctic on NSR and seek greater engagement with Russia in the sustainable       extraction of hydrocarbons and other mineral resources available in the       region.\nIndia and Russia could set up a       special Joint Working Group specifically for cooperation in the Arctic and       Russian Far East.\nIndia could seek collaboration       with Russia for the accelerated acquisition of Polar Research Vessel.\nScientific cooperation between       Arctic and Antarctic Research Institute of Russia and National Centre for       Polar and Ocean Research\, Goa could be further enhanced through scientific       and research MoU’s.\nIndia and Russia could consider       signing a manpower pact for the supply of skilled workforce to the Arctic       and RFE region.\nIndia and Russia could collaborate       to set up training of seafarers for polar voyages and India could supply       Indian seafarers for Arctic shipping.\nThe option of extending the       North South Transport Corridor to the Arctic through Russia’s Unified       Deep-water System to provide a multimodal transport corridor could be       further explored.\nIndia needs to facilitate       Russia’s access to the IOR to further deepen its naval engagements.\nBoth the navies could consider       institutionalized interactions between the Indian Navy’s Eastern Fleet at       Visakhapatnam and the Russian Navy’s Pacific Fleet at Vladivostok. \nMoU for Naval to Naval       Cooperation between the Indian and Russian Navy needs to be concluded at       the earliest.\n\nDr. Sinha invited the panelists  for their comments and questions. \nCmde. Abhay Singh mentioned that the critical aspect of India-Russia  bilateral relationship is that it is fundamentally driven and governed by the  governments themselves. There is a very limited ground level compatible  ecosystem to further develop the mutual partnership. He also mentioned that  unlike China\, both the countries have different economic systems where maximum  investments come from the public sector rather than private enterprises.  \nDeputy Director  General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr) Bipin Bakshi AVSM\, VSM (Retd.)\, asked the speaker to  comment on the Russian perspective on various issues discussed in his  presentation. He specifically asked the speaker regarding the Russian  perspective on India’s leaning towards the West by highlighting India’s shift  from AN 12 and IL 76 to C 130 and C17 transport aircrafts. DDG also mentioned  that with India’s arms procurement diversification\, the entire airborne system  will significantly change from Russian to Western systems. He also highlighted  the AUKUS deal and commented on growing Russia-Pakistan and Russia-China  relations and asked the speaker to comment on those. \nCol. (Dr) Divakaran Padma Kumar Pillay (Retd.) in his remarks highlighted  Russia’s support to India in 1971 Bangladesh war when the whole Western world  was against India. He highlighted that Russians not only trailed USS Enterprise  in the Bay of Bengal but they also deployed 44 Motorised divisions against  China at the Sino-China border to stop any Chinese involvement in the war. \nDr. Nihar K Nayak commented on the Himalayas (also known as the third  pole) by comparing it with the Arctic. Dr. Nayak made an important point by  saying that both the Arctic and the Himalayas as the major source of  livelihood\, economy and human security are dramatically impacted by climate  change. He called for undertaking a joint study to find the scientific  interlinkages between the two regions.  \nMr. Bipandeep Sharma asked the speaker regarding the Chinese developments  of manned and unmanned underwater capabilities in the Arctic and then asked the  speaker to comment on whether India is developing such capabilities in the  Arctic.  \n  Capt. Anurag Bisen gave  extensive insightful remarks to all the comments and questions asked by the  panelists and the participants.  \n  The Monday morning meeting  ended with a valid observation from Dr. Sinha\, the chair\, that India must  diversify its strategic relationship\, but should not forget Russia in the whole  matrix of diversifying its interests.    \n  *************** \nReport prepared by Bipandeep Sharma\, Research Analyst\,  Non-Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-on-prospects-of-maritime-cooperation-between-india-and-russia-in-the-indian-ocean-region-arctic-and-russian-far-east
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211129T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211130T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132706Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240227T040223Z
UID:63043-1638163800-1638250200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar on Political Developments in Pakistan
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow and Coordinator of the South Asia  Centre\,   Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies  and Analyses (MP-IDSA) spoke on the topic ‘Political Developments in Pakistan’  at the Monday Morning Webinar on 29th November 2021. The webinar was chaired by  Dr. Pushpita Das\, Research Fellow and Coordinator of the Internal Security  Centre\, MP-IDSA. \nDirector General (DG)\, Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, Dr. Smruti S. Pattanaik\, Research  Fellow\, Vishal Chandra\, Research Fellow\, Dr. Priyanka Singh\, Associate Fellow\, Dr.  Gulbin  Sultana\, Research Analyst\, Mr. Nazir Ahmad Mir\, Research Analyst and Dr. Zainab Akhter\, Research Analyst participated as panelists. \nExecutive  Summary\nDr. Ashok K. Behuria analyzed the trajectories of the emerging political  landscape\, the state of civil-military relations and internal security  developments in Pakistan.  \nDetailed  Report\nThe chair Dr. Pushpita Das in her introductory remarks highlighted the  emerging fault lines between the ruling government and the Army during the latest  appointment of the Director-General (DG) of Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI). Dr.  Pushpita noted that the Imran Khan-led regime has been sidelined by the  generals while selecting the new DG of ISI. She also noted that the hasty reconciliation  between the government and Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan (TLP) indicates the  ruling regime’s surrender to the demands of hardline religious groups. With  these words\, the chair invited the speaker\, Dr. Ashok Behuria to elaborate on  these issues. \nDr. Ashok Behuria dwelt on the continuing political tussle between the  government and the opposition and highlighted the growing discord between the two  on several policy matters. The opposition\, he said\, targeted the government particularly on its  economic and foreign policy choices and its failure to check the rising  inflation in the country. He mentioned that the opposition had so far taken out  around 23 protest marches against the government. He also pointed out that  unflustered by all this\, the Pakistan Tehreek-e- Insaf (PTI) government led by  the Prime Minister (PM) Imran Khan had passed 33 bills in the joint sitting of  parliament on 17 November without holding talks with the opposition to evolve a  consensus. The controversial bills which were passed included bills related to use  of Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) in the coming elections\, the Anti-Rape  Bill and bills related to the International Court of Justice. \nThe speaker noted that behind-the-scene manipulations by the deep state  ensured a majority for the government in the joint sitting to pass these bills.  The speaker maintained that the government and the opposition may not also necessarily  be on the same page even on important national security matters. \nSimilarly\, the speaker also referred to the latest controversy surrounding  the recent leaked-audiotapes of former Chief Justice Saqib Nisar where he was heard  telling someone that it was imperative to keep Nawaz Sharif and his daughter  Maryam Nawaz behind bars to bring Imran Khan to power. According to the  speaker\, the growing nexus between the Judiciary and the Army particularly concerning  the recent tapes cannot be ignored\, and the controversy that followed furthered  widened the gulf between the government and the opposition. The speaker  stressed that though the nexus between the Judiciary and Army is not new to  Pakistan\, however\, recently it had become more visible. He noted that in recent  years\, the opposition had been criticizing the Army like never before.  Moreover\, the opposition questioned the legitimacy of the ruling dispensation  on the ground that the present government is at the helm of power through a “stolen  election.”  \nIn the second part of the talk\, Dr. Ashok dealt with civil-military relations  and held that there might have been some signs of disruption between them in  previous months\, however\, after Saqib Nisar tapes emerged\, the Imran Khan government  and the Army seemed to work closely together\, which pointed to a civil-military  reconciliation at the moment. However\, the speaker maintained that the public  opinion is shifting away from Khan to the opposition for which the military  might be looking for an alternative to Imran Khan in the next elections. \nThe third theme pertained to military-militant issues. The speaker held that  there was a deep historical relationship between the Army and the militant  hardliner religious groups and stressed that it was the Army that brought  religious groups like TLP to the mainstream to delegitimize Sharif’s politics and  accused him of being un-Islamic. The Army\, he said\, had used these groups tactically  both in the past and in the present\, but he cautioned that these groups were not  monolithic and some elements within these groups operated beyond the influence  of the Army. He dwelt on the backdoor agreements between the Army and the TLP  and lately with Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and said that TTP wanted to  establish Islamic rule in Pakistan like the Taliban in Afghanistan. Therefore\,  the Army was trying hard to divert their attention towards India and  particularly towards Kashmir. \nThe speaker noted that whenever Pakistan faced any major  internal/domestic crisis\, the Army always tried to divert the attention of groups  threatening it from within towards India. The recent spike in infiltration bids  along the Line of Control (LoC) pointed to this trend\, he argued. The speaker  emphasized that in the coming days\, such developments would increase. He also  brought it out in his presentation that the state-controlled media in Pakistan had  hardened their position on Kashmir and India and this was on expected lines given  the internal political\, economic and security challenges that Pakistan was  beset with. \nComments\,  Observations and Questions from the participants\nThe Director General in his comments held that any upheaval in Pakistan would  ultimately affect India and cautioned that the vicarious pleasure that Indians  tend to derive from the economic and political crises that Pakistan is beset  with will not help India strategically. He maintained that the Army had a final  say in Pakistan politics as well as its foreign policy choices and reminded the  audience that Pakistan Army’s mindset was still rooted in what they called as  unfinished business of partition when it comes to Jammu and Kashmir. \nDr. Smruti S. Pattanaik noted that although Imran Khan had completed his  four years in power\, his government is mired in scandals related to corruption\,  rising inflation among other challenges in the domestic sphere and therefore the  Army is waiting for the right opportunity to find an alternative to him. She  maintained that the opposition parties\, particularly Shahbaz Sharif and Bilawal  Bhutto\, seemed to be willing to work with the Army. \nIn the Q&A session\, the speaker responding to the queries\, held that  even if developments in Afghanistan did not have any direct bearing on the  civil-military relations in Pakistan\, it had emboldened the Jihadi-radical  elements which would pose a critical challenge to the Pakistani state in  future. He held that the economic crisis may provide fuel to the opposition to  take on the government but that may not affect Imran Khan’s political fortunes  very much\, as help from China\, Saudi Arabia and US was likely to come in to  help Pakistan tide over the crisis. Dr. Ashok noted that the Army had played a  tactical role in striking a deal between the TLP and the ruling government\,  however\, while referring to past deals\, he stressed that the present understanding  between the TLP and the government might be reversed\, depending upon the  calculation of the army and the prevailing security scenario in future. He also  cautioned that there are varied sorts of elements within these religious groups  that can disrupt the army’s strategies despite their warming up to the army.  \nKey  Takeaways:\nThe latest political crisis (leaked tapes\, judicial crisis\, opposition  parties protests\, Imran Khan Government’s collusion with the religious  hardliners) and economic crisis (rising inflation\, Pakistan rupee depreciating  to its lowest ever value) have led to massive criticism of Imran Khan’s  policies\, but as per the speaker\, the multiple crises will not affect his immediate political and electoral prospects. \n  On the political front\, Imran Khan continues to enjoy the support of the  Army and Judiciary. \n  The Opposition parties are rather in disarray and lack the institutional  and mass support to challenge Imran Khan on the political domain as a united  front. \n  On the economic front\, there are no imminent chances of a collapse. In  addition to the strong institutional incentives in the domestic sphere\, China  does not want Pakistan to collapse. Even the United States will come to its aid  if there is an economic collapse. \n  The success of the Taliban in Afghanistan have energized Islamists in  Pakistan like never before. \n  Any major upheavals in Pakistan have direct and indirect security  implications for India\, particularly concerning the infiltration and cross  border skirmishes in the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir. \n  The Report has been prepared by Mohd. Usman Bhatti\, Research Assistant\,  South Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-on-political-developments-in-pakistan
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211122T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211122T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132706Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130548Z
UID:63044-1637559000-1637559000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar on "Systems Approach to Procurement - A Historical Perspective"
DESCRIPTION:In the Monday Morning Webinar held on  November 22\, 2021\, Col. Manish Rana\, Research  Fellow\, Defense Economics & Industry Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for  Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) spoke on the topic “Systems Approach to Procurement – An Historical Perspective”. Col.  Vivek Chadha\, Research Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, moderated the session. The Webinar  aimed to draw certain lessons from  the patterns which were emerging through study of the history of defence  procurement in India and also try to understand the complexities by adopting a  Systems Approach. The webinar also attempted to identify the fixes that have  failed due to interaction of various elements and sub-systems within the  defence procurement system in India\, to enable guide the decision makers in  formulating better and enduring Defence Procurement Policy. \nThe speaker gave a brief introduction to the Systems Approach to explain  what it means and how it works\, as also how we can utilize it in our Defence  procurement system as such. He brought out that any organization is created  with some objective in mind based on a felt need and it consists of various  sub-systems and elements which interact with each other to provide the desired  outcome. However\, over a period of time these relations start affecting each  other’s way of working and outcome leading to reduction in efficiency and  problems start surfacing. When the problem is identified\, the aim is to get the  feedback from the environment as to what is happening and why it is happening  and based on that feedback the changes in the interaction of the sub elements  /sub systems are introduced to make the organization behave in a particular way  or come out with a outcome which is desired. \nCol. Manish Rana brought out that Systems Approach focuses on a problem  which emerges with the interaction among the elements in society\, enterprises\,  and the environment. When we see a problem\, we don’t see a problem in isolation  we see the genesis of that problem in the interaction with the other sub-systems  and sub-elements within that system and accordingly we consider various  responses to come out with the solution. As told by Albert Einstein “The significant  problems we face today cannot be solved at the same level of thinking at which  they were created”.  That is the thought  process behind analyzing a problem from a different perspective from a  different point of view and from a different level of thinking. The crux  remains that complete system is more than the simple sum of the elements which  are existing in it (“Whole is greater than sum of the parts”). And for the  organizational problem solving the systems thinking approach offers a higher  level of thinking. \nThe speaker talked about Defence procurement as a system.  Major sub-system/elements which come into play  into this system are Service Headquarters\, MoD\, Industry and external factors. Service  headquarters in itself is a kind of system which have various sub-systems  within itself (Operations\, Perspective planners\, procurement sections\,  maintenance sections). MoD also is a smaller system or a sub-system having  various departments under it. Further we have Industry as another major element  which forms part of procurement system. Industry includes Indian entities\, Foreign  OEMs\, Start-ups\, MSMEs\, DPSUs. Another major factor which needs consideration  is the external environment. The procurement system directly or indirectly interacts  with the external environment through MEA policies\, PMO directives\, Ministries relating  to Industries and MSMEs etc. All these elements can be brought together under  one system to be able to define the system of defence procurement and there  interactions amongst each other and its effect on the outcome if studied  objectively will give us leverage points to ensure system continues to produce  the desired outcome.  \nConcept of causal loops as a tool for systems analysis was explained and  “Fixes that Fail ‘Archetypes was discussed by the speaker. This behavioral  pattern suggests that to fulfil a particular need or gap whatever action you  take that may give you certain results in the short run\, however\, it may also  happen that over a long term this particular action causes some unintended  consequence which over a period come back to haunt us and keep increasing the  problem further. Aim of adopting a Sytems approach is to identify such  possibilities by study of behavioral patterns in history to avoid introducing a  fix which may fail again. \nCol. Manish Rana discussed the Historical Perspective of Procurement in  India and highlighted that modern Defence industry which was setup in India before  1947 was essentially to meet the colonial interests. They had created a particular  system towards which small mills\, gun powder factories\, gun carriages  production facilities etc were set up for whatever limited requirement they had.  The British rulers were not inclined towards making bigger weapon systems or undertaking  major defence projects in India as the cost of producing those systems in India  was appreciated to be higher as compared to procuring them from England. The  initial infrastructure that was set up at that time was very limited in scope  for various reasons which were suiting the colonial power at that time and was  able to at best meet the Indian Armed Forces requirement of so called  Quartermaster stores only. \nSpeaker  mentioned about the Industrial policy of 1956 and its impact on defence  procurement and production. It was a major turning point in the Indian Defence  Production system. The 1956 Industrial Policy was in accordance with the national  objective of socialist pattern of society at that time\, towards which the  public sector was given a push. Government had recognised and realised that the  planned and rapid development is the need of the day. However\, the industrial  base in India at that time was not able to give the results that were required and  not able to put in the required capital in major sectors like defence. Hence\,  the basic sectors and some strategically important sectors were put directly  under the control of the government. The State assumed direct responsibility  for the future development of industries over a wide area. Like exclusive  responsibility of Railways and Air transport\, arms and ammunition and atomic  energy.  \nResearch  and development in various fields was also realized to be an important aspect  and towards this the DRDO was established in 1958. Prof. PMS Blackett played a major  role to guide the government and  helped government to take the policies forward. Unfortunately\, as per PMS  Blackett the threat perception of India which was very limited and he suggested  that India needs to procure weapons system to cater for their internal turmoil and  limited external threat only. In one of his documents\, it is also mentioned  that he had advised the government to take a holistic threat perspective and  come out with likely future scenarios and based on that decide what defence  equipment factories and projects should be established by the Government of  India. Which somehow did not happen\, and we kept on struggling with the limited  resources. Whereas the future of science was realised in other sectors and  developments happened accordingly. Col. Manish Rana emphasized that the crux of  the matter remains that we rightly pushed for the public sector units but we did  not realise at that time was the need for gestation period in procurement and the  production of defence equipment as also necessity of comprehensive threat  assessment based requirements in defence.  \nCol. Manish Rana linked India’s dependence on Russia to the geopolitical  realities of 60’s and 70’s when China-Pakistan and USA were coming closer. At  that time\, we went for a treaty with Russia in 1971 i.e.\, Indo-Soviet Treaty of  Peace\, Friendship and Cooperation and focus shifted to import of defence  equipment through Govt to Govt negotiations and single vendor contracts. Though  we did not lose sight of indigenous capacity enhancement\, towards which licensed  production contracts were introduced. But the desired aim was not met as there  was limited transfer of technology. Over a period of time we went into comfort  zone and got used to single vendor procurements. However\, in 1990s as  industrial capacities started improving and economy got liberalised\, defense  production started opening up to private sector and we also started diversifying  our import of defence products from other countries as well. Since multi-vendor  acquisitions are complex and time consuming the institutional deficiencies started coming to fore. India realised that it needs to formalise the  procedures and reduce discretion amongst decision makers involved in defence  procurements. The Public Accounts Committee of Parliament in its 187th Report  in 1989 recommended that Government should draw up comprehensive guidelines  relating to defence purchases and contracts. Later the Kargil War and consequent  recommendations from Group of Ministers ensured we started working on policy  aspects with a renewed purpose of strengthening our system. Director General of  Defence Acquisition was created in MoD and detailed procedural guidelines  called Defence Procurement Procedure (DPP) were promulgated in 2002 (revised in  2005\, 2006\, 2008\, 2009\, 2011\, 2013\, 2016 and 2020). Offsets were also introduced  in 2005.  \nCol. Manish Rana presented a causal loop with capability gaps as the main  focus and steps taken to cover them since independence. How the various factors  like indigenous solutions\, public sector units\, Global purchases etc affected  our overall process were discussed in detail. He concluded that crux of the  systems approach is to have a simple solution and gaining maximum advantage by  identifying historical patterns and leverage points in causal loops. He  highlighted that historically it has been seen that encouraging Research and  Development and striking a balance between import and indigenous development  may be the key to success of Defence Procurement as a System. Constant threat  evaluation is required so that we don’t end up splurging on the things that we  don’t require. Also he left the audience with the thought of what should be our  focus\, should we ‘Indigenise the past or learn lessons from past and try to indigenise  the Future’. \nThanking the speaker for a  comprehensive analysis and the valuable insights\, the Chair Col. Vivek Chadha  called on Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, DG\, MP-IDSA\, to share his remarks on the theme. Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy congratulated the presenter for the  insightful presentation and mentioned instances where India has done well in  indigenizing defence systems. However\, he raised the question of the barriers  that have impeded India’s beginning in the realm of indigenised defence  systems. Amb. Chinoy also mentioned that “Whenever India has decided to make  something in India\, it has done very good” and gave examples of the recently  unveiled INS Vishakhapatnam as India’s success story. \nMaj. Gen. (Dr)  Bipin Bakshi (Retd) DDG\, MP-IDSA highlighted  that our services have been reluctant to go for indigenous weapons till  recently. Maj. Gen. Bakshi said that one of the reasons  is that technological gaps are still there. He mentioned that Covid-19 has  given fillip to indigenisation by exposing dependencies on global supply  chains. He also emphasized that we need to strike a balance between foreign and indigenous sources. \nThe Panelist Samuel Rajiv\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA commented that there  is a need for a re-emphasis on Atmanirbhar Bharat. He said that the whole point  of indigenisation is to reduce the capacity gap so we need to measure how much  of capacity gap can be filled. However\, the speaker Col. Manish Rana disagreed  that there is a reluctance in the Indian armed forces to adopt Indian weapons.  The floor was then opened for the Q&A session which emphasised on the need  to improve processes\, and barriers to these improvements.  \nReport prepared by Richa Tokas\, Research Intern\, Defence Economics & Industry Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-on-systems-approach-to-procurement-a-historical-perspective
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211116T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211116T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132707Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130548Z
UID:63045-1637040600-1637040600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar on Climate Summit: Taking Stock
DESCRIPTION:Dr.  Uttam Kumar Sinha Centre Coordinator Non-Traditional Security Centre\, Manohar  Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses spoke on the topic “Climate Summit: Taking  Stock” at  the Monday Morning Webinar (held on Tuesday) on 16th November\, 2021.  The webinar was chaired by Dr. Rajiv Nayan\, Centre Coordinator\, Nuclear and  Arms Control Centre. Deputy Director General\, and members of the institute  attended the webinar. \nExecutive Summary\nThe  impacts of climate change are being felt in every sphere. With rising  temperatures and the world dangerously hurtling towards thresholds limits of 1.5°C to  2°C\, there has been an urgent  need to deal with the situation. The recently held COP 26 in Glasgow aimed to  address climate emergency with set of rules and obligations for states.  Various issues such as climate finance\,  nationally determined contributions\, ‘phasing out’ and ‘phasing down’ of coal  and fossil fuels\, deadlines for net-zero emissions and much more were  discussed.  \nDetailed Report\nThe  chair\, Dr. Nayan highlighted the many newly emerged ‘terms’ and ‘ambiguities’  during the COP 26 summit and asked the speaker to enlighten the audience with  these terminologies. He also evoked the speaker to contextualize climate change  before analyzing the joint statement made at COP 26.  \n  In his opening remarks\, Dr. Sinha emphasized that climate  change is well and truly an emergency and the world is grappling on how to deal  with it\, mitigate it and more importantly\, how to adapt to climate change.  These as the speaker explained remain highly contested ever since the signing  of the United Nation’s Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) in 1992.  Commenting on the UNFCCC\, Dr. Sinha mentioned that it is a multilateral treaty  styled as framework convention in which the parties acknowledge the existence  of a problem (climate change) and commit to cooperative actions. It was framed  in such a manner that as the convention evolves\, it would move towards a series  of protocols and agreements that would make it more progressive\, and then  finally an acceptance of stringent obligations would come into force. The  Conference of Parties (COP) to UNFCC is the apex decision-making body that  takes decisions and lays out pathways to deal with climate change implications.  Successive COP summits since 1995\, as the speaker explained\, has seen a convergence  towards climate obligations.  \nDr. Sinha then gave a conceptual\,  intellectual and epistemological understanding of climate change. He mentioned  that humanity is currently living in an informal geological epoch of Anthtopocene\, in which human activities directly  and indirectly has altered the entire composition of the global atmosphere and  has significantly impacted the climate ecosystem. He further mentioned that the  developed countries\, in particular\, have\, despite the evidences\, been in denial  of their high per capita emission trajectory that they have consciously  undertaken since the post-industrial revolution. Talking about the colonial  projects of resource extraction and colonization of landscape by the Europeans\,  particularly the Dutch and the British in the 17th and 18th centuries\, Dr.  Sinha reminded the audience of the colonial powers destructive strategies that massively  transformed the landscapes for control and profit. He also mentioned that the  world has inherited and become habitual to unsustainable extraction and  consumption of resources that is justified through development\, comfort and  poverty eradication. The speaker categorically stated that if the world needs  to look at the future and has to limit the global temperature rise between 1.5°  C to 2°C\, then the entire system of production\, management and governance needs  to be transformed. This also includes changes in behavior\, consumption pattern  and lifestyle alteration.  \n  Commenting on the nature of  statements made by world leaders at COP summits\, Dr. Sinha observed that some  are profound while some are business-as-usual but some remarkably  transformational. He categorized Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s  statements at COP 26 as transformational as other world leaders failed to make  any big impression. Interestingly\, the speaker highlighted Indira Gandhi’s  sensational speech at the United Nations Conference on the Human Environmental  (UNCHE) in 1972 in Stockholm\, in which she mentioned\, “are not poverty and need  the greatest polluter?” He said that this statement is rightly being recalled even  today by Indian climate negotiators. He clearly underlined that the poor matter  and\, therefore\, development is the key for India.  \n  While  the climate challenges are unique the politics around it is familiar.  Explaining this Dr Sinha observed that the climate summits are not alien to linkage  politics and power dynamics and has often seen realignment of forces and  groupings to emphasize respective countries needs and requirements. It is for  this reason that the semantics of the final text of the COP summits are  intensely contested. He cited the example of India-China insistence to ‘phase  down’ rather than ‘phase out’ of coal in the final text draft of COP 26 summit.  The speaker thereon enlightened  the audience to the overall acceptance of climate science which he noted is influencing  the politics to search for possibilities. He quoted\, ‘if politics is the art of  possible\, science is the art of soluble’.  \nFocusing on the key elements of the COP 26  Glasgow\, Dr. Sinha highlighted the following: \n\nA  stronger action to achieve 1.5° C limit.\nNations  to strengthen their climate action plans and nationally determined  contributions (NDC). \nTo ‘phase  down’ the uses of unabated coal power and ‘phase out’ inefficient fossil fuel  subsidies. \nDeveloped  countries were asked to double the finance for adaptation by 2025 from the 2019  levels. An updated time till 2023 has been given to developed countries to  fulfil their commitment of releasing promised $100 billion climate fund to  developing countries. \nDeveloping  countries like India are allowed to use carbon credits for meeting their first  NDC targets. \nDeveloped countries can buy carbon credits to  meet its own emission reduction targets\, till 2025. \n\nFocusing on Prime Minister Modi’s Panchamrit at COP 26\, Dr. Sinha firmly believed that India’s intention has been to be part  of the solution and not the problem and therefore the mixture of five nectar  elements of India’s climate action is extremely noteworthy. This raises India’s  credibility as a climate-conscious country and proves India’s determination and  value of commitment to climate action. The key elements of Panchamrit was  then explained:  \n\nIndia  will reach its non-fossil energy capacity to 500 gigawatts by 2030.\nIndia  will meet 50 per cent of its energy requirements from renewable energy by 2030.\nIndia  will reduce the total projected carbon emission by 1 billion tonnes from now  till 2030.\nTill  2030 India will reduce the carbon intensity of its economy by less than 45 per  cent.\nFinally\,  by the year 2070 India will achieve the target of net-zero emissions.\n\nDr.  Sinha emphasized that India is now the driver of climate change narrative\,  unlike the previous times when India was seen as climate denier. He mentioned  that India’s actions are immediate (2020-2030) unlike many countries including  EU who have made future net-zero targets the mantra. it is the current decade itself that defines those.  Finally\, in his concluding remarks Dr. Sinha mentioned that it is important to  note that given all the difficulties that prevail\, hope will always remain in  bringing changes that the world requires in near future but hope needs to be  backed by deeds and actions and not mere pledges.  \nThanking Dr. Sinha for his enlightening  lecture\, the chair made several critically important comments. Dr. Nayan  mentioned that currently\, the climate summit is moving away from the semiotic  rhetorical structure to a more norm building process. He talked about climate  realignment that is taking place and critically highlighted the role of OPEC  countries (currently led by Russia) in the climate debate and argued that these  countries still remains the custodian of the world’s fossil fuels and how these  oil producing countries respond and shape the climate change debate will be  interesting to observe.  \nComments and observations from the participants followed  thereon:\n  \nBipandeep Sharma commented on the issue of  sea-level rise and its impact on the small island territories and states in the  Indian Ocean Region. \n  Dr. Nihar Nayak observed that COP26 was an  action-oriented summit. Referring to all the historical pledges made by the  developed countries\, he highlighted that the developing countries are very  dissatisfied regarding the unmet climate commitments of the developed  countries. He also highlighted the number of groups that emerged within the  countries at COP summits and thereon mentioned a significant transition from  climate mitigation to climate adaptation in COP 26 summit. He further highlighted  the number of agreements signed at COP 26 some of which included methane  emission reductions\, reduction in deforestation and transitions to net-zero carbon  emissions. Finally\, commenting on India’s position on COP 26\, Dr. Nayak  mentioned that COP 26 is basically a commitment and a collective responsibility  that each state needs to take.   \n  Col. (Dr.) DPK Pillay in his remarks highlighted India’s position on  climate change. He mentioned that much of the bulk of carbon emission has been  led by the developed world. He asserted that India being the 7th largest  country\, is barely responsible 3 per cent of emissions that take place. He  mentioned that India is far ahead of developed countries in reducing carbon  emissions in terms of the solar alliance\, afforestation and renewable energy. \n  Capt. Anurag Bisen (Indian Navy) mentioned that the Glasgow Deal  fails to hold into account the developed countries commitment to climate  financing. He also asserted that there has been a general tendency to shift the  climate narrative against India in the climate summit but India has maintained  its firm stance. \nDy. Director General Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi\,  AVSM\, VSM (Retd.)\, gave  his observations and highlighted that with the rising temperatures and  sea-level rise most of the island territories would be submerged underwater in  times to come. He also highlighted glacier melt and breaking away of massive as  a reflection of climate urgency. Commenting on the role of the Indian Army and  its contributions to address the issue of climate change\, Maj. Gen. Bakshi  asserted that a lot has changed in the last 20 years. He underlined several afforestation  initiatives by the army and a significant transition from coal and kerosene-based  heating systems (at higher altitudes along the India-China and India-Pakistan  border) to LPG based heating system.  \nQuestion and Answers.\nIn his response\, Dr. Sinha re-emphasized on  the role of science and technology and its interface with climate change. Finally\,  Dr. Sinha mentioned that the world can have different pathways to deal with  climate change but the overall vision is quiet clear that climate change is an  emergency. Dr. Sinha concluded that targets are still achievable provided  pledges turn to deeds\, it requires a collective action of states but more  importantly a change of mindset of western developed countries.  \nKey Takeaways:\n\nClimate  change is now an emergency and needs immediate collective action of states.\nIn successive  COP summits since 1995\, an upward graph of stringent obligations have been  employed to the framework of convention.\nHumanity  is currently living in a geological epoch of Anthtopocene\, the roots lie  in high per capita emission trajectory of the developed countries.\nThere has  been a series of realignment of forces between states at COP summits.\nIndia-China’s  insisted on ‘phase down’ rather than ‘phase out’ of coal in the final text of  COP 26 summit.\nCOP 26  has asked countries to ‘phase down’ the uses of unabated coal power and ‘phase  out’ inefficient fossil fuel subsidies.\nDeveloped  countries have been given the timeline 2023 to deliver on their commitment of  promised $100 billion climate fund to developing countries.\nIndia has  committed to its own approach of ‘Panchamrit‘ to address climate  change.\n\n*************** \nReport prepared by Bipandeep Sharma\, Research  Analyst\, Non-Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-on-climate-summit-taking-stock
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211108T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211108T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132707Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130548Z
UID:63046-1636349400-1636349400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar on "ASEAN-India Summit: Outcome and Prospects"
DESCRIPTION:Event Report\nDr  Udai Bhanu Singh\, Centre for Southeast Asia and Oceania made a presentation on  “ASEAN-India Summit: Outcomes and  Prospects” on 8 November\, 2021. The session was moderated by Dr Arpita  Anant. The panelists included Director-General Amb. Sujan Chinoy\, Deputy  Director-General Dr Bipin Bakshi\, Col RP Singh and Mr Akash Sahu. It was  attended by MP-IDSA faculty and other invitees. \nExecutive Summary\nThe session outlined the significance of ASEAN as a  regional organization in the Indo-Pacific and its continued relevance despite  emergence of newer security structures such as the QUAD or AUKUS. India and  ASEAN align on the policy of rules-based order in the region and already  cooperate on a number of areas including supply chains\, energy\, climate\,  disaster management and skill development. There is a need to strengthen these  engagements and focus on economic and business ties between the two regions by  providing a boost to infrastructure on both sides and connectivity. The shared  values between India and ASEAN may be complemented with shared growth and  development\, which may be useful in maintaining regional balance of power. \nDr  Singh spoke on India’s relations with ASEAN and the recently concluded ASEAN-India  summit. He explained India’s position of commitment to ASEAN centrality in the  Indo-Pacific. Given the uncertainty that has arisen due to ASEAN’s inability to  take prompt action on the Myanmar crisis\, many have been skeptical of ASEAN’s  relevance as a formidable regional organization. However\, India’s policy of  engaging with ASEAN must not be driven by such skepticism since despite a lack  of consensus on certain issues\, ASEAN nations think alike on number of other  fronts such as economy\, trade\, tourism\, industry etc. India may continue to  engage with ASEAN to enhance cooperation on these issues.  \n  The  world has changed significantly from the times when ASEAN was formed in 1967\,  and today\, the global order is being challenged by the aggressive rise of  China. The Southeast Asian nations are closely interconnected with China  economically and the gap in their military capacities in comparison to China is  huge. Hence\, the collective ASEAN identity has assumed much more importance  than ever in successfully resisting China’s attempts to coerce member nations  into ceding claims in the conflicted South China Sea territory. Maintaining  good relations with India will also be favourable for ASEAN with a view to  sustaining balance of power in the region. India and ASEAN can continue to  build partnerships on the basis of their shared history\, cultural linkages and  political willingness from both sides.  \n  PM  Modi’s speech at the recent summit was indicative of India’s interest in  deepening engagements with ASEAN\, especially in vaccine production. He also  laid focus on the shared values between the two regions and cooperative efforts  in fighting the COVID-19 pandemic. Security for All and Growth in the Region  (SAGAR) and Indo-Pacific Oceans Initiative (IPOI) are India-led initiatives  aimed at improving regional maritime security. It has considerable scope for  ASEAN to be involved for comprehensive joint efforts. There is also much scope  for strategic alignment for India and ASEAN. The ASEAN Outlook on Indo-Pacific\,  released in 2019\, is the organization’s major step to realizing a common vision  for Indo-Pacific with a rules-based order and freedom of navigation. India and  ASEAN can work to reduce the gaps in development and cooperate in areas such as  pharmaceuticals. India is part of many forums with ASEAN like East Asia Summit  (EAS) and ASEAN Defence Ministers’ Meeting Plus (ADMM+)\, which has allowed it  to better understand the region’s security issues.  \n  India  is also engaged with ASEAN on areas of non-traditional security such as fast-changing  climate and protection of the region’s rich biodiversity. The year 2022 will be  ASEAN-India year of friendship. It will also be the year for Cambodia’s  chairmanship of the organization. Cambodia has developed close relations with  China over the years and in the year of its last chairmanship of ASEAN in 2012\,  had pushed Beijing’s agenda in context to South China Sea issue. India’s  engagement with ASEAN\, and particularly Cambodia\, may be observed carefully  with regard to developments on the South China Sea conflict. Summarizing the  presentation\, Dr Anant underlined the increasing importance of minilateralism  in the Indo-Pacific and the need for India and ASEAN to maintain a robust  relationship.  \n  The  DG complimented Dr Singh for the presentation and shared his views on  India-ASEAN relations. He pointed out that economics and infrastructure is  where the competition lies when it comes to Southeast Asia. There has been a  tendency in India to focus on civilizational linkages with the ASEAN region at  the cost of developing business and trade connectivity. This may be problematic  given the fast pace of Beijing’s ingress into the region with grand plans like  BRI. Despite India’s cultural and religious linkages with countries in  Southeast Asia\, there has been less than expected convergence on issues of  strategic importance due to overarching economic influence of China. India  should consider strengthening ties with ASEAN by allocating much greater resources  for development of infrastructure between the two regions. The DDG observed  that role of ASEAN has come under speculation due to its lack of effectiveness  in dealing with some contentions issues\, but nevertheless it remains one of the  central pillars of stability in the region. He stressed that ASEAN centrality  may continue to be the rule of thumb for multilateral forums in the  Indo-Pacific region. He raised a query about India’s connectivity projects in  its northeastern region with Myanmar\, and the progress of the Kaladan  Multimodal transport route.  \n  Dr  Singh clarified that challenges remain for India’s two flagship projects. One  is the ambitious Kaladan multi-modal connectivity project which links Zorinpui  in Mizoram with Myanmar’s Sittwe port in the Rakhine state\, and the other is  the Trilateral Highway between Moreh (in Manipur\, India) and Mae Sot in  Thailand via Myanmar. One predominant challenge is the lack of infrastructural development  within India’s northeast and within the border regions of Myanmar. For the  project to gain pace\, it is crucial that connectivity within Northeast is  strengthened speedily. Another reason is instability in the Rakhine state due  to the Rohingya issue. It may be difficult to register progress as long as  violence continues in areas of Rakhine critical to the Kaladan project.  \n  Some  concerns were raised on India’s approach to ASEAN\, especially as member states  themselves are of varying opinions on recent security developments such as AUKUS.  It was discussed that this may be primarily due to differing relationships with  China. Vietnam has taken a softer approach to AUKUS while Indonesia and  Malaysia have expressed concerns. It was also agreed that India may carefully  observe role of large powers in the region such as Russia and the US. On RCEP\,  it was acknowledged that not signing the agreement in the first go was being  seen internationally as a missed opportunity for India as it would be excluded  from a vast free trade zone. Given some domestic restraints and pressure\, India  could not sign the agreement and may revisit if some of its reservations could  be addressed. A beginning has to be made by revisiting the terms of the  ASEAN-India FTA. India must also continue to increase cooperation with ASEAN on  supply chains resilience as the COVID-19 has exposed the vulnerabilities of the  present logistics. Such cooperation may be extended to areas such as energy\,  given India’s vast potential for solar energy production. \nReport prepared by Akash Sahu\, Research Analyst\, Centre  for Southeast Asia and Oceania\, MP-IDSA
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-on-asean-india-summit-outcome-and-prospects
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211101T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211101T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132744Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130548Z
UID:63047-1635744600-1635744600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar – Coup in Sudan and Fallout
DESCRIPTION:Monday Morning Webinar – Coup in Sudan and Fallout\nNovember 01\,  2021 \n  In the Monday Morning Webinar held on November 01\,  2021\, Ms. Ruchita Beri\, Senior Research Associate and Coordinator Africa\, Latin  America\, Caribbean and United Nations Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for  Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) spoke on the topical “Coup in Sudan and  Fallout”.  Dr. M.  S. Prathibha\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA\,  moderated the session. Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Maj.  Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA\, and scholars  of the institute attended the webinar. \nExecutive Summary \nThe webinar  shed light on the conditions triggering the Coup in Sudan\, its internal as well  as regional impact and provided an insight on the likely implications it holds  for India. It was assessed that the coup would worsen the domestic situation\,  reverse all the gains made by Sudan over the last two years and tensions may  flare up in the region. The close ties shared between Sudan and India; and the  role played by other external powers in the country was also highlighted. The  importance of restoring civilian rule in Sudan in the near future was  underscored by the Speaker.  \nDetailed Report \n  The Chair\, Dr. M. S. Prathibha\, began the webinar by  sharing introductory details about the coup in Sudan. On October 25\, 2021\,  General Abdel Fattah al-Burhan\, the military chief  and head of Transitional Sovereignty Council\, dismissed the government and  declared a state of emergency. The Sudanese Prime Minister Abdallah Hamdok was  temporarily detained and is currently under house arrest. The Chair stated that  these events had quashed hopes for a peaceful transition of power. She invited  the Speaker to further discuss in detail the conditions that enabled the coup  and explore prospects for a democratic transition in Sudan. \n  At  the outset\, Ms. Ruchita Beri highlighted that General al-Burhan\, the military  chief has seized the power in the government\, dissolved the transitional  council\, declared a state of emergency and imprisoned the civilian leaders.  Referring to the previous failed coup attempt in September 2021\, she emphasised  that the current move by the military had sparked widespread protests in the  country and condemnation across the world. She stated that African Union (AU)  had suspended Sudan until it restored civil rule\, and shed light on the  responses of the United Nations\, Arab League and some of the neighbouring  countries. Ms. Beri assessed that the political crisis in Sudan would lead to  worsening of the situation internally and externally.  \n  The speaker stated that the transitional authorities  in Sudan consisted of members from the military and civilians from the Forces  of Freedom and Change party (FFC). Identifying that tough economic reforms had  led to deepening of differences within the FFC; she highlighted that tensions  had been brewing in the political circles\, pro-military protestors had held  demonstrations and the Port of Sudan had been blocked by a tribal group with  the help of the military. The speaker observed that economic crisis as well as  acute shortage of food\, currency and fuel was one of the reasons triggering the  coup. Stating that the military leadership of the sovereign transitional  council was slated to shift to a civilian leadership in November\, she analysed  that key items on the civilian agenda in the agreement also could have caused  the military to act. She underscored that other causes for the coup could have  been the civilian agenda of ensuring accountability on violation of Human  Rights during the rule of President Bashir\, vocal criticism of the army by Prime  Minister Hamdok\, the strict economic reforms and fear that Army might lose  their control in the commercial sector. \n  With regard to internal impact Ms. Beri remarked that  the coup had reversed all progress that Sudan had made. Owing to its efforts to  transition to a democracy\, the country had recently begun to receive  international financial assistance; all of which had been paused following the  coup. The speaker underlined that the coup threatens Sudan’s fragile peace and  would worsen the shattered economy leading to rise in unemployment. Referring  to the external regional impact\, Ms. Beri stated that tensions may flare up in  the region. She assessed that the coup would inflame existing boundary and  territorial disputes\, influence the political dynamics surrounding the ‘Grand  Ethiopian Renaissance Dam Project’\, affect the Tigray crisis and increase the  security concerns of the region. \n  Ms. Beri shed light on the close historical ties  shared between Sudan and India. She mentioned that India is invested in the  energy sector of the country\, has provided Lines of Credit\, is a key  development partner for Sudan\, Sudan was a beneficiary under India’s Vaccine  Maitri initiative and India was at the forefront of providing food aid to Sudan  in November 2020. Stating the value of bilateral trade and that major brands  like Tata and Mahindra are some of the companies present in Sudan\, she said Oil  and Natural Gas Corporation Limited (ONGC) withdrew its operations in 2020 owing  to disagreements. The speaker observed that the Minister of State for External  Affairs Shri. V Muraleedharan’s visit to Sudan on 18-19th October  2021 implies that India exercises leverage in the country.  \n  She shared that United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Saudi  Arabia are close external partners to Sudan as they have business interests and  are strategically linked in the war against Terrorism. Furthermore\, Sudan has  helped in fighting against the Houthi rebels and UAE is invested in the ports  in Sudan. Ms. Beri underlined that although previously China shared close  military relations with Sudan\, it has in recent years diluted its economic  partnership. Expressing concern about the future in Sudan\, Ms. Beri stated that  the coup could potentially increase internal chaos and regional conflicts would  flare up. She concluded by underscoring the importance of restoring civilian  rule in Sudan in the near future. \n  Thanking the speaker for a comprehensive analysis and  the valuable insights\, the Chair called on Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, DG\, MP-IDSA\,  to share his remarks on the theme. Amb. Chinoy drew attention to and raised  queries on the long term implications of the coup on India’s trading community  and the possibility of the internal chaos in Sudan descending into a graver  humanitarian crisis. He reflected on the likely scope of attention the  international community would extend considering it is currently focused on the  situation in Afghanistan. Amb. Sujan stated that security and drug consignments  particularly at ports could be misused during times of chaos and collapsing  government structure. He enquired about the likelihood of the Port of Sudan  being used as staging point for arms and drugs. Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi  (Retd.)\, DDG\, MP-IDSA\, made a reference to the Sudanese military chief’s  announcement on the appointment of a technocrat instead of an elected  politician to lead the council. He remarked on the importance of countries  evolving its own system of governance and stated the examples of Libya\, Iraq  and Afghanistan. Comparing international response to the coup in Myanmar and  underscoring the need for homegrown evolved system of governance\, Maj. Gen.  Bakshi asked the Speaker to share views on how the situation in Sudan would  play out. \n  In her response\, Ms. Beri reiterated the security  concerns and strategic importance of Sudan which is strategically located  connecting the Sahel\, Horn of Africa and the North of Africa. She emphasised  that worsening situation in Sudan would impact the region as a whole. Regarding  the Indian trading community in Sudan\, she mentioned that Indian Embassy had  issued a safety advisory to all Indians in Sudan and recalled earlier missions  by India to evacuate Indians stuck in the conflict. The speaker stated that the  Port of Sudan is currently blocked which would increase illegal trade in the  future. Mentioning about India’s past defence cooperation with Sudan\, she  remarked that India may revive its diplomatic parlays with Sudan to help with  the transition. To explain the reasons for appointment of a technocrat\, Ms.  Beri shed light on the commercial and political entrenchment of the military in  Sudan and their fear of losing the existing control under a civilian rule. She  mentioned about international and regional negotiation processes underway  regarding Sudan. \n  The webinar concluded with a vibrant and an engaging  Q/A session which raised some interesting themes. Key highlights of the Q/A session  were the inputs shared on the status of the civilian society in Sudan which is  not a monolith and it’s potential to influence the politics; global opinion  against the coup; failure of United Nations Security Council (UNSC) to produce  a presidential statement on the situation in Sudan due to opposition by Russia  and China which could cause frictions in international response to the coup; the  increasing magnitude of the protests by Sudanese nationals against the coup;  implications of the coup on the larger regional geopolitics; the role of AU in  bringing stability as Sudan and Ethiopia have become a theatre for geopolitical  competition between West Asian powers like Turkey\, Egypt\, Saudi Arabia and UAE;  potential of a military governed Sudan becoming a partner of the Sunni bloc against  Iran; implication of the coup on the agreement signed between Russia and Sudan  to establish a naval base near the port of Sudan; future trajectory of  Sudan-Israel ties and the likely flaring up of issues on the dynamics of Nile  river water sharing.  \n  \nReport prepared by Ms. Sindhu Dinesh\, Research  Analyst\, ALACUN Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-coup-in-sudan-and-fallout
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211025T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211025T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132744Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130548Z
UID:63048-1635139800-1635139800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar on Implications of Enhancement of Area of Jurisdiction of BSF
DESCRIPTION:Event Report\nDr Pushpita Das\, Research  Fellow and Centre Coordinator Internal Security Centre\, MP-IDSA spoke on the topic “Implications of  Enhancement of Area of Jurisdiction of BSF” at the Monday Morning Webinar held  on 25 October 2021 at 10 am. The webinar was chaired by Dr Smruti S Pattanaik\, Research Fellow MP-IDSA. \n  Director General\,  MP-IDSA\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy; Deputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr)  Bipin Bakshi\, Retd\, and scholars & members of the Institute attended the  webinar. \nExecutive Summary\nThe  Union Government on 11 October 2021 through a notification amended the BSF Act  to enhance the jurisdiction of the Border Security Force (BSF) in States  sharing border with Pakistan\, Bangladesh and Myanmar. The Notification  increased the operational area of BSF from 15 kms to 50 kms in States of  Punjab\, West Bengal and Assam. In the North Eastern States of Manipur\, Mizoram\,  Tripura\, Nagaland\, and Meghalaya and in Union Territories of Jammu &  Kashmir and Ladakh no change has been made as the whole area comes under the  jurisdiction of the BSF. However in Gujrat\, the operational area is reduced to  50 km from 80 km. The States of Punjab and West Bengal have opposed this and  called it an attack on federalism. These states asked why the Union government  did not consult state governments before taking such a decision. The BSF  however welcomed the decision and hoped the move will help in curbing the  trans-border crimes. Although BSF welcomed the move but the need is to train  and educate BSF about various acts and their implementation. The central  government also should work closely with state governments to better manage the  country’s international borders. \nDetailed Report\nDr Pushpita Das began her presentation by talking about the MHA  Notification. She explained that the Notification increases the operational  area of BSF from 15 kms to 50 kms in three states of Punjab\, West Bengal and  Assam. In Gujrat\, the operational area is decreased from 80 Kms to 50 Kms and  in states like Manipur\, Mizoram\, Tripura\, Nagaland\, and Meghalaya and in Union  Territories of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh the operational area remains the  same. \nThe decision to amend the BSF Act of 2014 to enhance  the operational area and jurisdiction of BSF has come in the backdrop of the  changing political situation in Afghanistan. There are apprehensions that  anti-India elements in Afghanistan and Pakistan might try sneak into India  through international borders or try to disrupt peace in the country. In recent  months\, terrorist incidents have increased in Jammu & Kashmir\, and the  movement of terrorists and drones dropping weapons along LoC and international border  was reported as well. There were reports of drones dropping weapons in Punjab  also. Similarly\, along the Bangladesh border\, the incidents of illegal  migration\, cattle smuggling and smuggling of fake Indian currency notes are issues  of national security concern which apparently triggered MHA to enhance the  operational area of BSF. \n  The MHA Notification extends the jurisdiction of the  BSF in powers that it already enjoys under Criminal Procedure Code (CrPc)\, the  Passport Act 1967\, and the Passport (entry into India) Act 1920. The BSF still  does not have authority to investigate and prosecute anyone in the extended  operational area. They are authorized to raid and make arrests but they will  have to handover the seized consignment and the arrested persons to the local  police.  \n  The Notification evoked mixed responses. Some believe  that the extension of the jurisdiction will help in defeating the cross-border  smuggling and illegal infiltration. Others see the move as an infringement on  the rights of the states or in other words “a direct attack on  federalism”.  The BSF welcomed the  decision. They believe it will bring uniformity in areas of operations and help  in effectively curbing the trans-border crimes. Based on her interviews with  BSF officers\, Dr Pushpita highlighted an important issue of relationship of BSF  with police and local police of the states. In areas close to border\, people  generally don’t like the presence of BSF. The police fails to perform their  duties when it comes to dealing with infiltrators and smugglers. Some officers  believe that the police is susceptible to political pressure which makes it  necessary for BSF to have additional powers of investigation and prosecution.  However\, some officers do not agree with this demand for additional powers and  seek the authority to hand-over the suspected cases to central investigating  agencies like NIA and CBI instead to local police. Without such powers  trans-border crimes can’t be curbed effectively. \n  The Assam government has supported the Notification  and is sure that it will help in addressing the issue of cross-border smuggling  and illegal infiltration. The Punjab and West Bengal governments have  criticized the central government for unilaterally taking such an important  decision. Both the state governments have termed it as direct attack on federal  structure of India. \n  Dr Pushpita also reminded about the BSF Amendment Bill  of 2011\, wherein the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) attempted to extend the  jurisdiction of BSF to the whole country. The UPA government of the day  reasoned that BSF is deployed in counter insurgency and anti-naxal operations  in the country and should be allowed to operate in any part of the country  without any restriction. She further informed that under Section 139 (3) of the  BSF Act\, the government has to lay the Notification for discussion in both  Houses within thirty days. \nQ & A Session\nThe Deputy  Director General of MP-IDSA Maj Gen (Dr) Bipin Bakshi in his remarks said  that there are pros as well as cons of the new Notification and the operational  benefits outweigh the cons. He further said that extension of jurisdiction is  necessary because 15 kms is not enough for better results\, but at the same time  coordination and synergy is important between BSF and local police. About BSF’s  demand of directly handing over cases to central investigating agencies\, DDG  said that there may be capacity issues with this proposal as there could be a  barrage of cases to CBI or NIA if  BSF starts referring cases directly to them. \nAnswering a query about impact on cities within 50 Kms\,  Dr Pushpita made it clear that BSF can operate under Criminal Procedure Code  (CrPc)\, the Passport Act 1967\, the Passport (entry into India) Act 1920. It is  still not clear how BSF can address the issue of drones in the extended areas of  jurisdiction. Answering the question about necessity of consultation with  states\, she agreed that taking state governments on board before taking such  decisions should be a priority. \nKey Takeaways\n\nThe decision to extend the  jurisdiction of BSF in states sharing border with Pakistan and Bangladesh will  certainly help in effectively curbing cross-border smuggling and illegal infiltration. \nHowever\, before taking such significant decisions\, the  Union government should consult the state government. That is the main question  that states like Punjab and West Bengal have been asking since MHA issued the  Notification. \nMoreover\, coordination and synergy between BSF and  local police is necessary for better results.\n\nReport prepared by Dr Manzoor Ahmad\, Research  Analyst\, Internal Security Centre\, MP-IDSA
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-on-implications-of-enhancement-of-area-of-jurisdiction-of-bsf
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211018T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211018T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132744Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130548Z
UID:63049-1634535000-1634535000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar – Unpacking the Rise of Terrorism in Mozambique
DESCRIPTION:Monday  Morning Webinar – Unpacking the Rise of Terrorism in Mozambique\nOctober 18\,  2021 \n  In the Monday Morning Webinar on October 18\, 2021\, Ms.  Ruchita Beri\, Senior Research Associate and Coordinator Africa\, Latin America\,  Caribbean and United Nations Centre\, MP-IDSA spoke on the topic “Unpacking the  Rise of Terrorism in Mozambique”.  Dr.  Lakshmi Priya moderated the session. The webinar was attended by Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\,  Director General\, MP-IDSA\, and scholars of the institute.  \nExecutive Summary \nThe webinar  drew attention to the crisis unfolding in Mozambique and underscored its  importance and implications for India and the International Community at large.  It was identified that the rise of terrorism was due to ideological as well as  tribal\, economic and social factors. The speaker underscored that the  manifestation of terrorism\, availability of natural resources\, response of the  Mozambican government and the organised crime network in the province were  among the four major factors for the rise in concern on the crisis in  Mozambique. Speaker highlighted the close ties shared between India and  Mozambique; and suggested likely avenues of engagement for India to aid  Mozambique in its crisis. \nDetailed Report \n  Dr. Lakshmi Priya\, Chair for the Webinar\, introduced  the topic by mentioning that the United States designated Abu  Sulayfa Muhammad of the ISIS Mozambique as  a global terrorist in August 2021. She pointed out that in April 2021\, French  Company Total Energy withdrew its economic activities in the country owing to  the security situation. The violence started in 2017 and has led to the loss of  3000 lives while over a million people have been displaced internally. Stating  that a peace deal effort has been ineffective\, she called on the Speaker to  present the theme.  \n  Ms. Ruchita Beri began her talk by underlining that  there are several factors that have led to the rise of Terrorism in Mozambique  and it is a matter of concern to the neighbouring African countries as well as  to India. The speaker stated that new frontiers of Terrorism were emerging and  is finding ground in new places\, especially in Southern Africa. The rise of  terrorism in Cabo Delgado province in northern Mozambique is a source of  concern for the international community as it has the potential to destabilize  southern Africa. Initially a youth movement challenging local Sufi  establishments\, the Al-Shabab Mozambique since 2017 started to engage in armed  terror activities and is linked to Ansar al-Sunna which is active in Tanzania  and along the east coast of Africa. \n  Ms. Beri identified that the rise of terrorism was due  to ideological as well as tribal\, economic and social factors including local  grievances like economic isolation and exclusion\, forced displacement of the  people and resentment against influence of elites drawn from President Filipe  Nyusi’s Makonde tribe. Mentioning that the group primarily consists of unemployed  youth\, Ms. Beri stated that the lure of ideology as well as material benefits  were motivational factors to join the terror group. The leadership of the group  made up of committed jihadists from Islamist networks in the east African Coast  demands the imposition of rule of Sharia Law\, has strengthened its hold over  time and has acquired capability to operate in coastal waters. Although not  much is known about the group’s funding mechanism\, it is clear that the  economic base is in northern Mozambique and is connected to the illicit  economy. \n  After providing a background of the terror group\, Ms.  Beri emphasised on the reasons and need for international community to take  note of the terrorism in Mozambique. Alarms have been raised by various  international actors on the rise of terrorism in Mozambique. She shed light on  four factors for the rise in concern among the international community –  manifestation of terrorism\, natural resources\, response of the Mozambican  government and the organised crime network in the province. First\, the manifestation  of violent extremism in Mozambique is a new phenomenon for Southern Africa. Earlier  confined only to Tanzania\, it now has jihadi connections as well as associations  with the Islamic State of Central African province. Second\, the province of  Cabo Delgado is rich in natural resources. It has vast deposits of rubies and is  located close to Mozambique’s offshore natural gas deposits. It is estimated  that Mozambique holds about 100 trillion cubic feet of gas and offshores  fields\, and has been touted as the world’s next energy superpower in the  making. The escalation of violence has raised questions over the future of  extensive investments by big oil companies like Total\, Shell and ONGC Videsh  besides others which are involved in major offshore exploration projects. \n  Ms. Beri identified the third factor as the response  of the Mozambican government to stem the tide of terrorism. Despite support  from private military companies\, Mozambican security forces have been unable to prevent  the extremists from taking control of several towns. The deployment of the  South African Development Community (SADC) military forces and Rwandan troops  on the request of the Mozambican government has yielded some success in  countering the growing militancy in the province. Fourth\, the dynamic in Cabo  Delgado is amplified by the organised crime network involved in illegal trading  of timber and rubies in cities like Mocímboa da Praia and Pemba. Reports show that Cabo Delgado is  a key point for narcotics trade in the region and trafficking of heroin from Afghanistan  via Pakistan. The speaker stated that narcotic trade may be funding the terror  activities of Al-Shabab in the region. \n  Ms. Beri underscored the close ties shared between  India and Mozambique and shed light on the implications of the security crisis  on India’s interests in the region. She stated that the current conflict has  implications on India’s close cooperation in food\, energy and maritime security  spheres. Indian companies are heavily invested in the energy sector and India  also imports pulses from Mozambique. The speaker highlighted that the maritime  region around Mozambique was crucial for India-Mozambique defence partnership  and India’s strategic outreach to the Vanilla Islands. She underlined the  maritime cooperation shared between the Indian Navy and Mozambique; including  delivery of fast interceptor boats during Raksha Mantri Rajnath Singh’s visit  in 2019; and shed light on the training programme by India to Mozambican  defence armed forces. \n  Ms. Beri assessed that if the conflict continues\,  humanitarian crisis is likely to grip Mozambique and the wider region would  descent to instability. The crisis would influence all aspects of Mozambican  economy and impact India’s investments. Stating the existing fear that  terrorists may relocate to other areas in the country\, Ms. Beri suggested that  besides military action\, the Mozambican government must open dialogue with the in  the region. She proposed that India must consider its options in Mozambique\, increase  its consultations with the local government and with external actors and  leverage its credentials as a non-permanent member of the United Nations  Security Council (UNSC) and observer status in the SADC and UN. Ms. Beri  concluded by stating that bilaterally India could assist Mozambique in counter-terrorism  training and share intelligence at a regular basis. \n  Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, DG\, MP-IDSA shared his remarks  on the theme. He began by complimenting Ms. Beri for her presentation which  shed light on all salient aspects of the rise of terrorism in Mozambique and  succinctly brought out the importance that Mozambique holds for India in  historical as well as contemporary political\, economic and energy dimensions.  Mentioning that the close bilateral ties are not new\, Amb. Chinoy stated that  the eastern seaboard of Africa has always been of great significance to India’s  external engagement across the western Indian Ocean Region. He highlighted the  level of integration shared between people of African origin and Indians\, and drew  concern to the type of terrorism in Mozambique that has emerged over the last  two decades interlinked to the demise of Al Qaeda. He identified that offshoot  local terrorist movements are ideologically driven and seek  internationalisation by congruence with larger established outfits like Al  Qaeda and ISIS. Amb. Chinoy shared that besides working closely with the  Mozambican authorities\, India could engage with countries like Portugal and  Brazil to evolve greater consensus in the region. Stating that ‘what happens in  Mozambique\, will not stay in Mozambique’\, he concluded by appreciating Ms.  Beri’s talk for highlighting what’s ahead and why it is important. \n  The speaker responded by agreeing to the comments on  the historical ties shared between India and Mozambique\, shed light on the role  of Indian diaspora in Mozambique’s economy and provided an insight into the  complexity of the terrorism in the continent. On partnering with Portugal and  Brazil in Africa\, Ms. Beri mentioned India’s policy efforts to connect with the  Portuguese in Africa\, India’s TEAM-9 initiative and Brazil’s investment in  natural resources sector in Africa. The webinar concluded with an engaging Q/A  session with inputs on target of Al-Shabab which inflicts violence on its own  people more than government installations; international sanctions against the  terror group; concerns on influence of external terror outfits which could  further radicalise the population; concerns on the involvement and future of  SADC forces in the conflict; China’s limited involvement in Mozambique and  India’s close defence and security cooperation with Mozambique. \n  \nReport  prepared by Ms. Sindhu Dinesh\, Research Analyst\, ALACUN Centre\, MP-IDSA
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-unpacking-the-rise-of-terrorism-in-mozambique
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211011T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211011T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132745Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250308T060418Z
UID:63050-1633930200-1633930200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Webinar on Political Trends in Iraq and Challenge for Stability
DESCRIPTION:Event Report\nMs Nagapushpa Devendra\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA\, spoke on the topic “Political Trends in Iraq and Challenge for  Stability” at the Monday Morning Webinar held on 11 October 2021 at 10 am. The webinar  was chaired by Dr Muddassir Quamar\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA. Dr Lakshmi Priya\,  Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA and Dr Jatin Kumar\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA  participated as panellists.   \nExecutive Summary\nMs Nagapushpa Devendra analysed the political trends and  outcomes in Iraq\, especially in light of the parliamentary elections held on 10  October 2021. Following a brief overview of the existing political situation\, the  speaker highlighted the latest electoral trends and political compositions  grounded in the sectarian divisions. Furthermore\, she underlined the economic  turmoil and its major fallouts on the people which have influenced their  political decisions. The presentation also dealt with India–Iraq relations and  the areas of potential cooperation. Iraq’s relations with the other regional  countries\, the challenges that follow and its importance in maintaining  regional stability were also analysed. \nDetailed Report\nDr Muddassir Quamar in his introductory remarks stated that Iraq has  been going through a difficult time since 2003\, after the fall of Saddam Hussein.   It is affected by identity-based politics grounded in sectarianism\, religious  extremism and ethnic and tribal divisions. In the last few years\, it has also  faced other difficult challenges\, including COVID-19 pandemic\, economic  mismanagement and political turbulence and demonstrations which have further  aggravated the political situation causing instability. Following a brief  background along with the mention of the latest parliamentary elections held in  Iraq on 10 October 2021\, he handed over the floor to the speaker.   \n  Ms Nagapushpa Devendra started her  presentation by giving a background of the political situation in Iraq since  the defeat of the Islamic State (IS). She said that the first elections were  held in 2018\, but it was only in 2019 that a new government could be formed  under Adel Abdul-Mahdi who was forced to resign in December 2019 after protests  broke out against his government. Mustafa Al-Kadhimi became the prime minister  in May 2020.  She further discussed the 2019 Iraqi protests\, namely  Tishreen Movement\, which stemmed from the disillusionment among Iraqis against the  political system and governance failure. Their demands included an end to  institutionalised corruption\, electoral reforms\, a government of technocrats  and early elections.   \n  Ms Devendra stated a few reasons for Iraq’s early  parliamentary elections including the outbreak of COVID-19 pandemic and price  competition among the OPEC (Organization  of the Petroleum Exporting Countries) such as  Russia\, Saudi Arabia and the UAE. Since Iraq’s economy is heavily dependent on  revenue generated by oil export\, it suffered greatly when oil prices were hit  as a result of the price competition. All these factors\, clubbed with the  internal disturbance and the previously persisting economic and political  situation pushed Iraqi leadership to hold early elections in 2021\, which were originally  scheduled for 2022.      \n  Before discussing the election results\, Ms Devendra gave an overview of the  reformed electoral laws introduced in 2021. The new laws have made it easier for smaller parties  and independent candidates to contest the elections\, although with certain  pre-existing roadblocks.  \n  Ms Devendra discussed the  participation of various political blocs such as Shia\, Sunni and Kurds in  October 2021 elections. According to her\, the Sadrist Movement\, backed by the  prominent Shiite cleric Muqtada al-Sadr\, has a good chance of winning the  largest Shiite vote.  \n  With regards to Sunni bloc\, the competition is expected to take place  between two major political groups\, Civil Democratic Forces Alliance\, headed by  current parliament speaker Mohammed Al Halbousi and Azem Iraq Alliance\, headed  by businessman Khamis Al-Khanjar. Currently Sunni parties together hold 73  seats in the parliament and their leaders claim that it will reach 80–90 seats  after the approval of 83 electoral districts.  \n  With regards to Kurdish bloc\, the speaker opined that two political  parties\, namely\, Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) and Patriotic Union of  Kurdistan (PUK) may secure a majority of seats in the semi-autonomous region of  Kurdistan. In her view\, the KDP coalition is expected to dominate in the  Kurdish provinces of Erbil and Duhok. Apart from the above two parties\, the  Kurdistan coalition is another major Kurdish group. Ms Devendra said that in  this election a great divide was seen among the Kurdish people\, as observed by  the campaigning methods.   \n  The speaker also mentioned the two newly formed political parties\,  namely\, Harakat al-Waei and Hezbollah Brigades\, which contested the  parliamentary elections this year. She observed a change in the campaign agenda  of the parties\, wherein most of the candidates promised to fulfil the domestic  needs of the Iraqis such as offering jobs\, goods and services and  infrastructural projects\, to name a few.     \n  The speaker went on to elaborate on the possible outcomes of the  election. Firstly\, a likely division between the two major Shia parties\,  namely\, Sadrist and Fatah can be foreseen. Secondly\, the presidency is likely  to go to the PUK as has happened in the previous elections. Thirdly\, there may  be an end of opposition from smaller parties in Kurdistan\, since Patriotic  Movement of Kurdistan has joined the largest opposition group namely Gorran Movement to solve its  leadership crisis. Lastly\, in order to be a part of the next government the  Sunni and Kurdish parties will have to come together with the Shia  victors.   \n  According to the speaker\, regional and international actors want Kadhimi  to continue as prime minister since Iraq has witnessed relative stability under  his leadership. He initiated domestic reforms to create jobs and improve the  living standard of Iraqi people. In addition\, he brought together the key  regional countries to discuss the developmental issues in the Baghdad Conference\,  held recently in Iraq.   \n  Ms Devendra discussed the challenges faced by Iraq under two heads  namely\, domestic and regional. The domestic challenges include the following.  First\, elections will yield a larger number of smaller blocs in the parliament\,  which would make government formation and decision-making difficult. Second\, it  will be a difficult task to deal with corruption and unemployment\, undertake  major reforms\, prevent resurgence of ISIS and keep COVID-19 crisis under  control. Third\, asserting control over some of the pro-Iranian armed groups  will pose another major problem.   \n  While discussing the regional challenges\, she underlined that the US’  withdrawal of troops will be a major security challenge for the new Iraqi  government. On China’s engagement with Iraq\, the speaker said that China is  working to integrate Iraq into its “predatory” Belt and Road  Initiative (BRI). The economic investments under the same initiative will not  stabilise Iraq. According to her\, anti-US actors in the country frame Chinese  Belt and Road investments as a potential alternative to US economic support.  Regarding Russia\, the speaker said that its growing ties with the Iranian proxy  militias in Iraq could threaten not only Iraqi stability but also US’ interests  in Iraq and Syria.    \n  Ms Devendra elaborated on the various areas of India and Iraq  engagements. India’s economic engagements with Iraq range from increased  bilateral trade\, India becoming a preferred medical help destination for Iraqis  to participation of Iraqi pharmaceutical companies in Indian events.  Furthermore\, India and Iraq share common regional concerns over various  countries such as Syria\, Turkey and Iran\, to name a few. India has also been  actively participating in Iraq’s political realm by extending support towards  any initiative which strengthens Iraq’s democratic exercise.   \n  The speaker suggested various potential areas for strengthening India–Iraq  relations. In her view\, the areas which could be actively explored include  developing trade agreement\, establishing virtual platforms of outreach\, India’s  use of soft power in Iraq and undertaking capacity building of Iraqi security  forces to counter terrorism. This would help ensure stability in Iraq which is  of regional interest for West Asia and the global community.   \n  Following Ms Devendra’s reflection on Iraqi political  scenario and elections\, Dr Muddassir Quamar highlighted and summarised the  major problems in Iraq such as that of the two-fold challenges faced by the  current political leadership. These include the domestic economic and political  turmoil and a significant influence of external powers in Iraq along with that  of the armed militias within the country. He concluded by thanking Ms Devendra  again for her valuable insights into the above-mentioned issues and then  invited suggestions and questions from the other panellists namely Dr Jatin  Kumar and Dr Lakshmi Priya who underlined the issue of the lower turnout as a  result of voter’s disgruntlement against the ruling elites and lack of  confidence in the political system.  \n**************** \nReport prepared  by Dr Jatin Kumar\, Research Analyst\, West Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA \nDownload Complete [PDF]
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-webinar-on-political-trends-in-iraq-and-challenge-for-stability
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211006T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211007T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231224T112035Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240227T032655Z
UID:64572-1633498200-1633584600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:54th ANNUAL GENERAL BODY MEETING
DESCRIPTION:The 54th Annual General Body Meeting (AGM) of the Manohar Parrikar    Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) will be held on             06th October\, 2021 at 1200 hours at the MP-IDSA Auditorium. Individual invitations to the Life Members and Members have already been mailed. However\, any Life member and Member who may not have received the same due to any reason may treat this as a notice for the meeting. \nPlease note that only LIFE MEMBERS AND MEMBERS form the General Body of the Institute. \nNorms of social distancing and other COVID-19 related precautionary measures will be ensured.  \nFor any clarification please contact. \n\n\nCol Rajeev Agarwal (Retd)\nAssistant Director\nTele: 2671 7983\, Extn. 7301\n  Fax:          26154192 (DG)\n  26154191 (DDG)\n26146833 (AD) (Telefax)
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/54th-annual-general-body-meeting
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211001T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20211001T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132745Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250308T060538Z
UID:63051-1633066200-1633066200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Seminar on “India and UN Peacekeeping – An Appraisal”
DESCRIPTION:Event Report [PDF] \nProgramme [PDF] \nSpeaker Profile [PDF]
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/seminar-on-india-and-un-peacekeeping-an-appraisal
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20210927T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20210927T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132806Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250308T060702Z
UID:63052-1632720600-1632720600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:MP-IDSA Monday Morning Webinar on Anatomy of AUKUS Nuclear Submarine Deal and Key Takeaways
DESCRIPTION:Event  Report\nCmde Abhay K. Singh\,  Retd\, Research Fellow\, Military Affairs Centre\, MP-IDSA spoke on the topic “Anatomy of AUKUS Nuclear  Submarine Deal and Key Takeaways” at the Monday Morning Webinar held on 27  September 2021 at 10 AM. The webinar was chaired by Dr Jagannath P. Panda\,  Research Fellow\, MP-IDSA.\n  Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Ambassador Sujan  R. Chinoy; Deputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr) Bipin Bakshi\, Retd\,  and scholars & members of the Institute  attended the webinar. \nExecutive Summary\nDeciphering the complexities of the AUKUS (Australia\, UK  and US) Nuclear Submarine Deal was the key focus of the webinar\, where Australia’s  decision to cancel its deal to procure conventional attack submarines from  France and acquire nuclear submarines through a trilateral security pact was  extensively discussed. The analysis of Australia’s naval history reveals that  the Australian Government had several times in the past opted for conventional  submarines over nuclear submarines in the 1960s\, 1980s and 2010\, taking into  consideration cost-effectiveness\, combat capability and the strategic  requirements. However\, the deteriorating strategic conditions of the region  have forced Australia to backtrack from its 2016 decision to acquire  conventional attack submarines from France and enter into a trilateral pact to  procure nuclear submarines from the US and the UK.  \nInsecurity over China’s aggressive military and economic  expansion has been cited as the key factor behind Australia’s decision to  procure nuclear submarines. The AUKUS puts Australia in the vanguard of the  political alignment posed to counter the rise of China. Australia’s intended  patrol stations are concentrated between the Sea of Japan in the East and the  Malacca Straits in the West pointing out that Australia views China as the most  important security concern. The AUKUS may not undermine QUAD\, or the Quadrilateral  Security Dialogue (QSD)\, and both alliances are likely to be complementary to  each other. It was stated that the French reaction to Australia cancelling the  attack submarine deal was exaggerated by the media. AUKUS’s potential to  promote regional stability can only be ascertained by assessing the long-term  implications of the trilateral pact. \nDetailed Report\nDr Jagannath P. Panda commenced the session with his opening remarks about the topic by  referring to AUKUS as a trilateral security pact focused on intelligence  sharing on secret technology of building nuclear-powered submarines.  \nCmde Abhay K. Singh\, Retd\, began his presentation by exploring the rationale of  Australia’s decision towards AUKUS and its geo-political implications. Explaining  the overwhelming superiority of nuclear submarines over conventional submarines  including the ones with the advanced air-independent propulsion in terms of  speed\, range and combat capability\, Cmde Singh elucidated the rationale behind the  Australian Government’s decision to acquire American-built nuclear submarines instead  of French-built conventional submarines. Cmde Singh then went on to chronicle  the Royal Australian Navy’s (RAN) long history of operating submarines from as  early as 1913. But the narrow industrial base combined with their extensive  dependence on the British Navy led to Australia being unable to develop  indigenous submarine building capability. The deliberation by the Australian leadership  to raise independent maritime capability started in the 1950s when the  withdrawal of British Navy from the Indian Ocean became evident.\n  By 1959\, taking into account the  cost-effectiveness and simplicity in operation of conventional submarines\, the  Australian leadership was convinced that they would be sufficient to meet the  strategic requirements of that time. As a result\, the RAN acquired six British  manufactured Oberon Class that operated from 1967 to 2000. In the 1980s once again  the debate over nuclear versus conventional submarines arose when the  Australian Government began deliberating on replacing the existing Oberon Class  submarines. Cmde Singh stated that the high maintenance cost of the Oberon Class  and heavy dependence on British technical support convinced the Australian  Government to indigenously build the revolutionary Collins Class submarines in  collaboration with Sweden\, thereby improving the defence industrial base of  Australia. \nCmde Singh explained how in 2009 Australia  initiated the Future Submarine Programme (FSP) to acquire submarines possessing  greater range\, longer endurance and enhanced combat capabilities than the  existing Collins Class submarines. Once again the debate over the propulsion system  of FSP began and Australia took into consideration RAN’s requirement to  establish patrol stations from the Sea of Japan to Malacca Straits. Although it  became clear that only nuclear submarines can meet RAN’s strategic requirements  to carry out prolonged covert patrols but the absence of nuclear energy  industry and no availability of bipartisan consensus for nuclear propulsion  once again led to Australia opting for conventional submarines. French Shortfin  Barracuda\, German Type 216 and Japanese Soryu Class submarines were among the  contenders of the FSP race\, out of which French Shortfin Barracuda was selected  by the Australian Government for acquisition at an estimated cost of over $50  billion.  \nCmde Singh pointed out how shortly after the  deal was finalised\, the programme came under extensive media scrutiny over the document  leak of India’s Scorpene submarines\, delays and cost overruns. This prompted  the Australian Government to review its decision regarding the French attack  submarines\, taking into consideration the deteriorating strategic environment\,  the indispensable requirement of nuclear submarines to confront the strategic  threat and the manageability of the fall-out of the conventional attack submarine  deal with France\, all of which culminated in Australia’s decision to acquire  nuclear submarines through the AUKUS trilateral security pact. Cmde Singh  concluded his presentation by stating that AUKUS’s potential to provide  strategic stability\, initiate a regional arms race\, undermine QUAD\, including its  impact on India’s nuclear submarine programme\, is yet to be assessed by  observing unfolding developments of the future. \nIn the discussion that followed\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\,  MP-IDSA remarked that China’s growing military and economic rise is the key reason  behind growing security concerns amongst nations in the region including  Australia. He further commented that through AUKUS\, Australia strengthened its  resolve into becoming the strongest link in the global political configuration  to counter China’s aggressive growth. The French reaction to the cancellation  of the submarine deal was overblown by the media by citing how both France and  the US have quickly re-engaged with each other on security and strategic  cooperation. The Director General encouraged further deliberation on assessing  the implications of Australia’s move for India’s maritime security and also for  the nuclear non-proliferation regime. Maj.  Gen. Bipin Bakshi\, Retd\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA pointed out how Australia  had expressed apprehensions towards India’s growing naval power in the 1990s  and conversely at present no longer views India as a threat which is evident  from the concentration of RAN’s patrol stations towards the North. He further  stated that AUKUS may not undermine QUAD nor would it transform into a new  security alliance. \nBrigadier Satyavrat Pagay\, currently Research Fellow at MP-IDSA\, opined that AUKUS is essentially an American-backed  alliance to counter China. He expressed the need for India to deliberate on  whether India’s strategic autonomy can be preserved by becoming a part of QUAD  and if AUKUS has the potential to benefit India during military conflict. He  also brought out that to counter AUKUS\, China may endow Pakistan with military  assets and technology which would change the balance of power in the region.  Taking into consideration the unresolved border issues with China\, Brigadier  Pagay stated that India must deliberate on whether it would be able to balance  its budgetary allocation between land-centric forces and the navy.  \nDr Rajiv Nayan\, Senior Research Associate\, MP-IDSA\, commenting on the ramifications of AUKUS to  the non-proliferation regime\, stated that the US has always been reluctant to  share even low enriched uranium-powered nuclear submarines even with close  allies like Australia and Canada in the past. Therefore\, US’s recent decision  to supply Australia with submarines powered by high enriched uranium reactors  has resulted in several nations raising eyebrows. He further stated that the  existing non-proliferation treaties lack any clear definition regarding nuclear  submarines as weapon platforms and hence are unlikely to have any serious  ramifications.    \nDuring the Q&A session\, in response to the question on why Australia’s  intended submarine patrol stations did not go beyond the South China Sea into  the Indian Ocean\, Cmde Singh stated that submarine deployment is based on the  respective nation’s threat perceptions and hence Australia’s submarine patrol  stations are concentrated towards the north with a focus on China. Responding to  another question comparing force structure and budgeting of India and  Australia\, Cmde Singh stated that there can be no comparison as Australia’s  expenditure towards Defence has always been minimal as it is part of a security  alliance that can cater to its security requirement. Responding to a question  on whether AUKUS undermines QUAD\, Cmde Singh stated that both the alliances are  complementary to each other. On being asked whether India in any way can take  advantage of the situation by enhancing its security cooperation with France\,  Cmde Singh stated that due to the cancellation of the submarine deal with  Australia\, France will have surplus production capability thereby allowing  India to utilise it for its own military acquisition.   \nKey Takeaways:\n\nThe deteriorating strategic environment due to China’s aggressive  military and economic expansion is the key factor behind the creation of AUKUS.\nAUKUS is not likely to undermine the existing QUAD but rather both  alliances will be complementary to each other.\nAustralia through AUKUS has consolidated itself into becoming one of the  strongest links in the political configuration formed to counter China.  \nFrance’s reaction to Australia’s cancellation of the multi-billion  dollar attack submarine deal has been exaggerated by the media. \nEven with the acquisition of the nuclear submarine\, Australia’s military  capability will extensively be dependent on its security alliance partners. \n\nReport prepared by Mr R. Vignesh\, Research  Analyst\, Military Affairs Centre\, MP-IDSA \n \nDownload Event Report [PDF]
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/mp-idsa-monday-morning-webinar-on-anatomy-of-aukus-nuclear-submarine-deal-and-key-takeaways
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20210727T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20210727T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132806Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130549Z
UID:63053-1627363800-1627363800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Webinar on Global Geopolitics and Regional Security Environment in West Asia
DESCRIPTION:The Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses and The Strategic Studies Centre\, Cairo \nIs organising a webinar on \n“Global Geopolitics and Regional Security Environment in West Asia” \nAmb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General MP-IDSA and Staff General Adel Mohamed Hassan Eldeeb\, Director Strategic Studies Centre Cairo\, will lead the Webinar on both sides. \nThe Programme of the Webinar is attached. \nDownload Event Report [PDF] \n\nExecutive Summary \nWebinar on “Global  Geopolitics and Regional Security Environment in West Asia” organised by the  Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) and  the Strategic Studies Centre (SSC)\, Cairo\, on July 27\, 2021.  \n\nThe world is experiencing a major  global geo-economic shift and COVID-19 pandemic has acted as an accentuating factor.  China’s economic rise has been accompanied by unilateralism and a military  assertiveness that is bound to be resisted by all peace-loving nations.  Technology\, particularly in fields of telecom\, Artificial Intelligence\,  cyberspace and data security are the new battle grounds. \nChinese bid to bring trade diplomacy  in South Asia has brought a new challenge in India’s neighbourhood. The most challenging  aspect of the security is the unfolding situation in Afghanistan. Taliban is  coming back with great momentum and is trying to establish its hold in  Afghanistan in a violent manner. Regional cooperation is needed to contain this  issue but Pakistan is not on board. If the issue is not contained the region  will become a breeding ground for fundamentalism which will further increase  the security challenges. \nFor India\, Indo-Pacific is gaining  currency as a vastly more inclusive concept in terms of economic prosperity in  a much wider region. The Biden Administration has taken a more engaging outlook towards  the Indo-Pacific region. His policies towards Asia include more focus on  multilateral mode of engagement with respect to climate change\, trade\, connectivity  and development; focus on building a responsive partnership with Japan and  South Korea; continuing rivalry with China and to remain engaged in the Korean  peninsula. \nScholars from the SSC stated that the previous US administration’s ‘maximum  pressure’ policy that pushed Iran to the corner has affected the regional  security and stability. On the other hand\, the activities of Iran-backed  proxies or armed groups increased in the region\, particularly in Syria and  Yemen and has caused serious security concerns for the regional countries. \nParticipants from SSC argued that for  the Biden Administration\, the case of Iranian nuclear deal remains a top  priority. Ho in their policies and perspectives towards each other and the  region. They argued that given the change of  behaviour from both the parties\, an amended nuclear deal is possible\, if Iran  adheres to the JCPOA and the US removes sanctions on Iran. \nEgypt believes that Israel wants to  be the only state with nuclear power in the region. Its policies are to ensure  that no other state possess such power. Israel is working with the US\, and other Western countries to ensure  sanctions on Iran to continue so as to force Iran to abandon its nuclear  programme. \nThe situation between Iran-Israel  will continue to remain tense. Tehran’s support to Assad regime\, and groups  like Lebanese Hezbollah and Hamas will continue to challenge Israel’s national  security.\nTurkey is following a Neo-Ottoman  policy in West Asia which has alarmed other key regional players. Its policies have  led to several problems in the African countries especially in Libya. Also\,  with its new maritime ambitions\, Turkey intends to expand its naval presence in  the Horn of Africa\, Red Sea and Persian Gulf regions. It taken steps to enhance  its naval capacity in the region\, especially Africa which has led to serious  fictions between Turkey and other regional powers like Saudi Arabia\, UAE and  Egypt.\nFor India the goal is to achieve  rapid and inclusive economic growth in a stable and peaceful environment. Our  strategic autonomy is better today. India is non-permanent member in the UNSC that  has given it a fresh opportunity to engage with partners including Egypt and to  help strengthen multilateralism.\n Egypt’s role has become more significant as it  has taken a number of steps to stabilise the region by rooting out terror  groups\, minimising internal conflicts and preventing regional turmoil in Libya  and Palestine. Egypt played a critical role in bringing a temporary truce between  Israel and Hamas in May this year\, which was praised by the international  community. Egypt’s position on Libya as well as Mediterranean region is to  balance Turkey’s presence in the region. \n Counter-terrorism has emerged as one of the  leading areas of cooperation between India and Egypt. There are several  mechanisms including regular cooperation between the Ministry of Defence of two  countries and the Joint cooperation committee’s regular meetings between senior  officials from both sides. \n India and Egypt that have common interests in  security and the stability of the West Asian region to strengthen their  partnership. It is imperative for both the countries to cooperate and  coordinate on regional security\, especially in the area of strategic  cooperation.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/webinar-on-global-geopolitics-and-regional-security-environment-in-west-asia
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20191217T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20191217T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132807Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250311T064120Z
UID:63056-1576560600-1576560600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:10th Y.B. Chavan Memorial Lecture
DESCRIPTION:Download Programme [+]
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/10th-y-b-chavan-memorial-lecture
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20190717T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20190717T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132906Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130737Z
UID:63057-1563341400-1563341400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Round Table Discussion on "A Study of the Kural: Concepts and Themes"
DESCRIPTION:Venue: Room No. 005\, IDSA  \n    Date: July 17\, 2019  \nThe discussion was initiated by Director General\, IDSA\, Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy. In his welcome remarks\, he observed that the Indian strategic thought in the  last five years has been more anchored in India’s own strategic ethos than ever  before. He highlighted the growing relevance of vernacular languages to foster out-of-box thinking which has enabled people with linguistic skills to gain meaningful employment in both public and private sectors.    \n  Amb. Chinoy raised a few questions\, based on the history of invasions into  India\, for the lead discussant\, Col. P.K. Gautam (Retd.)\, to incorporate  in his presentation. These include:   \n\nHas the Indian strategic thought ever been  linear in terms of shaping the decision making of the dynasties that ruled  India? \nGiven the history of Mughal and British rule in  India\, did the local rulers and the people inculcate the traditional Indian  ethos in their strategic thinking?\nWhat happened to the Indian strategic culture during these ‘long  centuries’?  \nHas any historical study been conducted ever before  to examine these issues or are they only now gaining traction\, given the fact  that today India is in-charge of its destiny?\n\nThe  Chair of the discussion\, Amb. R. Rajagopalan\, highlighted the ongoing debate  about India’s existing strategic culture. He argued that India’s strategic  culture is often used impulsively rather than being based on an objective  definition. While stressing the presence of a strong strategic culture in  India\, he lamented the fact that the majority of the country’s scholarly  literature is focussed on Kautilya. He highlighted 10 other schools of thought  which are yet to be explored. He also dwelt on the lack of enthusiasm as well  as platforms for Indian scholars vis-à-vis their international peers to study  India’s strategic culture. He observed that one of the best translations of Thirukural is by a British national.    \nAmb.  Rajagopalan further stated that India’s strategic culture is not monolithic but  is rather mosaic. However\, as a composite\, it is more coherent than in most  contemporary nation-states\, including the United States.   \nHe  argued that Thirukural (Kural in short) is not a sacred text. He observed that Thirukural is a  combination of the words Thiru and Kural. The word Thiru denotes sanctity (sacredness) of Kurals\,  and Kural signifies short verses (couplets). Thirukural\, meaning ‘sacred  couplets’\, is considered equivalent to the Vedas\, and is one of the most  important works in the Tamil language. It is also called the masterpiece of  Tamil literature. However\, it is not a religious text since it highlights a  commoner’s way of life and offers perspective on various things. Also\, the  followers had bestowed the honour of Thiru on its author Valluvar\, and  therefore the name – Thiruvalluvar.   \nHighlighting  the differences and similarities between Kautilya’s Arthashastra and  Thiruvalluvar’s Thirukural\, Amb. Rajagopalan pointed out that Kautilya  was a man in the king’s court responsible for advising the king\, whereas Thiruvalluvar  was a common weaver who spoke about everything in his text\, including  statecraft.   \nThe lead  discussant of the session\, Col. Gautam\, began  his presentation by pointing out that Thirukural is a 2\,000-year-old Tamil book that compresses 133  different topics into poetry. These topics range from war (like Sun Tzu) to  economics (like Kautilya)\, and good governance to social reforms. The text is also cognisant of the institutions of war  and national interest\, and the instruments of exercising state power. It  has pragmatic advice for the ruler\, and is\, therefore\, among the most complete philosophical works.      \nElaborating further on Thirukural\, Col.  Gautam informed that it consists of 1\,330 Kurals  divided into 133 chapters called Adhikaram.  The entire work is divided into three sections – Aram\, Porul and Inbam\, meaning dharma/virtue\, wealth/goods  and pleasure/love respectively. Out of the four aspects of Purushartha – Aram\, Porul\,  Inbam and Veedu (Moksha) – Thirukural addresses  only the first three and advocates the path to Veedu through the others\, as a result of which it is called Muppal (three elements) and Muppalil Narporul (four aspects in three  elements). Its uniqueness lies in its method to attain Moksha (Veedu) through  the other three elements and by following a married life based on dharma.  \nCol. Gautam illustrated this in the following structure:   \n\n38 Adhikarams  (380 Kurals) in Aram section.  \n70 Adhikarams(700 Kurals) in Porul section.  \n25 Adhikarams  (250 Kurals) in Inbam section.  \n\n According to Col. Gautam\, “Kural is not a moral utopian sermon.  It recognises political realism in a world where till date there is no world society  or world government. This calls for building alliances (friends)\, armed forces supported  by treasury\, secured urban centres led by an able king who is advised by  competent ministers\, productive countryside and upright people. If all the  above conditions blend-in with political virtue and legitimacy\, a state can  emerge prosperous and ensure good life for its subjects.”   \nCol. Gautam also highlighted the Thirukural’s political and economic  relevance that can be applied in modern times. These include:   \n\nKing’s Qualities and Duties (Chapters 39-46):  This  section is a lesson on good governance. There are three sources of income for the  king – unclaimed wealth\, taxes\, and customs collection from the foreigners. In  Valluvar’s world\, there were three channels of equitable distribution of wealth  – defence\, public works and social service. The kurals were primarily addressed to the King\, but many of them  applied to people in equal measure. Today\, democracies have replaced kingdoms while  political parties and ministers have replaced kings. The qualities that Thiruvalluvar  attributes to kings are naturally expected to be found in our leaders. \nEconomic Planning (Chapters 47-50): This section is a lesson on economic governance.  According to Valluvar\, “the energy and effort spent on action without adequate  prior planning will not produce the desired result.” Today\, this is referred to  as the cost-benefit analysis. Similarly\, Verse 478 is an excellent principle of  public finance and financial administration – “If the revenue of the State is limited\, the king should keep the  expenditure within bounds.” Our failure in economic development reflects  our inefficient planning and implementation. \nQualities of Ministers (Chapters 64-68):  These chapters consist of dissertations on ministers – their  qualifications\, characteristics and activities. This is an important section on  statecraft. “A Minister is one who makes excellent consideration of time\,  means\, place\, manner and the difficulties. He excels in firmness\, knowledge\,  preference and protection of subjects. He gives sound advice to the king and  people. A Minister must possess – power of speech (because wealth and evil  result from his speech)\, firm in action and proper consultation. Far better are  the seventy crores of enemies for a king than an unfaithful minister at his  side.”\nThere is also a chapter on management techniques and decision-making processes. “A minister is  conversant with the best methods of performance; he should avoid actions that  yield no benefit or bring grief to the king. Even though he may see his mother  starve\, he should not act hastily.” After considerable thought\, planning and  analysis\, one arrives at a decision. One should not back out once a decision  has been made.   \n\nEnvoy/Ambassador (Chapter 69) and King’s Advisers  (Chapter 70): Chapter 69  is on diplomacy. “Envoy should have: love for the king\, knowledge of his  affairs\, pleasing attributes; power of speech and ability to bring glory to his  country. The ambassador should fearlessly seek his country’s good even though  it might cost him his life.” In Chapter 70\, Valluvar says that an adviser to the ruler “should give firm  advice to rectify errors”. In comparison\, today’s advisers (secretaries to ministers)  often hesitate in giving credible advice. \nGood Army and Soldiers (Chapters 77-78): In this section\, Valluvar talks about valour and  honour. He says\, “the army that conquers without fear is the chief wealth of  the king.” A good army is one that stands firm. It must be capable of resisting  unitedly. An army cannot last long without brave generals. “What if a host of  rats roar like the sea? They will perish at the mere breath of the cobra.”  Valluvar also says that it is the affection of the people that maintains the morale and efficiency of the army. If people  hate the army\, it will dwindle. The army in garrison has to be constantly  engaged\, otherwise\, it will lose its efficiency. “A soldier’s achievement is in  his valour; on the days he has not received wounds in action are days lost to  him.”  \n\nCol. Gautam observed that Thirukural also reflects Valluvar’s outlook on social reforms. For  example\, kurals33 and 93 on Kollamai (non-violence)  and Kallunnamai (abstinence from  alcohol)\, respectively\, highlight the anomalies found in the society during the  period\, which was also known as the Golden Era of Tamil Sangam\, and measures to  bring about changes.   \n Col. Gautam concluded by arguing that the need of the hour is to be inspired by Kural’s normative and didactic  philosophy. The values of aram or dharmais supreme. It is aram which regulates both porul and imbam.  Col. Gautam noted that even Mahatma Gandhi had taken a similar line in his Hind  Swaraj. The Kural in Tamil\, therefore\, adds value to the Indian heritage\,  and many of its ideas and concepts are relevant not only for contemporary  times but also the future.   \nFollowing points were raised during the ensuing discussion:  \n\nThirukural is not an ethical or moral literature. It is an  encyclopaedia of mankind\, and is\, therefore\, a universal script.\nThere is a lack of understanding of the Tamil  literature. For instance\, a majority of people fail to understand the existence  of male and female perspectives in the Sangam literature.\nThere is a need to explore ways in which Kural can be further interpreted in the  fields of political science\, defence\, engineering\, etc.\nShould texts like Kural not be made mandatory in education and government services  curriculum?\nThe debate revolving around Kural is ‘underrated’.\nIs Kural and  moral realism inter-linked? \n\n Report prepared by Ms. Nagapushpa Devendra\, Research Analyst\, IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/round-table-discussion-on-a-study-of-the-kural-concepts-and-themes
CATEGORIES:ROUND TABLES / WORKSHOPS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20190308T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20190308T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132906Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130738Z
UID:63058-1552023000-1552023000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Round Table Discussion on "States of Emergence\, States of Knowledge: A Comparative Sociology of International Relations in China and India"
DESCRIPTION:Topic: States of Emergence\, States of Knowledge: A Comparative Sociology of International Relations in China and India \nSpeaker: Dr. Peter Marcus Kristensen\, Associate Professor\, Department of Political Science\, University of Copenhagen \nCompiled by Rajrajeshwari Singh \n8 March 2019 \nDr Peter Marcus  Kristensen\, Associate Professor at the University of Copenhagen initiated a  discussion on the topic “States of Emergence\, States of Knowledge: A  Comparative Sociology of International Relations in China and India”.  \n  Kristensen’s paper is an outcome of  interviews conducted with members of the academic community in China and India.  Its aim is to examine the relationship between the geopolitical rise of these countries  in international relations and their knowledge production in the field of international  relations. The paper attempts to explore the theoretical and empirical  relationship between the socio-political condition of emerging/rising powers  and their attempts to theorise International Relations\, which it categorises as state of emergence and state of knowledge. Kristensen  highlighted the need to reject a bifurcation between Western IR and the ‘ir’ of  rising powers\, which is common in the sociological and historiographical  literature. The scholar community in rising powers has a view that is embedded  in the state of emergence in  different ways. Kristensen uses four registers – constitutive\, civic\, infrastructural and psychological – and  examines how the scholar community in India and China interacted with these  registers.  \n  The constitutive register which emerges from the state of emergence is concerned with the larger epistemological  order\, for instance\, the association between the growing global interests and  stakes of the rising powers and the epistemic objectives of their IR  scholarship. This register was more optimistically accepted in China. In India\,  a minority of scholars contended that new ‘Indian’ theories of IR should be  located within the framework of global IR theory. Moreover\, a significant  number of Indian scholars were sceptical of India’s emerging power status.  \n  The civic register is problem oriented and serves as a conjunction of  science and politics to address and solve real world problems. It has two  modes\, one to serve as policy advisor to the state\, and the second to perform  the function of a public intellectual and thereby enrich the public discourse  and understanding. The principal difference between China and India in this  regard is that Chinese scholars are more attuned to the role of policy advisors  whereas their Indian counterparts operate more in the public mode. \n  Infrastructural  register features the condition of economic growth and expansion of resources made  available for research. China has experienced immense growth in IR infrastructure\,  which has enabled a Chinese theoretical discourse to emerge. India’s more  gradual emergence has meant that its IR infrastructure has not expanded to the  extent that it has happened in China. Moreover\, Indian IR remains a-theoretical  and conflated with area studies. \n  Psychological  register is the sensibility or awareness of being located in a country that is perceived  as an emerging power. In China\, this sentiment is widespread\, which has not  only boosted the confidence of Chinese scholars but also their sense of wanting  the world to hear their Chinese voice. There is a similar sense of confidence in  India and receptivity to the views of Indian IR scholars abroad. However\,  Indian scholars also feel that only their contributions on India are valued\,  with Western IR still setting the agenda and confining Indian IR to an inferior  position. \n  Kristensen concluded by pointing  out that China and India differ in the co-productive knowledge with respect to  their histories. Different scholars had a different take on the state of  emergence. The differences between China and India are partly explained by the  more advanced rise of China. There is a stronger sense of ‘Chineseness’ within  China’s scholarly discourse\, something that is absent in India.  \n  The following points were raised in  the ensuing discussion: \n  S. Kalyanaraman pointed out that  Indian IR neglected theory partly because of its strong critique of Western IR  theory with its emphasis upon power politics and its efforts to reform the  international economic and security order through nonalignment and the pursuit  of peace. This situation has begun to change since the end of the Cold War with  India’s turn towards greater realism and its integration into the West-led  international economic and security order.  \n  Rajeesh Kumar highlighted the  multiple paths that the development of Indian IR is likely to take\, influenced as  it is by its own traditions as well as by Western IR theory and the inspiration  provided by the development of IR theory in China. \n  Deepshika Shahi of the University  of Delhi highlighted recent trends in IR theoretical development including her  own work on Advaita as a global IR theory. She also pointed out that India’s  diversity means the prevalence of multiple schools of IR theories.  \n  Nazir Mir highlighted the contribution  of the Indian subaltern school to the IR discourse. In addition\, he pointed out  the influence of external factors on the development of theory in the United  States in addition to the role of America’s self-perception of its role\, status  and interests in international affairs.  \n  Kristensen noted the importance of  avoiding regional labels to IR theories such as London School\, Copenhagen  School\, Chinese IR\, Indian IR\, etc.  \n  Kalyanaraman concluded the round  table by referring to the continuing validity of Martin Wight’s three-way  typology of realist\, rationalist\, and revolutionary approaches to IR as a  useful framework within which to apprehend the thought processes of thinkers  and scholars in non-Western countries.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/round-table-discussion-on-states-of-emergence-states-of-knowledge-a-comparative-sociology-of-international-relations-in-china-and-india
CATEGORIES:ROUND TABLES / WORKSHOPS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20180119T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20180119T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132907Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130236Z
UID:63061-1516339800-1516339800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:The Nitisara or the Elements of Polity by Kamandaka: Continuity and Change from Kautilya’s Arthashastra
DESCRIPTION:Chairperson: Amb A. N. D. Haksar (Retd)External Discussants: Prof. Jayati Srivastava\, Dr. Medha Bisht\, Dr. Saurabh MishraInternal Discussants: Gp. Capt. K. K. Khera\, Col. Vikrant Deshpande \nMajor Arguments of the Paper\nSince India is one of the longest surviving civilisations\, there is likelihood that principles of statecraft are continuing through ages. This paper probes this possibility and argues that many concepts and principles of statecraft in India have not changed and that continuity is embedded in the vocabulary and concepts in the Indian tradition. They have survived due to their own enduring logic. This paper compares Arthasastra and Nitisara and analyses the enduring continuities in statecraft\, diplomacy and aspects of warfare. It seeks answers to the following questions: (a) What are the continuities and changes in the vocabulary and concepts from Kautilya’s Arthasastra to Nitisara?; (b) What is the vocabulary of Kamandaka in a stand-alone mode?; and\, (c) What is the contemporary relevance of the answers to these findings?  \nThe author found both texts are ahistorical\, dealing with the acquisition of wealth and its distribution and emphasising on war as the last resort. Some common aspects adhered to in both the texts are: mastering of control over the senses including non-violence; the need to ensure that the state of matsyanyaya does not prevail; anvikshiki; maintaining balance among dharma\, artha and kama; importance of intelligence; the seven prakrits and twelve vijigisus in a circle of kings or mandala theory; six measures of foreign policy; the upayas in which there is no war mongering and use of force is the last resort; issues of disasters (vysanas) that may afflict the constituent elements (prakrits) and how to overcome them prior to the execution of a policy; duties of diplomats and intelligence gathering; and\, aspects of war and use of power by sticking to the priorities of mantra-shakti (counsel or diplomacy)\, prabhav-shakti (economic and military power)\, and utsah-shakti (leadership).  \nThe paper also points out the dissimilarities in concepts employed by the two texts. To begin with\, while Kautilya’s work is inspired by statesmanship and is of a complex nature often questioning earlier scholars\, Kamandaka’s is a lucid and academic work and an abridged version of the Arthasastra. In terms of uniqueness\, Kamandaka stands out for deliberating at length not only on the four upayas (as mentioned in the Arthasastra) of sama \, dana\,  bheda and danda but also the powerful concept of Upeksha (a combination of neglect or diplomatic indifference and the supreme virtue of patience) which was the strategy adopted by the Indian freedom movement. The impact of Kamandaka can be further seen on the Hitopadesa by Narayana\, which has 90 verses of Kamandaka including sixteen types of alliances. \nIn the end\, the paper argues that India’s geo-cultural space extends beyond the Himalayas up to Central Asia. This has also been highlighted by the History Division of the Ministry of External Affairs in the second White Paper published in 1959 “Historical Background of the Himalayan Frontier of India\,” in which the Raghuvamsha of Kalidas is mentioned. In both this White Paper and in the text of Kamandaka\, there is mention of the Kushan empire and Kanishka.       \nMajor points of discussion and suggestions to the author\n\nThe time frame of both the Arthasastra and Nitisara as well as the context in which they were written forms a significant background for the comparison process. Further\, the Buddhist influence on Kamandaka and Kautilya can enrich the paper by providing another dimension. \nThematic structuring of the paper can be done on the basis of Kamandaka’s notions on war\, tactics\, ethics\, dharma\, etc.\, and an overall idea can be given about what is distinctive about Indian texts as compared to western texts. \nWhen one approaches a non-western text\, the method adopted should be devoid of an interpretative orientation and frames of comparison. Further\, the techniques of communication should be picked carefully focusing on the inclusive macro tradition over multiple micro traditions.\nMethodology adopted by these texts can be discussed in the paper along with historical similarities and dissimilarities as well as political situation of that time while explaining the central themes of both\, mentioning their categorization along with the reason for dissimilarities and commonalities. \nThe difference between Nitisara and Arthasastra lies in the idea of legitimacy which changed over time. While Arthasastra was dependent on deliverance of kingly duties\, Nitisara focuses on valour and the military qualities of the ruler.\nAuthor’s personal opinion should come out more strongly amongst the commendable literature survey and referencing. And\, to extend its reach to the masses\, the paper can be made more lucid.\n\nReport prepared by Ms. Lakshmi Priya\, Research Assistant\, IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/the-nitisara-or-the-elements-of-polity-by-kamandaka-continuity-and-change-from-kautilyas-arthashastra
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20171222T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20171222T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132945Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130550Z
UID:63062-1513920600-1513920600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:A Strategic Perspective on the US National Security Strategy 2017: Report on an IDSA Panel Discussion
DESCRIPTION:The Trump administration released its National Security Strategy (NSS) document on December 18\, 2017. The document was released in the very first year of President Trump’s tenure\, cataloguing the themes in US strategic thinking and issues impacting both domestic and foreign policy. In comparison with previous iterations\, the latest NSS appears more direct and assertive\, hints at a sense of decline in American power in the wake of the rise of powers that have been termed revisionist and as posing a direct threat to the US position in the world. The language is harsh\, polarising and counterproductive for a superpower.  \nThe Trump administration’s national security strategy comprises of four pillars – Protect the American people\, the homeland and the American way of life; Promote American prosperity; Preserve peace through strength; and Advance American influence. Further\, the NSS 2017 also highlights America’s interests in various regions and its relations with individual countries.   \nSince the end of the Cold War\, the US viewed practically all countries of the world as a de facto partner in pushing globalization forward and in its crusade against terrorism. However\, with the changing security environment\, the outlook of the majority of nations has also changed. And from the latest NSS\, so has the outlook of the United States itself. \nThe document remarks that the current global order is characterised by great power competition. In the doctrine\, both Russia and China are named ‘competitors’\, while Iran and North Korea are called “rogue” states threatening the American way of life. They all are termed challengers to “American power\, influence and interests\, attempting to erode American security and prosperity”. The NSS asserts that the assumption that drove previous US administrations to engage and seek to integrate these rival powers\, namely\, that they will emerge as benign and trustworthy partners\, has failed. Further\, the NSS highlights Trump’s America first policy throughout\, but also states that America will cooperate with its allies and partners on the basis of reciprocity – sharing the responsibility and burdens. This is in contrast to previous US administrations\, which followed a high degree of unilateralism in security affairs but resorted to multilateralism in the economic domain. In addition\, the latest NSS also gives high priority to technological innovation and the protection of intellectual property.   \nThe NSS signals the official recognition that the grand strategy of liberal hegemony pursued since the early 1990s has only contributed to the weakening of America\, led to wasted expenditure of blood and treasure\, and not helped promote and preserve the American national interest; and hence is no longer viable. Further\, the previous grand strategy has neither succeeded in entrenching America’s global leadership nor in integrating China and Russia as obedient junior partners in the US-led liberal international order. The NSS clearly acknowledges and echoes the realist view that international politics is characterised by competition and contest for power and influence. \nOn China\nPart of the great power game brewing at the international level is an emerging competition between a progressive America and regressive China in the Indo-Pacific. The US pull out from the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) and its war of words with North Korea has enhanced China’s room for manoeuvre especially in the wake of the Xi Jinping’s consolidation of power at the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China (CPC).  \nIn previous NSS documents\, China’s rise was welcomed and its active participation in international institutions and forums was moderately appreciated. But the latest NSS portrays China negatively\, without offering even a slight token of appreciation. It also questions China’s growing presence in Asia\, Africa and Europe\, indirectly accuses China of engaging in the theft of intellectual property and views its hold over critical infrastructure\, growing nuclear capabilities\, unfair trade practices\, military modernisation and military outreach in South Asia and Southeast Asia as threatening the sovereignty of neighbours. Hence the promise of help held out to Asian nations to maintain their sovereignty. \nOn West Asia\nThe document also talks about putting an end to the hitherto undue importance accorded to the Israeli-Palestinian issue by focusing more on the immediate and dire problems facing West Asia like jihadism\, the growing influence of the Iranian “rogue regime” and the Syrian crisis. It talks of providing US allies with missile defence systems to ward off threats from Iran and the continuation of US military presence in the region. \nIn effect\, Trump’s approach to West Asia is marked by continuity with the long-term US foreign policy trajectory. It seeks to strengthen bonds with tested allies\, Saudi Arabia and Israel\, and takes a belligerent stance against Iran. Trump’s approach is in contrast to Obama’s who reached out to Tehran and democratic Islamists at the supposed expense of US relations with Israel and Saudi Arabia. However\, Trump’s subsequent declaration of shifting the US embassy to Jerusalem has inadvertently brought the Israel-Palestinian issue back to the front burner\, contradicting his implied aim of underplaying it in the NSS document. \nThe importance Trump gave to issuing the NSS in the very first year of his presidency\, releasing it personally through a televised address\, appears to be in apparent response to criticisms about the lack of clarity in his foreign policy. However\, the document itself is riddled with contradictions and arguably adds to the confusion. \nBy referring to the word ‘competition’ about 75 times in the document\, the US is inadvertently conceding that it is no longer the unrivalled hegemon of the world\, but is facing stiff competition from Russia and China\, in particular. Thus\, the US is acknowledging that it is a power in decline and needs to get its house in order\, as implied in the slogan ‘Putting America First’. \nOn India\nNSS 2017 highlights India quite positively. The document states that “we welcome India’s emergence as a leading global power and stronger strategic and defense partner. We will seek to increase quadrilateral cooperation with Japan\, Australia\, and India”. The most recent National Defence Authorisation Act allows US allies to cooperate with it in advancing India’s defence capabilities. While it is clear that the US has initiated a zero-sum game\, whereas India only desires a balancing approach\, the association with America might have negative consequences for India.  \nThe characterisation of Russia as well as of Iran as challengers of the current international order is inconvenient from the Indian perspective\, and is likely to complicate India’s relationships with these countries and make these relationships issues in India’s ties with America. But the mutual need for a stronger strategic partnership is also likely to ensure that these issues do not derail the current trajectory of India-US relations. The starting point for India’s foreign and security policy formulation and recalibration should not be how America or China or Russia view the world and who they respectively view as adversaries\, but the threats and challenges India perceives\, especially from China and Pakistan and terrorism\, as well as India’s enduring interests in preserving its predominance in the sub-continent\, acquiring a high degree of influence and an important role in the extended neighbourhood stretching from Suez to Shanghai\, and ensuring that both Asia and the world at large remain multipolar.  \nContradictions\nThe 3rd Viscount Palmerston had noted: “We have no eternal allies and we have no perpetual enemies. Our interests are eternal and perpetual”. The Trump administration’s NSS brings that clear distinction to the fore. However\, there remain discontinuities on climate change\, China\, Russia and Iran. The threats presented by China and Russia to US interests differ: while Russia has military technology and nuclear weapons\, it is beatable; but even though China cannot destroy the US\, it is not beatable.  \nThe NSS mentions how the US had helped to create a network of states to advance a common interest\, and engaged both economically and militarily to ensure peace and stability. But the current administration has pulled out of various multilateral forums like the TPP and on crucial issues such as climate change. Not to mention the stir created by President Trump when he recognised Jerusalem as the capital of Israel\, which isolated America even more – the majority of US allies and partners (including India) voted against the US proposal in the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA). The move\, however\, did bring the Arab and Muslim world together on this issue.   \nThe NSS states that in order to advance American interests the country must employ forward diplomacy\, articulating American interests. But it is not clear if those interests are to be articulated historically. Nor is this administration’s understanding of US national interests clear. Moreover\, the announcement of cuts to the state department budget and possible reduction of funds to the UN along with the rejection of economic multilateral forums appears counter-productive in advancing American influence. In the document\, several strong statements are used (such as against cyberattacks)\, which all require international cooperation\, but no framework is provided for any such cooperation. In the given framework\, the foundation of trade and security cooperation with other states relies on consonance with the terms and conditions proposed by the US. America has moved away from free trade to ‘free\, fair and reciprocal’ trade. It doesn’t want to continue with the North Atlantic Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). The document speaks of taking direct action against terrorist networks\, sanctuaries and supply chains\, but falls short of taking stern action against states such as Pakistan.  \nThe Strategy in the Regional Context \nThe NSS establishes a fault line implying that if a state is weak and non-democratic\, it makes for an aspiring partner. And a strong but non-democratic nation is an enemy\, and a danger to world peace. The document does not clearly differentiate between states such as Saudi Arabia and Iran\, and Pakistan and Iraq. It appears to be coddling authoritarian powers (Saudi Arabia) in the ranks\, while condemning and criminalising the geopolitical ‘other side’ (Iran).  \nAccording to the observations and policies provided in the document\, conflict remains a high possibility. Neither the US nor China is working for international cooperation but only for self-interest\, thus creating conditions for a zero-sum game. The NSS encourages joining the US ‘block’ if a state believes in the principles of democracy\, rule of law\, free and open Indo-Pacific and working towards American interest which is in turn claimed to be in the interest of world peace.  \nPresident Xi Jinping\, on the other hand\, has promoted the Chinese model for economic prosperity and governance for domestic development\, essentially bifurcating Asia between an Economic Asia and a Security Asia. This can be noticed in his speech at the 19th National Congress of the CPC and in his proposition of a new Security Concept during the Conference on Interaction and Confidence-Building Measures in Asia (CICA) and the ‘New Type of Great Power’ relations approach that China seeks to forge with the US. The NSS articulates the same and repeatedly refers to great-power competition. But what Asia needs is sustained US leadership as well as continuing Chinese economic support.  \nThis report is based on a panel discussion on the US National Security Strategy 2017 held at the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA). Speakers on the panel were Maj. Gen. Alok Deb (Retd.)\, Dr. G. Balachandran\, Prof. P. Stobdan\, Dr. Jagannath Panda and Dr. Adil Rasheed. Comments from Dr. S. Kalyanaraman and Director General Jayant Prasad have also been included. \nThe report has been compiled by Swati Arun.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/a-strategic-perspective-on-the-us-national-security-strategy-2017-report-on-an-idsa-panel-discussion
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20171117T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20171117T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T125423Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250312T011432Z
UID:62743-1510896600-1510896600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:COP23 Companion Event on India’s Climate Mitigation and Adaptation: Key Strategies
DESCRIPTION:Venue:  Hilton Hotel Bonn\, Berliner Freiheit 2\, Bonn \n\nCOP23 Companion Event on India’s Climate Mitigation and  Adaptation: Key Strategies\n  ––sharing of  green information\, news and views –– \n\nPost-Paris\, the international community is determined  to meet the global climatechallenge with the help ofnew strategies and initiatives  that simultaneously promote inclusive\, sustainable socio-economic development\,  environmental sustainability\, and sustainable peace. India’s role as a global  climate actor is critical. Luckily\, India is quickly synchronizing with the new  climate goals. India promotes cooperation on disaster risk management\, clean  energy\,and innovative green technology solutions that combine development  potential with the reduction of carbon emissions. North-South technology  transfer is only one part of the climate-development nexus. Indigenization of  technology innovation and knowledge sharing are emerging as increasingly  important approaches to climate action.  \nGOAL\n  This conference provides a platform to highlight  India as an important scene of green innovation\, while explainingIndia’s key  strategies in green policy development\, as reflected in India’s evolving  position in climate negotiations. In this conference we will present and discuss  India’s viewpoints\, initiatives and key strategies\, as India makes  thetransition to a new “green evolution”.  \nBACKGROUND\n India accounts  for about 4.5 per cent of global greenhouse gas emissions and is the fourth  largest emitter of greenhouse gasses. The Paris Agreement on Climate Change\, which sets  out the architecture for carbon emission reduction after 2020\, was ratified by India on October 2\, 2016. The  Paris accord safeguards the principle of common but differentiated  responsibility and respective capabilities (CBDR-RC)\, which has remained a  non-negotiable aspect of India’s climate position. This principle squarely puts  the major responsibility on developed nations to drastically cut their carbon  emissions and provide the necessary finance\, technology and capacity building  for developing economies to mitigate and adapt to climate change. India would  like all the key elements–adaptation\, mitigation\, finance\, technology transfer  and capacity building–to be incorporated in the global climate deal. \n  India’s  additional contribution to climate action is provisional onthe availability of  finance and technologies from the industrialized economies. India also  encourages the development of aset of rules to tax or regulate the higher  emissions by corporationsacross the globe\, as well as a framework of efficiency  and climate awareness.In the field of disaster management\, India wants to operationalizeloss  and damage in the long-term\, and set up mechanismsto compensate for  climate-related losses that especially affect Small Island States\, Least  Developed Nations\, and developing countries. \nIndia also wants toplay a more proactive  climate and development role\, domestically and abroad. Regionally\, India  recognizes that climate action can open up new opportunities to overcome trust  deficits through heightened inter-state cooperation on disaster preparedness\,  early warning systems\, disaster risk reduction measures\,and sharing of real-time  data. \nCONCEPT\nCo-organized by the Indian Institute for  Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA) and the Peace Research Institute Oslo  (PRIO)\, this conference is a part of the two institutes’ current research  cooperation on India in the World:  Emerging Perspectives on Global Challenges\, and its subproject on Climate Change. The aim of this event is  to create a platform whereIndian academics\, analysts and practitionerscan  present and interact witha global audience at the COP23 summit. The format:  maximum ten-minute informal presentations will be followed by Q&A\, debate  and interaction.  \n\nPROGRAM\n\n\nSession I            Setting the stage – 0900  AM – 1000 AM \n\nModerator:                 Uttam  Sinha\, IDSA \nSpeakers:                    Jayant Mauskar\,Member\, Prime Minister Council on Climate Change & Henrik Eriksen\, Head of Norway’s Delegation to COP23  \nSession II           High Technology\, Low Emissions – 1000 AM – 1200 AM \nModerator:                 Åshild Kolås\, PRIO \nSpeakers:                   Lydia Powell\,Observer Research  Foundation (ORF) & Sanjay Gupta\,Consultant\, the World Bank  \n  \nJOIN US FOR LUNCH 1200 AM – 0130 PM  \nAddress:             Ulrike Scharf\, Bavarian State Minister of the Environment  and Consumer Protection 0130 PM – 0145 PM  \nSession III           Disaster Preparedness  and Co-operation 0145 PM – 0300 PM\n    Moderator:                  Jason  Miklian\, PRIO  \nSpeakers:                    C.R.Babu\,Professor Emiritus\,  Delhi University\, Eklabya  Sharma\, International  Centre for Integrated Mountain Development (ICIMOD) & Kamal  Kishore\,National Disaster Management Agency\n \nRead report
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/cop23-companion-event-on-indias-climate-mitigation-and-adaptation-key-strategies
CATEGORIES:CONFERENCES,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20170112T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20170112T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T132946Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125603Z
UID:63065-1484199000-1484199000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Launch of two books on Arthashastra
DESCRIPTION:Books\n\nSubrata K. Mitra and Michael Liebig\, Kautilya’s Artha??stra: An Intellectual Portrait-Classical Roots of Modern Politics in India\, Baden-Baden\, Germany\, Nomos\, 2016.\nMichael Liebig and Saurabh Mishra (eds.)\, The Artha??stra in a Transcultural Perspective: Comparing Kautilya with Sun-Zi\, Nizam al-Mulk\, Barani and Machiavelli\, New Delhi\, IDSA\, Pentagon Press\, 2017.\n\nAbout the Books\nThe two books deal with Kautilya’s Artha??stra. The first book\, co-authored by Subrata K. Mitra and Michael Liebig\, titled\, Kautilya’s Artha??stra: An Intellectual Portrait – Classical Roots of Modern Politics in India\, showcases the endogenous politico-strategic thought that underpins and drives India’s rise in the 21st century. The political institutions and processes in contemporary India have remained deeply grounded in its pre-modern political heritage\, succinctly codified in Kautilya’s Arthashastra. These themes are explored through such bridge concepts as ‘modernity of tradition’ and ‘re-use of the past’ in tackling contemporary political problems. These concepts are key factors that explain the resilience and stability of India’s hybrid political institutions and democratic system\, as well as its foreign policy conduct.  \nEven though Kautilya’s Artha??stra is one of the foundational texts of political science and international relations (IR) theory\, its contribution has\, so far\, not been duly acknowledged. It remains largely marginal or peripheral or\, worse\, ignored in the academic mainstream. This book\, therefore\, seeks to mainstream Arthashastra in the field of South Asian studies\, comparative politics and comparative political theory.   \nThe second book\, edited by Michael Liebig and Saurabh Mishra\, titled\, The Artha??stra in a Transcultural Perspective: Comparing Kautilya with Sun-Zi\, Nizam al-Mulk\, Barani and Machiavelli\, is the product of a collaborative effort by the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA)\, New Delhi; South Asia Institute (SAI)\, Heidelberg University; and the Institute of South Asian Studies (ISAS)\, National University of Singapore (NUS). This volume contains papers exploring Kautilya’s Artha??stra in a transcultural perspective\, comparing it with the thoughts of Sun-Zi\, Nizam al-Mulk\, Barani and Machiavelli.  \nIt is agreed that the field of modern IR and Political Theory is predominantly Eurocentric\, and based on European sources of philosophy and history. But\, nowadays\, scholars have been exploring the possibility of a world intellectual history\, as ideas are dynamic throughout temporal and geographical spaces. They transform\, hybridise and travel long distances over a period of time in such a manner that they appear as belonging to the place where we find them at a particular point of time.  \nIt is also intriguing to observe that India\, with a long civilisational and philosophical history\, is credited with no contribution to the evolution of modern IR and Political Theory. Therefore\, this volume explores the philosophical systems\, thought-figures and ancient cultural spaces\, on the path from India to Europe\, looking for any possibility of Kautilya’s Artha??stra\, the most comprehensive and systematic text available on the art of governance from ancient India\, having interacted and influenced the evolution of IR and Political Theory that are considered as originally European intellectual contributions.  \nChapters in this book give ample and convincing reasons for initially believing in the Artha??stra’s value and making further research on Indian contribution to the intellectual history of IR and Political Theory a desideratum. The ‘Introduction’ of the book has been jointly written by Michael Liebig and Saurabh Mishra. The edited volume comprises of seven chapters: ‘Kautilya Redux? Re-use\, Hybridity\, Trans-cultural Flow and Resilience of the State in India’ by Prof. Subrata K. Mitra (ISAS)\, ‘Understanding Kautilya’s Artha??stra: Origination\, Migration and Diffusion’ by Pradeep Kumar Gautam (IDSA)\, ‘Kautilya and Machiavelli in a Comparative Perspective’ by Michael Liebig (SAI)\, ‘Artha??stra – Reflections on Thought and Theory’ by Medha Bisht (South Asian University\, New Delhi)\, ‘R?jadharma\, Legitimacy and Sovereignty in the Artha??stra’ by Saurabh Mishra (IDSA)\, ‘Kautilya and Sun- Zi on War and Strategy: Exploratory Comparative Analysis’ by M.S. Prathibha (IDSA)\, and ‘Fat?w?-ye jah?nd?ri: Hybrid Political Theory in the Delhi Sultanate (Perso-Islamic and Endogenous Traditions of Statecraft in India)’  by Seyed Hossein Zarhani (SAI). \nProceedings\nThe proceedings began with welcome remarks by Shri Jayant Prasad\, Director General\, IDSA\, in which he said that this unique work throws light on the imprint of the Arthashastra on the psyche of key Indian leaders like Mahatma Gandhi\, Jawaharlal Nehru and Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. Speaking about his co-authored book\, Prof. Subrata K. Mitra (Director\, ISAS\, NUS) noted that the Artha??stra covers all the broad aspects of political\, military\, social\, economic\, and cultural life\, and the diverse components of power that are the constitutive elements of the state but which are absent in the discourse of Plato and Aristotle\, the two founders of the Western philosophical tradition.  \nIndia’s strategic culture\, according to Prof. Mitra and Dr. Liebig (Fellow\, SAI\, Heidelberg University)\, endures despite many colonial attempts to extinguish it. It is\, therefore\, important to understand the past and gauge its impact. On behalf of Heidelberg University\, Prof. Rahul Mukherji\, Head\, Department of Political Science\, South Asia Institute\, had sent the following message: \n\nThe Department of Political Science at the South Asia Institute in Heidelberg is deeply interested in the Indian state. Scholarly work is adept at demonstrating the failures of the Indian state. While this is an important intellectual exercise\, India’s rise could not have been without some deft management of the Indian state. The Department is deeply interested in exploring not only why the saga of the Indian state is a story of a glass half empty but also why the glass is half full. It is only when we seek to explore how an empty glass that was supposed to disintegrate\, is now half full\, can we discern how it will become a fuller and more glorious one. \nThe story of Kautliya’s legacy is significant. India’s strategic culture according to the Mitra and Liebig\, endures despite many colonial attempts to extinguish it. It is therefore important to understand that past and gauge its impact. To give one example\, that India averts terror threats despite such adversity and diversity\, is not only an under-noticed achievement\, it could have lessons for classic nation-states of Europe used to living in more homogeneous communities. Could it then be that India’s ability to deal magically with intelligence\, even within the framework of a plural polity\, is something scholars have missed? This is only one among numerous aspects of India’s strategic culture pre-dating to ancient Kautilyan times that require deep scholarly research. \nThe Department rejoices in the pioneering achievement of Mitra and Liebig for bringing out the importance of India’s past for understanding its strategic culture. We hope that the Department of Political Science in the South Asia Institute and the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses will continue to work innovatively and with an indigenous perspective towards understanding how the Indian state works to succeed so often\, even though it fails some times. \n\nRelease of the Books by the Guest of Honour\, Shri A.N.D. Haksar\nThe guest of honour was Shri Aditya Narayan Dhairyasheel Haksar\, a distinguished scholar-diplomat\, who served as high commissioner and ambassador to a number of countries like Kenya\, the Seychelles\, Portugal and former Yugoslavia. He had also raised the Foreign Service Institute (FSI)\, New Delhi.  As a scholar of both Sanskrit and English\, he is known for his exquisite and crisp translations of many known and unknown Sanskrit classics into English including Panchatantra\, Narayana’s Hitopadesa\, plays of Bhasa\, Dandin’s Dasa Kumar Charitra\, Kshemendra’s The Courtesan’s Keeper and Three Satires from Ancient Kashmir\, Kalyana Malla’s Suleiman Charitra\, and Raghuvamsam of Kalidas. His rendition of Bhartrihari’s Satakatrayam or Three Centuries is forthcoming. In November 2016\, he delivered a talk at the India International Centre (IIC) on “India’s Forgotten Heritage: Cultural Intermingling and Harmony in Sanskrit Literature”. He has also contributed a chapter in Volume I of the edited book on Kautilya\, titled\, “A post–Kautilyan View of Diplomacy: The Nitisara of Kamandaki”. He has been actively guiding and mentoring the IDSA project on Indigenous Historical Knowledge. \nAfter the release of the two books\, an overview of the two books was given by Dr. Michael Liebig (SAI\, Heidelberg University) followed by Dr. Saurabh Mishra (IDSA). Reflecting on the resonance of Kautilyan theory in the day-to-day practices of statecraft\, Shri Shyam Saran\, Chairman\, Research and Information System for Developing Countries (RIS)\, and former Foreign Secretary\, in his remarks said that the categorisation of what constitutes ‘comprehensive national power’ has been amply defined in Kautilya’s Artha??stra. Commenting on several elements of the Artha??stra that are relevant even today\, Shri Saran said the importance of a good ruler and a good counsel\, based on knowledge and wisdom as advocated in the Artha??stra\, are critical even in today’s political set up. \nGeneral Discussion\nThere was a consensus to undertake more research in the future. In his closing remarks\, Shri Haksar said that the effort so far is both rich and important but not yet conclusive. He offered two practical suggestions: First\, research needs to be cognisant of the fact that there was a gap of more than 2\,000 years post-Kautilya. Given  this\, he  reiterated the need for a method for internal widening and a look at not only Kautilya’s Artha??stra but also post-Kautilyan traditions of writing in this field. Kamandakis’s Nitisara being one on diplomatic activities. Shri Haksar pointed out that Moriz Winternitz (1863 – 1937)\, a well-known Indologist\, in his writings on the history of India literature\, subsequent to Kautilya’s Artha??stra\, had listed 13 other works covering a span of 1\,000 years\, over a geographic spread from Kashmir to Kerala and Gujarat to Bengal. He suggested that it will be worthwhile to widen the research and exploration to establish changes\, modifications and continuities in Kautilya’s Artha??stra. Three texts that now need to be incorporated in the Indigenous Historical Knowledge project are: (a) Nitisara of Kamandaki\, (b) Laghuartha-Nitishastra by Hem Chandra\, a Jain from Gujarat\, 1088–1172 AD\, and (c) Yukti-Kalpataru attributed to King Bhoja. \nSecondly\, Shri Haksar said that the idea of an IDSA book that widens the scope across cultures is very important. He referred to the research done by Dr. Liebig and others taking into account spaces from India’s neighbourhood to Europe and China.  \nCol. P.K.Gautam (Retd.)\, in his vote of thanks\, expressed his appreciation for the support and encouragement received from the previous and current leadership of the Institute for the project on Indigenous Historical Knowledge. He also said that the soft copy of one of the books – The Artha??stra in a Transcultural Perspective: Comparing Kautailya with Sun-Zi\, Nizam al-Mulk\, Barani and Machiavelli – would soon be uploaded on the Institute’s website for the benefit of the readership.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/launch-of-two-books-on-arthashastra
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20161123T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20161123T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T125431Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250315T144649Z
UID:62750-1479879000-1479879000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:International Conference on ‘Addressing the Challenge of International Terrorism and Radicalisation’
DESCRIPTION:Venue: IDSA Auditorium (Second Floor) \n\n\nConcept Note\nAs the foremost threat to international peace and security\, global terrorism is an implacably complex\, intractable and suigeneris phenomena. As the origins\, scope and impact of the global menace extend beyond conventional security and military paradigms — covering religious\, political\, socio-economic\, demographic and at times historical vectors — a purely militaristic and security-centeric response to the threat often lags behind the proverbial curve. \nThus\, even after decades of militarily defeating and destroying various bases and their human and material assets\, the swamp of terrorism continues to spew new forms of violence on the global scene\, ever more adept in unusual modes of asymmetric warfare and worldwide appeal. \nIn addition\, the increased ideological\, military\, logistical and financial support provided by certain states to non-state terrorist outfits as part of their covert\, sub-conventional warfare directed against peace-loving nations remains a matter of serious international and humanitarian concern today. The time has come to universally reject the use of terrorism as state policy by any country\, irrespective of real or perceived injustice. Terrorism must be denounced unequivocally and without any pre-conditions. The classification of ‘good terrorism’ vis-à-vis ‘bad terrorism’ also needs to be summarily dismissed. \nAs terrorism threatens the unity and territorial integrity of various Asian countries — particularly those in West Asia\, South Asia and Central Asia — the importance of reinformed efforts in the fight against radicalisation and terrorism both at the individual and regional levels cannot be overstated. It is noteworthy that several governments of these regions have already launched indigenous counter-terrorism and counter-radicalisation campaigns that have achieved varying degrees of success. Clearly\, there is room for greater effectiveness and cooperation among these countries inter and intra-regionally. We must also make an earnest endeavour to learn from eachothers’ experiences\, especially given the evolutionary nature of both the threat and the ensuing responses. \nAs the threat of terrorism metastasises into rapidly morphing and ever more virulent forms\, there remain several blind spots and shades of confusion in counter-terrorism operations conducted by various agencies nationally and internationally. The situation underscores the importance of greater clarity\, coordination and even collaboration of counter-terrorist campaigns among countries to combat global jihadism with transnational linkages. There is a need to properly define\, identify\, and effectively reverse the processes that produce and catalyse radicalisation\, violent extremism and terrorism. \nTo begin with\, it is essential to unravel the character arc of a typical terrorist\, from the time of the germination of radical thought to the person’s transition to violent action. In other words\, there is a need to explore various theoretical models and frameworks that counterradicalisation experts of various countries have developed to explain the transition of an ordinary citizen into a radical and violent extremist or terrorist\, in order to understand the motivations and circumstances that abet the transformation. The study has become all the more important with growing threats of home-grown terrorism in various countries and rising incidents of lone-wolf attacks. \nThe institutions\, forums and mediums required to facilitate constant exchange of experience and expertise among soldiers and counter-terrorism experts\, thereby aiding each other with the latest updates\, research and operational know-how at the inter-state\, inter-regional and intra-regional levels is the need of the hour. Efforts are needed to build and nurture relevant mechanisms. The limitations of the international system in this regard need to be studied and effectively addressed.  \nAnother cardinal point is the constant monitoring and analyses of the constantly evolving extremist discourse and the changing objectives in order to develop effective counternarratives on a sustained basis\, as part of comprehensive strategic communication programs. \nThe irony of employing information technology and new media to effectively spread the contagion of atavistic discourse and the use of the most advanced psy-ops techniques\, as well as hybridised fourth generation warfare\, demands intensive study and analyses. The prospective threat of a CBRN (Chemical\, Biological\, Radiological and Nuclear) attack\, which is an increasingly disconcerting and imminent danger\, remains a critical field for study. \nIt is difficult to overemphasise the need for developing relevant legal\, institutional and social structures\, institutions and mechanisms that countervail the global outreach of terrorism. The role of civil society\, moderate religious groups\, and non-government organisations in dredging the morass of extremism through community outreach programs\, public relation campaigns\, educational courses\, employment counselling sessions\, interactive cultural and sports programs\, etc. need to be explored to the fullest extent possible. \nThus\, it is by developing and deploying a diverse and comprehensive\, and simultaneously\, highly coherent and synergised intra-regional counter-terrorism policies ? with the involvement of various countries\, important think tanks\, and relevant experts and influential leaders of all communities – that an effective counterpunch can be delivered to the growing monstrosity of jihadism so that the proverbial swamp of violent extremism could be effectively drained. \n\nProgramme\n9:30 – 10:00        Registration\n10:00 -10:45      Inaugural Session\n\nWelcome Remarks (Shri Jayant Prasad\, Director General\, IDSA)\nOpening Address by Shri N.N. Vohra\, Honourable Governor of  Jammu and Kashmir\n\n10:45 – 11:00      Tea Break\n11:00 – 13:00     Session  I: The Ideological Frontier against Terror – Chairperson: Ambassador Chinmaya  Gharekhan\n\nCounter Radicalisation: Conceptual  Confusions in an Ideological War – Dr Adil Rasheed\, Research Fellow\, IDSA \nGlobal Jihad: Present Trends and  Future Scenarios – Dr. Mostafa Zahrani\, Director General of Strategic Affairs\,  Ministry of Foreign Affairs\, Iran \nImpact of Syrian  Conflict on Islamic Radicalisation – Prof Haldun Yalcinkaya\, Senior Researcher  and Coordinator for Security Studies Program ORSAM \n\n13:00-14:00       Lunch  Break\n14:00-15:30       Session  II: Contours of Radicalisation in the “Heart of Asia” – Chairperson: Prof S D  Muni\, Distinguished Fellow\, IDSA\n\nImpact of Radicalisation in Central  Asia and Afghanistan – Ambassador Abdusamat Khaydarov\, Head of Office\, UNAMA \nCombating State Backed Cross-Border  Terrorism – Dr. Davood Moradian\, Afghanistan\, Afghan Institute for Strategic  Studies. \nRadicalisation in India: Impact of  Regional Dimensions – Ms. Prabha Rao\, Senior Fellow\, IDSA \n\n15:30-15:45        Tea Break\n15:45-17:00       Session  III: Country Studies of Counter-Terrorist Initiatives – Chairperson: Cmde C Uday  Bhaskar (Retd)\n\nCountering Radical Ideology in Asia:  Chinese Perspectives – Dr. Yan Shuai\, Assistant Professor\, CICIR\, Beijing\,  China \nRadicalisation and its Impact on the  Pakistan: – Dr. Ashok Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, IDSA \n\nhttp://www.idsa.in \nEvent Report [+]
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/international-conference-on-addressing-the-challenge-of-international-terrorism-and-radicalisation
CATEGORIES:CONFERENCES,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20161019T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20161019T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133006Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130739Z
UID:63067-1476855000-1476855000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Compressing politics on COIN: Implications for counterinsurgency theory with reference to India’s Northeast
DESCRIPTION:Chair: Prof. Rajesh  Rajagopalan \n  Discussants:  Brig. Narender Kumar\, Col. Pradeep Singh Chhonkar\, Col. Vikrant S. Deshpande  \nMr. Walterman elaborated on his paper about the  theoretical debates of Counterinsurgency (COIN) and the growing complex  challenges that have confronted the traditional theorization of COIN. The paper  deals with the relationship between COIN and the complex aspects of latest insurgencies.  Mr. Alex argued that the old theorization of COIN\, which was conditioned by Cold  War understanding and the traditional division of “duties into 80% political  action and 20% military”\, has almost become stagnant. He argued even the 21st  century democracies have been adopting this mechanism for dealing with  insurgencies. Mr Waterman noted there is a need to overcome this “conceptual  inertia” in order to address the complexity of changed insurgencies and this  paper is an attempt in that direction.  \nWaterman argued that the continued theorisation and  division of COIN into political and military are inadequate for dealing with insurgencies  as these have evolved\, grown complex and are sometimes thriving upon  alternative political models. Defeating the political in the insurgencies remains challenge for any COIN rather than merely crushing  its guerrilla tactics. That means in many ways that COIN has become 100%  political.  \nWith regard to India\, Waterman argued that in India  the rebel groups were recognised from the beginning as “misguided citizens” by  then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru and the approach to deal with them has  been overwhelmingly political with less use of military tactics. However\, this approach  has not paid off in the way the state would have liked it to. According to Waterman\,  the current notion of political embedded in COIN understanding fails to take  into account the complexity of the political environment at the two levels: One  is that counterinsurgents and insurgents are not the only actors that can have  an overall political impact. There are other influential actors as well; strong  local  politicians\, civil society or foreign  intelligence agencies. Second is that the interactions within this environment  may not reflect the traditional and complex political competition. Some elements  of an insurgency may be seeking to carve out an ethnic exclusionary base to  consolidate power while others may be seeking to control drug trafficking or  likewise. Such vested interests are not uncommon in the latest insurgencies.  \nWaterman argued that the Indian approach of a  combination of political engagement and military coercion\, has been successful  in co-opting those groups who are willing to be part of the mainstream and  empowering political actors to bring them to negotiations. Though this has been  successful\, for example\, in Mizoram with the Mizo National Front (MNF)\, it\,  however\, remains an exception. In other Northeast states like Nagaland\, issues  remains unsettled. In Bodoland\, the Peace Accords of 1993 and 2003 created a  new kind of identity politics within the Bodo society\, fragmenting it\, and creating  new forms of violence that led to the emergence of “other armed groups” who are  creating their own space. Insurgent groups tend to exploit vulnerable sections of  a society and grey area to their interest. Many a times\, insurgent groups react  to a particular COIN approach differently based upon their political and social  conditions. These different signals from different groups “produce  complications” which the current political primacy in COIN fails to cover  appropriately. Similarly\, apart from the political\, the force used in the COIN  is meant to weaken the insurgent groups and bring them on the negotiating table.  This\, however\, changes the political/power dynamics: apparently empowering one  group and sidelining the others.  \nTherefore\,  though the political primacy on COIN is rightly the main feature\, but it is  unable to capture increased complexity present in the latest insurgencies. For  that we need to re-visit the old theory of COIN and attempt a new theorization  for capturing the latest dynamics and actors involved. We need to revise the theory  in order to successfully draw generalisations to cover diverse cases.  \nBrig. Narender Kumar\n  Brig. Kumar in his comments argued that there are indeed  complications in the process of COIN\, as the paper argues. But these arise also  from the geography\, demography and relationship between ethnic groups as well\,  whose understanding may differ from the mainstream. As a case in point\, in the Northeast\,  there was no concept of state as it is understood now. The effort from the  centre to compress the local structures and traditions has created problems. For  example\, Assam was one of the most developed regions in India. Attempted reform  of its structure without taking into account the local traditions led to the  problems it is faced with today. In other places like Manipur\, conflicts exist  between the ethnic groups themselves rather than with the centre or state.  Overall\, Brig. Kumar argued\, given the complexity\, where is the space for the  political? The situation demands closer to an 80% military and 20% political  approach. Therefore\, at best\, it was more likely that the political and  military will go hand in hand.  \n  In  Nagaland\, insurgency is an industry which provides jobs to the unemployed  youth. This is because there are no economic opportunities for them. It’s  fortunate that the people are forcing the insurgent groups to maintain the  cease fire. There is a requirement for the northeast to be first integrated  with itself\, then with the main land.   \nCol. Pradeep Singh Chhonkar\n  Col. Chhonkar argued that the paper presented aptly  analyzes the concept of political in COIN and dynamics involved in  insurgencies. This complexity has grown mainly because of the vast number of actors  involved in these insurgencies. These actors control economic\, social and  political power and use them to pursue their interests. Many Northeast  insurgencies are complex because these are not insurgencies of traditional understanding  and features but are used for controlling the drug market\, fake currency and  for extortions. He suggested that Nagaland could also be included as a case  study for a situation in which\, when one group is talked to\, the others feel  being sidelined.     \n Col. Vikrant S. Deshpande\n Col. Deshpande opined that the paper highlights two  elements of COIN: political approach and utility of force. It argues that the  existing theory doesn’t entail the complexity involved in insurgencies and for  analyzing this Northeast is taken as case study. COIN practice precedes the  theory and it is not that the practioners are not aware about the  complications. The measures taken in Northeast were ineffective not because the  design or intention were missing but because of the wrong execution. \nCol.  Deshpande was of the opinion that the idea of utility of force in the paper can  be further developed. Force is used to achieve tactical ends. It needs to be elaborated  why the use of force should stop at getting a fighting group to the negotiating  table.  \nProf. Rajesh Rajagopalan\n   Commenting on the paper\, Prof. Rajagopalan argued that  three points need to be taken into consideration: i)academic theorizing has practice behind it; \, i.e.\, a theory’s premise  is empirical data or/experience which informs the theorist’s understanding of  an issue which he/she then tries to give a theoretical explanation.  ii)\, the binary division of the COIN theory debate into the political and  military doesn’t cover all the dimensions involved. Besides\, the perspective of  a theorist or practioner has a significant impact on this; and iii) As a corollary to  the second point\, therefore\, for better or worse\, there is politics involved in  this division of the COIN into the political and military itself\,. An  academician or a practioner after all has his subjectivity involved in this  process which influences his/her understanding of the COIN.  \n          Prof.  Rajagopalan further argued that the concept of political in COIN is not  applicable at the global level. India is fighting insurgencies internally and the issues of human rights\, citizenship rights\, democratic values  and excessive use of force are factors in play while taking on the insurgent  groups\,; unlike in international  counterinsurgency enterprises\, of the type found in Afghanistan and Iraq. In an  attempt of theorization\, we also need to open the black box from the both  sides\, i.e.\, from the state and from the insurgent side as well. Prof.  Rajagopalan noted that a major challenge for the paper would be to draw generalizations  from the application of the (reformed) COIN theory in cases where there are  complexities involved\, like in the Northeast region of India.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/compressing-politics-on-coin-implications-for-counterinsurgency-theory-with-reference-to-indias-northeast
CATEGORIES:ROUND TABLES / WORKSHOPS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20160610T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20160610T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133006Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130237Z
UID:63068-1465536600-1465536600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:India's Foreign Policy Options in the Asia-Pacific: A Critical Evaluation
DESCRIPTION:The IDSA Fellows  Seminar by Dr S. Kalyanaraman\,  Research Fellow\, IDSA\, on the topic “India’s Foreign Policy Options in the  Asia-Pacific: A Critical Evaluation” was held on Friday\, June 10\, 2016. It  was chaired by Sudhir T Devare\, India’s former Ambassador in North Korea\, Visiting  Fellow and former Director General of the Indian Council of World Affairs\, New Delhi. To discuss the paper\, two external  and two internal discussants participated in the seminar: Prof Sujit Dutta\, the Mahatma Gandhi Chair at the Nelson Mandela Centre for Peace and  Conflict Resolution\, Jamia Millia Islamia\, Delhi and whose expertise is in  Chinese Politics\, Foreign and Security Policies\, India-China Relations\,  International Affairs in East Asia\, India’s Strategic Thought\, International  Relations; and Rajesh Rajagopalan\, Professor in International Politics at  Jawaharlal Nehru University\, New Delhi\, whose areas of research are  international relations theory\, military doctrines and nuclear weapons and  disarmament; Dr. Uttam Sinha\, Research Fellow at  IDSA; and Cdr. Aman Saberwal\, Research Fellow at IDSA.  \n  In his presentation\, Dr. Kalyanaraman  began by highlighting how the Asia-Pacific region is gaining greater salience in both the economic  and political spheres\, how China is emerging as a central player in this  unfolding dynamic\, and what impact these developments have for India’s security  and role in the region. It is against this backdrop that he critically evaluated  four policy options that have been prescribed for India. These are:  \n  Multi-Alignment: Proponents argue  that multi-alignment not only enables India to advance its core developmental  priorities through greater economic integration at the regional and global  levels but also helps preserve its strategic autonomy by avoiding too great a  dependence on any one major power. Contrary to these assertions and  aspirations\, however\, multi-alignment is unlikely to prove practicable in an  Asia-Pacific that is tending towards fragmentation into rival economic and  security groupings led by America and China\, respectively. Practising  multi-alignment would be impracticable because\, during periods of intensified  great power rivalry\, alliances are likely to be rigid and the interactions  between rival great powers zero sum and conflictual in nature\, thus rendering  membership in multiple groupings impossible and the contradictions involved in  pursuing such a policy unmanageable.  \n  Nonalignment: A modified version of nonalignment\, Nonalignment 2.0\, between  China and America is the second policy prescription that has been identified.  Advocates contend that nonalignment would help India derive economic\, military  and technological benefits from multiple sources as well as enable it to play  the role of “a unique bridge” between different countries and groupings. But  this idea of replicating the policy adopted during the Cold War to the  unfolding circumstances overlooks the fact that the Soviet Union did not pose a  threat to India whereas China does. Further\, external balancing in the form of  an alliance is necessary given limited domestic economic and military  capacities and the growing power asymmetry vis-à-vis China. \n  Bandwagoning with China: The  third prescription is the establishment of a closer economic relationship and  forging of a new political equilibrium with China. While India would indeed  gain from a closer economic relationship with China in terms of furthering its  domestic economic transformation\, it is highly unlikely that enhanced economic  cooperation would either cause an amelioration of rivalry or move the two  countries towards a mutually acceptable political accommodation. \n  Aligning with America: Alignment  with America is the fourth policy choice. Advocates view an alignment with  America as necessary to protect India’s core values of democracy\, pluralism and  secularism from an authoritarian China aligned with jihad-exporting Pakistan.  Further\, an alliance with America is also necessary\, even natural\, given the  vast and growing power asymmetry between India and China\, which gulf can be  bridged only through external balancing given the lack of “political will and  executive capability” to rapidly build up national power through internal balancing.  There is no denying the importance of\, and even necessity for\, an alliance with  America to counter China’s growing power and consequent ability to reshape the  Asian and international order. But two main objections have been articulated by  critics to such a policy course. First\, it would prematurely antagonise China  and impel that country into adopting overtly hostile policies towards India.  The second objection is that an alliance with America would transform India  into a junior partner and lead to its enmeshment in various American military  misadventures. \n  Concluding  his presentation\, Dr. Kalyanaraman pointed out that China’s rise to great power  status poses major challenges for India’s foreign and security policies. Given  that India will not be able to arrive at a mutual political accommodation with  China\, and given that dealing with China requires external balancing because of  limited internal capacities\, the optimal policy option for India is to forge an  alliance with the United States. \n  The  presentation was followed by comments by the discussants. \n  Prof. Sujit Dutta: \n  Prof.  Dutta began by noting that the paper has raised many interesting ideas which were  central to the foreign policy discourse in India. The paper is based on the ‘Offensive  Realist’ theory of international relations. The principal argument revolves  around the thought that “India needs an alignment with United States to deal  with the emerging challenges from China”\, and this has been well articulated. Nehruvian  foreign policy has often been criticized thus: it did not look into the realities  of power politics clearly and therefore India suffered. The paper has gone to  the opposite of the Nehruvian paradigm\, i.e.\, it has dealt with power politics  in terms of military alignments which poses problems in many ways. India’s political  elite are not very happy with power politics in the international domain although  they are happy to practice power politics in the domestic domain. So\, it is very  difficult for a consensus based foreign policy on the assumption that power  politics should drive India’s foreign policy. Second\, liberal institutionalism  and liberal interdependence which are the fundamentals of the liberal peace are  also important. China is a trade dependent country. It can ill afford to  undermine interdependence. China’s economy is declining and it should  understand that India today is a good market. Third\, China’s power has been  magnified. China spends on defence much more than India but China’s security  paradigm is much more problematic than India’s. India’s defence expenditure  should rise for sure but it need not to be same as China’s. Further\, we must  not underestimate the overwhelming power of the United States. China is in no  position to catch up with the United States anytime soon. We must not overstate  China’s power. India’s economy is rising and it will reach up to China’s level  soon. So we should analyse what India’s foreign policy is and what changes it  requires within the framework of an independent foreign policy. It cannot be  done in isolation with other countries but it can be done in cooperation with  other countries due to globalization. We need a proactive foreign policy. In  this multi-polar world\, balance of power is required so that no single country  dominates the others. By getting engaged with the United States in terms of  alliance rather than strategic partnership\, we will constrain ourselves. The  United States has many flaws in its policies\, like Pakistan policy\, Vietnam  policy in the past\, etc. It is important to have relations with all the great  powers. India-China relations today are far less acrimonious than at the time  when we had no trade relations. \n  Prof Rajesh Rajagopalan:  \n  China  has a great impact on other nations in every term\, whether economic or defence.  China is larger than all of its key competitors in Asia. China has already surpassed  that threshold where it can be balanced by a combination of regional countries.  If you have an imbalance of power\, there must be a balance created irrespective  of the policies of other countries. The US can anchor the regional countries to  create a balance against China. There is a difference between alignment and  alliance\, which can be shown by the alignment of China-Pakistan during the cold  war\, even when Pakistan had an alliance with the US. They had collaboration on  a number of different levels. It is always necessary to point out that  difference between alignment and alliance. Alignments have their own problems.  One of the problems of American alignment is not just the capacity of the US  but its willingness to align\, and this is one of the key problems that India  and all other countries face. India has been gradually moving away from nonalignment  for the past 30 years. According to various surveys\, the US has public support  in India. Inter-dependence has not prevented China from dealing aggressively  with countries in South-East Asia and East Asia. China is a dominant power  irrespective of its aggressive behaviour. India doesn’t have the power to  internally balance China. An alignment is about meeting specific threats. India-US  partnership should be looked at from this perspective. \n  Uttam Sinha: He  pointed to five trends in the changing geopolitics of the Asia-pacific: \n\nThe Chinese moves at developing a  counter strategy to deal with US rebalancing to Asia-Pacific region have  potentially set the stage for the new polarising order in Asia.\nThere are limits to full convergence of  Asian country’s economic interests and their political objectives. It is the  natural political dilemma witnessed in the region which will lead china to seek  competitive relations with Asian neighbours.\nThe US\, India and China are pushing  their respective interests in the region by reaching out to old and new  friends. Alliances and partnerships are turning to be dynamic.\nChina and India are going to compete  and cooperate at the same time. China will take advantage of the Indian market  but on the strategic front relations will be tricky.\nEmergence of new great game –India’s  Act East policy\, US rebalance and China’s OBOR.\n\nAman Saberwal:  \n\nThe title of the paper is “India’s Foreign Policy options in  Asia Pacific”\, but it seems to focus totally on China\, so perhaps a more China  centric title could be considered. \nChina’s air force squadrons and  aircraft are higher in number than India’s for sure\, but then they also have  more service and maintenance complexities than India’s.\nOnly Army and Air Force aspects have  been discussed but not the Navy’s in which realm India is more capable. \nIndia’s military strength has been  greatly underrated in the paper.\n\nIntervening  from the floor\, Director General Jayant Prasad said that there should be emphasis  on both internal and external balancing\, as well as an independent foreign  policy even while being aligned. But alignment bordering on some kind of  alliance system with the US could be dangerous for India. \n  In  his concluding remarks\, Amb. Sudhir Devare noted that: \n\nIndia should be dexterous rather than  being  aligned to countries\nChinese aggressiveness has become a  matter of concern. \nThe fact of multi-polarity has come in the  frame now.\nThe policy of maintaining relations  with middle power needs to be continued. The aspect of cooperative security  needs to be explored.\n\nPrepared by  Urvashi Rathore\, Research Intern\, IDSA
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/indias-foreign-policy-options-in-the-asia-pacific-a-critical-evaluation
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20160315T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20160315T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133006Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250305T230438Z
UID:63069-1458019800-1458019800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Understanding National Security Implications of Climate Risks
DESCRIPTION:Special Guest Speaker: Sir David King\, the UK Foreign Secretary’s Special Representative on Climate Change \nBackground\nThe Council on Energy\, Environment and Water (CEEW) along with other international partners\, including the British Foreign and Commonwealth Office (FCO-UK)\, recently undertook a risk assessment of climate change impacts across the world. As part of it\, a war game scenario exercise was undertaken in India which Sir David King\, the UK Foreign Secretary’s Special Representative on Climate Change\, led with CEEW. \nThe gaming exercise highlighted two important points: (i) climate impacts will further pressurise the security establishments of countries across the world\, and (ii) for ensuring national security\, defence personnel will need to engage not only with defence experts\, but also with climate scientists\, social scientists\, and economists. \nAs a follow up of the joint research effort\, CEEW and the Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (IDSA) held a roundtable discussion with some key defence and national security experts of India to elicit views on the critical issue of the implications of climate induced risks for national security and on how these can be mitigated. The discussion aimed at initiating a long term and deeper engagement of scientists and policy makers with Indian defence and national security experts. \nWelcome Remarks\nThe discussion started with welcome remarks by Mr. Jayant Prasad\, Director General IDSA. In his opening remarks\, Mr. Prasad stressed that national security is a paramount concern for India\, and experts on national security need to be aware about threats to national security arising from various quarters. Our defence forces deal with natural formations like ice-capped mountains and rivers and any impact on these is bound to have concerns for national security. He highlighted that the cross boundary issue is very important. Any intervention in China as a response to climatic disasters can have huge implications for India. The national security community has until now mainly dealt with traditional threats while the climate community has dealt with climate impacts in a general way. It is important that these two communities interact and there is an improved understanding of climate change impacts on national security within India’s defence establishment. \nIntroduction\nDr. Arunabha Ghosh informed the participants about the global climate risk assessment work undertaken by CEEW\, UK-FCO\, Harvard University\, and Tsinghua University jointly. He informed that this risk assessment exercise was based on intensive collaboration with domain experts. One of the most interesting elements of this assessment exercise\, that is relevant for the internal security debate\, was a war gaming exercise. This war gaming exercise was hosted by CEEW in India\, and had representation from the scientific community\, defence community\, and policy making community across the major nations of the world including China\, India\, UK\, USA among other nations. \nThe exercise highlighted that we live in a probabilistic world\, and climate change impacts will increase the uncertainties around the weather systems. Planning for resource management will have to deal with these increased uncertainties. In addition\, there could be unforeseen shocks to the system with unexpected responses from various countries that will pressurise the national security establishments. \nThe aim of this discussion is to start a dialogue between the national security and climate risk communities within India and prepare for these newly emerging challenges to India’s national security. \nSpecial Address by Sir David King\nSir David King in his special address discussed three important themes. First theme was of environmental migration. He informed the group that one of the reasons that led to the Arab Spring was the sharp increase in food prices. Environmental impacts are manifested in different ways. Many of these are catastrophic extreme events like cyclones and floods. The difference is in terms of how long-lasting the impact is. A drought can increase the prices of essential food commodities for the whole season/year. Such shocks impact a large section of the society\, especially the poor\, who are forced to migrate\, creating pressure on resources and infrastructure on other parts. This leads to an increase in conflicts and has implications for national security. \nSecond theme was of climate risks. Science has unequivocally shown that climate impacts are increasing. There are different kinds of risks – systematic risks and unsystematic risks. We need to have a better understanding of both. Once we understand the different kind of risks\, we need to understand their probabilities\, most likely to least likely. Sir David emphasised that we need to plan for not just the most likely impacts\, but also for impacts that are less likely but have catastrophic implications. Both systematic and unsystematic risks will have implications for internal as well as external security that needs to be understood in a better way. \nThird theme dealt with global cooperation. In terms of the response of governments\, national security is generally based on unilateral actions. Responses to climate change related impacts could however lead to wider cross-country conflicts. For example\, the war gaming exercise led by FCO-UK and CEEW with other partners highlighted a scenario in which there is a climate change induced drought leading to high crop production losses in China\, because of which China stops exports of key crops. This leads to similar protectionist measures by other countries and an increase in global commodity prices leading to unrest and conflict within and between countries. Countries across the world think about their own national security\, not of the larger world outside. Impacts of climate change cannot be managed this way. Global cooperation needs to be enhanced for addressing national security implications due to climate change and there is no alternative to this. \nKey Discussion Outcomes\nFollowing are the key points that emerged from the discussion among the participants: \nAn evolved understanding of national security: An interesting point raised by the security experts was that the traditional way of looking at national security and defence has largely been determined by geopolitical concerns. The evidence and insights shared by the experts on climate risks however suggests that national security and defence will need to be viewed from an angle of natural environment and climate impacts as well. Does this mean that we are proposing a new theory of war and national security? This is an interesting question and needs to be reflected upon by the stakeholders. \nImproved risk assessment methodology: Our understanding of how to characterise risks is improving\, but it still has a lot of room for improvement. It is clear that we need to have more rigorous analytical frameworks for a better understanding of climate risks. It was recognised that there are private insurance firms that have quantitative experts trying to better characterise climate risks. However how climate risks can impact national security adds another layer of complexity to it. Current risk assessment frameworks are a very good beginning\, but are limited in nature. Risk assessment experts need to enhance and improve the methodological framework for better understanding of risks and their linkages with national security. \nExisting risks to the defence forces: Climate change is always perceived to be a very long-term debate\, with a horizon of many decades. We need to realise that impacts are already happening. Incidences like avalanches and flash floods have been increasing and this has negatively impacted our defence forces. Location of military bases could be impacted by global warming and climate change. There are such near terms risks for our forces that need to be identified and adapted to. Climate change impacts can’t be viewed as only a long-term risk anymore. \nIncreasing pressure on disaster management forces: Armed forces are being increasingly called upon as an initial point of response to natural disasters in India. There is an opportunity cost of using defence forces for disaster management. As the frequency of disasters increase\, the resource allocation for the military too needs to increase. Hence climate change also impacts resource planning and allocation\, and this aspect needs to be considered while understanding linkages between climate change and national security. \nA longer term engagement between national security and climate risk experts in India: It was highlighted that Indian experts on national security have until now not engaged intensively with the climate risk experts. Also\, the climate risk experts in India have focused on improved understanding of the risks but have not engaged with the national security experts informing them about the implications of climate change induced risks for India’s national security. The current discussion was intended as a first step in that direction and both these communities have to ensure that there is a continuous and long-term engagement between them. \nWay Forward\nDr. Uttam Sinha gave the final vote of thanks to all the participants for engaging with this process. He mentioned that the views of national security experts are critical for better understanding of how climate risks would impact national security\, as well as an improved understanding of climate risks itself. He re-emphasised that there is a need to build an understanding of climate risks within India\, and it is critical now that we build on earlier research as well as the day’s discussions to institutionalise cooperation between the climate risk and national security communities within India. It is imperative that we strengthen this long-term cooperation for enhancing India’s national security. \nList of Participants\n\n\n\n Name\n Organisation\n\n\nMr. Jayant Prasad\nIDSA\n\n\nDr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\nIDSA\n\n\nCol. (Retd.) P. K. Gautam\nIDSA\n\n\nCol. Pushpendra Mair\nResearch Scholar\, TERI University\n\n\nMs. Shebonti Ray Dadwal\nIDSA\n\n\nDr. Smruti S. Pattanaik\nIDSA\n\n\nDr. G. Balachandran\nIDSA\n\n\nSir David King\nFCO-UK\n\n\nMs. Frances Hooper\nBritish High Commission\, New Delhi\n\n\nMr. Sayantan Sarkar\nBritish High Commission\, New Delhi\n\n\nDr. Purnamita Dasgupta\nInstitute of Economic Growth (IEG)\n\n\nDr. Lydia Powell\nObserver Research Foundation (ORF)\n\n\nDr. Arunabha Ghosh\nCEEW\n\n\nDr. Vaibhav Chaturvedi\nCEEW
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/understanding-national-security-implications-of-climate-risks
CATEGORIES:ROUND TABLES / WORKSHOPS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20160311T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20160311T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133006Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130237Z
UID:63070-1457674200-1457674200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Why China Trumps India in the Oil Industry in Angola and Nigeria?
DESCRIPTION:Chairperson: Ambassador Mahesh Sachdev (Retd.)External Discussants: Prof. Alka Acharya and Prof. Girijesh PantInternal Discussant: Ms. Ruchita Beri \nThe competition between China and India in Africa has been an important and recurrent theme of discussion within the academic community. The paper presented by Raj Verma contributes to the ongoing discussion by making a comparative study of the Chinese and Indian interests and stakes in the oil sectors of the two West African countries: Angola and Nigeria. In recent years\, West Africa has emerged as a major energy producing region with Nigeria and Angola as major players. If Nigeria is the largest oil producer in Africa and has the second largest oil reserves\, Angola is the second largest oil producer and has the third largest oil reserves. Proven oil reserves in Nigeria have increased from 23 billion barrels in 2001 to 37 billion barrels in 2015. In Angola\, proven oil reserves have almost doubled from 5.4 billion barrels in 2001 to nine billion barrels in 2015. Oil production has also increased significantly in Angola. \nThe paper seeks to explain why China’s national oil companies (NOCs) have been able to outperform Indian oil companies (both NOCs and private sector oil companies) in Angola and Nigeria. The paper identifies four reasons in this regard: first\, the Chinese NOCs have more oil blocks in Angola and Nigeria compared to the Indian companies; second\, NOCs from China are able to outbid Indian oil companies when they directly compete for the same oil block; third\, Chinese NOCs are favoured as partners both by the African NOCs as well as the international oil companies (IOCs); and fourth\, Chinese NOCs have access to better quality oil blocks compared to the Indian companies. These four reasons can be attributed to macro level and micro level factors.  \nAt macro level\, the difference in the economic\, political and diplomatic support received by the Chinese and Indian oil companies from their respective governments plays a huge role in China outperforming India in Angola and Nigeria. It is important to note that China has foreign exchange reserves of more than US$ 3.33 trillion compared to India’s modest US$ 348.93 billion.\nAt micro level\, access to capital\, rate of return on investment\, pricing of oil\, risk aversion and ability to acquire technology are factors that place Chinese NOCs at an advantageous position. The Chinese NOCs have greater access to cheap capital than the Indian oil companies as they are able to borrow at 0-1 per cent interest rate domestically\, whereas the cost of capital in the domestic market for Indian state owned enterprises including NOCs and private sector enterprises is 10-11 per cent. Moreover\, the Chinese NOCs operate at lower rates of return on investment compared to the Indian oil companies. Similarly\, while the Chinese NOCs operate at a margin of three to four per cent in general\, the Indian NOCs operate at a margin of 10-11 per cent. Indian private enterprises operate at margins close to 18-20 per cent.  \nThe Chinese valuations of oil and investment is very high as it is able to take substantial risks due to massive financial resources available to it and hence are able to outbid India by shelving out vast amounts of money to acquire oil blocks. Chinese valuations of the oil blocks in Nigeria and Angola have been on the higher side as Chinese assume that their economy will keep growing at a high rate and the demand for oil will remain a primary mover of international oil prices. While Indian firms have better project management skills\, Chinese are able to purchase technology with greater ease as they have colossal financial resources. Given this asymmetry of power and resources\, it may be difficult for Indian oil companies and other corporations to compete with China in direct competitive bidding for oil assets in Africa. \nDiscussion and Suggestions: \n\nWhile the paper presents a good empirical material\, it needs to be interpreted theoretically.\nIn the recent past\, Chinese state owned enterprises have witnessed significant changes in terms of greater devolution of power taking place.\n\nChina’s energy mix is going through a transformation due to factors such as climate change. In the next 10 to 15 years\, India will become a major global energy player due its sustained economic growth. Taking into consideration these factors\, their impact on the oil sector in Africa has to be analysed.\nWhy China is not reluctant to invest in risky countries like Sudan and Iraq too needs to be analysed.\nRole of domestic institutions in China’s foreign policy making has to be understood in order to comprehend its decision making process for acquiring global energy assets.\nIt is important to explore how change in strategic value of oil assets in coming years is likely to impact or transform China’s policy towards Africa.\n\nIf perceptions matter\, then it is important to analyse why India despite its rich historical connections and diaspora has not been able to sufficiently influence the perceptions of the African people.\nIt should also be noted that Africans are getting disenchanted with Chinese companies as they bring their own labour and do not transfer technology to them.\nThe African perspective on Chinese and Indian engagement in African oil industry needs to be properly understood. Africans are interested in diversifying their energy operators.\nThe political aspect of the Indian and Chinese engagement in Angola and Nigeria needs to be factored in along with the economic aspect.\n\nReport prepared by Mr. Nachiket Khadkiwala\, Research Assistant\, IDSA
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/why-china-trumps-india-in-the-oil-industry-in-angola-and-nigeria
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150529T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150529T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133106Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250228T001713Z
UID:63072-1432877400-1432877400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Strengthening Nuclear Security: Compliance to the Principal Legal Instruments of Nuclear Security
DESCRIPTION:Chair: Dr  Arvind KumarExternal  Discussants: Dr Sitakanta Mishra and Dr Manish DhabadeInternal  Discussants: Mr S Samuel C Rajiv and Ms Sourabhi  Mukherji  \nPresentation\n  Nuclear security concerns  during the Cold War era revolved around the concepts of nuclear deterrence and  nuclear proliferation. However\, in the 21st century\, due to  increased globalization\, political instability and terrorist activities around  the world\, there is a greater threat of theft\, sabotage\, unauthorized access\,  illegal transfer or other malicious acts involving nuclear or other radioactive  substance. In this context the author in this paper points to the urgency of  having an international consensus on building a more robust nuclear system with  legal instruments which would be put in place to prevent the misuse of  sensitive nuclear and radiological material by terrorists. Dr Kazi in her paper  highlights the gaps in the nuclear security system where there are no  substantial legal instruments that have been developed to control the transfer  of these sensitive materials to miscreants. A stronger nuclear security system  is also needed due the existence of nuclear weapons in domestically unstable  and politically volatile regions. In such places\, the nuclear facilities are  susceptible to vulnerabilities like accidents\, miscalculations\, sabotage and  pilferage. Therefore\, a nuclear security system with legal instruments would  allow more effective regulation and make individual states more accountable for  the safety of their nuclear capabilities. Hence\, the need for international  cooperation to control nuclear/radioactive sources around the world is of  paramount importance for the prevention of nuclear terrorism and ensuring  global security.\n Dr Kazi looks at three  existing critical instruments for strengthening nuclear security:  \n\nConvention  on the Physical Protection of Nuclear Material (CPPNM) of 1980\n\nIt is the only legally binding  international instrument in the area of physical protection of nuclear material\nIts primary objective is to facilitate the  safe transfer of nuclear materials.\n\nAmendment  to the CPPNM OF 2005\n\nSenior Expert Group for the Review of the  IAEA’s  Programme of Activities  recommended that a possible revision on the CPPNM should be done to address the  issues of prevention of unauthorized possession of nuclear material and access  to nuclear facilities\n2005 CPPNM amendment emphasised the  importance of sharing best practices that would be critical to developing a  stringent physical protection system. \n\nInternational  Convention for the Suppression of Acts of Nuclear Terrorism (ICSANT) of  2005  \n\nPrevention of the misuse of  nuclear/radiological materials.\nRequires State-parties to make every  effort to adopt appropriate measures to ensure the protection of radioactive  material\, taking into account relevant recommendations and functions of the  agency. \n\n\nThese three legal  instruments urge cooperation for the prevention\, repression and elimination of  terrorism in all forms and calls upon states to criminalize offences related to  the misuse of nuclear/radioactive materials. However\, Dr Kazi argues that  despite all these efforts\, the legal instruments mentioned above remain  ineffective and lack universality. One of the reasons for their ineffectiveness  is complacency. Since in reality no incident of this sort has taken place\,  there is no urgency in complying with a nuclear security system to protect  nuclear/radioactive material. Second\, is the lack of universality\, as countries  that do not have stockpiles of nuclear/radioactive material do not feel the  need to implement effective controls on nuclear material. Nevertheless\, the  author argues that State-parties and non-state parties have the prime  responsibility of generating the requisite political will for an effective  implementation of these legal instruments. If need be\, incremental transparency  in nuclear matters can be effected to generate confidence about its security concerns  which could in the future help to produce a necessary political will for making  these legal instruments universal. \n    Discussion  and Suggestions\n\nThe history and evolution of terrorism and  the way it has been tackled by states have to be mentioned in the context of  nuclear/radioactive materials falling into the wrong hands. \nHistorical debates surrounding the legal  instruments for nuclear security system should be elaborated.\nThe difference between nuclear security  and nuclear safety has to be mentioned and also how the former is evolving in  comparison to the latter. \nEvolution and reforms made in the various  Nuclear Security Summits have to be included to have a more comprehensive  understanding of the evolution of nuclear security. \nThe politics behind non-compliance should  be an integral part of the argument to highlight the lack of universality for  the nuclear security system at the international level.\nThe nature of the balancing act has to be  taken into consideration in the management of nuclear terrorism and nuclear  proliferation.\nThe human element or negligence of  security of nuclear facilities domestically has to be taken into consideration.\n\n(Report  prepared by Ms. Kuhoo Saxena\, Research Intern\, IDSA)
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/strengthening-nuclear-security-compliance-to-the-principal-legal-instruments-of-nuclear-security
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150529T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150529T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133106Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250228T001607Z
UID:63073-1432877400-1432877400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:India’s Decision Making on Cross Border Natural Gas Pipelines (1989-2012)
DESCRIPTION:Chair: Dr. Gulshan Dietl\nExternal Discussants: Ms. Lidya Powell and Mr. Ragunatha Mishra\nInternal Discussants: Dr. Smriti Pattnaik and Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha \nIn the 21st century a nation’s economy thrives on its efficient and boundless use of energy. In this context\, India holds one of the largest markets of energy consumption in the world. Therefore\, energy security has become the paramount focus of Indian Foreign policy. To achieve this goal\, India is pursuing a broad range of options to diversify its energy sources. It ranges from LNG deals\, buying oil and gas spot markets\, acquisition of oil and gas fields abroad\, etc. One of the options is sourcing of energy supplies from neighbours (immediate and distant) through pipelines because of India’s comparative advantages in transportation costs as compared to other modes such as LNG. In this frame of reference\, Government of India identified three natural gas pipeline options: IPI (Iran-Pakistan-India)\, TAPI (Turkmenistan-Afghanistan-Pakistan-India) and MBI (Myanmar-Bangladesh-India). Kulkarni’s paper focuses on the decision making process involved on these natural gas pipeline projects from 1989 to 2012 and the factors that have influenced India’s decision making on cross border natural gas pipelines. \nThe paper examines the decision making process in this regard by using “Rational Actor Model Theory”\, which is based on cost benefit analysis and Masuda’s condition for Cross Border Pipelines. Kulkarni investigates the rationale behind India’s joining these projects which are costly and geopolitically controversial. The paper also attempts to understand India’s reasons for pursuing TAPI over IPI and MBI. \nKulkarni acknowledges that there is a clash between India’s need for energy security and its strategic interest. Hence\, taking this into account\, he recommends evolving a balance between the two. \nKey Points from discussion:\n\nThe paper discuss appropriate financial regime and commercial viability through cost benefit analysis. At the centre of any such decision making exercise should be the evolution of a balance between the management of geopolitical risk and commercial viability.\nThe energy demand in India is huge. However\, the demand is unmet because it cannot be transformed into purchasing power. Absence of stakeholders for using LNG to generate power is one example.\nWhy is the government reluctant to pursue gas projects as it has simultaneously pursued projects for LNG ports?\nAny analysis of decision making must include the agencies\, organisational structure and authorities involved in decision making. A critical examination of the decision making process is required.\nWhether any inter-ministerial conflict existed in the government during the course of decision making and implementation of the projects has to be taken into consideration.\nThe decision on applying the Rational Actor Theory and ‘Masuda’s’ model in the context of South Asia must be taken into consideration. A special focus is needed to understand the TAPI gas pipeline given the internal dynamics of India and Pakistan. One of the decision making models that is well suited for the conditions prevailing in South Asia is Richard Snyder’s.\nThe reasons for the government to opt for IPI\, TAPI and MBI rather that Oman–India pipeline or SAGE Pipeline should be carefully analysed. The analysis should also include the costs involved.\nAny decision making process on energy projects must include the following:\n\nProvision of providing excess to energy to every one\nSecuring energy supply\nTrying to limit carbon emissions\nImplementation of choices and alternatives of decision-making process must be in compliance with India’s fiscal and environment policies.\nGas pipeline construction must be looked at from the perspective of strategic investment. The presence of Iran and Unites States in this region should be taken into consideration.\n\n\n\n(Report prepared by Satyam Malaviya\, Research Intern\, IDSA)
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/indias-decision-making-on-cross-border-natural-gas-pipelines-1989-2012
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150522T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150522T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133106Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250228T001818Z
UID:63074-1432272600-1432272600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:India in Global Governance: Engaging the Counter-Terrorism Regime
DESCRIPTION:Chair: Mr. G. K. PillaiExternal Discussants: Dr. Suresh K. Goel and Dr. Rana BanerjiInternal Discussants: Dr. Vinod Kumar and Dr. Saurabh Mishra \nPresentation\nThe paper focuses on the counter-terrorism regime and highlights that there is a gap in the literature in demonstrating India’s evolving role in the norm building process of this regime. In the paper the author focuses on the post-Cold War period and uses the counter-terrorism regime as a case-study to assess whether India’s engagement has been substantial to the global governance of counter-terrorism. There have been studies of India’s role in the counter-terrorism regime but they all focus on the years after the 9/11 incident. However\, Dr. Anant argues that India has been very active and constructive with its engagement with counter-terrorism regime since much earlier. Some examples of India’s constructive contribution in the counter-terrorism regime were: \n\nIndia had played an important role in the drafting of the General Assembly Resolution 40/6 in 1987. India firmly believed that the underlying causes have to be mitigated in order to end the menace of terrorism. India also recognized the difference between terrorism and movements of self-determination and at the same time was wary of terrorism perpetrated by mercenaries with a view to undermining territorial integrity.\nIn 1991\, speaking on the subject of violence related to movements of national liberation\, India held on to its pre-Cold War position that it recognized the right of self defence of legitimate national liberation movements.\nWith regard to terrorism and human rights\, after the Declaration of Human Rights in 1993\, India in this context\, while referring to Pakistan’s involvement in the 1993 Mumbai attacks\, in a country report on human rights in the Third Committee of General Assembly in 1993\, said that terrorism was the greatest impediment to the realization of human rights. \nAt the plenary of the General Assembly in 1995\, India was critical of United Nations doing nothing to defend democracies from extremists and other violent threats.\nAfter the adoption of the International Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings in 1997\, India pushed the General Assembly to fulfill the commitment made in Resolution 51/210 and set up an Ad Hoc Committee to first adopt an international convention for the suppression of acts of nuclear terrorism and\, then a comprehensive convention on international terrorism.\n\nThe paper highlights that India played a crucial role in sponsoring and supporting many resolutions on counter-terrorism in the post-Cold War period. For example: \n\nIn 1996\, India tabled the Draft International Convention on Suppression of Terrorism in the General Assembly\, which aimed to deal with state support to terrorism. India was much ahead of developed states in pointing out the menace of state sponsored terrorism.\nIn 1997\, India co-sponsored a draft resolution on Human Rights and Terrorism\, which was adopted in 1999.\nIndia was the lone country that voted against paragraphs 10 and 11 in the debate of Draft resolution A/C.3/58/L.71: Protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms while countering terrorism in 2003\, which made no reference to violation of human rights by terrorists.\nIn 2000\, the General Assembly took up for discussion India’s Draft Comprehensive Convention of International Terrorism.\nIn 2002\, India co-sponsored the Draft Resolution on Hostage Taking and introduced the resolution on Measures to prevent terrorists from acquiring weapons of mass destruction in the General Assembly.\nAnd in 2006\, India supported and joined the Global Counter-Terrorism Strategy Adopted by the General Assembly.\n\nAlso\, India has been regular in its commitment to the counter-terrorism regime by submitting reports to the concerned UN committees regarding the action it has taken at the national and international levels to curb the menace of terrorism. India has also been vocal in pointing out the problems of non-compliance with anti-terrorism conventions and has urged that a way be found to punish states that abet terrorism. India has made suggestions to make the Counter-Terrorism Committee more effective and accountable through getting more feedback from countries\, increase in interaction between countries and seeking reports to identify violations. Based on all this\, Dr. Anant concludes that India has gone much beyond using existing systems to highlight its concerns regarding international terrorism and the evidence adduced above reiterates the fact that India has been a constructive player in the multilateral counter-terrorism regime. \nDiscussion\n\nIt is important to mention how the Indian government’s position and thinking has changed over the years on the issue of terrorism and how this has been shown through our engagement at the international level.\nHighlighting the difference in the understanding of terrorism and which definition does India support is important.\nDomestic imperative for international suggestions by India has to be mentioned. \nReceptivity to India’s responses with regards to international financing mechanisms of terrorism should be considered.\nInternational monitoring and how India is coping with it internally is of significance.\nPolitics of regime building\, partnership and structural review of the regime should be mentioned as part of the argument.\nContextualization of global and internal terrorism and a link between the two have to be established.\nA watershed event has to be mentioned to show the changes in India’s approach to terrorism at the international level.\nReasons for the failure to build coalitions on terrorism for furthering India’s national interest should be considered.\nPolicy recommendations on how India should form coalitions so it can put its view across at the international level should be analyzed.\nPolitics of compliance and the role of powerful nations should be considered and how has India contributed tobettering compliance among nations should also be included.\nIndia’s role as norm taker or norm maker should be clearly identified.\nSupport by other countries for India at the counter-terrorism regime should be mentioned and also it is important to indicate as to which group India belongs to at the international level.\n\n(This report has been prepared by Ms. Kuhoo Saxena\, Research Intern\, IDSA)
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/india-in-global-governance-engaging-the-counter-terrorism-regime
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150515T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20150515T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T234151
CREATED:20231223T133106Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130237Z
UID:63075-1431667800-1431667800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Iran Sanctions and India
DESCRIPTION:Chair: Prof. Girijesh PantExternal Discussants: Prof. Gulshan Dietl\, Nidhi VermaInternal Discussants: Dr. G. Balachandran\, Shebonti Ray Dadwal \nThe paper examined the sanctions imposed by the UN Security Council (UNSC)\, the United States (US) and the European Union (EU) against Iran in the aftermath of the Iranian nuclear issue being referred to the UNSC in February 2006 and the responses and implications for India as a result of these measures. UNSC sanctions primarily involved asset freezes of and travel bans on entities and individuals connected with Iran’s nuclear and missile programmes. India took executive actions to conform to UNSC sanctions measures and prevent possible misuse. These were however in continuation of measures it had been taking prior to 2006 as well (like the June 2005 WMD Act)\, which strengthened its regulatory and legislative mechanisms for preventing the sale of WMD-related materials and technology to wrong hands. The paper dwelt on some pertinent issues relating to the Iran-O-Hind shipping Company (IHSC)\, which was specifically targeted by UNSCR 1929 of June 2010.       \nUS and EU sanctions targeting Iran’s crude oil exports have had a significant impact on major importers like India. These measures were based on the contention that Iran was using oil revenues to fund WMD-related programmes\, a concern that was first raised in the preamble to UNSCR 1929. The foundational US sanctions legislation targeting Iran’s petroleum sector was the Iran and Libya Sanctions Act (ILSA) of 1996\, which became the Iran Sanctions Act (ISA) in 2006. The paper gave a brief account of the legislation\, as well as changes carried out in ISA as part of the Comprehensive Iran Sanctions and Divestment Act (CISADA) of 2010. CISADA further imposed restrictions on the sale of refined petroleum products to Iran\, affecting Indian companies like Reliance. Section 1245 of National Defence Authorisation Act (NDAA) 2012 targeted the Central Bank of Iran (CBI) for the first time and called for ‘significant reductions’ of imports of Iranian crude and prescribed exemptions from sanctions if a country did so. Section 504 of the Iran Threat Reduction and Syria Human Rights Act (ITRSHRA) severely curtailed Iran’s foreign exchange earnings by mandating that funds owed to Iran as a result of bilateral trade in goods and services be “credited to an account located in the country with primary jurisdiction over the foreign financial institutions.” \nThe EU Decision of July 2010 and the subsequent EU Regulation of October 2010 (specifically Article 10) impacted payment mechanisms like the Asian Clearing Union (ACU) which India was using to pay for Iranian oil. Further\, prohibition on the provision of insurance services (Article 12) by European-based insurance providers for ships transporting Iranian crude had a negative impact on Indian refineries. The paper briefly described the impact and responses of Indian oil companies like the Chennai Petroleum Corporation Limited (CPCL) and Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Limited (MRPL) to these measures\, as indicated in their annual reports. \nThe US and EU sanctions measures led to a significant reduction in India’s import of Iranian crude\, which came down to less than five per cent of the total imports in 2014-15\, from 13 per cent in 2009-10. Indian policy makers have also often cited the prevailing sanctions regime as negatively affecting India’s investments in Iran’s energy sector. The paper gave a brief account of the status of the agreements signed between Indian and Iranian companies including the December 2009 agreement for the South Pars Phase-II and Farzad-B gas field\, IOCL ‘s investments in the Farsi Block\, among others. The paper closed by noting some of the pertinent developments in the post-Joint Plan of Action (JPOA) period\, including the significant role played by Indian oil companies in JPOA sanctions relief. It ended by noting that the sequencing of sanctions relief as part of a comprehensive nuclear deal would have a bearing on the nature of Iran’s oil trade with key energy partners like India. \nDiscussion and Suggestions to the Author   \n\nIndia is not the only state affected by sanctions. It will be interesting to know how other countries have coped with these measures.\nChina for instance seems to be more adept at engaging economically with Iran\, though it is also circumscribed by the same sanctions and it is also part of the P5+1. China has also apparently built a business centre and is in the process of building a petrochemical complex in Chabahar. \nAspects regarding India’s recent decision to go ahead with investing in Chabahar could be explored. What material changes if any has resulted in this decision?\nAn exploration of the context surrounding these various sanctions measures would be useful. What were the reasons underpinning the increase in the nature of sanctions targeting Iran’s petro-chemical sector from 2010 onwards? An examination of US as well as Iran’s domestic political and energy context would throw more light on the issue. \nThe author was urged to conduct interviews with retired or serving policy makers to the extent possible to get inputs on some of the aspects covered in the paper. \nSome forward-looking aspects in terms of policy recommendations could be incorporated into the paper\, including on such issues like the possible impact of an impending deal on Indian businesses and oil companies as well as on India’s balance of trade with Iran. It was pointed out that India would be dealing with a ‘different Iran’ in the aftermath of a nuclear deal.\nThe paper could explore US-EU interaction on the issue of sanctions vis-à-vis Iran and see if there were any divergences or convergences over the issue\, especially since EU countries were significant importers of Iranian oil prior to 2012.\nRegional dynamics specifically the role of Saudi Arabia and the nature of increase in its oil exports in the aftermath of sanctions targeting Iran could be highlighted.\nUS pressure on India vis-à-vis its energy trade with Iran as well as investments in Iran’s energy infrastructure and view towards projects like IPI can be included.\n\nReport prepared by Sourabhi Mukherjee\, Research Intern\, Nuclear and Arms Control Centre\, IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/iran-sanctions-and-india
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR