BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20210101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230426T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230426T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233218
CREATED:20231223T131048Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62940-1682487000-1682487000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Talk on "MP-IDSA and Policy Research" by Dr. Uttam K. Sinha and Dr. Ashok K. Behuria
DESCRIPTION:Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence  Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised  talks by Dr. Ashok K.  Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, South Asia Centre\, and Dr. Uttam K. Sinha\, Senior  Fellow\, Non-Traditional and Security Centre on “MP-IDSA and Policy Research”   which were held on 26 April 2023. The talks were attended by the Associate  Fellows\, Research Analysts\, Interns and other scholars of the Institute. \nExecutive Summary\nThe Manohar  Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) is India’s foremost think tank for  advanced research in international relations\, especially defence\, strategic\,  and security issues. It provides training to civilian\, military\, and  paramilitary officers of the Indian Government. It was established on 11 November  1965. The Senior Fellows of the Institute shared their experience in MP-IDSA  and talked about its importance\, and also offered their views on how to improve  the quality of research at the Institute and spelled out the norms prevalent at  the Institute pertaining to publication\, media interaction etc.   \nDetailed Report\nDr. Ashok Behuria  started\, by discussing the background against which IDSA was conceived soon  after the India-China War in 1962. He said that after the 1962 debacle\, it was  felt necessary that there should be a think tank focusing on strategic issues  in India\, which would keep an eye on the changing geopolitics and suggest  policy alternatives for decision-makers in the realms of foreign and security  policy of the country. \nInstitutions like  RAND Corporation and the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) were  taken as models and finally\, the Institute was established in November 1965. He  quoted from the writings of Shri K. Subrahmanyam while discussing how MP-IDSA  functioned during its initial days and emphasised that all the Institute’s  scholars must read the article by K. Subrahmanyam on the Birth of IDSA.  \nHe talked about  the academic freedom that is fundamental to research at MP-IDSA and held that  the freedom provided to the scholars should be used judiciously. Rather than  criticising government policies\, the job of the researchers is to provide a  constructive critique of government policies and provide the policymakers with  options and analyses of the prevalent strategic environment both in the  neighborhood and at the global level.  \nHe urged the  scholars to be very careful about their study and said that the focus should be  on providing solutions to India’s strategic challenges. He emphasised the  importance primary sources while conducting research. He advised scholars not  to use the name of either MP-IDSA or the Government of India while expressing  their views unless they were mandated specifically to do so. Pointing to the  rise in social-media participation by the youth these days\, he said that while  it was welcome to do so\, the scholars must practice restraint while expressing  their views and ought to stick to their areas of expertise.  \nContinuing the  discussion\, Dr. Uttam Sinha started with a question about how it had been  working in a think tank like MP-IDSA. He said that it was essential to read K.  Subrahmanyam’s article on the Birth of IDSA and said that when Shri  Subrahmanyam was the director of IDSA he highlighted that we should always keep  in mind where we are located and what is the function of the Institution. He  held that criticism was an important part of research but it should always be  constructive and enriching. He said that the scholars must remember that  whatever they would write\, especially through the MP-IDSA website or  publications\, would be read by the government\, and therefore there has to be a  fair degree of caution in what the scholars seek to express and how balanced  their articulation is.  \nDr. Behuria added  that we should find a way to strengthen our audio-visual projection as well so  that we can propagate our views through the YouTube channel which will project  the Institute in a big way.  \nDr. Uttam pointed  out that language and communication were important and said that the scholars  needed to find ways to better express themselves.    \nDr. Vishal  Chandra\, Research Fellow\, shared his perspectives and said that one of the  major responsibilities of the scholar was to try to simplify things for the  reader and present her/his viewpoint in a very reader-friendly manner. He said  that the scholars should identify the gaps in the existing discourse on a  particular theme and then attempt her/his research on hitherto unexplored  areas.  \nDr. Sinha said  that the role of MP-IDSA scholar was to sensitise the public on issues of national  security which is the mandate of the Institute as per its MoU.  \nMrs. Mayuri  Banerjee\, Research Analyst\, commented that we should write in a way that we can  publish our work and it is acceptable to a wider range of audience. \nDr. Rajorshi Roy\,  Associate Fellow\, commented that in terms of speaking and writing skills\, one  needs to keep developing them over time.  \nLastly\, the  speaker and the audience discussed the Institute’s interface with the media and  how the scholars should carry themselves in media.  \nReport  prepared by Mr. Karan Phular\, Intern\, Centre of Europe and Eurasia\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/talk-on-mp-idsa-and-policy-research-by-dr-uttam-k-sinha-and-dr-ashok-k-behuria
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230424T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230424T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233218
CREATED:20231223T131049Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62941-1682314200-1682314200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “Integrating India’s Northeastern Region in the Backdrop of “Act East Policy”
DESCRIPTION:Col.  Gurinder Pal Singh\, Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence  Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “Integrating India’s North East Region  in the Backdrop of “Act East Policy” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 24th  April 2023. The session was moderated by Col. (Dr.) DPK Pillay\,(Retd).\,  Research Fellow. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, the Director General of MP-IDSA\,  Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, the Deputy Director General of MP-IDSA  and scholars of the Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nAct East Policy is a key foreign policy that aims to  further strengthen India’s relationship with the South East Asian region  through three ‘Cs’- Commerce\, Connectivity and Culture. In the process of  establishing connect with the South East/Asia Pacific region\, integration of  India’s North Eastern Region can be understood as both a precondition for the  success\, as well as a desirable outcome of the said policy. The need is to  develop a robust and comprehensive strategy towards this end through an  integrated approach. Challenges remain multi-dimensional that include  insurgency\, Indian Insurgent Group (IIG) camps\, arms trade\, and other  governance and administrative issues. In order to fully utilise the untapped  potential of the North Eastern region\, strategies and their effective  implementation is paramount.  \nDetailed Report \nCol. (Dr.)  DPK Pillay (Retd.) began the meeting with a brief introduction about Col.  Gurinder Pal Singh.  \nCol.  Gurinder Pal Singh began his presentation by putting forth a brief outline of  his presentation that emphasised the challenges faced while incorporating the  North Eastern Region within the context of the “Act East Policy”\, and to  present strategies derived from the ‘Net Assessment Process’ to address these  challenges effectively. Col. Singh proceeded by giving a brief historical  background and evolution of the physical as well as political composition of  North Eastern States. The nomenclature ‘seven sisters’ was eventually evolved  to ‘Ashtlakshmi’ with the inclusion of Sikkim within North Eastern fold in  2002. The diverse demographic composition of North Eastern Region is riddled  with division on tribal lines and heterogeneity\, further complicated by the  improper state border demarcation.  \nThe speaker  then dwelled on the Act East Policy\, announced by the Prime Minister Narendra  Modi during the East Asia Summit in Myanmar in November 2014. The policy not  only entails economic or foreign policy orientation rather it exhibits  political\, strategic and cultural characteristics. It is due to its extreme  significance that institutional mechanisms for dialogue and cooperation have  been established. All these mechanisms have been directed towards and driven by  three overarching C’s- Commerce\, Connectivity and Culture.  \nHe further  discussed in greater detail six challenges facing the North East Region- Insurgency\,  Indian Insurgence Group (IIG) camps\, illegal arms trade\, AFSPA\, Peace Accords  and other aspects. The government’s action on this entire front has to some  extent been encouraging but lots need to be done so as to further the  integration process.   \nHe then  took the presentation to a ‘Net Assessment’ phase where he explained in detail  the formulation of strategies based on the problem statement emanating from the  situation on ground. For instance\, in this case\, integration of North East  Region is the overall objective. To proceed ahead\, scanning various internal  and external factors impacting the region is required. After the detailed  assessment of the region\, as well as government’s own strength\, suitable  strategies have to be crafted out. The strategy must be clearly illustrative of  what actually it entails\, without any ambiguity. He went on to use this  formulation in problem statements from a diverse set of landscape ranging from  Governance\, Economic\, Cultural and Social Development strategies. \nCol. Singh  concluded the presentation with some of the key recommendations across three  different landscapes- Governance\, Socio-political and Economic. Under Governance\,  he emphasised upon inclusive growth model\, enhancement of trust\, transparency  and governance benefits reaching to the grass root level as drivers to  integrate the region. In this regard\, he recommended streamlining the land laws  to overcome the complex traditional system. This will help in land acquisition\,  encourage private enterprises and resolve ownership aspects involving tribal  groups and other stakeholders. One of the important aspects is to increase  North East representation in North Eastern Council and Ministry of Development  of North Eastern Region.  \nIn  socio-political domain\, Col\, Singh recommended tasking Civil Society  organisations\, and other local organisations for participative contribution  towards project monitoring\, executing and implementation of government schemes.  Further\, he recommended opening higher education institutes and centres of  excellence to further hone the much needed bridge between the North East Region  and rest of India. In the economic domain\, trade induced industrialisation\,  investment in communication infrastructure\, designating NER as a Special  Economic Zone can lead to increased investment\, export promotion\,  infrastructure and skill development. Further\, enhancing human resources can  lead to numerous socio-economic benefits including increased productivity\,  investment\, innovation\, social development\, social cohesion and sustainable  development.  \nComments and Questions \nCol. (Dr.)  DPK Pillay complimented the comprehensive presentation. He agreed to the  contention that the number of casualties due to insurgency have significantly  gone down due to a certain designed strategy being followed by the Armed Forces  and the Police. He illustrated the three pronged strategy followed to deal with  North East problem. The strategy entails\, end to all inter-state disputes by  2022\, no interference in indigenous socio-cultural life of tribals and  enhancing economic growth in the region. He further agreed with most of the recommendations  made by Col. Singh in his presentation.  \nThe floor  was opened for questions and comments. The Director General\, Ambassador Sujan  R. Chinoy\, the Deputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\,  and scholars of the Institute contributed to the discussion. In his remarks\, Ambassador  Chinoy emphasised on ‘national integration’ which is considered an important  ongoing process. He believes that on the integration  part India has done quite well\, especially in the last few years. The period  has witnessed resolution of unresolved boundary disputes between the states\,  forward movement\, dialogues with various underground groups. Connectivity is  another milestone achieved in the last few years in terms of construction of  roads\, highways\, feeder connectivity and bridges. On the point of trade led  development of the region\, Ambassador Chinoy pointed out that trade needs proper  transportation which  under the “Act East Policy” is a problem as the Kaladan multi-model project\,  Tamu-Kalewa-Kalemyo project and other similar projects have been languishing  for a long time. Airways led commerce is also not an option due to issues  related to market connectivity and specific goods related problems. \nAmbassador Chinoy  further highlighted the need for mental acceptance and integration of North  Eastern indigenously developed businesses which at the moment are dominated by  West India. Lack of large scale industrialisation is notable too.  \nCol. Singh agreed with  most of the observations brought forth by Amb. Chinoy and attributed most of  the positive developments to ‘Political Will’. \nMaj. Gen.  (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) highlighted that Bangladesh (more  specifically\, Chittagong) forms the natural flow of the land. Hence cutting  trees\, mountains\, terrains across north east for developmental purposes is not  wholly sustainable. He further emphasised upon better diplomacy in terms of  getting critical support from Bangladesh and Bhutan in tackling insurgency  issues.  \nIn response to Dr.  Gulbin Sultana’s question regarding religious peace in the region\, Col. Singh  highlighted the Buddhist\, Hindu and Christian circuit as an instrument to cater  to the religious aspirations of the people.  \n  In response to Dr.  Smruti Pattanaik’s question on free movement regimes and free trade\, Col. Singh  highlighted that a lot more needs to be done to control and regulate the  movement across the India-Myanmar Border. \nDr. Pushpita Das  highlighted the traditional nature of tribal society as the crux of the  problem. She stated that the need is to change the nature of society in order  for development initiatives to percolate down to the grass-root level. \nCol. Manish Rana  pointed out the paradox of mixing economic and cultural integration. According  to him\, preservation of cultural uniqueness is more important than the resolve  over cultural integration. \nMr. Jason Wahlang asked  about the prospects of integration in the longer run in light of tribal-non  tribal clashes witnessed in the North Eastern Region. Col. Singh asserted that  there are multiple socio-political issues which certainly impact the prospects  of integration. He cited the example of Citizenship Amendment Act that was  misconstrued in North East as targeted against indigenous inhabitants\, while a  lot of minorities have benefited from the Act on the western borders. \nReport prepared by Mr Abhishek Verma\, Research Analyst\,  Internal Security Centre\, MP-IDSA
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-integrating-indias-northeastern-region-in-the-backdrop-of-act-east-policy
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230417T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230417T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233218
CREATED:20231223T131148Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240305T062120Z
UID:62942-1681709400-1681709400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on रणनीतिक संचार: सहमतियों का निर्माण और भारत
DESCRIPTION:17 अप्रैल 2023 की  सोमवार ‘सुबह की बैठक    ’     में\, ओमप्रकाश दास\, रिसर्च फेलो\, मनोहर पर्रिकर रक्षा  अध्ययन और विश्लेषण संस्थान\, ने “रणनीतिक संचार    :     सहमतियों का  निर्माण और भारत     (Strategic Communication: Manufacturing of Consent and India)” विषय पर  एक व्याख्यान दिया।  व्याख्यान की अध्यक्षता डॉ. राजीव  नयन ने की और  बैठक में मेजर जनरल     (डॉ    .    ) बिपिन बख्शी (सेवानिवृत्त    )     के साथ संस्थान  के अन्य स्कॉलर्स की  उपस्थित रहे ।  \nसारांशः\n  सामरिक – रणनीतिक हित सिर्फ सीमाओं तक सीमित  नहीं होते है\, बल्कि यह सीमाओं से बहुत आगे तक जाते हैं।  वैश्विक भू    – राि में मनोवैज्ञानिक युद्ध या  लोक     राजनय की भी  एक महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका  होती है।  इसके माध्यम से ज्यादा से ज्यादा  लोगों तक पहुंचने की  कोशिश की जाती है। इस पूरी प्रक्रिया में  नैरेटिव    (कथानक) का  निर्माण तो होता ही है\, लेकिन ये आगे  जाकर     “सूचना का शस्त्रीकरण    “     भी कर सकता है। ‘रणनीतिक संचार    ’     एक विकसित होती हुई अवधारणा है\, जिसकी  संरचना अभी भी पूर्ण रूप से विकसित होने की  प्रक्रिया में है। ‘रणनीतिक संचार    ’     को  भारतीय  परिप्रेक्ष्य में समझें तो\, भारत द्विपक्षीय और बहुपक्षीय कूटनीति और राजनय के जरिए  एक व्यापक कथानक के निर्माण की  कोशिश करता रहा है। इसमें भारत की ‘सॉफ्ट पावर    ’     का भी एक महत्वपूर्ण स्थान  रहा है\, जो भारत की  विदेश  नीति का ज़रूरी हिस्सा  भी है। पिछले पांच सालों में  व्यापक रूप से ‘सहमतियों के  निर्माण’ की प्रक्रिया और उसके उपयोग को दक्षिण    – पूर्व एशिया में देखा जा  सकता है। एक बड़े स्तर पर\, यहाँ मीडिया स्वामित्व की प्रकृति  बदल रही है।  साथ ही मीडिया की  राजनीतिक    – आर्थिक सरंचनाओं में भी बदलाव हो रहा है। जिसका उपयोग  चीन विशेषकर अपनी ‘सॉफ्ट पावर    ’ के     विस्तार  में करता रहा है\, जो उसकी ‘रणनीतिक  संचार    ’     का ही  हिस्सा है। भारतीय परिप्रेक्ष्य में भी  यह साफ़ दिखाई  देता है कि कैसे मई 2020 के बाद  से\, चीनी मीडिया     (जैसे ग्लोबल टाइम्स\, चाइना       डेली और शिन्हुआ) ने भारत  पर भ्रमित करने वाले  मीडिया सामग्रियों का हमला व्यापक रूप से  बढ़ा दिया है।   \nDownload Complete Report [+]
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-%e0%a4%b0%e0%a4%a3%e0%a4%a8%e0%a5%80%e0%a4%a4%e0%a4%bf%e0%a4%95-%e0%a4%b8%e0%a4%82%e0%a4%9a%e0%a4%be%e0%a4%b0-%e0%a4%b8%e0%a4%b9%e0%a4%ae%e0%a4%a4%e0%a4%bf%e0%a4%af%e0%a5%8b
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230410T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230410T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233218
CREATED:20231223T131148Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240306T001205Z
UID:62943-1681104600-1681104600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Sustainable Development Goals: India's Challenges and Accomplishments
DESCRIPTION:Col. (Dr)  Divakaran Padma Kumar Pillay\, Research  Fellow\, Non-Traditional  Security Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses\, spoke on “Sustainable Development  Goals: India’s Challenges and Accomplishments” at the Monday Morning Meeting  held on 10 April 2023. The meeting was moderated by Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\,  Senior Fellow and Centre Coordinator\, NTS Centre\, MP-IDSA. Deputy Director  General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) and the scholars of the Institute  participated in the discussion. \nExecutive Summary\nThe  Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) were adopted by the United Nations in  2015. The basic objective set forth by these SDGs was to eradicate poverty\,  protect the planet\, and ensure global peace and prosperity by 2030. Nation  states are taking desired actions to meet these SDGs as per their national  capacities. In the context of the Russia-Ukraine conflict\, a significant amount  of economic resources have been drained that could have otherwise been used to  meet the objectives of global SDGs. India\, in comparison to many other states\, has  done significantly well in achieving its SDGs. \nDetailed Report\nDr. Uttam Kumar Sinha gave a brief  introduction about the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and highlighted  that SDGs require collective global action and India in the past has shown  remarkable success in achieving some of these\, while others still require  significant action. After his brief introductory remarks\, Dr. Sinha requested  Col. Pillay to make his presentation. \nCol. DPK Pillay started his  presentation by highlighting the need for sustainable development. He mentioned  that climate change and the over-exploitation of resources has impacted global food  production and has also resulted in global water scarcity. In his presentation\, he highlighted various  global initiatives on sustainable development including the  Stockholm Conference in 1972\, the Earth Summit in 1992\, the Kyoto Protocol in  1997 and the Paris Agreement in 2015. Col Pillay also discussed three key  elements of sustainable development i.e. Environmental Sustainability\, Social  Sustainability and Economic Sustainability. Highlighting the challenges to sustainable  development in the context of the Russia-Ukraine conflict\, he mentioned that  the conflict has drained a significant amount of economic resources that could  have otherwise been used to meet the objectives of global SDGs. Referring to  the emerging global shortages of food\, fuel and fertilizer\, Col. Pillay  mentioned that the conflict in Ukraine has significantly impacted global supply  chains.  \nIn  assessing India’s SDGs\, he highlighted the key roles played by various  ministries and organizations\, including the NITI Aayog\, the Ministry of  External Affairs\, the Finance Ministry\, the  Ministry of Environment\, Forest and Climate Change\, and the Ministry of Panchayati  Raj. Col. Pillay further discussed India’s initiatives such as Mahatma Gandhi  National Rural Employment Guarantee Act\, National Food Security Act\, Swachh  Bhatart Abhiyan and Atal Mission for Rejuvenation and Urban Transformation that  marks India’s important contributions in achieving SDGs. Col. Pillay mentioned  that despite these positive initiatives there are several challenges that  hinder India’s pace in achieving its national SDGs. These include financial and  budgetary constraints\, the issue of overpopulation and technological  limitations. Col. Pillay concluded with an optimistic universal prayer  highlighting India’s ethos in achieving common global good and SDGs. \nॐ सर्वे भवन्तु सुखिनः । सर्वे सन्तु निरामयाः ।  \n  सर्वे भद्राणि पश्यन्तु । मा कश्चित् दुःख भाग्भवेत् ॥ ॐ शान्तिः शान्तिः शान्तिः॥  \nQuestions and Comments \nPost the presentation\, Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha invited Deputy  Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd)\, for his comments\, and  then opened the floor to participants for their comments and questions. \nMaj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) highlighted the role  of the Urja Ganga Gas distribution pipeline that provided cheaper gas to 20  cities and towns in the hinterland. He mentioned that as we are in the process  of moving towards achieving SDGs\, this ongoing transition is also leaving  carbon footprints. He asked the speaker regarding the possible option that  India could take to limit such footprints.  \nMr. Arvind Khare asked the  speaker about India’s approach to social security and social justice in  achieving SDG targets. He further enquired about India’s approach in building adequate  facilities and infrastructure for Divyang Children. \nDr. Swasti Rao asked the  speaker to explain and differentiate between SDGs and Paris Agreement goals. \nDr. Adil Rasheed commented on the  interlinkages between political structures and their role in SDGs. He also  asked the speaker to comment on the role of modern political structures in  meeting various challenges of the state’s SDGs.   \nCol. DPK Pillay gave extensive and insightful remarks on all the  comments and questions raised by the participants. \nReport prepared  by Bipandeep Sharma\, Research Analyst\, Non-Traditional Security Centre\,  MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-sustainable-development-goals-indias-challenges-and-accomplishments
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230403T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230403T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233218
CREATED:20231223T131148Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62944-1680499800-1680499800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Analysing the EU Security Dialogue in Brussels: Implications of the Ukraine War for Europe\, the World\, and for India
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Swasti Rao\, Associate Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence  Studies and Analyses\, spoke on “Analysing  the EU Security Dialogue in Brussels: Implications of the Ukraine War for  Europe\, the World\, and for India” at  the Monday Morning Meeting held on 3 April 2023. The session was moderated by Cmde. Abhay Singh\, Research Fellow\,  MP-IDSA. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Maj. Gen.  (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Senior\, and  scholars of the Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nDr. Swasti Rao participated in the first edition of the  Schuman Security and Defence Forum in Brussels between 20-21 March 2023. The  Presentation gave an overview of the discussion at the dialogue and analysed  the capabilities of the European Union in strengthening its Security. \nDetailed Report\nCmde. Abhay Singh commenced the session by briefing everyone about the  previous years’ gas imports from Russia to European Union (EU) markets. He  talked about the approaches of different countries within Europe to assist  Ukraine in the war. \nDr. Swasti Rao stated that her  presentation would briefly explain the discussion at the Schuman Security and  Defence Forum\, where she had participated. She started by underscoring the EU’s  awareness of a more comprehensive understanding of security and putting efforts  into deepening the relationship\, not only with NATO and US but also across the  globe\, as they see the importance of like-minded partnerships in the current  period. The bloc aspires to become more autonomous and to focus on strategic  autonomy to become a global security provider through building key defense  partnerships. Cooperation with partners is the fundamental pillar of the EU  security and defense agenda. The motto for the Schuman Security and Defence  Forum 2023 was ‘stronger together in an unstable world’. The EU is focused on  strengthening its cooperation with regional organizations and also on crisis management  and stabilization worldwide. Dr. Rao also briefed about the European Peace  Facility and Security and Defence dialogues which are the key instruments of  the EU to strengthen their Partnership capabilities. \nDiplomatic relations between the  European Union and China seem more stable today than last year. Although  Beijing was not invited to the dialogue\, the EU is becoming more and more aware  of the requirement to form a uniform rule of engagement with Beijing. She  mentioned the speech of the European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen about  EU-China Relations and their new strategy to converge on “de-risking” ties with  China. The de-risking would essentially limit the EU’s vulnerability to a  broader range of stress factors and possible disruptions caused by Beijing and  China-related geopolitical tensions. \nThe speaker discussed the high  impact of events taking place in Europe like the Russia-Ukraine War\, energy  security crises\, climate change\, green transition\, and an escalation over  Taiwan\, etc. She said that the key takeaways from ‘day 1’ of the dialogue were  deliberations on the EU’s transactional diplomacy in Africa and Russia’s  presence in the Middle East via the Wagner group. She also mentioned  conversations on maritime space\, cyber capabilities and artificial intelligence  warfare\, security and politics of space\, Brexit\, etc. And finally\, she  emphasized the role of joint exercises for the EU. \nFurther\, she talked about EU  relations with India. India is a crucial partner for the EU\, and the West\, and  the geopolitical situation has opened a more comprehensive array of foreign  policy pathways for India to engage with the EU and vice versa. There have been  strategic talks with India for the security of the Indo-Pacific region. Noted  factors in their relationship were the Free Trade Agreement negotiations\,  Defence Cooperation with Europe\, India’s neutrality on Ukraine\, and India’s  relations and oil purchases with Russia. \nDr. Rao then discussed the Maritime  Domain Cooperation. The EU’s coordinated maritime presence is focused on the  western Indian Ocean Region (IOR)\, with India as a critical partner. There have  been talks on enhancing the Indo-Pacific Strategy and the potential of a  trilateral partnership. Other themes discussed were the global gateway\, green  hydrogen production\, and space cooperation. \nThe speaker highlighted the remarks  by the Swedish Minister of Defence on threats to the EU in today’s complex  environment. The minister said there is unprecedented cooperation between the  EU and NATO with reference to the joint declaration between the two on various  points in January 2023\, further adding to their plans for the division of  labour for collective defense across the globe. \n  In the concluding remarks\, Dr. Rao  said that as the challenges to global security grow\, the EU needs to work  together with partners and allies. \nQ&A Session\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy complimented the speaker on her  presentation. He commented on the change in concerns of the EU on its security\,  be it national\, international\, or energy. He said that we should do a very  careful analysis of the EU’s desire to expand in the security space of the  Indo-Pacific. The EU should change its way of looking at India and the Global South  for better partnerships in the region. He suggested a deeper study of sensitive  issues to strengthen our ties with the EU but on our own terms. \nMaj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) questioned the focus of the EU on  strategic autonomy and their capabilities to operate in the Indo-Pacific  region. He also pointed out NATO pivoting to Asia. He further added that we see  a regional division as the EU goes for the western IOR and AUKUS\, mainly on the  Western Pacific. He further asked whether the EU believes they can defeat  Russia with the recent internal disturbance within Europe. \nWith regard to the Director General’s  remarks\, Dr. Rao agreed with his comments and talked about the oil purchases in  Japan. She also emphasized the massive trade between the EU and China and  mentioned the EU hybrid threat toolbox. In response to the Deputy Director  General’s comment\, Dr. Rao pointed out that the deepening ties with the US and  NATO are key\, but the EU’s aspiration to achieve strategic autonomy should be  looked upon as a complementarity. Further\, she highlighted the EU’s ways of  achieving strategic autonomy and stated that they needed a balance between NATO  and strategic autonomy after the war to achieve their goal. She then briefly  mentioned the EU strategy for the Indo-Pacific. \nMr. Abhishek Verma\, Research  Analyst\, asked if there was any discussion about nuclear strategy and planning  and how Germany looked for a collective security framework that Europe is  coming up with\, like European peace facilities. Dr. Rao said there was no  discussion on nuclear strategy and planning\, but it was mentioned in passing.  In reply to another question\, she said that Germany does not want to be seen as  a country that is going alone like Poland but instead wants to be seen as going  along with its allies. \nMr. Niranjan Oak\, Research Analyst\,  questioned about providing lethal aid to some African countries through  European Peace Facilities. In reply to this question\, the speaker stated that  EU sentiments are evident in Europe and that if they want to ensure peace\, they  must have the capabilities to do that. She further added that the first aid  would go to Niger and Mali\, and after that\, they are going to Africa as they  are worried about the Wagner group.  \nDr. Deepika Saraswat\, Associate  Fellow in West Asia Centre\, pointed out the absentees of the Schuman Security  and Defence Forum and the EU’s outlook towards Central Asian countries\,  ignoring the importance of connectivity. In reply to this\, Dr. Rao stated there  had been a lot of talk on connectivity. Still\, the purpose of this forum was  only focused on Security and Defence partnerships leaving out economic aspects  for the moment.  \nThe report was prepared by Mr. Karan Phular\, Intern\,  Centre of Europe and Eurasia\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-analysing-the-eu-security-dialogue-in-brussels-implications-of-the-ukraine-war-for-europe-the-world-and-for-india
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230320T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230320T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233218
CREATED:20231223T131148Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62945-1679290200-1679290200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Presentation on Cultivating and Sustaining Subject Matter Experts in the Indian Army
DESCRIPTION:Col.  Guriqbal Singh Gill\, Research  Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses  (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on     “Cultivating and Sustaining Subject Matter Experts in the Indian  Army” at the Monday Morning  Meeting held on 20 March 2023. The session was chaired by Col.  Vivek Chadha (Retd.)\, Research Fellow. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director  General\, MP-IDSA and scholars of the Institute were in attendance.   \nExecutive Summary \nThe need for specialists  in armed forces was first felt at the turn of the century. However\, the current  organisational matrix in the armies world over may not be conducive to fostering  specialists. This includes issues like lack of talent identification\, limited opportunities  for specialists based on talents identifed\, an overemphasis on operational domain\,  a lack of a talent management information system\, a lack of a more versatile  approach to differentiation and promotion of officers and a lack of growth  opportunities for specialists. The speaker undertook an environmental scan  of the best talent management practices in armies worldwide. He proposed  recommendations based on the scan and his experience in the Army.   \nDetailed Report\nCol. Vivek Chadha  (Retd.) opened the session by emphasising that the debates around  specialisation are relevant not only to the Army but to various fields such as  the corporate sector\, civil services and sports. The debates revolve around  training people in a niche area of expertise instead of generalised training  that may be utilised in different positions but consequently will be less  intricate. Col Chaddha then handed over the stage to the speaker  Colonel G.S. Gill.   \nThe speaker stated that  the cultivation of subject matter experts has become prominent only in the last  two decades for armies of different nations. Drivers include resource  constraints\, changing nature of jobs that require specific skills\, and the  changing nature of security threats.   \nThe speaker defined subject  matter experts as individuals with a deep understanding of a particular job\,  process\, department\, function\, technology\, machine\, material or type of  equipment. They have existed in all three services of the Armed Forces\, in  different measures\, with the Air Force and Navy having a higher proportion of  experts. The Indian Army utilises experts in procurement\, equipment management\,  indigenisation\, and technical development. Expertise will increasingly be  utilised in domains like cyber warfare and space\, the new niche domains. The Indian Army needs many more subject  matter experts\, especially in top echelons of the force.   \nThe speaker noted that  talent management is critical for developing subject matter expertise in the  Army. Talent management is having the appropriate amount of individuals\, with  the appropriate skill sets and levels of motivation\, at the appropriate  location and time. Critical factors to talent management for the Indian Army  are developing talent\, retaining talent and secession planning. In  order to develop talent\, talent needs to be identified\, and mechanisms are  needed for the same. Successive deployments in their specific fields can then  develop the individual    ’s  talent and expertise. The Indian  Army needs to develop mechanisms to  retain talent as it often misses out doing the same by not deploying individuals in  the fields they have expertise in. The Army also needs to provide a vision for  domain experts in terms of policy.   \nAccording to the speaker\,  the US Armed Forces lead the world in efficient talent management practices\,  which includes a talent management information system test bed which was  followed by the Joint Officer Management (JOM) program\, a career long program  dedicated to developing experts for joint force structures. The UK launched its  own talent management program\, the Unified Carrier Management program\, one year  before the US in 2021. The program was created to enhance the military    ’s capacity to retain and train soldiers in specialised positions  and is currently also in the testing phase. The UK    ’s  program like the US system is also based on a career management information system;  the Indian Armed Forces currently lack a similar system. Surprisingly\, the  oldest talent management system belongs to the Singapore Army\, which has  different entry\, rank and pay structures for domain experts.  \nThe speaker noted that  historically\, the Indian Army manages its officers to increase their ability to  compete for promotions and leadership. This strategy fosters a command-centric\,  operationally-driven culture. Non-operational postings are avoided despite the  fact that they can help one get the specialised knowledge necessary for most  senior officer positions\, the bulk of which are non-operational. Hence\, the  organisational culture in the Army maybe detrimental to specialisation.   \nThe training methodology  also inhibits the nurturing of specialists. This is so because most courses are  designed to prepare an officer for command\, as a platoon commander or as a  company commander. There do exist certain courses that are designed to impart  specific domain knowledge like information warfare or financial planning.  Unfortunately\, officers are often not utilised in the specific domains they  receive training in.   \nFirst and foremost\, the  speaker recommended the setting up of a policy framework with respect to the  creation and continuation of subject matter experts. This needs to be followed  by the setting up of an elaborate talent management information system. The  speaker further stated that the career path for non-operational specialists  needs to be widened to make it a lucrative choice. Lastly\, there is a need for a  differentiation methodology that is conducive to specialisation. Currently\, we  have a differentiation methodology of bimodal distribution produced by  comparing all officers to a command-centric or operational yardstick only by  means of the Annual Confidential Report System. The excessive emphasis on  promotion needs to be reduced in selection boards for the promotion of officers  and a methodology focusing on each officer’s individual growth\, qualifications  and best employment matching their talents is required.  \nThe moderator\, Col.  Chaddha then opened the floor for questions and remarks. The Director General\, Ambassador  Sujan R. Chinoy\, contributed to the discussion. He noted that the need for  specialisation is also extremely relevant to the Indian Civil Services\, apart  from the Army. Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) and scholars of the  Institute contributed to the discussion. Col. Vivek Chadha concluded the  session.  \nReport prepared by Mr.  Aayush Maniktalia\, Intern\, Defence Economics & Industry Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-presentation-on-cultivating-and-sustaining-subject-matter-experts-in-the-indian-army
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230306T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230306T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131148Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62946-1678080600-1678080600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “India’s Continued Engagement with Afghanistan: Looking Ahead”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Vishal  Chandra\, Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and  Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “India’s Continued Engagement with Afghanistan:  Looking Forward” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 06 March 2023. The  session was moderated by Dr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, and Coordinator  of the South Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, the  Director General of MP-IDSA\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, the Deputy  Director General of MP-IDSA and scholars of the Institute were in attendance.  \nExecutive Summary\nTwenty years after being ousted from power by  forces of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO)\, the Taliban regained  control of Afghanistan in 2021. Since taking office in 2021\, the Taliban-led  regime in Afghanistan has been diplomatically isolated; not a single country  has yet formally recognised their government. Violence  against ethnic minorities\, disrespect for women’s rights\, and violations of  civil liberties are just a few of the problems that continue to mar the  Taliban’s regime in Afghanistan. Moreover\, internal ethnic conflict and power  struggles within the Taliban\, ties to terrorist groups like Al-Qaeda and the  Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP)\, and recurrent attacks by the Islamic State  Khorasan Province (ISKP) have harmed Afghanistan’s security situation and put  the Taliban under pressure in their own backyard. Thus the poor socioeconomic indicators as well as a  worsening of security conditions point to a gloomy future. India\, a vital  supporter of Afghanistan’s development and prosperity\, has remained close to  the country despite numerous challenges and has gained the respect of the  Afghan people. New Delhi chose a people-centered approach meant to support the development  and well-being of the ordinary Afghan citizen. \nDetailed Report\nIn his opening  remarks\, Dr. Ashok K. Behuria offered a brief overview of how the Taliban had  regrouped in rural Afghanistan and all along the Afghanistan-Pakistan border  regions\, and had returned to power in Afghanistan in August 2021. Dr. Behuria  added that the Taliban had faced multiple challenges since reclaiming control  in 2021\, including a crisis of legitimacy as well as economic and security  issues. He emphasised that despite having to cope with numerous security and  economic challenges\, the Taliban were deftly handling the deteriorating  economic situation and had made some progress in lowering the number of  terrorist attacks and casualties in Afghanistan. He emphasized that despite  regional and global obstacles\, India should continue to support the people of Afghanistan. \nDr. Vishal Chandra  began his presentation by highlighting the fact that since no government has  recognised the Taliban regime in Afghanistan\, the Taliban are working very hard  to gain international legitimacy\, and that other countries’ were very  circumspect in engaging the Taliban. The country is currently experiencing a  severe humanitarian and security crisis following the Taliban taking back  control of Kabul. There are 28.3 million people in need of humanitarian relief  and support\, 14.7 million of whom are in acute need. Among the 28.3 million  people in need\, 6.4 million women and 15.2 million children require immediate  humanitarian help. Dr. Chandra observed that the number of persons in need has  dramatically risen from 24.4 million in 2022 to 28.3 million in 2023. He  pointed out that 75% of Afghanistan’s total state spending was on aid and  support from abroad\, citing the UNDP 2022 study. \nWhile humanitarian  relief is trickling in\, not quite to the satisfaction of the Taliban and the  Afghan people\, the country is also experiencing a serious security crisis and  violent outbursts\, which are being coordinated by the ISKP and other terrorist  organisations. He stated that in addition to ISKP\, there are other  ultra-orthodox Taliban factions that either question the legitimacy of the  current Taliban leadership or oppose some of its policy goals. He also informed  the audience that ethnic groups that had earlier collaborated with the Taliban  and coordinated operations against NATO forces (because they shared similar  ideologies) were at the moment vying for control over resources\, influence\, and  positions. However\, he noted that despite the constant attacks against the  Taliban regime and their patrons\, the Taliban seemed to have prevented the  situation from getting out of control; but it is uncertain how long Taliban  will be able to maintain their control over diverse forces exercising their  influence in Afghanistan. The failure of Taliban leaders to incorporate  non-Pashto tribes in its administrative and policy establishment continued to  be a significant obstacle for them\, in addition to the ISKP threats\, he said. \nDespite these  challenges\, Dr. Chandra was of the opinion that the Taliban were trying their  best to manage the economy by raising domestic taxes\, particularly through  customs duties\, as well as through informal and conventional levies on mining\,  transportation\, and agriculture\, which have increased with a crackdown on  corruption. Afghanistan  also exports coal to Pakistan.  The  Taliban have also made it clear that their government would pose no risks to  India or other nations in the region\, and they have promised that their  territory would not be used as a base for terrorist attacks against other  countries. Mr. Vishal emphasised that the Taliban’s relationships with Al-Qaeda\,  the TTP\, and other designated militant groups\, however\, remained intact\, and it  was unclear how they were planning to maintain such relationships while  pursuing international legitimacy.  \nGiven this\,  Mr. Chandra said it has posed a very interesting dilemma for India whether it  could engage the people of Afghanistan without engaging the Taliban. He argued  that because of India’s centuries-old cultural and civilizational ties to  Afghanistan\, there is strong sympathy among Afghan civilians for India. This has\,  over the years\, not only helped India to acquire the trust of Afghans cutting  across ethnic lines but also to maintain its neutral position despite  significant political and security upheavals over the years. India’s present commitment\,  he emphasized\, was primarily focused on infrastructure\, humanitarian relief\,  and developmental aid. \nAccording to  Dr. Chandra\, India has remained the largest regional contributor of aid for  Afghanistan’s development and humanitarian assistance. Since 2001\, India has  adopted a multi-sectoral aid strategy that includes both large and small-scale  projects and covers all regions of Afghanistan. Large-scale infrastructure  projects include the construction of the Afghan Parliament\, the 218 km road  from Zaranj to Delaram\, and the construction and commissioning of the Salma Dam  power plant in the province of Herat. \nDr. Chandra  stated that India had also been the driving force behind numerous short-term  community-based development initiatives that emphasised local ownership and  management and covered agriculture\, rural development\, education\, health\, and  vocational training\, including  the renovation of Kabul’s Habibia School. These community-based initiatives  have a clear\, immediate effect on the daily lives of the people. For instance\,  the Indian Council for Cultural Relations (ICCR) sponsors a large number of  yearly long-term university scholarships for Afghan students studying in India  for undergraduate and graduate degrees. India similarly offers vocational  training to Afghan women and youth. India also offers initiatives to improve  capacity in the areas of agricultural research\, healthcare\, and rural  development. Recently\, India  provided 40\,000 of wheat and 500\,000 doses of COVID-19 vaccine. India\,  therefore\, has maintained its policy of “staying the humanitarian  course” in Afghanistan after the Taliban seized control again in 2021.  \nDr. Chandra  concluded that India had gained knowledge and experience of working in  Afghanistan’s challenging political and security environment over the years.  Notwithstanding practical difficulties\, he pointed out that India had largely  been successful in dealing with Afghanistan\, regardless of the ideological  leanings of Afghan regimes\, with the exception of the first Taliban rule  (1996-2001). In addition\, he stated that India does not have any parochial  foreign policy goals in Afghanistan and that because India has been more  responsive and adaptable to local circumstances\, it has been able to preserve  both trust and people-to-people ties over time. In order to continue its aid  and assistance initiatives in Afghanistan\, he urged India to send a  humanitarian envoy to Kabul. \nComments and Questions\nThe floor was  opened for questions and comments. The Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R.  Chinoy\, the Deputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, and  scholars from the Institute contributed to the discussion. In his remarks\,  Ambassador Chinoy pointed out that the conflict in Ukraine has diverted  attention from the Taliban\, which has allowed them to consolidate their regime  in Afghanistan. He stressed that there was still potential for an internal  Taliban fault-line to blow up at some point\, which might lead to further  instability. He added that the alleged death of an ISKP commander of Kashmiri  descent in Afghanistan was excellent news for India. India\, he  continued\, must maintain its humanitarian aid efforts while keeping an eye on  political and security developments in Afghanistan.  \nReport prepared by Dr. Mohd. Usman Bhatti\,  Research Assistant\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-indias-continued-engagement-with-afghanistan-looking-ahead
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230301T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230301T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131207Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130737Z
UID:62947-1677648600-1677648600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Interaction with the Geneva Centre for Security Policy (GCSP)
DESCRIPTION:Manohar Parrikar Institute for  Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised an interaction with a three-member  delegation from the Geneva Centre for Security Policy (GCSP) led by Ambassador  Thomas Greminger\, Director\, GCSP on 1 March 2023. The interaction was chaired  by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA. Senior scholars\,  research analysts\, and interns of the institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nThe manifold implications of the Russia-Ukraine conflict  have questioned the nature of European security and its tenets. With no  resolution in sight\, the human\, economic and political costs are mounting. A  roadmap for reconstructing peace and security in Europe can be through Confidence  Building Measures\, subregional arms control\, and a dialogue on the principles  of European security. \nDetailed Report\nAmb. Chinoy began the interaction by  introducing the delegation to the various research facets and training modules  of MP-IDSA. In his remarks\, Amb. Chinoy stated that the impact of the  Russia-Ukraine conflict has been felt beyond the borders of Europe\, where  geo-security has taken precedence over geo-economics. The conflict has resulted  in the questioning of the nature of European security. He highlighted  overlapping loyalties and complex interdependencies in a globalised world\, wherein\,  India shares cordial relationships with both Russia and the United States\, as  does Germany with China. He emphasised the importance of ending the conflict  and stated that India is well-positioned to mediate a resolution. \n  Amb. Greminger introduced the audience to the  functioning of GCSP and the dialogue space it offers. He stated that the  current status of the war in Ukraine can be comprehended in four phases\,  starting with the Battle for Kyiv\, followed by the Battle for Donbas\, a  successful counter-offensive in Kharkiv and Kherson\, and finally\, the war of attrition. \nAmb. Greminger presented five possible  scenarios. First\, the highly likely continuation of the ongoing high-intensity  warfare. Second\, a continuing low-intensity conflict. Third\, an escalation  through military means in the South\, destruction of strategic civilian  infrastructure\, cyber attacks\, and\, although unlikely\, the use of nuclear  weapons. Fourth\, an unlikely scenario could be conflict termination through a  one-sided victory. Finally\, a favourable scenario could be a negotiated  conflict resolution that covers territorial issues in Crimea and Donbas\, war  crimes\, and reparations. \n Amb. Greminger discussed the  implications of the conflict and emphasised that it has had a significant impact  on peace in Europe. He first highlighted the human costs of the conflict\,  including eight million refugees\, 90\,000 civilian casualties\, as well as  skyrocketing inflation and acute food insecurity. Secondly\, he drew attention  to the critical damage to civilian infrastructure. Thirdly\, he discussed the  economic consequences\, including energy insecurity and trade disruptions.  Finally\, he focused on the political consequences of the conflict\, stating that  the world is moving towards a “Cold War 2.0” where deterrence will  dominate the landscape of European security. He also observed that security  will continue to be focused on territorial defence\, resulting in high defence  budgets. Amb. Greminger emphasised the changing nature of cooperation on other  agendas\, including transnational issues and dealing with complex geographies. \n  He presented a roadmap for  reconstructing peace and security in Europe. First\, he stressed the need for  the Russian Federation to respect international law and territorial  sovereignty. Second\, he suggested that trust can be rebuilt through Confidence  and Security Building Measures (CSBMs). Third\, the United States’ negotiated  response to Russia should include military risk reduction and subregional arms  control. The fourth step should involve a dialogue on the principles of  European security itself. This should be followed by a review of the status of  “bridge” countries (Armenia\, Azerbaijan\, Belarus\, Georgia\, and  Moldova) that share geographical proximity with Russia\, as well as the role of the  North Atlantic Treaty Organisation in those countries. Lastly\, he emphasised  the importance of considering the future role of Russia in the European  security order. He concluded that peace and stability in Europe can only be  achieved through cooperation with Russia\, not without it. \nDiscussion\nAmb. Chinoy emphasised that it is highly improbable that any of the permanent members of  the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) could completely overpower one  another. He specifically noted that the collapse of Russia in this context is  nearly impossible. He further discussed the current period of great uncertainty  due to the suspension of the New START Treaty. According to him\, if neither  side is willing to make concessions\, it will only lead to an escalation of the  conflict and a one-sided victory will become even less likely. Amb. Chinoy  concurred with Amb. Greminger that peaceful negotiation is the most viable  option. However\, he pointed out that conditional negotiation is not possible.  He emphasised that territorial control is an essential aspect of the  negotiation\, and the illegal occupation of Indian territories by Pakistan and  China provides a common ground for discussion. \nMaj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) highlighted that of the likely scenarios  presented by the speaker\, only one discusses the end of the conflict. He also  discussed the role of external support to Ukraine. \nDr. Rajorshi Roy raised a query on the future of European commitment to  Ukraine. \nMr. Om Prakash Das inquired about the characteristics of ‘Cold War 2.0.’ \nDr. Jason Wahlang raised a query about Europe’s reactions to China’s Peace  Plan for Ukraine.  \nAmb. Chinoy discussed the pre-conditions for Russia and Ukraine to negotiate the end of war  and the possibilities of who would lead the Ukrainian front for negotiation. \nThe discussion ended with a Vote of  Thanks by Amb. Chinoy. \nReport was prepared by Ms. Richa Kumaria\, Intern\,  Non-Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/interaction-with-the-geneva-centre-for-security-policy-gcsp
CATEGORIES:ROUND TABLES / WORKSHOPS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230228T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230228T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131207Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62948-1677562200-1677562200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Talk by Ambassador Anil Wadhwa on "Future of India-Australia Economic Cooperation"
DESCRIPTION:A talk by Ambassador Anil  Wadhwa\, Distinguished Fellow\, Vivekananda International Foundation\, New  Delhi\, on “Future of India-Australia Economic Cooperation” was organised by the  Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) on 28  February 2023 at 1100h in room number 005. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director  General\, MP-IDSA\, who chaired the session\, began the proceedings by briefly  explaining the topic. He said that India-Australia relations were stunted for  many years and revolved around cricket\, commonwealth and curry. However\,  relations recently improved with India and Australia forging the Comprehensive  Strategic Partnership. The development of the Indo-Pacific construct also  brought the two countries closer. The New Education Policy was likely to draw  Australian universities to India. There has been positive movement in economic  relations between the two countries in light of the India-Australia Economic  Cooperation and Trade Agreement (INDAUS ECTA). Although there have been Indian  investments in Australia\, there exist some issues regarding the same. Commenting  briefly about Australia-China relations\, Ambassador Chinoy observed that there  was a fractured view of the rise of Beijing in different parts of Australia\,  based on economic and security considerations. Setting an apt background for the  speakern the Chair invited Ambassador Wadhwa to deliver the talk. \n Ambassador Wadhwa started by  talking about geopolitical events during and post-COVID-19 years. He spoke  about aggressive Chinese actions vis-à-vis Australia in the aftermath of the Australian  demand for an enquiry into the origins of COVID-19. Canberra felt let down due  to the Chinese ban on Australian imports. Shipments of coal kept waiting at the  ports. The big businesses involved in China felt the need to diversify to  reduce dependency on Beijing. Through all these years\, India-Australia  relations were improving. The two countries elevated their ties to the  Comprehensive Strategic Partnership in 2020. Prime Minister Narendra Modi  promised Australia that India would be involved in that country’s economy. The speaker  mentioned a report titled ‘An India Economic Strategy to 2035’ by Mr. Peter  Varghese that focused on ten economic sectors and was limited to ten states of  India. He informed the audience that the reciprocal report titled ‘Australia  Economic Strategy’ (AES) authored by the speaker looked at 12 economic sectors  of Australia\, including futuristic areas and was not restricted to any of the  provinces in that country. Further\, he spoke about the Australia-India Economic Cooperation and Trade Agreement  (ECTA)\, signed in April 2022 and that entered into force in December 2022. \n The author of the AES spoke  enthusiastically about the growing Indian diaspora in Australia. He stated that  the diaspora was hard-working and controlled several boardrooms in Australia.  They could act as a bridge between the two countries. Further\, he highlighted the  high-level exchange of visits from the two sides\, including the PMs and  ministers. Ambassador Wadhwa pointed out a number of bilateral initiatives that  have been kicked off between the two countries. It included an Australia-India  Centre of Excellence for Critical and Emerging Technology Policy; a diaspora  mapping report titled “Australia’s Indian Diaspora: A National Asset – Mapping  the Community’s Reach into the Australia-India Economic Relationship” Critical  Minerals Investment Partnership; Future Skills Initiative; Green Steel  Partnership; New and Renewable Energy Partnership; and a vast number of  collaborations in diverse fields such as e-mobility\, rare earth material\,  strategic reserve funds\, science\, green partnership\, and infrastructure forum\,  among others. On the military front\, he mentioned mutual logistics agreement  and the four-country Malabar naval exercise as examples of substantial  engagement. \n Talking about INDAUS ECTA\, the  speaker enlightened the audience about the benefits of the deal\, which gives  duty-free access to goods from each country to the other. Indian companies have  benefitted by investing in Australian coal. The pact has made the movement of  students easier. Also\, service providers such as Yoga teachers and chefs have  benefitted. He said that the Albanese Government increased the quota for  trained manpower. There was ample opportunity in fields of nursing\, carpentry\,  masonry\, and perimeter security\, among others. Progress has been made in the  research collaboration. The Mechanism for the Mutual Recognition of  Qualifications has increased employability. Ambassador Wadhwa stated that  Australia has immense Liquified Natural Gas (LNG) export potential that might  replace countries from West Asia for India’s energy needs. By 2035\, India will  likely become one of Australia’s important export markets\, and Australian  investments in India will also likely see an uptick. The speaker said the  country had kept aside billions of dollars for the commercial mining of  critical minerals and the space industry\, among others.  \n Further\, Ambassador Wadhwa spoke  about the Australian University campuses being set up in India. He said such  universities are essential from the perspective of the Indian market. The  speaker explained that the ECTA neutralised some of the disadvantages of not  being part of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) or the  Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). He said that Australia was a small market. Therefore\,  there was a limit to the trade. Commodities such as minerals would be very  important in the future\, since the country contains some of the essential  critical minerals. Australia has substantial pension funds of trillions of  dollars\, and India’s Production Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme was attracting Australian  investment. Regarding the Australia-India Comprehensive Economic Cooperation  Agreement (AI-CECA)\, the speaker said that it could be a bench setter for other  Free Trade Agreements India is negotiating with other nations. However\, the  Australian dairy industry has been kept out of the negotiations. Indian  agriculture has much to learn from Australia regarding the use of technology to  manage agriculture efficiently.  \n Ambassador Wadhwa listed a number  of areas of bilateral cooperation mentioned in the AES that included commodities  (critical minerals like lithium\, mine safety\, manufacturing of mining equipment);  LNG exports; construction of warships\, support ships\, corvettes; textile and  textile design; groundwater management solutions and recycling of water;  Education (training the trainers programme); space technology; collaboration in  e-learning; grid technology (remotely controlled grid stabilisation);  healthcare; farm and dairy production (food processing units); fintech (cloud  and other technology); tourism; infrastructure development; and automobile  spare components.  \n Following the talk\, the Chair  observed that India-Australia relations had come a long way in the last decade.  There existed synergies with India. However\, China has made exceptional inroads  in Australia. There are vast numbers of Chinese students. China is buying land  parcels in the country. But after trade tensions with Beijing\, Australia was  trying to diversify relations. Ambassador Chinoy agreed with the speaker that  India had an opportunity in the automobile\, Information Technology\, Micro\,  Small & Medium Enterprises\, and defence sectors. The Chair also saw the  opportunity for bilateral cooperation in third countries\, especially the  Pacific Islands. He opined that the ECTA was a good initiative for the two  countries. However\, he also flagged the irritants in the relationship\, such as the  problem of illegal immigration and attacks by Khalistani supporters on temples.  \n In the ensuing question and  answer session\, Ambassador Wadhwa said there was distrust regarding Indian  companies in Australia in the past. But now\, Indian companies get contracts for  various projects. Regarding Uranium export\, the speaker said that India does  not require uranium from Australia\, and the Non-proliferation Treaty is an  emotive issue in Canberra. Australia has limited capacity to go beyond Sri  Lanka and participate in African affairs. Chinese media has a strong influence on  media and academia. India should learn sports stadium management from  Australia. The Australia-United Kingdom-United States (AUKUS) pact was designed  to counter China in the Pacific. \n  Report  was prepared by Mr. Niranjan Oak\, Reasearch Analyst\, Nuclear and Arms Control  Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/talk-by-ambassador-anil-wadhwa-on-future-of-india-australia-economic-cooperation
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230227T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230227T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131207Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62949-1677475800-1677475800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning on  Capability Development Challenges in Indian Army
DESCRIPTION:Col. Manish Rana\, SM\, Research Fellow\, Manohar  Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and  Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “Capability Development Challenges in Indian Army” at  the Monday Morning Meeting held on 27 February 2023. The  session was moderated by Col. Rajneesh Singh (Retd.)\, Research Fellow. Maj.  Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA\, and scholars  of the Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nCapability  development which is defined as a continuous process involving various  stakeholders such as military planners\, policymakers\, procurement agencies\, and  industry planners holds great significance in the military domain\, particularly  in the context of the Indian Army’s proposed acquisition of a Closed Quarter  Combat (CQB) Carbine. However\, impediments in the planning process and  long-drawn procurement processes hamper capability development. Further\, the  missing collaboration and coordination among various stakeholders leads to lack  of environment management and trust amongst multiple stakeholders.  \nThe case  study of CQB Carbine highlights the delays and challenges faced in its  procurement due to environmental factors like a decade of defence procurement  scam overdose\, changes in defence procurement systems\, and stakeholders’  conflicting priorities. In this context\, it is imperative to highlight the  importance of effective collaboration and coordination among stakeholders and  trust-building to expedite capability development. \nDetailed Report\nColonel  Rajneesh\, Research Fellow\, opened the session by bringing out the issues  related to capability development and the budget availability for procuring new  equipment for the Armed Forces. He brought out the dilemma of reduction of  manpower to optimise the budget vis a vis higher allocations to Armed Forces.  He also suggested alternatives like changes in doctrine\, recruitment and  retention\, modernisation and operational responsibilities. He then  handed over the floor to the speaker\, Colonel  Manish Rana\, Research Fellow.  \nFirst and foremost\,  the speaker defined capability development as the process of acquiring and  improving the Military’s capabilities to achieve strategic objectives. It  involves the identification of needs and developing strategies to meet them\,  ultimately resulting in the acquisition and development of new technologies\,  weapons systems and training programs. It was emphasised that capability  development is a continuous process that can only be accomplished over a period  of time. Colonel Rana observed that capability development involves a range of  stakeholders\, such as military planners\, policymakers\, procurement agencies and  industry planners. \nA glance at  numerous write-ups on the subject suggests a shortage of funds\,  non-availability of indigenous capabilities\, flaws in the planning process and  long-drawn procurement processes are significant challenges to capability  development in the Military domain. However\, what needs to be more present in  the academic research domain is the missing collaboration and coordination amongst  various stakeholders leading to non-tangible issues of lack of environment  management and trust amongst multiple stakeholders. While structurally and  intent-wise\, all these stakeholders are brought together to ensure the desired  capability is acquired in the most efficient and time-bound manner\, in  practice\, these stakeholders have different\, at times conflicting\, priorities.  There needs to be effective collaboration and coordination among these  stakeholders. Especially for the Armed Forces management\, not used to an  organisational culture based on negotiation and compromise\, the environment for  executing capability development becomes challenging.  \nThe speaker  highlighted his assessment of capacity building through a case study\, the  proposed acquisition of a Closed Quarter Combat (CQB) Carbine for the Indian  Army. A CQB Carbine has an effective range of around 200 metres. It is  lightweight\, manoeuvrable and has a high rate of fire while having less recoil.  These attributes make a CQB Carbine ideal for close combat\, such as urban  warfare and counterinsurgency operations in dense jungles. They would go a long  way to enhance the Army’s capabilities. Indian Army used World War II vintage 9  mm SMG for close-quarter battle needs until the early 2000s. Ordnance Factory  Board (OFB) produced the weapon\, and production stopped in the early 2000s as  the same was declared obsolete. \nThe INSAS  program started in the 80s\, in which modern assault rifles\, light machine guns  and CQB Carbine were to be developed indigenously and inducted into the Indian  Army. Colonel Manish noted that India used to manufacture WW II vintage CQB  Carbines at its ordinance factories until it was declared obsolete in the  1990s. When the INSAS family of weapons were introduced\, the Carbine was not  found suitable\, and the search for a better alternative took off. \nDespite knowing  in 2000 that INSAS Carbine was not suiting the bill\, the Request for Proposal  for a fresh weapon was only initiated in 2008. Eight to ten years to initiate a  case for a personal weapon is by no standards acceptable. Furthermore\, the case  could not be progressed as the Services Qualitative Requirements worked out  were found to be too ambitious. One needs to look at the environmental  realities of that time to understand why such a simple thing took so much time  to get initiated. Firstly\, it is obvious that despite the INSAS Carbine being  found unsuitable\, Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO) would  have tried its best to continue pushing for its induction as a lot of time and  money would have been invested in the program. The go-ahead for a separate  procurement would only have come after DRDO efforts to continue would have  convincingly exhausted. Secondly\, the time being talked of coincides with an  era of defence procurement scam overdose. The memory of the Kargil coffin scam\,  Tehelka scam and Scorpene deal scam even today gives goosebumps to people  involved in defence procurement\, what to say the paralysis they would have  brought into the system at that time. Thirdly\, the decade of 2000 to 2010 also  is remembered for large-scale changes in the Defence procurement system. The  Defence Procurement Procedure manual was first introduced in 2002 and underwent  numerous amendments in 2005\, 2006 and 2008. It is evident that the decade lost  in progressing procurement of CQB Carbine (2000- 2010) was indeed a challenging  decade for defence procurements in general. Hence\, more than anything else\,  what delayed the CQB Carbines’ induction in this decade was attributable  primarily to environmental factors. \n  In 2010\, a fresh  Request for Proposal (RFP) was issued for the weapon. Trials took place from  2011-14\, but the case hit another wall when one of the two vendors competing  for the project failed the trials due to a minor issue. Therefore only a single  vendor remained. Owing to the scam hangover of the previous decade\, the  officials were unenthusiastic about progressing with it due to the scrutiny  that it may have generated due to a single vendor\, and the case was stopped.  This highlights the resistance amongst stakeholders to manage environmental issues  and the need for more trust. \nIn 2014\, the  honourable Defence Minister directed that considering the operational necessity  of the weapon\, the Defence Ministry would opt for the Foreign Military Sales  (FMS) route from the US. Despite the Defence Minister himself taking a strong  stand on the issue\, the case did not progress. In 2018\, a fast-track process  was initiated. In this option\, a weapon currently in use in another armed force  can be inducted without extensive trials. Caracal\, a UAE-based arms  manufacturer\, was chosen as the supplier\, and the contract was planned to be  signed in 2019\, and weapons were to be delivered by 2020. However\, it was again  cancelled due to issues not being in the open domain\, highlighting a lack of  trust. One can presume that environmental factors again influenced the case.  Two significant factors that could have affected the decision may be the coming  of age of indigenous industry and DRDO. Indian industry\, which had so far been  more or less a silent spectator in the case\, had started acquiring certain  capabilities and\, combined with the clarion call for Atmanirbhar Bharat by our Prime Minister\, Shri Narendra Modi\, had  got adequately vitalised to start raising the ante for indigenous procurement  of CQB Carbine. DRDO also\, after improving its earlier versions\, started  production of a Carbine\, which had started getting inducted into paramilitary  forces in some quantities. The speaker observed that the opacity in such  procedures\, as highlighted above\, leads to the propagation of conspiracy  theories which is not in the interest of establishment.  \nA fresh RFP has  now been issued in 2022\, and the chase for a CBQ Carbine continues\, about four  decades after the need for it was felt. The speaker highlighted that in  capability development\, more often than not\, circumstances arise wherein the  procurements get unduly delayed\, and there seem to be no apparent reasons. As  per him\, the main challenge is managing environmental issues and building trust  amongst various stakeholders to avoid such a situation. He highlighted that the  issue\, being intangible\, finds little discussion in the academic field. In the  end\, he suggested using the Systems approach and study of Organisational  Culture to avoid the recurrence of such issues in defence procurement to assist  capability development. \nQ&A Session\nThe floor was  opened for questions and comments\, wherein scholars from the Institute\,  including the Deputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\,  contributed to the discussion. He noted that the bureaucracy’s insistence on  following the book helps avoid misuse of authority but may delay the induction  of critical capabilities in the Armed Forces. Colonel Rajneesh in his closing  remarks highlighted the importance of both tangible and intangible aspects  involved in the capability development process and thanked the speaker for an  enlightening talk covering the complexities of procurement procedures. \nReport  prepared by Mr. Aayush Maniktalia\, Intern\, Defence Economics & Industry  Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-on-capability-development-challenges-in-indian-army
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230220T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230220T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131207Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62950-1676871000-1676871000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on ''The Indus Waters Treaty: What is in Store?''
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Uttam K. Sinha\, Senior Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar  Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses\, spoke on “The Indus  Waters Treaty: What is in Store?” at the Monday Morning Meeting held  on 20 February 2023. The session was moderated by Dr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, MP-IDSA.  Deputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi\, senior  scholars\, research analysts\, and interns of the institute were in attendance.  \nExecutive Summary\n\nIndia  has issued a notice to Pakistan under the Indus Waters Treaty (IWT)\, alleging a  breach of the Treaty’s dispute resolution mechanisms. India has called for  modifications to the Treaty’s annexures and for negotiations on the issue\,  marking the first such request since its inception. \n\nDetailed Report\n\nDr. Ashok K. Behuria commenced the session by highlighting  that MP-IDSA has undertaken several studies to explore how the Treaty has  functioned since its inception and the likelihood of its survival. He  emphasised the need to harness the waters of the eastern rivers and noted that  the 3.6 million acre feet (MAF) allowance on the western rivers remains highly  underutilised. Dr. Behuria explained the graded dispute resolution mechanism  under Article IX of the Treaty. He also discussed Pakistan’s objections to the  Kishenganga and Ratle hydroelectric power projects being constructed by India.  He  added that India has sent a notice of modification to Pakistan under Article  XII (3) of the Treaty\, seeking a response within 90 days. He stated that  transboundary rivers should be seen as connectors\, not disruptors\, in bilateral  relations. \nWith these remarks\, Dr.  Behuria invited Dr. Sinha to make his observations. At the outset\, Dr. Sinha  stated that fear\, angst\, manipulation and misinformation often govern the  behaviour of the states on hydrological issues. He opined that as India expands  its water resources footprint in the UT of Jammu and Kashmir and the  Administration of UT of Ladakh\, Pakistan’s captiousness will only increase. He then  observed that water is an emotive issue in Pakistan’s domestic political  discourse. \n Dr. Sinha pointed out  that to understand the present circumstances\, it is pertinent to consider the  history of negotiations\, as well as the physiography and hydrology of the  basin. He cautioned against accepting the notion of India’s over-generosity in negotiating  the Treaty and emphasised that the IWT is an arrangement to divide the basin  rather than a water-sharing agreement. Drawing from his book Indus Basin Uninterrupted (Penguin  Random House\, 2021)\, he interestingly observed the critical role of the  engineers during the Partition in the division of the canals and the allocation  of the headworks to India. \n In the next part of his  presentation\, Dr. Sinha displayed maps of the rivers to depict their flow  across political boundaries. He discussed the dual context of rivers – their  interlinkage with politics\, society\, environment\, and the economy\, as well as  their importance in the hydropolitical security complex. Dr. Sinha observed  that the basin remained unified prior to the Partition\, which created a new  geography. While India emphasised its geographical status as an upper-riparian  state\, Pakistan focused on historical usage of water\, such as canal irrigation. \n Through maps\, the  speaker showed that the Indus Basin has a drainage area of 11\,65\,000 square  kilometres\, with India accounting for 27 per cent and Pakistan for 65 per cent  of the total drainage area. He opined that rivers are a technical issue and  political insinuations must be avoided\, and underlined that the IWT  negotiations prioritised technical and engineering solutions. The speaker  pointed out that the Treaty emphasises the utilisation of waters and not their  control. The negotiations eventually underscored ‘water rationality’ and India  effectively defended its rights on the eastern rivers. The Treaty was designed  to facilitate effective water cooperation through “checks and balances”. In  addition\, he noted that the IWT negotiations effectively addressed not only the  Punjab region\, but also the Jammu and Kashmir region. Dr. Sinha discussed that  the difficult terrain of the western rivers makes it challenging to achieve the  target of 3.6 MAF of storage capacity. He argued that Chenab carries the  potential to fulfil its storage needs. \n Through  various data sets\, Dr. Sinha displayed the status of the irrigated areas and  the hydroelectric projects under operation and construction. He added that\,  through the modification process\, India will also communicate the issues in  developing these projects.  He opined  that the Court of Arbitration will recognise India’s objections to the breach  of the Treaty’s dispute resolution mechanisms. He added that Pakistan\, through  its move to the arbitration court\, aims to set a legal precedent for all future  projects. In his conclusion\, Dr. Sinha advocated for a technical resolution to  the issues through a neutral expert. \n\nQuestions and Comments\n\nDr.  Behuria discussed  the potential outcomes if Pakistan chooses not to respond to India’s notice.  Additionally\, he drew attention to responses from the popular media in Pakistan  as well as the role of its domestic political turmoil. \n      Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) emphasised that despite India’s  relatively small catchment area\, it contributes nearly 50 per cent of the total  flow due to glacial melt. He also underlined the importance of distinguishing  between captive dams and run-of-the-river projects. \n      Mr. S.C. Saxena\, Member\, MP-IDSA made a query on the history of  bilateral negotiations between India and Pakistan. He discussed the importance  of technology in harnessing river potential. \n      Dr. Nihar R. Nayak discussed the geological structure  of the basin and inquired about the consequences of the suspension of the Treaty. \n      Col. Manish Rana raised a query on the factors that  compelled India and Pakistan to sign the Treaty and how India’s actions can  impact its lower-riparian status in the east. \nCol. (Dr.) DPK Pillay (Retd.) underscored the importance of  harnessing rivers and the success of the Ganga canal in irrigation. \n      Capt. Anurag Bisen (IN) highlighted the incompetence of the  World Bank in several bilateral arrangements globally. He raised the  possibility of abrogating the current Treaty and setting up a new Treaty on  India’s terms. \n      Dr. Priyanka Singh raised questions about the  neutrality of the World Bank and its decision to allow two parallel dispute  resolution mechanisms. \n      Dr. Anand Kumar discussed the financial costs of the  IWT negotiations and the strategic available options for India unilaterally. \n      Mr. Rohith Sai Stambamkadi raised a query on the strategic  implications of dams. \n      Commodore (Dr.) Mani Singh Mamik  (Retd.)\, through the online chat function\, inquired  about the loss of agricultural and fertile land after the Partition. \n In his response\, Dr. Sinha highlighted that unilateral  abrogation will not significantly reduce the availability of water in Pakistan.  In addition\, it will risk India’s international image and goodwill in the  neighbourhood\, and will cast doubts on its status as a responsible actor. He  added that India should focus on developing the water infrastructure capacities  allowed under the Treaty and clearly suggested optimising the Treaty. He added  that India’s strategic approach to water issues is highly unique\, as it is both  a responsible upper-riparian and a concerned lower-riparian. He further noted  that India’s cross-border water dependence is significantly high and reiterated  the need to build water storage capacity.  \n  The discussion ended with a Vote of Thanks by Dr. Ashok K.  Behuria. \n    The  report has been prepared by Ms. Richa Kumaria\, Intern\, Non- Traditional  Security Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-the-indus-waters-treaty-what-is-in-store
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230213T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230213T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131208Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62951-1676266200-1676266200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “Coastal Security Construct: The Indian Way”
DESCRIPTION:Comdt. M.  Srivastava\, Research Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, spoke on ”Coastal Security Construct: The  Indian Way” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 13 February 2023. Capt Anurag  Bisen\, Research Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, was the moderator. Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin  Bakshi\, the Deputy Director-General\, MP-IDSA\, and scholars attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nThe Mumbai blasts in 1993 and the 26/11  attacks of 2008 shaped India’s coastal security contours. The emergence of  coastal security construct dates back to 1990 in the aftermath of IPKF’s  withdrawal from Sri Lanka with the commencement of Operation Tasha.  Subsequently\, post 26/11\, Phases one and two of the Coastal Security Scheme  (CSS) were initiated to strengthen the coastal security mechanism. Phase three  is envisaged to be underway soon. However\, India needs those involved in  coastal security to constantly train\, equip\, exercise\, and keep reinventing the  wheel and incorporate the lessons learnt. \nDetailed Report\nCapt. Anurag  Bisen set the stage by introducing the audience to coastal security with some  facts. India has 7\,516.6 kilometres of coastline running through nine states  and four union territories. The territorial waters of India are 1\,55\,889 square  kilometres\, and the exclusive economic zone is 20\,30\,490 square kilometres\,  nearly 60% of the land area. There are over 3\,000 coastal villages and 1\,382  island territories\, with more than 120 million people involved in fishing  activities who use nearly half a million boats. India shares its maritime  boundary with the same number of countries with which it shares land  boundaries. 90% of India’s trade by volume and 70% by value is conducted  through the coast. Moreover\, 70% of energy requirements are also met through  the coast. \nThe Government  of India raised the Indian Coast Guard on the recommendations of the K.F.  Rustamji Committee. It started with two frigates and five patrol boats. Today\,  the Indian Coast Guard is the fourth largest in the world. Capt. Bisen said  that the most significant terrorist attacks India has faced have come from the  sea\, demonstrating the importance of coastal security. The Indian Navy proposed  setting up a Maritime Security Advisory Board in 2005. The National Committee  for Strengthening Maritime and Coastal Security (NCSMCS) was set up in 2009  under the cabinet secretary in light of the 26/11 attacks. The Group of  Ministers (GoM) report in 2001 recommended setting up a maritime security  committee at the apex level\, which the Government finally established in 2022  as a National Maritime Security Coordinator (NMSC). Capt. Bisen finally  remarked that neither maritime nor coastal security mechanisms had reached  finalisation\, and an impregnable maritime border remains a work in progress. He  then introduced Comdt. M. Srivastava and requested him to make his  presentation. \nComdt. M.  Srivastava began by observing that two events which shaped India’s coastal  security contours are the Mumbai blasts in 1993 and the 26/11 attacks of 2008.  In both cases\, the sea route was used\, as Capt. Bisen mentioned earlier. \nIndia’s Maritime Stakes\nComdt. M.  Srivastava started by highlighting India’s maritime stakes. About 26 crore of  India’s population lives within 50 km of the coastline\, which also has numerous  vital areas and points. Shipping is still the world’s most efficient and  economical means of transportation. India has twelve major ports and around 200  non-major ports. The major ports handled a cargo of nearly 530 Million Tonnes  during April-December 2021\, a jump of nearly 11% from 2020 during the same  period. The non-major ports also saw a considerable increase in traffic from  2017 to 2021. India’s maritime agenda was first published in 2011\, emphasising  port capacity enhancement\, developing port infrastructure\, promoting coastal  shipping\, etc. Presently\, India seeks a maritime-led economic growth through  its maritime vision-2030\, which is set to bring an investment of Rs. 3 lakh  crore and create twenty lakh jobs. India is also proto-testing offshore wind  energy farms with a target of 30 GW from offshore wind energy by 2030. It has  kick-started its deep sea mission for rare earth elements in the Central Indian  Ocean Basin. Policies such as Security and Growth for All in the Region (SAGAR)\, Sagarmala and Project Mausam align with a maritime-led  development. India’s economic growth is intricately intertwined with the seas\,  so its focus on a blue economy is inescapable. \nHowever\,  Comdt. M. Srivastava opined that in the contemporary era of global political  and economic interdependence\, the sea routes are increasingly facing safety and  security concerns as they are vulnerable to maritime terrorism\, piracy\, illegal  activities\, Illegal\, Unreported and Unregulated (IUU) fishing\, smuggling of arms  and ammunitions and natural disasters such as sea-level rise and cyclones.  \nMaritime Terrorism\nThere is a  growing nexus between maritime crime and terrorism. The sea’s vast expanse\, its  unregulatory nature\, blurred jurisdiction and stealth nature makes it a  preferred medium for  terrorists. There  are frequent seizures of arms\, drugs and narcotics consignments at sea\, which  indicates a disturbing trend. The nexus between drug traffickers\, terror  organisations and their financing is dangerous. The definition of maritime  terrorism as per the Council for Security Cooperation in Asia Pacific (CSCAP)  and offences in the maritime domain as laid in the Convention for Suppression  of Unlawful Acts against the Safety of Maritime Navigation or SUA convention  1988 (amended 2005) were highlighted. \nIndia’s Coastal Security Construct\nThe emergence  of coastal security can be traced back to 1990\, post the de-induction of IPKF  from Sri Lanka\, a low-intensity maritime operation (LIMO)\, Operation Tasha\,  commenced in Palk Bay. It was the first coastal security mechanism construct  involving multiple agencies\, including state police and administration. This  multi-layered concept of patrolling laid the foundations for coastal security  in India. Subsequently\, in 1993 the Mumbai blasts happened\, for which the RDX  was smuggled through the sea route. Operation Swan was initiated in September  1993 to prevent the transit of arms and ammunition along the coasts of Gujarat  and Maharashtra\, but there were challenges in terms of workforce\, resources and  intelligence inputs etc. Post Kargil conflict in 1999\, the Kargil Review  Committee (KRC) made recommendations to improve border management. A GoM was  formed\, which had a dedicated task force for border management. Its report came  out in 2001 and is known as the GoM report 2001. Intelligence efforts also  gained momentum to enhance coastal security by establishing a Multi-Agency  Centre (MAC). The International Ship and Port Facility Security Code (ISPS) was  also implemented to enhance port security. The Department of Border Management  was formed under the MHA in 2004. The Cabinet Committee of Security (CCS)  approved the first phase of the CSS. The CSS was based on the perspective plans  made by the coastal states and Union Territories\, which was implemented in 2005  for five years. The scheme consisted of setting up coastal police stations\,  outposts\, checkposts\, etc. However\, while this was underway\, the 26/11 attacks  again exposed the vulnerability of the Indian coastline and compelled India to  revamp its coastal security mechanisms. Various duties were assigned to the  Indian Navy and Coast Guard\, and a strong need for electronic surveillance was  also felt. Phase one of the Coastal Surveillance Network (CSN) project was  implemented from 2011 onwards\, and 46 coastal surveillance radar and  electro-optic sensors were established. The currently underway CSN phase two  includes the installation of 38 additional radar stations with eight mobile  surveillance systems. These will be integrated with vessel traffic management wsystems  (VTMS) of the Gulfs of Kutch and Khambat. Once in place\, this will lead to 109  surveillance radars along the coastline\, i.e. one radar per 74 km. The CSN  provides real-time surface surveillance up to 25 nautical miles\, and post-CSN phase  two\, a near gap-free electronic surveillance\, is envisaged. The Directorate  General of Lighthouses and Lightships (DGLL) also established a National  Automatic Identification System (AIS) chain by installing AIS sensors and  associated equipment at 87 existing lighthouses. The DG shipping also  implemented a Long Range Identification and Tracking (LRIT) system in 2009 in  accordance with IMO regulations. The National Command Control Communication and  Intelligence (NC3I) network correlates the data received from both Naval and  Coast Guard nodes and disseminates the information to the networked stations.  The CSS phase two was implemented from 2011 onwards\, emphasising the  strengthening of marine police. The NCSMCS was constituted in 2009 under the Cabinet  Secretary for apex-level coordination. Similarly\, the Steering Committee for  Review of Coastal Security (SCRCS) under the Secretary\, Border Management in  MHA was constituted in 2013. The state and district-level committees in coastal  states and UTs to monitor\, manage and steer coastal security issues have been  constituted post the coastal security review meeting held in 2016. The Marine  Police training at the National Academy of Coastal Policing (NACP) was  established at Okha in 2018. The Indian Navy\, Coast Guard and BSF form the core  of this academy. Further\, the newly approved National Maritime Domain Awareness  (NMDA) project is likely to facilitate seamless synergy and coordination  amongst the stakeholders. \nAdditionally\,  measures such as issuing Identity biometric cards for fisherpeople\, colour  coding of boats and online registration for fishing vessels have been  implemented nationally to strengthen the mechanism. Exercises such as Sagar Kavach\, Sajak and Sea Vigil are conducted periodically. Post 26/11\, community  groups were also formed in various states. The Indian Coast Guard has also  introduced community interaction which has now graduated to community  integration programmes. Comdt. Srivastava said that the coastal communities are  considered eyes and ears and are an integral part of a coastal security  construct. \nChallenges flagged and deliberated by  Comdt. Srivastava were as follows: \n\nLong inundated and porous coastline\nSuitable identification and tracking devices for small  fishing boats at sea.\nMaritime boundary issues and disputes\nThe diverse topography of India’s coastline compounds  the coastal security challenges.\nCoastal security is also connected to external factors  such as political turmoil\, economic collapse\, internal conflicts\, illegal  migration and climate change.\nThose involved in fisheries related crime and crime  associated with fisheries\, piracy and armed robbery at sea can easily be lured  into terrorist activities.  \nPrivate Maritime Security Companies (PMSCs) and  floating armouries at sea pose serious security concerns.\nMarine Police is still struggling with basic  impediments\, and its capabilities need to be strengthened further.\nSecurity of minor ports and fish landing centres  remains a grey area with a need for electronic surveillance.\nThere is also a need for more elaborate legal  provisions and fisheries regulation.\n\nRecommendations given by Comdt.  Srivastava were as follows: \n\nAnalyse the gap areas and finalise a plan of action for  implementing CSS phase three.\nCoastal security exercises\, joint training\, tabletop  exercises and workshops are to be conducted regularly.\nImprovement in the existing infrastructure\, jetties and  assets for marine police.\nCheckposts and CCTVs at fish landing sites should be  placed for access control.\nThe institutionalisation of entry and exit reporting by  Indian Dhows.\nMonitoring of unauthorised settlements along the  coastline.\nEmpower the fisheries department with an adequate  workforce\, sanctions\, and legal provisions.\nEmpower Marine Police with interceptor boats\, equipment  and training.\nImprovement of fisheries monitoring control and  surveillance.\nCountermeasures to underwater and ariel threats should  be developed.\nA mechanism for space-based monitoring needs to be  developed.\n\nComdt. M.  Srivastava concluded his presentation by saying that coastal security is a  multi-agency construct\, and efficient coordination amongst stakeholders is  imperative. The recently constituted NMSC is part of the NSCS\, which will  provide momentum to coastal security initiatives. Coastal security has  undergone a significant overhaul post-26/11\, and presently excellent support  from all stakeholders is experienced. However\, those involved in this construct  must train\, equip and exercise continuously and keep reinventing the wheel to  incorporate the lessons learnt. \nComments  \nCapt. Bisen  thanked Comdt. Srivastava for providing a comprehensive overview of the coastal  security construct\, activities of the Coast Guard\, an assessment of the  challenges faced and his recommendations for them. Given the Capt’s experience  of coastal security with the NSCS\, he provoked the discussion by asking if we  needed reform at higher level of coastal security construct. He also asked if  there shouldn’t be a single force for a single border as recommended by the  GoM. He then requested the Deputy Director General for his comments\, concluding  that MP-IDSA could work on this given the available expertise. \nMaj. Gen.  (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) thanked the Comdt. for his presentation and Capt.  Bisen  for his remarks. He began by  saying that this subject requires at least a day’s or a two-hour seminar. He  asserted that there is a clear need for recommendations on inter-agency  cooperation. The questions he raised were as follows: \n\nThe NMSC is primarily an advisor to the NSA\, so is it  possible to knit all agencies together?\nAre UAVs used for surveillance?\nWhy are we not seeing a large number of seizures by the  state marine police forces if they are being improved?\n\nTo Capt.  Bisen’s remarks\, the Comdt. said that the Steering Committee discusses issues  pertaining to coastal security with the stakeholders and initiates necessary  steps to strengthen the coastal security mechanism. Further\, the issues\, and  measures to strengthen the CS construct are deliberated at NCSMCS\, which is the  apex body and where all the concerned stakeholders are present. Therefore\, the  needed reforms at higher levels are in place and much so after the recent  appointment of NMSC. He then assured that all the government agencies are  working day and night in any given condition towards a robust coastal security  mechanism. He further explained in detail about the inherent security  challenges and differences between land and security at sea. At sea\, there is a  blurred jurisdiction\, with a different set of rules\, legal provisions and  jurisdiction in various zones such as territorial water\, contiguous zones and  EEZ. He then explained the advantages and necessity of a multi-agency mechanism.  He added that unlike the US after 9/11\, which merged stakeholders to form the  Department of Homeland Security\, India rightly preferred to go ahead with a  multi-layered system as India faces a set of challenges at sea which are quite  different from the US or Europe. \nComdt.  Srivastava agreed with Maj. Gen. Bakshi that this subject needs at least a one-day  seminar. In response to the latter’s questions\, he affirmed that the Indian  Navy provides training for ICG personnel at Naval training establishments\, and  there is a seamless synergy between IN and ICG. He flagged that identification  devices such as transponders for sub 20 mt. boats are also being developed. He  stressed that\, however\, along with technology\, there will always be a need for  physical presence at sea. The physical presence of ships and aircraft has no  substitute and is imperative. Their efforts\, however\, must be supplemented by  the use of technology. He briefly explained the current maritime domain  awareness system and touched upon space-based monitoring. He emphasised that a  holistic analysis and review of existing CS construct can be undertaken to  identify the gaps that could be addressed in the CSS phase three. The Comdt.  stated that marine police must be trained and equipped to meet their potential.  The academy at Okha will provide suitable training and enhance their capability  and seagoing skills. Various states are also taking administrative steps for  cadre management\, which will improve their operational capabilities.   \nMs. Sultana  raised questions about environmental security along the coast.The Comdt.  responded by stating how the Coast Guard helps the fisherpeople during natural  disasters and takes measures to curb marine pollution. He highlighted that ICG  conducts coastal clean-up exercises\, which are widely acknowledged. Studies on  climate change and challenges due to sea level rise or increased frequency of  cyclones or more intense storms are also underway by various agencies. The ICG  emphasises the concern for the marine environment and oil pollution at sea and  undertakes operations to protect marine species such as the endangered Olive  Ridley turtle. \nIn response to  the queries of Mr. Oak and Dr. Sanur Sharma on an indigenous navigation and  monitoring system\, Comdt. M. Srivastava briefly stated that measures are in  place\, and scientific organisations are working on enhancing our space-based  monitoring and surveillance capacity and capabilities. \nCapt. Bisen  thanked Comdt. M. Srivastava\, wished everyone an exciting week ahead and concluded  the meeting. \nReport was prepared by Mr. Nikhil Guvvadi\,  Intern\, Counter-Terrorism Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-coastal-security-construct-the-indian-way
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230210T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230210T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131248Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62952-1676007000-1676007000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Talk by Shri Rakesh Asthana on Narco-Terrorism and Drug Trafficking
DESCRIPTION:The Internal Security Centre of MP-IDSA organised a talk on  ‘Narco-Terrorism and Drug Trafficking’ by Shri Rakesh Asthana (IPS Retd.)\,  former Commissioner of Delhi\, on 10 February 2023. The other two discussants on  the panel were Shri Jayant Mishra\, Executive Council Member and Shri Shantanu  Sinha\, Research Fellow\, MP-IDSA. It was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\,  T20 Chair and Director General MP-IDSA\, attended by Deputy Director-General  MP-IDSA Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi and MP-IDSA scholars. \nExecutive Summary\nDeltails about drug trafficking and abuse in India were  discussed. The organised crime network’s linkages with terrorism are a  significant threat to India’s National Security and this aspect was elaborated  upon during the discussion. It was pointed out that the setting up of the  National Narcotics Coordination mechanism (NCORD) in furthering the agenda of  dealing with such organised terror with improved coordination will help address  the threat.  \nReport\nIn his welcome remarks\, Amb. Sujan Chinoy pointed out the  growing menace of drug trafficking and its linkages with terrorism to India’s  national security. Proximity to the Golden Triangle makes India vulnerable to  the trafficking of narcotics and drugs manufactured there and to the reverse flow  of precursor chemicals to these regions\, especially Myanmar. The proceeds from  sale of narcotics and drugs are then used to fund insurgencies and other  illegal activities. He said a similar situation is there on the western border\,  where Afghanistan and Pakistan have become the epicentre of the drug trade.  India has become not only a centre for transit but also a significant  consumption centre over the years. Recently\, it has been observed that those  who promote terrorism in India from across the border are using the proceeds of  such drug sales to finance terror activities. Drones are being used for drug  trafficking from across the border. Punjab has become a significant problem\,  and many drugs come through the Attari border. The money generated through them  finds its way into Kashmir for funding terrorism. There have been many seizures  off the coast of Gujarat\, and several arms and drug consignments have been  seized in the island territory of Lakshwadeep. There seems to be an emerging  nexus between the AfPak region and geographies as far south as Maldives and Sri  Laka. Amb. Chinoy concluded his opening remarks by saying how the complex  maritime environment threatens India’s coastal security and drug abuse is a  social problem that even Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressed in his Mann ki Baat. \nDefining the Drug\nMr. Asthana started by explaining what a drug is and  differentiating its various forms. There are two types of drugs\, narcotic and  psychotropic. Narcotic drugs can again be divided into two\, plant-based and  synthetic. Poppy\, Cannabis and Coca are plant-based drugs. Poppy’s derivatives  are Heroin\, Morphine\, Codeine and Oxycodone. Marijuana and Hashish are derived  from Cannabis\, and Cocaine is made out of the Coca plant. These are the three  significant drugs which are used by people all over the world. Another emerging  area is synthetic narcotic drugs such as Fentanyl\, Methadone\, Hydrocodone\,  etc.\, which are pharmaceutical drugs that are misused. Psychotropic substances  affect the central nervous system. They are medicines that are misused to get  high on them\, ultimately resulting in a person’s death. The third area is that  of precursor chemicals used to manufacture synthetic opioids. Most of the  precursor chemicals are of dual use. They have legitimate use cases in the  pharmaceutical industry; the other use case is for manufacturing illegal  psychotropic substances. \nDrug Trafficking and Abuse in India\nMr. Asthana highlighted the scale of drug abuse in India. A  large number of the youth in India are into drug abuse. AIIMS\, Delhi had  conducted a detailed survey in 2019 concerning drug abuse in the country. The  study’s results revealed the extent of the problem in India\, where 31 million  users of Cannabis\, 23 million users of opioids and 11.9 million users of  pharmaceutical sedatives are addicts. 2.06% of the population is affected\, the  average of which is far greater than in Asia and the world. A presentation was  made for the Prime Minister\, where he advised using the terminology of Death  Cresent and Death Triangle. The Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) has started  using this terminology since then. It was a valid point made by the Prime  Minister\, opined Mr. Asthana\, as it has adversely affected the State of Punjab  and the Northeast Region of India. \nIt is a lucrative trade for drug traffickers but a death  knell for society\, he said. An addict requires a 0.5-milligram dose per day\,  that is\, 360 metric tons of opioids per year\, for all the addicts in India  which is one metric ton per day. They cost 2-3 crores per kilogram\, which is  Rs. 1\,45\,000 crore of business annually. Against which the seizure was only 2.4  metric tons of Heroin in 2019 which is hardly 7% of the whole. After the NCB  and state police forces were sensitised to the results of this survey\, seizures  went up to 7.1 metric tons in 2021\, which is 19.7%. It is only the tip of the  iceberg\, and much work towards enforcement is required urgently. \nA Threat to India’s National Security\nDrug trafficking is a borderless crime\, and its extent makes  it very difficult to control. Death Cresent and Triangle produce 98% of heroin  and meth for the world\, which is being pushed into India for consumption and  transit to other parts like Western Europe\, Australia and Africa. Cocaine is  primarily produced in South American countries\, and via Africa or the Gulf\, it  reaches India by air or sea. Methamphetamine made in Myanmar is transported  through the sea route\, contributing the most to the total US$ 8 billion of  business done per annum worldwide. The trafficking routes in India are the Line  of Control in Jammu & Kashmir and the trade route at Attari. Sea routes are  through the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal. \nThe area under cultivation for the Poppy plant in Afghanistan  decreased from 2017 to 2018. However\, the outflow of Opium based drugs has only  increased since the Taliban took over the country as it is the most significant  contributor to their revenue. In 2022\, the Indian Navy and Coast Guard played  an enormous role in seizing 2\,009 kilograms of Heroin from the high seas. In  the same year\, 1\,063 kilograms of heroin was seized from the land routes. There  is also a new trend of using drones to drop off drugs across the border in the  northwest. \nThe drug lords of Pakistan\, Afghanistan and Iran work  together to push heroin through the Arabian Sea. Acetic Anhydride manufactured  in India is shipped illegally to Pakistan and Iran and is used in making  Heroin. After the abrogation of article 370 in Kashmir and the subsequent  strengthening of security along the border\, it became tough for the drug  traffickers in the northwest to smuggle drugs across the border\, so they  shifted to the maritime route. For the last four years\, the NCB has worked  closely with the Indian Navy and Coast Guard\, whose coordination with the Coast  Guards of Sri Lanka and Maldives resulted in many seizures at sea. \nThe Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) supports the drug lords  in Pakistan\, and the money generated through their activities is being used to  fund terrorist activities in India. The Haji Saleem network uses terrorists in  India to carry out their activities. Eight Indian assets of their network have  been identified in a Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) investigation whose links  go back to the ISI and other contacts in Sri Lanka and Australia. According to  Mr. Asthana\, such analyses help understand the magnitude of the problem at  hand. \nThe Kasargod network is another example worth mentioning\, as  per Mr. Asthana. It is a vast network with contacts in Sri Lanka\, Gulf and  Pakistan. They traditionally produced Ganja and sold it in the rest of India  and Sri Lanka. Gradually they moved into operating with other complex  narcotics. Recently\, their linkages within Lakshwadeep and Maldives have also  been mapped out. They also previously worked with the Liberation Tigers of  Tamil Eelam (LTTE). The kingpin of this network\, Mohsin K.P.\, is running the  show from jail in Qatar. \nRebel-controlled Shan and Kachin provinces of Myanmar share  their border with China. These rebels depend on China\, and the Chinese chemical  industry is very active in the regions across the border. Therefore\, almost 90%  of precursors are being supplied by the Chinese. This dynamic has significant  implications for India’s internal security. They are using the money generated  to fund insurgency in the northeast and left-wing extremism in India with the  supply of weapons. The rebels of Shan and Kachin are thriving through this  business with backing from the Chinese. This issue needs to be addressed with  just as much tenacity as India takes care of the northwest border. More than  2\,000 kilograms of heroin and meth were seized from Myanmar in the Bay of  Bengal\, the most infamous variant being that of the Yaba tablets. \nA new trend that has emerged during NCB’s investigation is  that drug handlers from abroad are hiring local gangsters in India to carry out  their activities. Drugs are being used to lure people to work for them. The  NCB\, National Investigation Agency (NIA) and the state police forces are all  working in tandem to curb such instances. The druglords of Mexico are planning  to set up a cocaine manufacturing facility in India because India is the  largest manufacturer of Potassium Permanganate\, which is used to treat the Coca  paste for it become Cocaine. \nHigher Organisation\nThe Ministry of Home Affairs devised a great proposal to  create a four-tiered National Narcotics Coordination mechanism (NCORD). NCB is  the nodal agency tasked with coordinating with various agencies against drug  trafficking. The Home and Special Secretaries head the Apex and Executive  Committees at the Central Government level. Chief Secretaries and District SPs  head the state and district-level Committees. In addition\, a Joint Consultative  Committee (JCC) system is led by the DG NCB\, which is supposed to ensure  coordination in investigations and anti-trafficking operations. \nIn conclusion\, Mr. Asthana affirmed that the Government of  India is committed to fighting drug trafficking and abuse. Besides being a  security threat it is also a social problem also that needs to be fought  constructively on the demand side and operationally on the supply side. \nAmb. Chinoy thanked Mr. Asthana for an ennumerative and  informative briefing and remarked that it is a great challenge to the nation.  He shared a brief anecdote from his time in Mexico\, where the Americans  contacted India as they discovered that drug precursors were coming from India\,  as mentioned by Mr. Asthana. Mr. Jayant Mishra was then invited for his  comments. \nMr. Mishra began his remarks by praising Mr. Asthana for  being the frontline warrior while NCB’s NCORD initiative took shape in his  capacity as the DG. He made the following brief observations: \n\nDrug  trafficking is not a stand-alone threat but is interlaced with arms and human  trafficking. Darknet markets are used for trafficking of drugs and precursors.\nWildlife  and antique trafficking are also intertwined with drug trafficking.\nThere  are a rising number of adolescent users\, and the gender gap is reducing with  psychotropic drug users compared to narcotic users.\nHard  drug markets being created in the west cause concern regarding terror  financing.\nWhile  new and emerging technologies are used to curb drug trafficking\, drug  traffickers use them to conduct thier business.\n\nAfter Mr. Mishra concluded with his remarks\, Amb. Chinoy made  a mention about Kashmiri school girls consuming drugs and how Chinese fentanyl  is destroying the American countryside. He then invited Mr Sinha to speak.  \nMr. Sinha highlighted how Pakistan’s narco-terrorist designs  against India constantly evolve and how they are reviving Khalistani militancy  and pushing drugs and arms into India. \nAmb. Chinoy thanked Mr. Asthana for bringing out the  Khalistani element and its role in drug trafficking in the region and opened up  the floor for a Q&A session. \nComments\nMs. Ruchita Beri asked if any Africans were involved in drug  trafficking to India. Mr. Asthana highlighted that many Africans from Nigeria\,  Mozambique\, South Africa\, etc.\, are overstaying their visas in India and are  involved with the smuggling of Cocaine and Heroin. He said it is a complex  issue involving another country’s citizens and must be dealt with  diplomatically. \nComdt. Manoranjan raised the query whether closed  pharmaceutical industries could be involved in drug trafficking. Mr. Asthana  said that such factories in Punjab\, Rajasthan and Gujarat are engaged in these  activities. \nMr. Khare asked about the employment status of high-precision  vehicle scanners for detection near borderlands. Mr. Asthana said that they are  being deployed in the northeast region. \nCapt. Bisen asked if a regional cooperative mechanism for  Indian Ocean littoral states can be conceived against drug trafficking. Mr.  Asthana said that there is already a significant amount of international  cooperation through the NCB\, and there are mechanisms already in place for the  same in BIMSTEC and SCO. \nComdt. Srivastava\, Col. Chada and Capt. Bisen’s  queries about whether amendments in laws regarding greater synergy between the  plethora of agencies involved and focus on the terrorism side of narcotics is  needed\, Mr. Asthana reiterated that there is already excellent coordination  between the NCB\, Enforcement Directorate and NIA. He mentioned that a draft  regarding amendments to the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS)  Act is currently being discussed by the law commission. Additionally\, the NCB  is being stregthened with enhanced manpower and resources to effectively deal  with the threat of drug trafficking in the country. \nReport prepared by Mr. Nikhil Guvvadi\, Intern\, Counter Terrorism Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/talk-by-shri-rakesh-asthana-on-narco-terrorism-and-drug-trafficking
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230207T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230207T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131248Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130235Z
UID:62953-1675747800-1675747800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of  Fellows Seminar  on The Geopolitics of Europe's Quest for Energy Security: Significant Achievements amid Myriad Challenges
DESCRIPTION:A MP-IDSA Fellows Seminar by Dr. Swasti Rao\, Associate  Fellow\, on “The Geopolitics of Europe’s Quest for Energy Security:  Significant Achievements amid Myriad Challenges” was held on 7 February 2023.  It was chaired by Prof. Gulshan Sachdeva\, Professor\, Jawaharlal Nehru  University\, New Delhi. The external discussants were Dr. Lydia Powell\,  Distinguished Fellow\, Observer Research Foundation (ORF)\, and Mr. Rajeev Lala\,  Associate Director\, S&P Global. Ms. Anandita Bhada\, Research Analyst at MP-IDSA\,  was the internal discussant. \nExecutive  Summary \nAlmost a year into the war in Ukraine\, European nations have  fast-tracked their energy diversification in order to reduce their dependency  on Russia. The main issues are policies adopted by Europe to diversify\, the available  options\, and prognosis for the future. \nDetailed Report\nThe Chair\, Prof. Gulshan Sachdeva\, in his opening  remarks\, stated that diversification of energy supplies would likely have a major  geopolitical implication. For example\, Europe moving towards the US for oil and  Russia diversifying its energy exports away from Europe\, towards Asia would  significantly impact the international arena. \nDr. Swasti Rao began her presentation with a question – “Does  Europe want to diversify its energy requirements from Russia?” She replied in  the affirmative but pointed out that the main issue is implementing this  vision. The speaker then highlighted the structure of her paper before briefly delving  into the ongoing developments in Russia-Ukraine war.  \nDr. Rao stressed that Europe is seeking to completely  wean itself away from Russian crude oil\, natural gas and coal. She highlighted  Europe’s dependency on Russian energy amidst the differentiation in patterns  and volume of such trade. She elaborated on the internal and external  differences in Europe regarding the diversification process. She pointed out Europe’s  plans to focus on alternative fuels in the form of hydrogen and nuclear\, apart  from creating new energy maps and import corridors. The fact is that today Europe  is looking into both short-term and long-term energy measures\, anchored to  avoiding any potential dependency. For Europe\, the supply chains should not  only be cost-effective but also more resilient.  \nDr. Rao highlighted the diversification measures  undertaken by Europe. These include import diversification\, short-term energy  imports\, protection of the most venerable cohorts\, and acceleration to new  renewables.  \nThe speaker elaborated on the macro and micro energy trends  in Europe – both before and since the conflict started. At the macro level\, there  has been a systemic and sustainable shift away from Russian energy. At the  micro-level\, Europe has sought to cut down domestic demand apart from  transition to renewables. These steps are\, however\, hampered by limitations that  include pipeline disruption\, oil re-routing\, global liquefaction capacity\, and  failure to meet market goals. \nMoving to the issue of transition to renewables such as  green hydrogen\, blue hydrogen\, and bio-methane\, Dr. Rao highlighted the sense  of urgency in the form of new European pathways to develop these alternatives.  She also referred to Europe’s attempts at developing new import corridors. She  emphasised that one of the reasons for Europe’s ongoing support to Ukraine is  anchored to Ukraine emerging as a promising option for green hydrogen.  \nOn the issue of expanding avenues of energy cooperation  between India and Europe\, Dr. Rao referred to the Trade Technology Council and  ongoing bilateral discussions in the field of hydrogen.  \nDr. Rao concluded by stating that Europe appears to have  shown a strong political will to diversify yet it would need strong political  leadership in what would likely be a very painful period ahead.  \nDr. Lydia Powell:\nDr. Powell\, while complimenting the author for her  presentation\, felt that there is scope for enhancing the analytical rigour of  the paper by moving beyond the summarizing and descriptive aspects. This  includes a more rigorous analysis of the post-Ukraine energy situation in  Europe and its future. She observed that the speaker could qualitatively  improve the section on “geopolitics of Europe’s quest for energy security”.  \nDr. Powell gave a few more suggestions to improve the  paper. First\, she suggested revising the opening section\, particularly the  framing of whether the European Union (EU) can replace Russia in the context of  energy. Second\, one needs to dwell on who the winners and losers of the current  geopolitical scenario are – this includes Russia\, EU and the US. Also\, whether Russia’s  calculations are long-term vis-à-vis short term? Third\, the speaker could address  the question of whether the fossil fuel and nuclear industries are the winners  in this climate. Fourth\, the speaker should address whether Asia has become the  winner given the renewed focus on the continent amidst Russia’s growing energy  exports to India and China. Similarly\, has the developing world lost out in the  short term on account of their energy crisis? Fifth\, the paper must address its  policy relevance\, particularly for India.  \nMr. Rajeev  Lala:\nMr. Rajeev Lala highlighted the need to add a caveat  around hydrogen – “hope”\, especially on green hydrogen. Meanwhile\, there exists  two proponents around hydrogen; one is the blue hydrogen proponent (led by  Saudi Arabia) and the other being the green hydrogen proponents (led by Japan\,  Korea\, Switzerland\, and South Korea). The key issue is financing\, as both  technologies are expensive; hence it is still most policymakers’ hope. \nThere also exists a significant variation in European  countries dependency on Russia. This has a direct bearing on each country’s  national position on Russia with the most critical stand being taken by  countries which have the least dependency. Mr. Lala suggested the need for a chart  to show this correlation by providing the examples of energy dependencies of Germany  and the United Kingdom on Russia.  \nThe discussant called upon Dr. Rao to focus on the interconnectivity  issue and the status of interconnectors across Europe. Meanwhile\, a section  could be added on the risks for 2023 and what could go wrong.  \nMr. Lala elaborated on ongoing discussions on “winter  approaching” and its potential impact on Ukraine\, and stressed that winter has in  fact already arrived in South Asia in the June-August period since all the gas  markets are interconnected. He referred to its impact on Pakistan which is  undergoing a prolonged energy crisis. In the same vein\, Europe’s energy  diversification could impact the Indian gas market\, which the author should  also focus on. \nMs. Anandita  Bhada:\nThe discussant stressed on the need to highlight the  winners and losers of the ongoing crisis. She referred to the eastern European  countries\, who being less economically developed\, have found cheaper Russian  energy more attractive. Ms. Bhada felt that the importance of interconnectors  must be emphasized since several eastern European countries are landlocked or  have a small coastline. In this\, the significance of Poland-Lithuania interconnector  should be emphasised. She also referred to the concept of projects of common  interests which help secure energy across the continent. This includes the  Baltic Gas Pipeline connecting Norway via Denmark to Poland.  \nApart from raising the question of financing\, Ms. Bhada highlighted  the use of rare earth elements sourced from China for energy transition to  renewables. She wondered whether a significant focus on renewables would mean  Europe would have an increased dependence on China for rare-earth elements? Ms.  Bhada also observed that the Brexit deal must be resolved for any substantial  gains between Europe and the United Kingdom. Finally\, regarding the reduction  of demand\, she pondered that by the time there is a reduction in the market for  Russian energy sources\, the need for the substitute would increase; thus\, how  would Europe balance it out?  \nProf. Gulshan  Sachdeva:\nThe Chair complimented the author for her work. He also  highlighted some of the areas of the paper which could be further improved.  \nFirst\, the title could be formulated for a more precise  understanding. Too many aspects within the title may create problems. There is  also a need for more in-depth analysis of the geopolitical factors at play.  \nSecond\, there is a need to have a discussion on the  concept of energy security and what is the European understanding of energy security.  There is also need to discuss the history of the European understanding of  energy security from the past to the current era.  \n  Third\, Prof Sachdeva opined that the Literature Review  might not be needed but gave the researcher the discretion to keep or remove  it.  \nFourth\, he highlighted the need to re-arrange the paper.  In the introduction\, the researcher could highlight the European concept of  energy security\, and then delve into the current geopolitical situation as a  result of which Europe has chosen to adjust its energy security policies.  \nFifth\, concerning the figures\, there is a need for  primary data\, and the use of multiple graphics is confusing for the readers.  For example\, a graph could be there for the situation before the Ukraine war  and the current situation.  \nSixth\, there is a need to refer to more primary documents  from the European Union; for instance\, the Repower EU Plan needs to be added.  \nSeventh\, Prof. Sachdeva observed that on India-EU  collaboration\, the researcher could avoid the over-emphasis on hydrogen since it  may divert from the crux of the paper. In this\, the paper needs to focus more  on the impact of energy diversification on India. A country like India is  significantly dependent on Russian arms and energy\, and there could be severe  implications for the geopolitics of the Eurasian region.  \nEighth\, the author must expand the conclusion. \nQuestions and  Comments \nDeputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi  (Retd.)  agreed with the Chair  on specific aspects of the paper which need to be reviewed. He observed that multilateralism  is weakening\, maybe to a certain extent even fracturing\, which has led to  multipolarity and emergence of regional groupings. In the past\, regional  groupings were linked to geography but several of those links are now fractured.  In the same vein\, he observed that geopolitics and ideology are fracturing  existing trade agreements\, for example\, the EU- Russian energy mix and the  US-China trade war. New alignments are shaping up\, and old friends and  alliances are finding themselves on opposite sides of the energy alignment;  simultaneously\, they are adapting and harmonizing with the current geopolitical  situation. \nOn green hydrogen\, he emphasised that Indian researchers  have been active. Nevertheless\, cost is a factor and the focus has also been  more on blue hydrogen. The questions of economics trumping geopolitics and the  success of the shift to hydrogen could be addressed. \nThe Q/A session broadly revolved around the themes of  transition to greener energy\, energy security\, energy politics within Europe\,  nuclear energy option\, North-South divide\, India’s ability to deal with global  risks and the need to focus on West Asia.  \nThe speaker responded to the comments and questions.  \n(Report prepared by Dr. Jason Wahlang\, Research Analyst\, Europe  and Eurasia Centre\, MP-IDSA)
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-fellows-seminar-on-the-geopolitics-of-europes-quest-for-energy-security-significant-achievements-amid-myriad-challenges
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230206T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230206T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131248Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62954-1675661400-1675661400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on ”India’s G20 Presidency: Opportunity to Resume Engagement in the Arctic”
DESCRIPTION:Capt. Anurag  Bisen (Indian Navy)\, Member Non-Traditional  Security Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses spoke on “India’s G20 Presidency: Opportunity to Resume Engagement in the  Arctic” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 6 February 2023. The meeting was moderated  by Col. (Dr.) D.P.K. Pillay. Deputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin  Bakshi\, (Retd.) and scholars of the Institute participated in the discussion. \nExecutive Summary\nThe suspension of the  Arctic Council post Russia-Ukraine conflict has resulted in the suspension of  all forms of scientific cooperation with Russia. As a result of this  suspension\, global climate change mitigation efforts are severely impacted.  India’s G-20 Presidency offers an opportunity for the G20 to strive for  resumption of scientific cooperation in the Arctic. \nDetailed Report\nCol. (Dr.) D.P.K.  Pillay introduced the topic to the audience and highlighted the  implications for the Arctic. In his opening remarks\, he mentioned that India’s  engagements with the Arctic date back to 1920 when the country under British Dominion  signed the Spitsbergen Treaty. He highlighted that the environmental  transitional occurring in the Arctic has direct implications for Indian  monsoons\, which have the potential of impacting the country’s food security.  Col. Pillay then invited Capt. Anurag Bisen (IN) to make his presentation on  the topic. \n Capt. Anurag Bisen (IN) started his presentation by  highlighting that India as Chair of the G20 Presidency could push for  re-starting dialogue amongst all the Arctic States. He further highlighted that  there is a need for the revival of all form of scientific cooperation within  the Arctic Council as well as through all other existing mechanisms of  cooperation that currently remain suspended. Capt. Bisen highlighted that  post-Russia’s special military operation in Ukraine\, all the seven Arctic States  have suspended their cooperation with Russia in the region. This includes the  suspension of the Arctic Council\, European Commission and the Barents  Euro-Arctic Council. Capt. Bisen\, in his presentation further mentioned that  Finland and Sweden’s decision to join NATO has further enhanced complexities  for regional cooperation in the Arctic. In his talk\, he also highlighted major  climate tipping points in the Arctic that play a crucial role in regulating  global environmental conditions. He asserted that any disruptions in the  thresholds of these Arctic tipping points would have grave regional and global  implications. He further mentioned that the Arctic remains globally connected  and that whatever happens in the Arctic does not stay in the Arctic. Capt.  Bisen also emphasized the fact that the Arctic is heating four times faster  than other parts of the Earth. He mentioned that this in the near future could  have challenges of sea level rise\, implications for coastal habitats\, soil  erosion\, impacts on wetlands and loss of fish\, birds and other plant life.  He also pointed out that since 40 per cent of  the world’s population lives within 100 km of the coastline\, rising sea levels  are expected to flood hundreds of cities worldwide. \nCapt. Bisen  also  explained the concept of ‘Arctic amplification’ and the role of methane in  further warming the Arctic ice. He then highlighted that since the suspension  of the Arctic Council\, scientific research of the five Asian Observer States in  the Council namely India\, China\, Japan\, South Korea and Singapore have been  significantly impacted. Capt. Bisen mentioned that though the world is facing  geopolitical tussles due to the Russia-Ukraine crisis\, it is difficult to  neglect Russia in Arctic decision-making. He also mentioned that since Russia  accounts for 53 per cent of the Arctic Ocean coastline\, ignoring Russia in  Arctic scientific research would not serve global scientific interests. \nIn the final part of his presentation\, Capt. Bisen explained  that scientific research in the Arctic is of great interest to India. He  mentioned the scientific interlinkages between the Arctic\, the Antarctic and  the Himalayas and explained their importance in shaping Indian and global  climatic phenomena. Citing the six pillars of India’s engagement in the Arctic  as outlined in the country’s Arctic Policy document\, Capt. Bisen mentioned that  these clearly justify India’s approach and future intentions in the region.  Moreover\, he also highlighted that the theme of India’s G20 presidency i.e. Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam- the world is but one  family\, also finds resonance in India’s Arctic Policy. He\, therefore\,  asserted that India through its G20 Presidency should call for resuming the  existing cooperation in the Arctic. He justified his stance by further  mentioning that 6 out of the 8 Arctic Council Permanent Member States\, and 12  out of the 13 Observer States are part of G20 member countries. In his  concluding remarks\, Capt. Bisen pointed out that Environment and Climate  Sustainability Working Groups in G20 could become key instruments. Lastly\, he  also recommended that the ‘Sherpa Track’ could also be used to expeditiously  revive scientific engagements in the Arctic. \nQuestions and Comments\nFollowing the presentation\,  Col. (Dr.) D.P.K. Pillay invited the Deputy Director General and  the participants for their comments and  questions. \nDeputy Director General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) complimented Capt. Bisen for  his presentation and highlighted MP-IDSA’s meeting with the Danish delegation  on various Arctic issues in the past. He also mentioned that MP-IDSA has always  remained at the forefront of conducting Arctic-related events. He mentioned  that the institution recently in collaboration with the Ministry of Earth  Sciences and NSCS conducted a one-day seminar on the Arctic. Lastly\, he  highlighted that the Arctic tipping points remain important for India as these  bear inter-linkages with Indian Himalayas\, therefore India’s scientific  collaboration with all the Arctic states remains extremely crucial. \n    Col. Vivek Chadha (Retd.) asked the speaker regarding his recent  visit to Geneva and asked if this idea of restarting Arctic scientific cooperation  through G20 found any traction with the representatives of the Member States  there. \n    Ms. Ruchita Beri asked the speaker if this suspension of scientific  cooperation with Russia in the Arctic was only as the result of the Ukraine  crisis\, or was there already developing geopolitical competition between  Western Arctic States and Russia\, that in the shadow of the Ukraine crisis  resulted in the termination of East-West cooperation in the region. \n    Ms. Mayuri Banerjee made a query regarding the military  exercises of States in the Arctic and how these hinder scientific cooperation  in the region. \n    Dr. Adil Rasheed commented on the geopolitics of climate change and  questioned the speaker regarding the Western States’ responses if India takes a  lead on such issues through its G20 Presidency. \n    Mr. Bipandeep Sharma commented on the issue of suspension of  the Arctic Council and termination of all forms of scientific cooperation with  Russia. He questioned that if the   existing mechanism of cooperation through the Arctic Council fails to  restart any form of cooperation with Russia\, how can G20 do it  differently?  He further highlighted that  Norway\, which is going to be the next Chair of the Arctic Council in May 2023\,  also does not hint at restarting any form of such cooperation with Russia in  near future. \n    Dr. Uttam Sinha complimented the speaker for his presentation and commented  on the point of ‘Arctic Exceptionalism’ mentioned by the speaker in his  presentation. Dr. Sinha mentioned that the concept does not exist in current  times as the world has become largely interconnected. This interconnectedness  is further linked to climate change\, where any transition occurring in the  Arctic has global linkages. Dr. Sinha further mentioned that the Arctic Council  till recently remained a successful forum to address various Arctic issues and  this ongoing suspension has brought it into a unique conundrum. Dr. Sinha  lastly pointed out that the world need not to forget the issues of Arctic  indigenous communities that are most vulnerable to climatic transitions  occurring in the region. \n Capt. Bisen gave a detailed  explanation to all these comments and questions asked by the scholars at the  Monday Morning Meeting. \n  Report prepared by Mr. Bipandeep Sharma\,  Research Analyst\, Non-Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-indias-g20-presidency-opportunity-to-resume-engagement-in-the-arctic
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230130T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230130T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131248Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62955-1675056600-1675056600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Saudi-Iran Relations: Between Continuing Friction and Frozen Talks
DESCRIPTION:Dr. P K  Pradhan\, Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and  Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “Recent Developments in Saudi-Iran Relations:  Between Continuing Friction and Frozen Talks” at the Monday  Morning Meeting held on 30 January 2023. The session was moderated by Dr.  Deepika Saraswat\, Associate  Fellow\, MP-IDSA.  Scholars of the Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary \nSaudi Arabia and Iran are two important players in the  West Asian region. Since the beginning of the Arab unrest\, the relationship  between both countries has further deteriorated. For Saudi Arabia\, the military  presence of the US in West Asia is a vital component of the regional security  architecture. On the other hand\, Iran opposes any external intervention in the  region. Iran’s presence in Yemen\, Syria\, Lebanon and Iraq has threatened Saudi  Arabia. Its major concerns are its national security and the freedom of  navigation as Iran has a significant influence over the two choke points  namely\, the Strait of Hormuz and Bab El Mandeb. Besides\, the Iranian nuclear  programme and Iran’s intervention in Yemen through Houthi forces are two key  issues of rivalry between them. In 2021 and 2022\, five rounds of Iraq-mediated talks  were held between Iran and Saudi Arabia at the official level in Baghdad.  However\, the change of government in Iraq has stalled talks and tension has  further deepened owing to the recent protests in Iran. Currently\, the major  challenges for both countries are to convert the talks into a serious and  credible political dialogue and to re-establish their diplomatic relations. The  reconciliatory approach shown by Iran and Saudi Arabia may de-escalate the  tensions in the short and medium term which may help in bringing temporary  peace and stability to the region. \nDetailed Report\nIn  her initial remarks\, Dr. Deepika Saraswat stated that in the last two decades\,  Iran and Saudi Arabia have emerged as two important players in the West Asian  region. Since the Arab uprising\, both the countries found themselves on opposite  sides of each other in proxy wars in Yemen\, Syria\, Iraq and elsewhere. This rivalry  took a disastrous sectarian dimension over a period of time and it reached its  peak in 2016. The conflict between the two further intensified with the  beginning of war in Yemen. More recently\, US President Joe Biden’s withdrawal  of support for Saudi Arabia’s war efforts in Yemen and revival of nuclear  diplomacy vis-à-vis  Iran\, paved a way  for both the countries to de-escalate tensions between the two. However\, the  relations between the two have again become hostile after Iran blamed Saudi  Arabia for a “media war”. \nDr. P K Pradhan started his presentation by giving a  historical background of the troubled relationship between Iran and Saudi  Arabia. He stated that the problems between Iran and the Gulf monarchies  started in 1979 when after  the Islamic revolution Ayatollah Khomeini  became the leader of Iran and declared to export his brand of Shia Islam to  neighbouring states.  This posed an  immediate security challenge to the Gulf countries. This was an important  factor which pushed Saudi Arabia to support Iraq in the 1980-1988 Iran-Iraq War. However\, during the  Iraq-Kuwait War (1990-91)\, Saudi Arabia supported Kuwait against Iraq. In 2003\,  during the US invasion of Iraq\, Saudi Arabia hosted the US forces which was opposed  by Iran. The outbreak of Arab uprising in the region in post 2010 period  further widened the Saudi-Iranian divide. \n  Dr.  Pradhan said that Saudi Arabia was not untouched by the Arab uprising as its Eastern province registered widespread protests. The  Saudi regime alleged that Shia cleric Nimr al-Nimr was instigating these  anti-government protests and executed him in 2016. The execution of Nimr  resulted in huge protests in Tehran. In addition\, Iran also strongly condemned  Saudi Arabia and threatened that the latter would “pay a heavy price” for his  execution. This pushed Saudi Arabia along with some other Gulf countries to  down grade its diplomatic ties with Iran. \nThereafter\, Dr. Pradhan explained the regional  security architecture in West Asia and highlighted the US’s vital role in providing  security to Gulf countries including Saudi Arabia. The US also has a military  presence in the all the six GCC countries.   On the other hand\, Iran says that there should not be any external power  involvement in the regional security architecture of West Asia. Iran proposes a regional security architecture in the Gulf with  the involvement of the regional powers only. \nDr. Pradhan mentioned that Saudi Arabia is hugely  concerned about Iran’s intentions. It feels that Iran will launch attacks  either directly or through proxies if the US forces withdraw from the region.  Saudi Arabia along with the GCC countries has  proposed the Middle East Strategic Alliance while Iran proposes Hormuz Peace Endeavour. Indeed\, there is a huge difference in perception of  the two countries with respect to the regional security architecture of the  region. Dr. Pradhan explained the threat perception of Saudi Arabia and Iran  through maps and highlighted that US military presence in the region is a  threat for Iran and the presence of Iranian proxies in the countries such as  Yemen\, Lebanon\, Syria and Iraq are threats to Saudi national security. \nAccording to him\, freedom of navigation  is a major concern for Saudi Arabia as Iran has significant influence on the two  choke points namely\, Strait of Hormuz  and Bab-el- Mandeb. If Iran disrupts the oil traffic\, it would impact oil  supply to Saudi Arabia. In the past conflicts\, Iran  has\, multiple times\, threatened to close the Strait of Hormuz if there is any threat to its national security. In  post 2015 period\, Houthis have attacked Saudi oil tankers in Bab-el- Mandeb and  in the Red Sea forcing Saudi Arabia to temporarily stop oil supply through Bab  El Mandeb in 2018.  \nIranian nuclear  issue is another key point of friction between Iran and Saudi Arabia. In 2015\, Saudi Arabia initially  adopted a conciliatory approach towards the deal. Subsequently\, Iran started  intervention in the region and provided funds to terrorist organisations and  other non-state actors which pushed Saudi Arabia to raise this issue with  regional and international powers. It welcomed President Trump’s decision to  withdraw from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) and also supported  the “maximum pressure” policy of the US. Regarding the Iranian nuclear talks in  Vienna\, he said that Saudi Arabia was closely watching it. However\, Saudi Arabia cannot do much about it. \nDr. Pradhan highlighted  the five rounds of talks which were held between Iran and  Saudi Arabia in 2022 in Baghdad.  The  talks were held between Khalid Al-Homaidan\, Chief of General Intelligence\,  Saudi Arabia\, and Saeed Iravani\, Deputy Secretary of Iran’s Supreme National  Security Council. Former Iraqi Prime Minister Mustafa Al-Kadhimi played a significant  role in facilitating these talks. However\, now there is a power shift in Iraq  which has stalled the talks between the two. \nAccording  to him\, there were various factors that have contributed to facilitating talks  between the two countries. Firstly\, Iran and Saudi Arabia are under international pressure due to  deteriorating internal security and humanitarian situation in Yemen\, especially\,  after Joe Biden became the President of the US. Secondly\, Saudi Arabia is under  US pressure to end its military offensive in Yemen. Thirdly\, after Trump’s  withdrawal from the JCPOA\, Iran was hopeful of reviving the deal under Biden.  Lastly\, war in Yemen has proved a burden on the Saudi budget whereas Iran is  looking for lifting of sanctions as a result of the Vienna talks. All these  factors have contributed in bringing both the countries to the negotiating  table. As result of talks\, the situation in Yemen has improved slightly and the  parties agreed on ceasefire. Though the ceasefire could not extend\, the  situation has improved slightly in Yemen. \n  Iranian  Vice-President Seyed Mohammad Hosseini met with Saudi Foreign Minister Faisal  bin Farhan on 2 January on the side-lines of the swearing-in ceremony of  Brazil’s President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva. In addition\, Foreign Ministers of  the two countries met in Jordan on the side-lines of the Baghdad-II Conference  on 19 December 2022. During these  visits both sides emphasised the need for continuing the talks. \nThe recent protests in  Iran have also contributed to Iran and Saudi Arabia tensions.  Since the protest erupted\, Iran has alleged that Saudi Arabia and Israel are  behind the protests. Iran alleged that Saudi Arabia has been supporting  particular media houses to spread propaganda against Iran. In addition\, Saudi  Arabia has also shared concerns with the US regarding possibility of a direct  or indirect attack from Iran amidst protests. \nWhile highlighting the  challenges ahead\, Dr. Pradhan said that converting the talks “to a  serious and credible political dialogue” and “to restore diplomatic  relations between two countries” continues to be a big challenge. Furthermore\,  the Iranian nuclear issue and crisis in Yemen also remains a big challenge for  the talks. He made three observations. Firstly\, the talks at present are at an embryonic stage. Second\,  considering the adversarial relationship between the two\, achieving substantial  progress would require long negotiations\, mutual trust and willingness to  engage in a political dialogue. Finally\, the reconciliatory approach exhibited by Iran and Saudi  Arabia may de-escalate the tensions in the short and medium term which may help  bring temporary peace and stability to the region. \nDr. Pradhan concluded his presentation by underlining  India’s approach toward the Iran-Saudi Arabia conflict. He said that India  has huge stakes with both the countries and regional stability in the Gulf is  in India’s interest. India has adopted a policy of neutrality and  non-interference in the Saudi-Iran conflict and appealed to both the countries to  resolve their differences mutually through dialogue and negotiations. \nThe  presentation was followed by a lively Q&A session. \nThe Report was prepared by Dr. Jatin Kumar\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-saudi-iran-relations-between-continuing-friction-and-frozen-talks
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230123T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230123T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131248Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62956-1674451800-1674451800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Key Developments in the Indo Pacific: Perceptions in South East Asia
DESCRIPTION:On  23 January 2023\, Ms. Shruti Pandalai\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, made a  presentation on “Key Developments in the Indo-Pacific: Perceptions in South  East Asia” at the Monday Morning Meeting. Cmde. Abhay Kumar Singh (Retd.) moderated  the session. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, the Director General of MP-IDSA\, Maj. Gen.  (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, the Deputy Director General of MP-IDSA and scholars  of the Institute were in attendance to enrich the discussion. \nExecutive Summary\nWith China’s aggressively increasing interest in  global leadership\, the Indo-Pacific region still serves as the pivot of global  geopolitics. Leading powers in the region are expected to demonstrate political  will and capability as nations\, large and small\, try to offset the effects of  increasing strategic competition. The quest for chances for practical cooperation\,  a rethinking of security and a balance between economic and security cooperation  with the rise in militarization are some important trends that are apparent  from the region’s expanding geopolitics. As observed\, there are concentrated  endeavours to strengthen the capabilities of Indo-Pacific nations in order to  provide them with realistic alternatives that go beyond binaries created around  ideological and political contestation. \nDetailed Report\nCmde.  Abhay introduced the topic with a brief overview of the developments concerning  Southeast Asia and the Indo-Pacific in the recent past. Thereafter\, he invited  Ms. Shruti Pandalai \, the speaker\, to make a presentation on the subject. \nMs.  Pandalai began by noting the continuance of the strategic high tide in the  Indo-Pacific\, which has been long in the making. Many nations have been working  in different combinations and permutations to make sure that a shared  foundation for cooperation in the region emerges. She stated that the goal of  these efforts is to create an equal\, rule-based system in which unilateralism  is restrained. Ms. Pandalai highlighted a few broad trends that have emerged  with distinguishable features in the Indo-Pacific region.  The first broad trend highlighted by her was  “issue-based coalition” which is driven by function. The collaboration of  like-minded nations in bilateral\, multilateral\, and plurilateral forms was the  second trend Ms. Pandalai emphasised.   Focused effort on capacity building of Indo-Pacific countries was  another broad trend highlighted by Ms. Pandalai. \nAccording  to Ms. Pandalai\, the conflict in Ukraine\, the escalation of the cross-Strait  problem\, and China’s threatening activities in the South China Sea have all  helped raise awareness of the Indo-Pacific region and the QUAD’s capacity to  deliver on both the economic and security fronts. \nFurther\,  Ms. Pandalai provided insights regarding key developments in the later part of  2022 vis-à-vis Indo-Pacific. National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year  2023\, which was passed into law\, is intended to strengthen the strategic depth  and material capability of Washington’s defence strategy\, according to Ms.  Pandalai. \nMs.  Pandalai observed that the Indo-Pacific region is closely watching Biden’s  signature achievements such as Inflation Reduction Act and the CHIPS Act.  According to Ms. Pandalai\, these decisions have created significant friction  with US allies in Europe and Asia. This was substantiated by citing articles  wherein the EU\, South Korea and the Director General of WTO have criticised  these legislations. Ms. Pandalai held that these legislations by the US are  seen by the countries in the region as “re-shoring” over “friend-shoring”. Ms. Pandalai  also discussed various overtures to Southeast Asia which have been offered by  the US recently. \nFurther\,  Ms. Pandalai highlighted the three transformational security documents that  were released by Japan recently. Ms. Pandalai pointed out three reasons for the  change in Japan’s attitude which include the recent behaviour and activities of  three revisionist powers China\, North Korea and Russia. The National Security Strategy\,  as pointed out by Ms. Pandalai\, has received mixed reactions from South Korea  and certain Southeast Asian countries. Regarding further bolstering of Japan-US  alliance through new agreements and meetings\, Ms. Pandalai held that the  summits sent out a clear message about bilateral security commitments being of  prime importance for both the US and Japan and that this alliance is regarded  by both countries as an instrument to project their combined influence to  promote stability in the region. \nFurther\,  Ms. Pandalai highlighted the increased cooperation between Australia and the US  in various domains ranging from security to climate cooperation through  ministerial consultations like AUSMIN.  Ms.  Pandalai opined that the notion of strategic equilibrium that has been proposed  by Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong was necessary as Southeast Asian and  Pacific countries have been sceptical in choosing any formal alliance or  coalition. Ms. Pandalai also highlighted Australia’s outreach efforts to South  Pacific countries like the Solomon Islands and Vanuatu along with the latest  overtures to ASEAN. \nMs.  Pandalai also highlighted recent changes in the relationship between India and  ASEAN as it evolved into a complete strategic alliance. Ms. Pandalai stated  that ASEAN and India have decided to strengthen their maritime links and work  together to combat cybercrime\, transnational crime\, and terrorism. Ms. Pandalai  emphasised South Korea’s ambitious Indo-Pacific strategy\, highlighting the  country’s commitment to enhancing supply chain ties with Southeast Asia and the  rise in arms exports to the region. \nWith  regard to the current scenario of the US-China relationship\, Ms. Pandalai  contended that Southeast Asia is concerned about the guardrails in the  relationship between these two giants which is at risk of irreversible damage. Ms.  Pandalai held that the Southeast Asian nations will move pragmatically when it  comes to sharing benefits with China and would be vigilant at the same time  when it comes to asserting their agencies. Ms. Pandalai also cited a report  regarding the dwindling of Southeast Asia’s public support to China as compared  to the US. \nWith  respect to ASEAN’s perspective on the Taiwan issue\, Ms. Pandalai stated that  ASEAN holds a “One China Policy”. Ms. Pandalai also highlighted the various  approaches of ASEAN countries to the Ukraine situation at the G20 Summit and  claimed that ASEAN has consistently refrained from criticising Russia while  also showing greater consideration for Russia. \nRegarding  the South China Sea issue\, Ms. Pandalai stated that breakthroughs are unlikely  in the negotiations on SCS ‘code of conduct’ this year because currently\,  Southeast Asia has its own economic priorities. Ms. Pandalai was of the opinion  that SCS will continue to face twin dynamics of confrontation and cooperation. \n   With regard to the question of Southeast Asia’s  cooperation on the Indo-Pacific issue\, Ms. Pandalai stated that ASEAN is open  to QUAD’s involvement in the region\, though in tandem with ASEAN centrality. In  concluding remarks of her presentation\, Ms. Pandalai held that India and ASEAN  can lean on each other as India rejects any bloc kind of security cooperation. \nFollowing  the presentation\, Cmde. Abhay invited the Director General\, Ambassador Chinoy  to offer his comments Amb. Chinoy observed that\, though late\, now the US looks  at Southeast Asia in terms of its economic and developmental needs whereas  earlier it looked at the region largely from the lens of security.  Amb. Chinoy also highlighted that now China  due to its enormous resources has got a strong presence in the region and that  Southeast Asia’s likeness to China is greater as compared to the USA. Also\, Amb.  Chinoy contended that Southeast Asia wants to manage the relationship with both  US and China and would not simply bandwagon. While concluding\, Amb. Chinoy  emphasised further development of relations not only with ASEAN collectively  but also at the individual level\, with the Southeast Asian countries. \nMaj.  Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.) also made observations about the major  happenings in the region and contended that these vigorous activities by  different stakeholders in the Indo-Pacific mark turbulent times for global  geopolitics. \nQ & A Session\nWhen  the floor was opened for Q&A sessions\, a scholar asked a question regarding  the relevance of ASEAN centrality and ASEAN’s views of US engagement on  economic issues. Responding to these questions\, Ms. Pandalai observed that  since assuaging of ASEAN’s concerns by QUAD countries\, repeated efforts have  been made to keep ASEAN at the centre of decision-making vis-à-vis the  Indo-Pacific. On the issue of ASEAN’s need for the US\, Ms. Pandalai held that  the US is vital for the economic development of Southeast Asia as recently most  of the ASEAN countries became a signatory of the US’ initiated Indo-Pacific Economic  Framework for Prosperity. \nOn  the question of whether the Ukraine conflict has diverted US attention away from  the Indo-Pacific\, Ms. Pandalai responded that this hasn’t been the case so far. \nThis report was prepared by Mr. Mohammed Shoaib  Raza\, Intern\, Southeast Asia and Oceania Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-key-developments-in-the-indo-pacific-perceptions-in-south-east-asia
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230111T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230111T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131349Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130547Z
UID:62957-1673415000-1673415000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Book Discussion: The Russia-Ukraine War - Lessons Learnt\, by Maj. Gen. (Dr.) G.D. Bakshi\, SM\, VSM (Retd)
DESCRIPTION:The Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence  Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, New Delhi organised a discussion on the book “The  Russia-Ukraine War: Lessons Learnt” authored by Major General G.D. Bakshi  (Retd.) on 11 January 2023. The book discussion was chaired by Ambassador  Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA. Commodore Abhay Singh  (Retd.) and Dr. Swasti Rao participated from the institute as discussants. The  discussion was attended by Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipan Bakshi\, Deputy Director  General\, MP-IDSA. MP-IDSA scholars were present. \nExecutive Summary\nAs the war in Ukraine lingers on unexpectedly  towards the one-year mark\, there are many lessons to be garnered from the  disruptions in the post-Soviet sphere. In this context\, Major General G.D.  Bakshi’s book raises a pressing question: What short-term and long-term lessons  can be learned from the conflict and what implications does the conflict have  for India? \nDetailed Report\nIn his opening remarks\, Ambassador Sujan R.  Chinoy stated that the conflict in Ukraine has lingered on unexpectedly and the  Russian special military operation has been met with great resistance and  pushback. The reverses on the war front have not pushed back Russia from  legislating new geography and a consequent redrawing of the map. The west has  backed Ukraine in the form of weapons and intelligence but a question arises as  to how long would this endure. There is also the creation of a false narrative  that India must take up a side between the two opposing forces. The conflict  has broader strategic implications for India. The Chair raised some important points.  Firstly\, that the treaty alliances are not a pre-requisite for allies to come  to one’s aid. Secondly\, a military conflict could easily erupt if any redlines  are crossed. Thirdly\, he questioned the potential for escalation between  nuclear states\, particularly in the Indian context with two adversarial nuclear  states on the border. Fourthly\, he brought up the similarity between the two  conflicts (Russia-Ukraine\, China-Taiwan) particularly in the irredentist  aspects. Fifthly\, he questioned whether we have entered an era of protracted  conflicts where no country can prevail over another. Lastly\, he asked with  India’s modernisation of its forces and its aim for self-reliance in the  defence sector\, what lessons can India draw for its own security needs. \nThe author\, at the outset\, stated that seventy  per cent of India’s military equipment is of Russian origin therefore\, the  outcome of the conflict is of major interest to India. He feels that Ukraine is  acting as a proxy of NATO against Russia. Due to the nuclear standoff\, most  felt that wars would be short and intense and based on this the ammunition  scaling has been limited. As a military analyst\, he feels that the war would be  extended for a longer period and there are serious implications for  international security. He stressed that the world has come full circle\, and  Russia has altered its strategy by returning to World War II strategies and  changing from brigades to divisions. The speaker predicts that there would be  some major changes in the war shortly. He stated that the United States pushed  Russia to a conflict by violating the redlines through NATO’s endless eastward  expansion. He stated that the world is facing a biological war\, and brought out  information about the presence of thirty-two biological labs being set up in  Ukraine.  \nAccording to the speaker\, the nature of warfare  has changed from low-intensity\, short-duration to high-intensity\, long-duration  warfare. He stated that ‘Clausewitz is back in fashion’. The  offence-over-defence dynamic has changed to a new equilibrium of defence-over  offence. He stated that the Russians’ weakest link was the conscripts\, which is  a prime lesson to be learned for India. Levels of battlefield transparency are  simply unprecedented which makes surprise impossible to achieve. The speaker  stressed that war is a test of national will and stamina\, and it is the most  for downsizing of the armed forces. Armies across the world are increasing  their sizes and this is not an era of just high-tech but also mass  mobilisations. Downsizing a force in the current international scenario could  be dangerous. \nConcluding his talk\, Maj. Gen. G.D. Bakshi  (Retd.) brought out some of the lessons to be learned from the conflict.  According to him\, the lack of armed forces is an issue and increased manpower  is a solution. Artillery is a winning factor and introducing it at the fastest  possible speed is a necessity. Underutilisation of Airpower should not happen.  Nuclear backdrops can happen between two nuclear states. Met factors could  cause serious problems if not followed. No blind spots should be present. \nFollowing the presentation\, the discussants were  invited for comments. Cmde. Abhay K. Singh (Retd.)\, Research Fellow\, Military  Affairs Centre\, remarked that Clausewitz was never out of fashion. Since the  conflict began\, various sweeping predictions were made on the future of the war  based on the lack of or sketchy information. Russia did plan for a short war\,  however\, after almost a year there is no certainty about where it would sway.  He stressed the need for considering necessary deductive inferences both  preliminary and tentative. He stated that contrary to the popular image of the  tenacious Ukrainians stopping Russian hordes\, a more complex picture has  emerged.  The propaganda value of the west’s  equipment has reduced as the war continued. He praised the author for his  efforts but stressed the need for a sharper editorial effort\, particularly in  the footnoting of important resources.   \nDr. Swasti Rao\, Associate Fellow\, Europe and  Eurasia Centre\, in her remarks focused on several points. She stated that the  need for a narrative on the experiences of the Eastern Europeans. Though  Ukraine is corrupt\, they have attempted reforms in every sector. There are  loopholes in Russia’s policies towards Eastern Europe. Sanctions have weakened  the Russian war machinery. China is having the last laugh and they have not  done anything to assist Russia. It is a time for Russia to diversify its fossil  fuels export. The war has led to NATO expansion to the Nordics. Germany’s rise  as a military power from diversification to missile systems after realising its  vulnerabilities is important to watch out for. European diversification efforts  are commendable\, which would mean less dependence on Russia and more on Europe.  India has been more involved in Eurasia and increases its presence. In her  conclusion\, she stated that a diminished Russia is not the best option for  India. \nThe Chair\, Ambassador Sujan. R. Chinoy\, in his  comments\, discussed the economic angle of bearing down and dismantling of the  economy during the Soviet Union era and the attempt to replicate it in the  current scenario. Amb. Chinoy stated that it is important to also examine the  attrition that the United States economy has suffered in the previous decades  and the long-term wars against insurgencies that the United States had to fight  and the impact. Every war brings about new technology\, with technology  evolution\, the demand for manpower may also reduce therefore\, the question is  does technology today help in determining what is mass (manpower) in the  current context?  \nDuring the Q and A session\, Col G.S. Gill\,  Research Fellow\, asked the author about the Agniveer scheme. Dr. Rajorshi Roy\,  Associate Fellow\, enquired about Russia’s ability to meet its defence  commitments to India given that its priority would be on the replenishment of  its reserves. Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\, Senior Fellow\, queried about the limited  use of sorties against Ukraine. Col. Rajneesh Singh\, Research Fellow\, asked  about the war objectives of the United States in the current conflict. \nResponding to comments and remarks\, Maj. Gen.  G.D. Bakshi (Retd.) stated that he had personal meetings concerning the Agniveer scheme with the upper echelons  of the government and requested to make changes to it. With reference to Dr.  Rajorshi Roy’s question\, whether Russia can meet India’s demand\, the author stressed that there would be a reduction and is all the more reason to become Aatmanirbhar. Regarding Dr Sinha’s  question\, he stated that the overreliance on S-400 has failed and that it has  not been able to live up to the hype. \nMaj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy  Director General\, delivered the Vote of Thanks and commented that Russia is a  reliable friend\, a P-5 member and the only reliable veto partner. With regard to the current situation in Ukraine he stressed that there is no negotiation space and the term ‘win’ is still not defined. \nReport was prepared  by Dr. Jason Wahlang\, Research Analyst\, Europe and Eurasia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/book-discussion-the-russia-ukraine-war-lessons-learnt-by-maj-gen-dr-g-d-bakshi-sm-vsm-retd
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230109T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230109T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131350Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62958-1673242200-1673242200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Emerging Opposition Politics in Bangladesh: Would It Be a Challenge to Sheikh Hasina?
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Smruti S.  Pattanaik\, Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar IDSA\, spoke on the topic  “Emerging Opposition Politics in Bangladesh: Would It Be a Challenge to  Sheikh Hasina?” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 09 January 2023. The  session was moderated by Dr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar  IDSA. Maj.Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, the Deputy Director General\,  MP-IDSA\, and MP-IDSA scholars enriched the discussion. \nExecutive Summary\nA massive protest was organized by the leading opposition  party Bangladesh Nationalist Party (BNP) against the government on 10 December  2022 in Dhaka. A large number of protesters gathered at Dhaka’s Golapbagh.  These protests organised by the opposition BNP are massive enough to demonstrate  that re-election of Sheikh Hasina’s Government in the January 2024 election  would not be easy. There are many factors which play a defining role in the  next election.  \nDetailed Report\nThe Monday Morning  Meeting commenced with Dr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, South Asia Center\,  MP-IDSA discussing the details of the nationwide massive protest organised by  the BNP against the government on 10 December 2022 in Dhaka. According to Dr.  Behuria\, the massive numbers of protesters are enough to upset the government. He  mentioned that the Sheikh Hasina government is in its third term.  \nDr. Pattanaik  initiated the discussion with a description of the opposition political parties  in Bangladesh. Where some of the parties\, especially the left groups are an  integral part of civil society movements\, some of the parties are part of the  two broad alliances led by the incumbent Awami League (AL) and the Bangladesh  Nationalist Party (BNP). For example\, BNP was associated with a 20-party  coalition. It is now reduced to a 12-party coalition. Similarly\, the AL has a  14-party coalition. Apart from these two major political parties\, other  parties\, except for Jatiyo Party and Jamaat-e-Islami Bangladesh\, do not have  significant electoral presence in the country. \nBNP and Its Alliance \nBNP was a part of a  20-party alliance in the last election held in December 2018. The BNP-led  alliance participated in the 2018 national election under the banner of the  Jatiya Oikya Front\, which also included former Foreign Minister\, Dr. Kamal  Hossain’s Gono Forum. During 2018\, the BNP-led coalition managed to get only 7  seats in total and 293 seats were won by the AL in an election that is  perceived as controversial and the government is accused of ballot stuffing and  this election is referred by some as ‘midnight’ election. In electoral  politics\, the AL is confident that it can win the next election even though the  opposition rallies made Sheikh Hasina address a rally in Chittagong in an  effort of ‘show of strength’.  \nMs. Pattanaik  talked about the dissolution of the coalition of Jamaat-e-Islami and BNP. Jamaat  Ameer argued that for the last five years\, there has been no joint program with  the BNP and the alliance has lost its political relevance in this context. Back  in 2018 prior to the election in Bangladesh\, there was a big question about  whether the Jamaat will be part of the BNP or not because some important  leaders inside the BNP spoke against the BNP’s alliance with Jamaat. However\,  electoral considerations made them to stick together and Jamaat which was  deregistered as a political party fought the election on BNP’s symbol. It is a  well-known fact that the Jamaat has a 12 percent vote bank in Bangladesh and  they managed to get 18 seats in 1991 and in 1996 they received 8.6% of votes  and won only 3 seats. The JI rose in politics only after it entered an  electoral alliance with the BNP prior to 2001 elections. After leaving the BNP  led opposition coalition\, Jamaat has applied for registration as the Bangladesh  Development Party. \nReligious Political Groups in  Bangladesh\nThere are two major  religious groups in Bangladesh\, one is Jamaat- e- Islami which has recently  applied for registration as the Bangladesh Development Party and another one is  Hefazat e Islam which defines itself as a political group. Jamaat is  ideologically a very strong party with a dedicated cadre. The party members are  associated with financial institutions\, banks\, have their chain of hospitals\, educational  institutions etc. which employ well-qualified cadres. Its stint in power between  the period 2001 to 2006 benefitted the party and it expanded its network. On  the other hand\, Hefazat-e- Islam mostly controls Qaumi madrassas and madrassa  students are its captive supporters. Many leaders belonging to this group are  also hold positions in other smaller religious political parties. In the last  election\, one more religious political party that stood third in terms of  support base is Islami Shasontantra Andolan. \nCivil Society in Bangladesh \nCivil society in  Bangladesh is also divided along ideological lines. Supporters are divided  along party lines and participate in the party programmes even though they are not  members of political parties. Civil society in Bangladesh is very vibrant and has  played a significant role in preserving the plural character of the state\,  culture\, language\, minority rights\, issues of livelihood\, gender etc. There are  civil society groups that work to preserve Islamic values in society and see to  it that no laws violate the tenets of Sharia. Bangladesh civil society is very  much opposed to military/authoritarian regimes and support democracy. People  across the civil society want to change but they are equally apprehensive about  the character of the next regime. \nStakeholders in Favour of the  Status Quo \nSince the last 15  years\, various stakeholders have aligned themselves with the Sheikh Hasina regime  and have benefitted from it. Both the government and its stakeholders depend on  each other for their sustainability. The long rule of AL has also resulted in  massive politicisation of bureaucracy as well as state institutions. Such  politicisation is not new in Bangladesh’s political history. Profiteering from  the regime has become a hallmark whether it pertains to arrest or selection of  candidates for local body and national elections. The character of the  Bangladesh Parliament been changed over a period of time. More than 60 percent  of current members of Parliament in Bangladesh are businessmen. \nIssues that Will Determine  the Ballot in Bangladesh \nOn the government  side\, it is said that economic development and stability in Bangladesh are the  key achievements of the government which will be determining factors for the upcoming  elections. In 2021\, Bangladesh saw 7.2 percent economic growth and in 2022 it  was 6.2 percent. This is despite the pandemic which affected Bangladesh’s  readymade garment exports as well as remittances. In the past decade\,  Bangladesh has witnessed infrastructure development\, and achieved energy sufficiency\,  till the Russia-Ukraine war hit the global energy market. The government has  taken a decision to address the shortage of foreign currency by curbing imports  of non-essential goods and has also taxed industries which are using imported  gas. \nThere are three  important factors. First\, to hold a multiparty election. BNP may not  participate in such an election but there will be other political parties who  will participate in the election conducted by the Election Commission of  Bangladesh. Second\, managing the perception of the west regarding credibility  of the election is another important factor. Apart from these\, managing the  domestic stakeholders would also be significant. In this context\, neutrality of  the armed forces would be important. India would watch this election as  domestic permutation and combination takes place with re-alignment of political  forces\, prior to the election. \nThe Deputy Director  General\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi said that India is an important factor  for Bangladesh but Bangladesh is also a defining factor for security of  northeast. \nThere were  questions regarding what would be main electoral issues and whether issues  raised by political parties are any different than those raised in past  election. \nMs. Pattanaik gave  insightful responses to comments and questions from the participants. \nThe report was prepared by Mr. Shubham Thorat\, Intern\,  South Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-emerging-opposition-politics-in-bangladesh-would-it-be-a-challenge-to-sheikh-hasina
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230102T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20230102T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131350Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125557Z
UID:62959-1672637400-1672637400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of Monday Morning Meeting on “US-Saudi Tensions: Possible Implications for the Petrodollar”
DESCRIPTION:Dr.  Adil Rasheed\, Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute  for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “US-Saudi Tensions:  Possible Implications for the Petrodollar” at the Monday Morning Meeting  held on 02 January 2023. The session was moderated by Dr. Muddassir Quamar\, Associate  Fellow\, MP-IDSA. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\,  MP-IDSA\, and scholars of the Institute were in attendance.                                                               \nExecutive Summary \nAs the world experiences tumultuous geopolitical  challenges on the Eurasian front\, stagflation in the US\, and continental energy  crisis in Europe\, the deteriorating Saudi Arabia-US ties can profoundly impact  the global financial system. This has become an increasing possibility as the  oil for security theme dictating the US-Saudi relationship has come under great  strain due to the OPEC+ countries’ decision to reduce the oil output in the  backdrop of the Ukrainian crisis. This has occurred despite several overtures  on the western leaders’ part. It is all the while as the Saudi leadership has  sought to diversify its security and economic partners\, growing close to BRICS\,  Russia\, and China\, and further away from its traditional western allies. In  light of these developments\, India must act decisively to mould a new and more  just international monetary system based on a basket of currencies and commodities. The Special Drawing Rights  (SDR) is an interest-bearing international reserve asset created by  the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in  1969as  an alternative to US Dollar and China-backed Petroyuan. \nDetailed Report \nDr.  Quamar introduced the topic of the Monday Morning Meeting by highlighting the  evolution of the US-Saudi relationship\, premised on the theme of security for  oil. As per this key feature\, US Dollar would be the medium of oil trade\,  ensuring global American hegemony. However\, it has recently faced several challenges  ranging from ones that are personality-based to that including international  turmoil in the oil market.  \nFollowing  the brief introduction\, the Dr. Quamar gave the floor to Dr. Rasheed.  \nInitially\,  the speaker briefly delved into the recent debates about how the international  order is in flux and asserted how there is great uncertainty about whether the  year 2022 has ushered in the post-pandemic world. Political experts have  debated the possibility of a worldwide transition into a post-liberal\, if not a  post-American global order. The Ukrainian crisis and the negative impact on  international trade due to protectionist policies and economic sanctions are  considered by observers to have played a critical role in ushering in this new  system. Finally\, Russia and China’s concerted efforts to draw the Kingdom of  Saudi Arabia (KSA) away from the western fold and de-dollarise the  international economy can potentially transform the global financial  order.   \nSubsequently\,  he shifted the focus to the widening rifts in the US-KSA oil for security ties  and the latter’s willingness to enhance cooperation with Russia and China  instead. Amid such developments\, western leaders ranging from former British Prime  Minister Boris Johnson\, American President Joe Biden\, French President Emmanuel  Macron\, and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz have visited oil-rich Arab countries\, including the Saudi Kingdom\,  to ensure they remain in the western fold and do not gravitate towards the  Russia-China nexus. The primary motive behind their visits was to convince the  oil-producing states to help in mitigating the European energy crisis and  stagflation in the US.  \nHowever\,  despite several of these overtures\, KSA has refused to pay heed. Instead of  cooperating with the western world by increasing oil production\, it\, along with  22 other Organization of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC)+ member  states\, reduced oil production by 2 million barrels per day. The White House  and the American allies perceived this decision as supportive of Russian  actions in Ukraine\, despite the OPEC+ countries’ claims of being guided solely  by their economic forecasts.  \nThere  has been a visible Saudi tilt towards Russia with doubling oil imports to meet  its domestic needs and a US$500 million investment in Russia’s three primary  energy companies. While these decisions aided the sanctions-hit Russian  economy\, they also created an uproar in the US Senate’s Foreign Relations  Committee. Threats to withdraw 3\,000 troops stationed in the Persian Gulf and  halt arms sales to Saudi Arabia were a part of the broader American counter-response.  \nOver  the past two years\, despite President Biden’s harsh rhetoric during his  campaign\, the White House has demonstrated a profound willingness to maintain  KSA as a critical regional partner\, by granting Crown Prince Muhammad bin  Salman (MBS) immunity from lawsuits related to Jamal Khashoggi’s murder and preventing  NOPEC and Yemen War Powers Bill from becoming laws\, among others. Nevertheless\,  the Crown Prince has been dismissive of these initiatives.  \nMoreover\,  MBS hosted Chinese President Xi Jinping in December 2022\, where the two leaders  signed a Comprehensive Strategic Partnership Agreement and agreed to enhance  oil trade. In addition\, President Xi discussed with other Arab heads of the  state the potential of trading oil and gas\, if only partly\, in Renminbi.  Notably\, Petroyuan was launched on the Shanghai International Exchange in 2018.  \nOverall\,  there are several reasons for this increasing discord between Saudi Arabia and  US. Some of them include ideological differences\, i.e.\, the clash between a  pre-modern Wahhabi and a secular republic state\, dredging up human  rights-related issues with the Gulf States and Israel or courting of Iran by  Democratic Presidents\, and the gradual American pivot to Indo-Pacific from West  Asia.  \nHere  it is vital to understand the potential consequences of US-Saudi friction on  the global financial system. Since the 1974 agreement between the Saudi Kingdom  and US and the subsequent 1975 agreement between OPEC countries and the US  about only conducting oil trade in US Dollars\, the US has been able to exercise  its economic hegemony or ‘exorbitant privilege.’ This was supposed to be a  temporary measure to salvage the floundering American economy. However\, this  ‘privilege’ expanded to the trade of gold\, agricultural products\, and copper\,  among other goods. Today\, every country participating in the oil trade must  keep US Dollars as reserves to purchase oil. Consequently\, global trade will be  impacted gravely should the petrodollar system unravel. Before this\, the  dollar’s value was linked to gold until it suffered a blow due to countries  such as France picking up its reserve of gold from America.  \nInterestingly\,  KSA’s primary oil purchasers\, i.e.\, India and China\, are part of the BRICS\, an  organisation the kingdom has expressed interest in joining as a member. Within  this context\, it is crucial to look back on the Russian Foreign Ministry’s 2022  proposal to establish a BRICS reserve currency backed by commodities such as  gold. The Saudi Kingdom’s bid to become a BRICS member\, mainly due to its  petroleum reserves\, might bolster this idea. This possible reserve currency is being seen (at least by  Russia) as an alternative to the US greenback and the IMF’s Special  Drawing Rights currency.  \nTherefore\,  it is necessary to explore how these developments might impact the Indian  economy. Over the years\, the US Dollar has proven unreliable\, and its costly  exchange rate against other currencies results in other countries incurring  high costs. These monetary fluctuations subject the Indian Rupee to volatility\,  and as recently indicated by our Finance Minister\, it is not the Rupee that is  falling. However\, the dollar is rising because of the Federal Reserve’s policies and not the  strengthening of the US economy. Nevertheless\, India cannot back the  China-backed Petroyuan because it would entail transitioning from one  currency’s exorbitant privilege to that of another. Thus\, India needs to take the lead in building an  international consensus towards developing a safer and just monetary  order for the future.   \nQ/A Session \nDr.  Quamar expressed his gratitude to the speaker for his detailed presentation and  invited questions from the attendees.  \nThe  Q/A session broadly revolved around themes such as the debate about the world  transitioning into a post-pandemic world\, the feasibility about establishing  the BRICS currency reserve\, the long-existing partnership between KSA and  China\, the Saudi Kingdom’s role as a partner in the American regional  counter-terrorism efforts and pivot to the Indo-Pacific. Furthermore\, debates  about the nature of liberalism\, Russian and Chinese efforts to de-dollarise the  global economy and the viability of the bilateral ties between Saudi Arabia and  the US and Iran as a counterweight to Russian and Chinese influence were some  of the other issues discussed. The speaker gave insightful responses to  comments and questions from the participants.   \nThis  report was prepared by Ms. Saman Ayesha Kidwai\, Research Analyst\,  Counter-Terrorism Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-monday-morning-meeting-on-us-saudi-tensions-possible-implications-for-the-petrodollar
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221226T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221226T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131350Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62960-1672032600-1672032600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on "China’s Zero-COVID Policy: Reactions at Home and Abroad”
DESCRIPTION:Ms. Mayuri Banerjee\,  Research Analyst\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses  (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “China’s  Zero-COVID Policy: Reactions at Home and Abroad” at the Monday Morning  Meeting held on 26 December 2022. The session was moderated by Dr. Titli  Basu\, Associate Fellow.  Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, and scholars of the  Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nThe  rising COVID cases in China have set off alarm bells all around the world. China’s  National Health Commission has ceased releasing information on the daily COVID  cases. The present surge in cases comes at a time when the nation is doing away with its Zero COVID policy and gradually opening up its economy and society.  \nA  look at China’s approach to the pandemic highlights its emphasis on stamping out the virus. China’s Zero COVID policy is essentially an elimination strategy that  aims to keep infection numbers as low as possible at all costs. Despite mounting criticism of policy excesses\, China’s Communist Party (CCP) reaffirmed  its commitment to the Zero COVID policy.  \nSince its inception three years ago\, the policy has achieved very little in comparison to the cost it has inflicted on the Chinese economy and society. The  population that once supported the policy is now increasingly opposed to it. It  remains to be seen how China will deal with the ramifications of the Zero COVID  policy.  \nDetailed Report\nDr. Basu commenced the Monday Morning Meeting  by highlighting the explosion in COVID cases in China. She emphasised that  China’s rapid surge in COVID cases has impacted the world’s health security and  geo-economics. Furthermore\, the surge in cases comes at a time when Beijing is  parting ways with its Zero-COVID policy.  \nLike other nations\, India is also reflecting  on this growing concern. Dr. Basu stated that India would be concentrating on  using a test-track-treat strategy in the future.  \n  Ms. Banerjee was given the floor by the moderator  after the brief introduction. \nThe speaker stated that the Zero-COVID policy  has been a topic of considerable debate from the time it was instituted\, in  2020. She began by exploring the timeline of the COVID-19 situation and  highlighted the long gap between reporting of the first cluster of cases in  early December 2019 and government response. According to Ms. Banerjee\, administrative  laxity allowed 5 million individuals to leave Wuhan and facilitated the rapid  spread of the virus to other regions of China as well as to neighbouring countries. \nThe speaker pointed out that China came under  heavy criticism for its slow response. It was as late as 23 January 2020 that Beijing  initiated strong measures to stop the virus’s spread. Ms. Banerjee stated that\,  in December 2020\, China began its vaccination program. Here\, she noted that\,  while China put much emphasis on stamping out the virus\, it did not enforce  vaccination as mandatory. In 2021\, China continued to report major outbreaks. \nFurther\, the speaker discussed China’s Zero  COVID policy. She observed that the policy became a cornerstone of China’s  response to COVID 19.  It came to signify  zero tolerance against COVID 19 infection and aimed to achieve zero  community-level transmission. Ms. Banerjee then cited a joint report by the World  Health Organisation and China that provided a theoretical framework for the Zero-COVID  strategy. \nMs. Banerjee observed that the Zero-COVID policy  was essentially an elimination strategy aimed at keeping infection numbers as  low as possible. However\, reports and instances emerged indicating government policy  excesses\, intrusive control measures\, mismanagement\, and lack of flexibility. The  severe lockdowns also posed enormous difficulties for Chinese citizens.  \nIn order to double down on the Zero-COVID approach\,  Provinces were divided into grids with grid controllers mandated to enforce the  protocol measures dictated by local authorities. She mentioned that the  government launched an app to monitor people’s movements to determine whether  they posed risk of contagion\, causing massive bewilderment and confusion.  \nFurther\, the speaker highlighted the number  of lockdowns imposed in China as compared to other countries. In this regard\,  she noted that in contrast to other countries\, China consistently increased the  number of lockdowns over the years.  \nMs. Banerjee stated that when the Omicron  Variant was discovered in November 2021\, China fine-tuned its COVID policy to  ‘Dynamic Zero-COVID policy’. She claimed that the modification was based on the  realisation that given the new variant’s high transmissibility\, zero domestic  outbreaks were not possible. According to the speaker\, in contrast to the  previous policy\, a greater emphasis was placed on prevention and containment.  However\, the difference on the ground was negligible.  \nMs. Banerjee also discussed why the  implementation of the COVID policy became so unresponsive to people’s needs.  First\, there was a fear of punishment among government officials\, and second\,  there was competition among local officials and Provinces in the hope of  political advancement.  \nAs the presentation drew to a close\, she  discussed the cost of Zero-COVID policy for both China and the international  community and moved on to highlight the reasons for continuation of the policy.  Ms. Banerjee stated that the policy had a significant human cost\, with an  increase in cases of depression and mental health issues. The Zero-COVID policy  also resulted in widespread disruption of supply chains on a global scale.   \nThe speaker cited several reasons why the  strict Zero-COVID policy was maintained despite significant losses: to  demonstrate the superiority of the Chinese political system over liberal  democracies\, to preserve the Government’s and Xi Jinping’s image\, particularly  ahead of the 20th Party Congress\, and low efficacy of home-grown vaccines; and low  vaccination rate among the elderly\, etc.  \nDuring the initial outbreak\, the Zero-COVID policy  was widely supported by the domestic population. The phrase “not being a  burden to the government” became prominent. However\, people’s attitudes  shifted over the course of two years. There was increasing concern that the Zero-COVID  policy could be self-defeating. Global reaction exhibited a similar trend. Foreign  investors were growing concerned about the policy’s impact on trade. Despite all  this\, in the 20th Party Congress\, Xi reaffirmed China’s commitment  to the Zero-COVID policy. The government did not roll-back most of the COVID  restrictions until December 7\, 2022.  \nMs. Banerjee concluded her presentation by  stating that the three years of Zero-COVID policy achieved very little as  compared to the cost it extracted from the Chinese economy and society. It  remains to be seen how China will manage to mitigate the implications left  behind by the Zero-COVID policy.  \nFollowing the presentation\, the Dr. Basu  invited the Director General\, Ambassador Chinoy to offer his comments.  \nAmb. Chinoy observed  that\, at this point\, China’s COVID policies  appear to be jeopardising the world much more due to their unpredictability and  the lack of transparency in decision-making. The Zero-COVID policy appears to  be an extremely short-sighted\, myopic decision. He emphasised that this is  heavily influenced by the existing political system in China\, where the CCP’s  sole objective is to retain power.  \nHe shared that the Chinese always carry out  their actions as mass movements and it  is these mass movements that have altered the  course of Chinese history. The element of control is indispensable to these  mass movements. A pandemic\, however\, is not something the CCP can control. As a  result\, China has shifted to the dynamic Zero-COVID policy\, demonstrating some  flexibility in their approach to COVID-19.  \nMs. Banerjee concurred with Amb. Chinoy’s  comments and stated that the chaotic situation demonstrates that no exit  strategy was planned by the CCP regarding its Zero-COVID policy.  \nKey Takeaways from the Q&A Session\nFollowing Ambassador Chinoy’s remarks\,  MP-IDSA scholars were invited to join the discussion. \nIn response to a question about the rising  number of cases in China and the possibility of a change in Chinese policy  regarding the rejection of Western vaccines\, Ms. Banerjee stated that the CCP  has been steadfast in its opposition to Western vaccines. A question was raised  about the disconnect between central and local government responses to the  COVID19 pandemic. Ms. Banerjee stated that the Zero-COVID policy was primarily  issued by the central government as a broad policy guideline\, leaving its implementation to  the various local governments. \nMs. Banerjee responded to a question about  the reasons for the shift to the dynamic Zero-COVID policy by stating two  possible reasons: growing frustration among Chinese citizens and higher  transmissibility of the Omicron variant. In response to a question about the  efficacy of Chinese vaccines and the implications for countries that have  imported them\, Ms. Banerjee stated that the efficacy of the vaccines must be  considered in the context of herd immunity and vaccination of the elderly  population. \nReport  prepared by Ms. Esha Banerji\, Intern\, East Asia Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-chinas-zero-covid-policy-reactions-at-home-and-abroad
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221219T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221219T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131350Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62961-1671427800-1671427800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Recent Developments in China’s Relationship with North Korea
DESCRIPTION:On 19 December 2022 Dr. M.S. Prathibha\,  Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, made a presentation on “Recent Developments in  China’s Relationship with North Korea” at the Monday Morning Meeting. Cmde.  Abhay Kumar Singh (Retd.) chaired the session. Maj.Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi  (Retd.)\, the Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA and MP-IDSA scholars enriched the  discussion.  \nExecutive Summary\nThe  geopolitical situation in the Korean Peninsula is growing tense. One of the  major reasons of this tension is North Korea’s missile tests. Several countries  including South Korea and the US have called on China to exert its influence on  Pyongyang to stop the tests. However\,  the complex relations between  North Korea and China\, Pyongyang’s propensity to follow an independent foreign  policy and recent developments in the international situation have cast a big  doubt on China’s capability and willingness to influence North Korea’s actions. \nDetailed Report\nCmde.  Singh introduced the topic with a brief overview of the developments with  regard to North Korea’s missile tests\, speculations about North Korea’s plans  to conduct its seventh nuclear test and the complex China-North Korea  relations. Thereafter\, he invited Dr. Prathibha to make a presentation on the  subject. \nDr.  Prathibha in her presentation highlighted three aspects. First\, North Korea’s  interests in conducting missile tests\, second\, the complex relationship between  China and North Korea and third\, the extent of Chinese leverage vis-à-vis North  Korea. Elaborating on the probable reasons why North Korea conducted so many  missile tests last year\, she reasoned that the tests are a way to improve the  quality of its nuclear deterrence and signal the international community to  negotiate with Pyongyang. The five-year plan unveiled in January 2021 talks  about a plethora of weapon systems such as Multiple Independently targetable  Reentry Vehicles (MIRVs)\, hypersonic cruise missiles\, nuclear submarines\,  solid-fuel ground missiles which either have been developed or are being  developed. Further\, North Korea could also be projecting these nuclear tests as  a counter to the military exercises conducted by the US\, South Korea and Japan.  Besides the military objectives\, these tests were also seen as way to maximise  North Korea’s position when the US is occupied with the Ukraine crisis.  \nTalking  about China’s interests in North Korea\, Dr. Prathibha shared that the stability  of North Korea’s regime is an issue of interest to China and that Beijing wants  to maintain North Korea as a buffer state. In Chinese perception\, the Korean Peninsula  is a frontier area where land and sea power connect and therefore\, plays an  important role in geopolitical terms. Also\, Japan’s rise is closely associated  with the Korean Peninsula as it used the region as a springboard to expand its  power. The region is an important maritime space for countries who might use it  to have a strategic confrontation with China. Thus\, in a crisis situation\,  Beijing will intervene militarily to safeguard China’s security interests. Another  reason for Chinese interest in North Korea is that the Korean Peninsula can  become an area where great powers balance each other. According to Dr.  Prathibha\, China’s policies towards North Korea are geared towards protecting  China’s security interests. Regime stability in Chinese calculation means  helping the regime survive economically\, politically and militarily. Highlighting  the complexity of the bilateral ties\, she observed that regardless of whether  North Korea is strategically coordinating with China\, the latter considers  North Korea an ally because of the overall strategic and historical interests. Also\,  Beijing is confident that no matter who rules Korea or how many times policies  change\, the Korean Peninsula will have to choose cooperation with China. In  this context Dr. Prathibha highlighted two important developments in the recent  past as instances of the complex relationship between China and North Korea.  She informed the audience that before 2012\, China had attempted to persuade  North Korea to follow Chinese footsteps of pursuing economic liberalisation  without political liberalisation. However\, that did not work out very well and  created a deep freeze in China-North Korea relations which extended till 2017. The  second development happened when in 2018 China decided not to push North Korea  in that direction and took steps to gradually relax the tense atmosphere.  \nWith  regard to the question of Chinese leverage over North Korea\, Dr. Prathibha  contended that there are two broad strands of thought within the scholarly  community. The first believes that as the survival of the North Korean regime  depends on Chinese assistance\, China has leverage over North Korea. However\,  there is a large section who believe that the relationship is complex and  China’s leverage is limited. Diverging from these arguments\, she observed that  instead of judging solely in terms of leverage\, one should also look at how the  shifts happening in the international system are driving the two countries  close to each other. For instance\, North Korea could be trying to gain  geostrategic and economic advantage out of the ongoing major power competition  by cooperating with Russia and China. Further\, mutual strategic interests like  pushing the US out of the Korean Peninsula could be a major driving factor in  China-North Korea relations. However\, it is noteworthy that North Korea follows  an independent non-aligned foreign policy and there is always resentment  against China’s help. Further\, lack of strategic coordination is apparent as  North Korea does not take into account Chinese concerns when conducting missile  tests. Reverting to the issue of Chinese capability to influence North Korea\,  Dr. Prathibha emphasised that Beijing’s attempts will depend on how China views  US policy towards North Korea.  \nShe  concluded her presentation by stating that the future trajectory of North  Korea’s foreign policy is unpredictable and how China\, Russia and North Korea  cooperation will pan out remains to be seen.  \nQ& A Session\nFollowing  her presentation Cmde. Singh urged Dr. Prathibha to share her thoughts on  China’s refusal to militarily intervene in North Korea’s support if Pyongyang  initiates a conflict. DDG\, Maj. Gen. Bakshi (Retd.) queried about China’s  frontier concept and how it directs China’s larger game plan. \n  When  the floor was opened for further questions\, several issues were raised  including whether North Korea will ever abandon its independent foreign policy  and the political viability of North Korea’s strategy vis-à-vis the US.  \nResponding  to these questions\, Dr. Prathibha observed that although China intends to  reduce US influence in the Korean Peninsula it does not want Pyongyang to  initiate a conflict and then drag China into it. Accordingly\, China has been  more willing to condemn North Korea’s nuclear tests (which it sees as a larger  threat) than ballistic missile ones. With regard to DDG’s query\, she stated  that China and Korea share historical relations and if there is any overt  balancing in the Korean Peninsula\, Beijing will make sure that it does not  become a threat. On the question of North Korea’s independent foreign policy\,  she informed that China too is weary about pushing North Korea as it is very  hard to control Pyongyang. Also\, the North Korean regime is more likely to take  drastic steps to maintain its independent foreign policy compared to other  countries. Lastly\, reflecting on the political viability of North Korea’s  strategy\, Dr. Prathibha observed that the missile tests are the only leverage  they have to draw the US attention to their policies.  \nReport prepared by Ms. Mayuri  Banerjee\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-recent-developments-in-chinas-relationship-with-north-korea
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221212T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221212T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131408Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62962-1670823000-1670823000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on "Nepal Elections: Implications for Domestic and Foreign Policy”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Nihar R. Nayak\,  Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses  (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on the topic “Nepal Elections: Implications for Domestic  and Foreign Policy” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 12 December 2022. The  session was moderated by Dr. Anand Kumar\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA. \nMaj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin  Bakshi\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA\, senior scholars and research  analysts\, and members of MP-IDSA participated in the meeting. \nExecutive Summary \nNepal has been witnessing  prolonged political instability. Modern Nepal had 44 Prime Ministers in 72  years of its political history since 1950. On an average a Nepali Prime  Minister served for 18 months. In 2015\, Nepal adopted a new constitution with  the hope that it would bring political stability. Unfortunately\, the country  witnessed two governments and again two attempts by former Prime Minister K.P.  Sharma Oli to dissolve the House of Representatives (HoR) from 2017 to  2022.  Nepal had five Prime Ministers  during the post-constitutional period. Given the fragile political history\,  voters hoped that the November 2022 elections would bring stability by having a  majority government (138 as the major mark) of the 275-member HoR. The  fractured mandate has once again dashed hopes of political stability in Nepal  in the near future. \nDetailed Report\nDr. Anand Kumar\, Associate  Fellow\, discussed Nepal\, a country that went through a decade long Maoist  insurgency and adopted a new constitution in 2015. According to the New Constitution\,  Nepal adopted a Federal Parliamentary system. 60 percent of the members are  directly elected and 40 percent are elected through proportional  representation. The total number of members in the HoR is 275 where 138 Seats  are required to win the election. Recently\, Nepal went through the general  election which was held on 28 November 2022. The Nepali Congress (NC) emerged  as the largest party in the house and could possibly form the government with  its alliance parties\, but despite their support\, the group is short by 2 seats  from the majority mark of 138. K.P Sharma Oli emerged as the biggest opposition  leader in the recent election. The main issues of this election were the  revival of the domestic economy\, political stability\, and the problem of governance.  \nDr. Nihar R. Nayak  commenced his presentation by saying that Nepal has been witness to prolonged  instability. The country is suffering from chronic political instability since  1950. In the 72 years of Nepal’s political history\, Nepal witnessed 44 Prime  Ministers. Nepal’s Ministership term is 5 years but the actual term is reduced  to an average of 18 months due to chronic instability. Dr. Nayak spoke about  the recently concluded election in Nepal which is called the “Election of  Hope” because the voters of Nepal hoped for political stability after a  long period of political instability. Nepal introduced the new constitution in  2015 for political stability in the country but it failed to achieve its  objectives. Rather\, it has witnessed five Prime Ministers after the adoption of  the New Constitution in 2015. The key mandates of the Constitution include  political stability\, the establishment of an inclusive society\, and the use of  national resources for rapid economic growth.  \nHe elaborated on the recently  concluded Nepal elections and the position of different political parties and  also the status of new national parties. As per the constitution\, the status of  the national party remains for five years.   The status gets updated after every Parliamentary and Provincial  Assembly election.  As directed in the  Constitution\, to hold a national party status\, a political party has to secure  one HoR seat under the first past the post (FPTP) and 3 percent of the total  votes cast under the Proportional Representation (PR) system. As per the  2022 election results\, there have been seven  national political parties that includes two new parties-the  Rashtriya Swatantra Party (RSP)  and the Janamat Party. \nBesides the fractured  mandate\, the 2022 election also witnessed some new trends which include the  absence of ideology and a CMP ( Common Minimum Program) while forming  alliances. Public disenchantment with the old political parties was visible  with the defeat of over 40 senior leaders.   Apart from this\, some other new developments took place like the  emergence and re-emergence of political parties\, the decline in Maoists’ total  vote share\, the poor performance of the Madhesi-based political parties\,  compulsory declaration of election expenditure by the candidates as per the  Supreme Court directive\, and common issues related to foreign policy were  identified in the electoral manifestoes of the top three political  parties.     \nDr. Nayak talked about the  possible foreign policy of the three main political parties- the NC\, Communist  Party of Nepal (UML)\,  and the CPN  (Maoist-centre). These parties proposed to have a good relationship with  immediate neighbors\, not have any military alliance with any country\, and  resolve border disputes with India. While   the NC has given priority to pursuing an independent foreign policy\,  expansion of ties with neighboring countries\, and resolving border issues with  neighboring countries through the diplomatic channel\, the CPN-UML wanted to  have more engagements with China by emphasising the  ‘One-China’ policy. The CPN (Maoist-centre)  has proposed to declare Nepal as a zone of peace.   \nDr. Nayak talked about the  possible scenarios in the context of the November 2022 results. In Scenario 1\,  there would be a NC-led government with the support of its alliance. The  alliance is short by two seats in order to form a government.  The alliance has to resolve both intra-party  and intra-alliance problems like tenureship of the Prime Minister’s position\,  the President\, and other constitutional positions. For example\, there are five  leaders within the NC who want to become the Prime Minister. Also\, the Maoist  Party wants the Prime Ministerial post for a period of 2.5 years. In Scenario  2\, there could be a left-alliance government in Nepal.  If the NC-led alliance fails to form the  government then the Maoists could switch to the UML side and a CPN-UML-led  government could be formed in Kathmandu. In Scenario 3\, the President would  explore possibilities to have an elected government for five years under  Article 76 of the Constitution. If no party or individual members are able to  form the government\, the house could be declared dissolved by the President on  the recommendation of the Prime Minister under clause 7 of article 76. \n Dr. Nayak concluded by observing that  Scenarios 1 and 2 would most likely unfold. However\, some wild cards (low  possibilities\, high impacts) like the accidental absence of some top political  leaders and the current President Bidya Devi Bhandari’s return to active  politics after her retirement in March 2023\, might change the political  situation in Nepal.  He concluded by  saying that given the current position of the political parties in the HoR and  the trust deficit between the alliance partners\, Nepal might continue to  witness political instability in the future. \nComments and Questions\nMaj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi\, Deputy Director  General\, made a suggestion to look at the concerns of India to resolve the  border issue between the two countries. He further stated that given the  special relationship between Nepal and India\, there should not be so much media  coverage during discussion on resolution of issues.  \nDr. Uttam Kumar Sinha  questioned about youth representation in the Nepal election \n Dr. Adil Rasheed made a  query about the problem of the revival of Jihadi terrorism in the Nepal Terai  region. \nThe speaker\, Dr. Nihar R.  Nayak gave detailed and analytical replies in response to comments and  questions from the panelists and participants.  \nReport prepared by Mr. Shubham Thorat\, Intern\, South Asia Center\,  MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-nepal-elections-implications-for-domestic-and-foreign-policy
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221205T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221205T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131408Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62963-1670218200-1670218200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on "India-France Defence Cooperation: Looking Ahead”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. S. Samuel C. Rajiv\, Associate  Fellow\, MP-IDSA spoke  on the topic “India-France Defence  Cooperation: Looking Ahead” at the Monday Morning Meeting held  on 5 December 2022. The session  was moderated by Col. Vivek Chadha  (Retd.)\, Senior Fellow\, MP-IDSA and attended by Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General\,  MP-IDSA and all the scholars of MP-IDSA. \nExecutive  Summary\nSince Independence\, India’s defence cooperation with France  has remained consistent. French aircraft like the Toofani\, Mystère\, Mirage\, Rafale and Alouette  helicopters have been some of the potent assets of the IAF. Over the years\,  India-France Defence Cooperation has evolved from buyer-seller relations to the  level of co-developers. Arms imports from France by India in recent times have  increased by over 90 per cent\, making it the largest European supplier of  defence equipment. India is France’s second-largest defence market\, after Saudi  Arabia. As part of its offset obligations relating to the Rafale deal\, Dassault  along with Reliance is manufacturing components of civilian jets with FDI of  100 million Euros. Out of the 56 offset contracts\, nine are being executed by  French defence companies and their subsidiaries. The naval variant of the  Rafale aircraft is a leading contender along with the US-manufactured F-18 for  India’s Multi-Role Carrier-Borne Fighter (MRCBF) procurement tender for the  Indian Navy’s aircraft carriers. Apart from fighter aircrafts\, India is also  procuring fifty-six C-295 manufactured by Airbus for the IAF.  These developments indicate that India is now  turning towards Europe for the import of military aircrafts. 2023 marks 25  years of the India-France Srategic Partnership. \nDetailed  Report\nCol. Vivek Chadha commenced the  session by stating that defence relations of India with France have remained  consistent since Independence. He said in more recent times\, France has been a  leading supplier of cutting-edge weapons and technology to India. He  highlighted that French-manufactured fighter jets have played a decisive role  in major operations during the 1965 War\, Kargil War and the Balakot airstrikes.  Col. Chadha highlighted that qualitatively a defence relationship evolves when  it goes beyond just a buyer-seller relationship and reaches a level of  co-development. With these opening remarks\, Col. Chadha invited Dr. S. Samuel  C. Rajiv to make his presentation.  \nDr. Rajiv began his presentation by  detailing the recently concluded India-France Annual Defence Dialogue in New  Delhi. He stated that arms imports from France by India have increased by over  90 per cent in recent times\, making it the largest supplier of defence  equipment to India among all the European nations. Dr. Rajiv brought out that  India is the second largest export market for French arms\, after Saudi Arabia.  He stated that in 1953\, the Indian Air Force (IAF) became the first export  customer for the French fighter aircraft\, Mystere\, which was renamed as  Toofani. Subsequently\, Mirages and Rafales were also procured.  He highlighted that the French defence company ‘Safran’ has been present for  over 65 years in India and 75 per cent of the aircraft and helicopters of the  IAF have Safran INS systems\, co-developed with Bharat Electronics Ltd. and the  Defence Research and Development Organisation.  \nHe then went on to explain the offset  policy relating to India’s procurement of the Rafale fighter jets. Dr. Rajiv  brought out that as part of its offset obligations\, Dassault along with  Reliance is slated to manufacture components of civilian jets costing 100  million Euros. He stated that out of the 56 offset contracts in India\, nine are  being executed by French defence companies. He highlighted that the naval  variant of the Rafale aircraft is a leading contender along with the US  manufactured F-18\, for India’s Multi-Role Carrier-Borne Fighter (MRCBF)  procurement tender for the Indian Navy’s aircraft carriers. He stated that both  the US and French have been aggressively pitching for their respective  aircrafts. \n  Dr. Rajiv stated that apart from fighter  aircrafts\, India is also procuring 56 C-295 manufactured by Airbus for the IAF.  He stated that these developments indicated that India is now turning towards  Europe for the import of military aircraft. He opined that if India opts for  the Rafale-Marine for its MRCBF along with the C-295\, then it would signify the  ascendance of European aerospace companies in the Indian market. He ended his  presentation by stating that the year 2023 is a crucial year for India-France  relations as it marks the 25th anniversary of their defence  cooperation. \nDuring the discussion\, Maj. Gen. (Dr.)  Bipin Bakshi brought out that the French Alouette light utility helicopter was  procured by India in 1965. Later these helicopters were manufactured as Chetak  in India under a license obtained by Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) as one  of the earliest examples of Transfer of Technology (TOT) between the two  nations. He also said that the Indian Armed Forces successfully fitted the HAL  Chetaks with SS-11 B1 missiles which were also manufactured by France. Gen.  Bakshi stated that French influence in India’s defence sector\, despite being  very significant\, has largely been underplayed. He emphasised that the  prospects of French contribution to the Indian defence industry must be closely  studied.  \nThe session concluded after an  insightful exchange of views between scholars during the Q&A session. \nKey  Takeaways\n\nArms  imports from France by India increased by over 90 per cent in recent times\,  largely on account of the Rafale and the Scorpene deals\, making it the largest  European supplier of defence equipment.\nIndia is  France’s second-largest defence export market\, after Saudi Arabia.\nOut of the  56 offset contracts in India\, nine are being executed by French defence  companies.\nIndia is  now turning towards Europe for the import of military aircraft.\n\nReport  prepared by Dr. R.Vignesh\, Research Analyst\, Military Affairs Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-india-france-defence-cooperation-looking-ahead
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221129T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221129T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131408Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130547Z
UID:62964-1669699800-1669699800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:One-Day Seminar titled "India and the Arctic: Prospects for Partnership"
DESCRIPTION:Manohar Parrikar Institute  for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, New Delhi in collaboration with the  Ministry of Earth Sciences\, Government of India\, organised a Seminar ‘India and the Arctic: Prospects for  Partnership’ on 29 November 2022. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA  delivered the opening remarks. The day-long seminar was divided into three  sessions.  \nThe first session on ‘Arctic Science and Climate Change’ was  chaired by Dr. Thamban Meloth\, Director\, National Centre for Polar and Ocean  Research (NCPOR)\, Goa. Dr. S. Rajan\, India’s representative to the United  Nations Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf (UNCLOS) and Dr.  Sandip Rashmikant Oza\, Senior Scientist\, Space Application Centre\, Ahmedabad\,  were the two panelists.  \nThe second session on ‘Arctic Geopolitics’ was chaired by  Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\, Centre Coordinator\, Non-Traditional Security Centre\,  MP-IDSA. The two panelists included Dr. Arvind Gupta\, Director\, Vivekananda  International Foundation\, New Delhi and Professor Sanjay Chaturvedi\, Dean\,  Faculty of Social Sciences\, South Asian University\, New Delhi.  \nThe third and final session on ‘India’s Arctic Capacity  Building’ was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy. Capt. Anurag Bisen  (IN)\,  MP-IDSA and Dr. Rahul Mohan\,  Scientist F\, International Cooperation and Outreach\, NCPOR\, Goa\, were the two  panelists.  \n  The vote of thanks was delivered by Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin  Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA.  \n  Participants included officials from the concerned  ministries\, armed forces personnel\, members of the diplomatic corps\,  representatives from the media\, think-tanks and the academia.  \nExecutive Summary\nThe Arctic is emerging as a region of high geopolitical and  geo-economic activity. As per recent scientific estimates\, the Arctic is  warming at a rate three to four times the average normal. An emerging  interconnection of ‘Science’ and ‘Geopolitics’ makes the Arctic a region of  global interests. With the release of India’s Arctic Policy\, its interest in  the region from scientific\, geopolitical and national capacity building  perspectives requires careful evaluation. The seminar covered critical emerging  issues in the Arctic and concluded with some key recommendations and policy  perspectives for India’s future engagement in the region. \nDetailed Report\nThe Seminar began with welcome remarks by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy. He discussed the Arctic’s immense  resource potential and its crucial role in maintaining global climate balance  by acting as a virtual thermostat. The Arctic is a bellwether of climate  fluctuations that the world is witnessing today and therefore\, according to  Amb. Chinoy\, there is need for greater scientific understanding of the region.  He highlighted the recent COP 27 Summit and its agenda on meeting the  challenges of global warming and opined that the impact of indiscriminate  materialism on the ecosystem cannot be escaped. He viewed the event of Arctic  becoming ice-free as an apparent conundrum which attracts commercial activity  and provides an alternative shipping route as well as worsens the climate  change crisis.  \nAmb. Chinoy raised the need for enhanced governance structures\,  greater resource management\, and environment and cultural protection. He also  discussed the relevance of India’s Lifestyle for Environment (LiFE) campaign  and reiterated the importance of India’s Arctic policy. Speaking about India’s  ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam\, Amb.  Chinoy informed the audience that India’s Arctic policy displays its intent and  readiness to play a global role and contribute to the global good. He observed  that the Arctic is emerging as a theatre for geopolitical contestation and that  it is antithetical to the very foundation of the Arctic\, which was envisioned  as a zone of peace since the end of the Cold War.  \nThe first session on ‘Science and Climate Change’ in the  Arctic was chaired by Dr. Thamban Meloth.  He highlighted that global warming has led to irreparable changes in the Polar  Regions and drastic reduction in sea-ice with severe implications for the  Arctic indigenous populations. In addition\, the Chair observed that an ice-free  Arctic will lead to several geopolitical ramifications and impact the  resources\, including the global fishing industry. Dr. Meloth noted that global  engagement with the Antarctic pened the doors for Polar Studies and that the  Himalayas and the Arctic are deeply connected through the global climate  systems\, thawing of permafrost and the Indian monsoons. The increasing number  of natural disasters\, including landslides and cloudbursts\, can also be  attributed to the same. During his remarks\, Dr. Meloth familiarised the  audience with the activities of the NCPOR\, the Indian research stations and the  various scientific expeditions to the Polar Regions. He particularly noted that  the NCPOR acts as an ‘Indian gateway to the Polar Regions’ and that all  activities related to the Arctic should also consider the welfare of the  indigenous populations.  \nSpeaking on ‘What Ails the Arctic Climate?’ Dr. S. Rajan explored the balance  between the scientific and non-scientific elements of the Arctic. He discussed  the climate system and the related oceanic variability and atmospheric  circulations and thereon addressed the link between the Asian monsoon and the  Polar Regions. He indicated that several studies have explored the link between  cold episodes in the North Atlantic and the Asian monsoon during the Holocene\,  and concluded his presentation by highlighting the challenges due to limited  knowledge about the natural processes within the climate system and the  inability of climate models to reproduce   observations accurately.  \nDr. Sandip  Oza made his presentation on India’s research in ‘Remote  Sensing of Arctic Cryosphere’. He explored the role of space to understand the  dynamics of the Arctic region and its support in analysing the  interconnectivity of multiple issues. The speaker discussed ice sheet  elevation\, mass balance\, and assessment of surface melt processes\, and as  evidence displayed several maps of the change in sea-ice masses in the Arctic.  He brought forth to the audience the web-based services for archival material  and dissemination of information related to the Arctic like the VEDAS  (Visualisation of Earth Observation Data and Archival System) Portal. Dr. Oza  discussed several potential and existing international collaborations for niche  studies in the Arctic\, for example the advanced Arctic weather monitoring  system and energy balance in the region. He then focused on the role of several  future space missions like NISAR (L&S dual frequency) and TRISHNA  (ISRO-CNES Optical & Thermal) in cryosphere studies. Dr. Oza concluded by  highlighting the joint Earth observing mission between NASA and ISRO (NISAR)  and the prospects of collaboration of several national and international  agencies for the exchange of knowledge\, capacity building\, and advancement in  techniques and infrastructure in the Arctic. \nThe second session on ‘Arctic Geopolitics’ began with a  detailed introduction by Dr. Uttam Kumar  Sinha. The Chair highlighted that the Arctic region witnessed cooperation  since the formation of the Arctic Council but has now started witnessing  political fissures between the states as a result of emerging geostrategic  realignments. He observed that the power shifts might possibly make the Arctic  Council redundant or at best limited in its function. Calling India a Tri-Polar  state\, Dr. Sinha highlighted that India’s engagements in the Arctic are  historic. He also referred to the classical work of the great Indian  nationalist and freedom fighter Bal Gangadhar Tilak to make aware India’s  civilizational connect with the Arctic region.  \nDr. Arvind  Gupta\, in continuation of the Chair’s remarks\, emphasised the  strategic importance of the Arctic\, more so with the ongoing Russia-Ukraine  crisis. Commenting on the Arctic Council\, Dr. Gupta mentioned that the Council  set up in 1996 was an important mechanism that provided a model for Arctic  governance and cooperation between states in the region. He pointed out that  Arctic seven (that are or will be NATO members) decision to not participate in  any of the Arctic Council’s meetings under Russia’s current chairmanship has  seriously impacted its functioning and that the Arctic governance structure  will consequently be under severe stress. The speaker observed that China’s  emerging presence in the Arctic will redefine the Arctic geopolitical and  geoeconomic dynamics. As NATO tries to isolate Russia in the Arctic\,  China-Russia cooperation would naturally tend to gather momentum. Speaking from  his experience and first hand observation\, Dr. Gupta elaborated on China’s  emerging investments in energy\, mineral resources\, tourism\, shipping and other  related projects in the Russian Arctic. On India’s approach\, the speaker  asserted that India needs to develop the required polar infrastructure  capabilities and should further strengthen its relations with all the Arctic  states. He highlighted that India-Russia cooperation remains critical in  fulfilling India’s interests in the Arctic and both countries need to take  adequate steps. He recommended that the Indian Navy should ensure naval  presence in the Northern Sea Route (NSR) by frequently sending its ships. Dr.  Gupta concluded that if India seriously needs to take a leadership position in  the world\, then it needs to have positions on every major global issue. The  Arctic is no exception. \nProf.  Sanjay Chaturvedi spoke on ‘Geopolitics of Connections and Disconnections in  the ‘Circumpolar Arctic’: Opportunities and Challenges before India’. He  emphasized that the Arctic region needs to be seen through a de-securitisation  context rather than the securitisation framework. He mentioned that the region  is currently witnessing re-securitisation or greater military buildups. Prof.  Chaturvedi noted that the ‘Connectivity’ aspect in India’s Arctic Policy is far  more important than the security aspect. By 2048\, the opening up of the  Northern Eurasian Rimland would enable greater connectivity between East and  West via North. This could enable the northern expansion of China which\, as a  result\, could add to greater geopolitical complexities. The speaker highlighted that India’s Arctic engagement will depend much  on how India imagines the Arctic as a space and place. Since “No Country will  ever own the North Pole”\, it justifies India’s narrative of the Arctic as a  Global Commons. While concluding\, Prof. Chaturvedi noted that the Arctic will  witness unilateralism\, bilateralism\, multilateralism and minilateralism to  address emerging challenges and that the key challenge before India’s Polar  diplomacy is how to translate India’s globally acclaimed Polar science  achievements into geopolitical influence in pursuit of India’s national  interests. \nThe final session of the  Seminar on ‘Capacity Building’ was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy. He emphasised the need to adopt a strategic view at the national level  that increases India’s Arctic engagement.   He reiterated the importance of capacity building in promoting both  strategic and scientific interests. The current challenges faced by the  Arctic Council and the choice before India whether to coordinate between Russia  and the Nordic states were highlighted by the Chair. He also raised the issue  of the Arctic as a ‘global commons’ and the Chinese involvement in the region. Amb.  Chinoy asserted that India needs its own Polar Ice  Breaker vessel to support its ongoing scientific research and other related  activities in the region. He further noted that as discussions on the  Arctic unfold\, the focus also has to be on the Antarctic Treaty System. He  discussed the need to build supply chains\, logistical capabilities\, and for  budget enhancement\, and increasing domestic academic capacity and skilled  workforce in the region. The Chair opined that India’s vision of ‘SAGAR’ and  Blue Economy also need to be promoted in the Arctic. \nCapt.  Anurag Bisen (IN) in his  presentation differentiated between capacity as material adequacy and  capability as possession of domain-specific expertise and skills. He opined  that the two domains also differ in the timeline required to acquire them. He  discussed the motives for developing capacity in the Arctic. These include the  impact on monsoons and rising sea-levels subsequently leading to a migration  crisis\, the opening of new shipping routes\, energy security and mineral wealth\,  and strategic contestation. Capt. Bisen added that India has legitimate  credentials to facilitate cooperation in the region. Thereon\, the speaker  compared India’s capacity building activities with that of China\, Japan\, and  South Korea\, which became Arctic Observers in 2013 along with India. The  parameters of comparison included setting up of research stations\, expeditions\,  membership of the International Arctic Science Committee\, Nordic Summits\,  release of national Arctic policies\, and Polar research vessels. Capt. Bisen  also compared the participation of the four nations in the Arctic Council Task  Forces. He highlighted that India has only actively engaged with three and  pointed out that thirteen Chinese institutions are affiliated with the  University of Arctic\, whereas NCPOR is the only institution from India. The  speaker also compared Arctic-related international collaborations of India\,  Japan\, China\, and South Korea and reiterated the need for India to increase the  budget for research and development. He introduced the audience to a budgetary  comparison between the Polar engagements of India\, South Korea\, and China and  opined that national academic capacity needs to be built to strengthen the  contributions of India’s scientific community. He made recommendations to increase  capacity and capability in the region. These included the setting up of Polar  research institutions in India\, the introduction of university-level programmes  and increased bilateral cooperation with the Arctic states.  \nIn his presentation\, Dr.  Rahul Mohan emphasised that the impact of climate change cannot be debated  and politics should not be intermingled with science. He highlighted that  NCPOR’s Polar Science engagements include the Antarctic Programme\, the Arctic  Programme\, and the Himalayan Cryosphere Programme. Other thrust areas of the  NCPOR include ocean sciences\, geoscience\, and operations and management. He  added that NCPOR runs two research stations named ‘Maitri’ and ‘Bharati’ in the  Antarctic\, a research station in the Indian Himalayas and the Himadri research  station in the Arctic. He also presented a timeline of India’s Arctic  engagement since the signing of the Svalbard Treaty in 1920. Elaborating  further\, the speaker highlighted that India has undertaken fourteen expeditions  to the Arctic with nearly 600 participants and noted that the major research  areas include Arctic precipitation and cloud monitoring\, long-term monitoring  of Kongsfjorden\, the impact of glacier melting\, mass balance dynamics and the  impact of pollutants in the region. Dr Mohan also displayed images of India’s  first underwater multi-sensor mooring in the Arctic (IndARC). He added that  India also utilises the Gruvebadet Atmosphere Laboratory and has contributed  instruments to the facility\, and that India has introduced the Polar Aerosol  Network to monitor and connect the Three Poles through scientific equipment. In  his recommendation\, the speaker opined that a pan-Arctic approach needs to be  adopted and that under India’s Arctic Policy\, NCPOR is aiming to develop online  courses and is conducting workshops with several academic institutions.  \nThe seminar ended with a formal vote of thanks by Maj Gen (Dr) Bipin Bakshi (Retd)\,  Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA. \nKey Takeaways and  Policy Recommendations\n\nThe Himalayas and the Arctic are deeply  connected through global climate systems\, thawing of permafrost and the Indian  monsoon systems.\nLimited knowledge about the natural processes  within the climate system and the inability of climate models to reproduce  accurate observations challenges scientific research in the Arctic.\nThe Arctic region maintains immense resource  potential in terms of minerals and hydrocarbon resources that India needs to  factor in the near future.\nThe ice-free Arctic will lead to several  geopolitical ramifications and impact   resources\, including the global fishing industry.\nAs NATO tries to isolate Russia in the Arctic\,  China-Russia cooperation will strengthen. \nIndia is a Tri-Polar state and its engagements  with the Arctic are prehistoric that find its acknowledgements in Bal Gangadhar  Tilak’s book ‘The Arctic Home in Vedas.’\nIndia’s ethos of Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam\, as mentioned in India’s Arctic Policy\,  displays its intent and readiness to play a global role and contribute to the  global good.\n ‘India’s Lifestyle for Environment’ campaign  can bring in new ideas to promote sustainable development in the Arctic.\nIndia needs to develop adequate Polar  infrastructure capabilities\, especially a Polar research vessel or an  ice-breaker ship and should further enhance its relations with all the Arctic  states.\nIndia should consider increasing its budgetary  allocation for Polar research. \nRussia maintains the largest territorial  extent in the Arctic. India-Russia cooperation in the Arctic could open new  avenues for further strengthening bilateral relations between the two  countries.  \nCooperation with all the Arctic seven  countries remains equally crucial for India to fulfil its national objectives  and emphasise its independent foreign policy in the region.\nIndian Navy should ensure naval presence in  the NSR by frequently sending its ships to the region. \n\nReport  Prepared by  Mr. Bipandeep Sharma\, Research Analyst\,  Mr. Pintu Kumar Mahla\, Research Intern and  Ms. Richa Kumaria\, Research Intern\, Non-Traditional Security Centre. \nWatch Complete Video [+]\nDownload Concept Note [PDF]\nProgramme Schedule [PDF]
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/one-day-seminar-titled-india-and-the-arctic-prospects-for-partnership
CATEGORIES:OTHER EVENTS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221128T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221128T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131408Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62965-1669613400-1669613400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on "Evolving Political Situation in Pakistan: Prognosis for the Future”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar IDSA\, spoke on “Evolving Political Situation in  Pakistan: Prognosis for the Future” at  the Monday Morning Meeting which was held on 28 November 2022 at 10 AM. The  meeting was moderated by Dr. Nazir Ahmad  Mir\, Research Assistant\, Manohar Parrikar IDSA. All the  scholars of the Institute participated in the meeting.  \nExecutive Summary\nDuring the meeting\, the speaker shared his  observations on the recent developments in Pakistan\, especially in the context  of the appointment of the new army chief and the ongoing political and economic  crises which have added to Pakistan’s fragility as a state. The speaker  provided useful information about the ongoing political situation\, focusing  especially on the politics behind the mass protests by former Prime Minister  Imran Khan and the appointment of the new army chief.    \nDetailed Report\nThe Monday Morning Meeting began with moderator Dr. Nazir Ahmad Mir providing an overview of the current political  situation in Pakistan\, especially in the context of the appointment of the new  army chief. He said that Imran Khan had basically two demands (i) an early  election\, and that (ii) the appointment of the new army chief should be based  on merit. Finally\, he accepted the decision of the Shehbaz Sharif Government to  appoint General Syed Asim Munir as the new army chief without much fuss.  \n Dr. Nazir further stated that Pakistan’s economy  was not in good shape and the situation worsened after the recent floods. He  dwelt briefly on the new debates in Pakistan these days about the future of  civil-military relations in the country and said that the army had  categorically stated that it would remain neutral in politics. Another  important development\, he said\, was the re-emergence of the Tehrik-i-Taliban  Pakistan\, which had put Kabul and Islamabad in a very difficult situation. He  posed the following questions: What will be Imran Khan’s next move\, after the  appointment of the new army chief?  How  would the economic crisis and the future of civil-military relations impact the  country’s stability or instability? How would domestic politics influence the  country’s foreign policy?  \n Dr. Ashok K. Behuria in continuation of  the moderator’s remarks tried to  analyse developments in Pakistan related to the retirement of the incumbent  Army Chief General Qamar Javed Bajwa and appointment of the new chief over the  last few weeks. He said that the controversy surrounding the selection of the new  army chief had started petering out and Imran Khan was in a de-escalation mode.  He held that Imran Khan’s protest march was all about the appointment of the  new army chief and he did not want Asim Munir in that position because he had  personal issues with him\, having shunted him out after only 8 months in office  as the Director- General of the Inter-Service Intelligence (ISI) in June 2019.  \n Imran also raised the issue of Shehbaz Sharif  consulting with Nawaz Sharif in London about the appointment of the army chief  and regarded it as improper in view of the fact that Nawaz was a convicted  person and had fled Pakistan. Imran had also shown his uneasiness when it  transpired that Nawaz favoured the selection of Asim Munir on the basis of  seniority. Imran’s followers had even raised the issue of Asim Munir’s  ineligibility because he has to retire two days before the army chief’s tenure  comes to an end.  \n Dr. Behuria also pointed out that Imran would  have liked either Gen. Faiz Hameed or Gen. Azhar Abbas as the next chief  because both of them had played some role in strengthening his political career  at the cost of his opponents for which he was touted as the ‘selected prime  minister’ by the Pakistan Democratic Movement (PDM). However\, when he saw that  decision was finally taken following due procedures by the incumbent  government\, he accepted it\, but not before queering the pitch at the very last  minute by saying that he would ‘play’ along with the President within the  confines of the law indicating that the President\, who was from his party could  delay the appointment by returning the file to the Prime Minister for  reconsideration! As per the Constitution\, the whole process would have taken  about 25 days after which he would have had to accept the decision of the government.  \n However\, ultimately good sense prevailed and  Imran accepted the decision and has now come out with statements suggesting  that he was prepared to put everything behind and move forward\, by which he  meant that he was not serious about his earlier allegations that the army had a  role to play in his loss of power and the US had orchestrated the political  crisis in Pakistan acting behind the scene.  \n Dr. Behuria said that Imran had been able get  people to back him and his rallies remind one of the rallies of Zulfiqar Ali  Bhutto of the 1960s when Bhutto fell out of favour with Ayub Khan. He also held  that Imran was likely to come back to power in the next elections and the new  army chief will have to find some way of mending fences with him. He also argued  that Imran-Bajwa differences cannot be regarded as Imran’s disillusionment with  the army. This also did not mean that Imran wanted civilian supremacy. He was  only unhappy with the army leadership for not supporting him at a moment when  his party lost majority in the National Assembly in March 2022.  \n He said that Pakistan was passing through  interesting times. However\, Pakistan’s approach to India was unlikely to change  much and the army under Asim Munir is expected to follow the path charted out  for him by his predecessors on Kashmir which is excessively focussed on final  resolution of the Kashmir issue through implementation of UN resolutions.  \n The presentation by Dr. Behuria was followed by  an animated discussion.  \n The Report  was prepared by Mr. Afroz Khan\, Research Assistant\, MP-IDSA.      
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-evolving-political-situation-in-pakistan-prognosis-for-the-future
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221121T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221121T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131448Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62967-1669008600-1669008600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “No Money for Terror": Challenges and Strategies
DESCRIPTION:Col.  Vivek Chadha (Retd.)\, Senior Fellow\, Manohar  Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “No  Money for Terror”: Challenges and Strategies at the Monday Morning Meeting  held on 21 November 2022. The session was moderated by Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\,  Senior Fellow\, MP-IDSA. Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd.)\, Deputy  Director General\, MP-IDSA\, and scholars of the institute were in  attendance.  \nExecutive Summary \nTerror financing is a multifaceted and transnational  security challenge for states\, gaining prominence in the aftermath of the 9/11  attacks. It has been a constant issue of debate in three significant events  organised over the past month – the 90th Interpol General Assembly\, the United  Nations Security Council Counter- Terrorism Committee’s Special Meeting\, and  the “No Money for Terror” Ministerial Conference. Furthermore\, it must be noted  that corruption levels in a society determine the severity and scale of  operations of terror funding practiced by individuals or groups\, and hawala  networks are considered the most efficient way for perpetrators to transfer  money illegally. Cryptocurrency is gaining prominence as a chosen medium of  money transfers. Finally\, the main takeaway would be that to succeed in dismantling  terror finance networks; states worldwide must ensure that the costs imposed on  terror funding outweigh the incentives involved. \nDetailed Report \nDr.  Sinha introduced the topic of the Monday Morning Meeting by highlighting the  recently organised “No Money for Terror” Conference\, hosted in New Delhi from  18-19 November 2022. He emphasised that the opening and concluding remarks by  the Indian Minister of Home Affairs\, Mr. Amit Shah were impactful\, high on  content\, and indicated a clear sense of direction. He spoke about how the world  is undergoing a permacrisis\, i.e.\, an age of constant upheaval.  \nFollowing  the brief introduction\, the Dr. Sinha gave the floor to Col. Chadha.  \nInitially\,  the speaker briefly delved into the three most recent and major conferences  about terrorism and terror finance conducted within one month – “No Money for  Terror”\, the UNSC Counter-Terrorism Committee’s Special Meeting resulting in  the Delhi Declaration\, and the 90th Interpol General Assembly. He  contextualised these events within the trend of renewed focus on terrorism  finance and hinted at how it has gained prominence as a critical issue  post-9/11. \nWhile  discussing Interpol’s 90th General Assembly\, he shed light on how the  resolution unveiled after the meeting drew to a close\, linked corruption\,  crime\, and terror funding as crucial factors in an interwoven model. The  meeting also focused on the need for global responses to such problems due to  financial systems’ interconnectedness. Corruption is the core enabler within  this dynamic\, and the more corrupt a society is\, the easier it becomes to undertake\,  among other activities\, financial crime.  \nNext\,  he underlined the critical features of the Delhi Declaration\, where  crowdfunding for terror purposes was one of the highlights of the 35-para  document. In this context\, it must be understood that there are traditional\,  anonymous\, decentralised\, and untraceable crowdfunding methods\, including the  hawala networks.  \nSubsequently\,  he shifted the focus to the “No Money for Terror” Conference\, primarily PM Modi  and Home Minister Shah’s speeches. In his inaugural address\, PM Modi spoke  about the key challenges facing the world. This includes cyber terrorism\, how  poorer nations bear the brunt of terrorism\, the use of terrorism as state  policy by some countries\, and the link between money laundering\, terror funding\,  and crime. It was reiterated by the speaker that corruption remains the enabler  factor for crime and money laundering.  \nAs  indicated by the Prime Minister’s Address\, specific approaches were highlighted  to bring out the salience of the above mentioned threats. For example\, criminal  actors use technology as an enabler\, while it is a solution for enforcement  agencies. Additionally\, multilateral forums should be employed to create  consensus and pressure on countries like Pakistan and China with double standards  on terrorism and create a uniform and straightforward approach to counter this  threat. This is keeping in mind that the China-Pak nexus has long been undermining  efforts to do so by blocking proposals at the UNSC.  \nFurthermore\,  it was understood that a unified approach to countering terrorism could not be  adopted unless this double-standard approach ends. Additionally\, dismantling  terror financing networks was also raised as an important issue while at the  same time emphasising that terrorism as an issue is far more critical than  terrorists committing an act of violence. Finally\, there is a need to prevent  the exploitation of systemic differences between various stakeholders by  hostile actors\, and attempts to reduce such fissures to the greatest possible  extent must be made.  \nCol.  Chadha also brought to the fore the five-point strategy unveiled by the Home  Minister to counter terror financing\, which was the crux of his address. It has  been highlighted below. \n\nEstablishing a comprehensive monitoring framework  involving cooperation and coordination between intelligence and investigative  agencies. \nTrace\, Target\, and Terminate.\nStrengthening and harmonising the legal structure\,  akin to the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act that clearly defines a terrorist  act and allows for the prosecution of guilty individuals under its guidelines.    \nMechanisms against misuse of next-generation  technology. \nA legal and regular framework for self-recovery. \n\nThe  speaker also spoke about the four characteristics of terror funding\, including  the legality of the origins of terror money\, its involvement in the  exploitation of financial systems\, and religion as a crucial motivator within  this scenario. Moreover\, it is fast-evolving and minimal funds are needed to  carry out a terror strike. He further talked about how terror finance will find  the path of least resistance. \nHe  deconstructed the hybrid model of the terrorism finance cycle\, highlighting the  three core elements of terror funding\, i.e.\, sources\, the transfer mechanism  and distribution. According to him\, hawala networks and legal transfer remain  the leading and efficient methods used in terror financing. \nCryptocurrency  has also been used individually or alongside hawala networks to sustain  terrorism. It is incredibly challenging\, nonetheless\, to trace and track  cryptocurrency exchanges. This dilemma is exacerbated by its uneven  implementation despite Financial Action Task Forces’ regulation number 15  concerning its regulation and legalisation. For this regulation to take effect\,  service providers have to be registered and regulated. More worryingly\, no  standards have been set for its use. As a result\, fissures such as these are  bound to be exploited\, the effects of which are already visible. Over the  years\, there has been a surge in terror funding cases related to  cryptocurrency\, from 5 to 20 per cent.  \nHowever\,  hawala is considered by the speaker to be more efficient because of how  difficult its transactions are to trace and track. Moreover\, it cannot be  regulated\, especially in countries like India\, where it is deemed illegal.  \nThere  are also local and global funding methods deemed equally effective\, including  extortion and crime occurring locally and those that permeate geographical  boundaries. Furthermore\, regulated and unregulated sources of terror financing  work together to sustain the system\, alongside land and air transfers (for  example\, through drones) and legal and electronic sources; the lattermost might  not always be regulated across borders.  \nHere\,  it is vital to understand that terrorists will exploit emerging trends\,  protocol lacunae\, information fissures\, and a divided house. To counter this\,  agencies must look at emerging trends for lessons and implementation\, create  global protocols\, improve methods of information sharing\, and ensure unity of  action. \nQ/A Session \nDr.  Sinha expressed his gratitude to the speaker for his detailed presentation and  raised a question about how MP-IDSA can offer a fresh perspective\, through  intelligence analysis\, about creating security architecture and legal and  financial systems to counter terror financing. Afterwards\, he invited questions  from the attendees.  \nThe  Q/A session broadly revolved around themes such as information sharing  challenges faced on a national level\, the narco-terror factor within terror  financing\, and the linkage between climate change and terror financing or  climate change and terrorism. It also examined difficulties facing India in  multilateral formats like the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation in addressing  its security concerns\, considering that Pakistan and China are permanent  members of this forum. Finally\, the speaker gave insightful responses to  comments and questions received from the participants.  \nThis  report was prepared by Ms. Saman Ayesha Kidwai\, Research Analyst\,  Counter-Terrorism Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-no-money-for-terror-challenges-and-strategies
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221121T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221121T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131409Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62966-1669008600-1669008600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on "COP27: An Assessment”
DESCRIPTION:Dr.  Nihar R. Nayak\, Research Fellow\, Manohar  Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses\, spoke on “COP 27: An Assessment” at the  Monday Morning Meeting held on 21 November 2022. The session was chaired by Dr.  Uttam K. Sinha\, Centre Coordinator\, Non- Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA. Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi\, Deputy  Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Senior Scholars\, Research Analysts\, and Interns of  the Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive  Summary\nThe 2022  Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate  Change (COP 27) was held from from 6 November to 20 November 2022 in Sharm  El-Sheikh\, Egypt. The presentation gave a comprehensive overview of the  Conference and the major issues raised during the meeting.  \nDetailed  Report\nDr. Uttam  Kumar Sinha commenced the session by introducing the audience to the recently  concluded COP 27 Summit. He highlighted that this year’s summit has been  projected as the ‘Implementation COP’ given that there is hope of focussing on  implementation of previous policies adopted. He noted that the current  geopolitical landscape represents a “permacrisis” that is characterised  by long periods of insecurity and instability.   \nWith these remarks\, Dr. Sinha  invited Dr. Nayak to make his presentation. At the outset\, Dr. Nayak introduced  the audience to the origin of the COP and its decision-making process. He noted  that the report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in 1990  and the 1992 Rio Earth Summit led to the establishment of the COP. He  highlighted that the UNFCCC does not legally bind or provide any timeline and  targets for the participants. However\, he added that it is mandatory to hold  regular COPs. Dr. Nayak opined that the third COP held in Kyoto in 1997 and the  COP 21 in Paris in 2015 are of particular relevance to the global climate  policy and established mechanisms of responsibility-sharing. He added that the  former was limited in mandate and especially for the developed countries\, while  the latter included all developing countries as well.  \nIn the next part of his  presentation\, Dr. Nayak displayed comparative figures to depict the top  greenhouse gas emitters on a global level. On a cumulative basis\, since 1850\,  the United States and European Union occupied the top positions. The speaker  then compared these with the emission status in 2018\, wherein\, China occupied  the top position. Dr. Nayak opined that climate negotiations have further led  to divisions between the developed and developing states. He added that  developing countries have been demanding the release of climate funds and the  introduction of the loss and damage fund. However\, developed countries continue  to avoid these demands. Dr. Nihar also presented the data displaying the  current status of Climate Finance and the amount contributed by developed  states. \nDr. Nayak also discussed the major  issues raised during COP 27 negotiations. He noted that several participants  demanded more action-oriented rules. He added that demands for the inclusion of  the Top 20 emitters\, including India and China\, to contribute to the climate  fund have also increased. The demands were met with some  opposition from India. He further noted that  the European Union has demanded that natural gas and nuclear power should be  declared as green energy and the International Monetary Fund proposed that the  carbon price floor should be fixed.  \nThe speaker further addressed three  critical issues that came up during COP 27 negotiations. Firstly\, he discussed  the demands for a Loss and Damage Fund led by the G-77 countries. Although  officially adopted\, he opined that its implementation will be a challenge.  Secondly\, Dr. Nayak also discussed India’s proposal for the phase-down of all  fossil fuels and the lack of support for the same. Lastly\, he highlighted the  debate on limiting global average temperature rise  to 1.5 degrees and the risks associated with  crossing that threshold.  \nThe speaker also tracked civil  society responses to the negotiation. He noted that the summit witnessed  large-scale participation from global energy companies and it was funded by  major polluting companies. He added that fossil fuel lobbyists included  delegates mainly from the United Arab Emirates and African countries that  influenced climate negotiations.  \nIn the next part of his  presentation\, Dr. Nayak discussed India’s stance at the COP 27. He noted  India’s re-emphasis on Common but Differentiated Responsibilities and  Respective Capabilities (CBDR-RC). India also sought clarifications on the  climate fund. The Mangrove Alliance for Climate was also launched in order to  promote the preservation of mangrove forests towards efforts to curb global  warming. He added that India opposed the demand for declaring ‘gas as green  energy’. Discussing the achievements of the summit\, he posited that spurring  private sector investments in the green energy market and the increasing use of  solar power is a success. \nDr. Nayak concluded by presenting  the challenges faced during climate negotiations. These included the absence of  implementation mechanisms on loss and damage fund provisions\, lack of consensus  on contentious issues\, geopolitical issues such as Ukraine and Taiwan\, the  growing influence of energy companies\, and a trust deficit between developed  and developing states.  \nDiscussion\nMaj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi\, (Retd.) underlined the  importance of the Loss and Damage Fund and highlighted the need to increase  renewable energy use. \nDr. Nazir Ahmad Mir raised questions on the 1.5° C threshold\, the global stance on Climate Change and  the role of African companies in supporting fossil-fuel use.  \nDr.  Deepika Sarawat enquired  about the institutional mechanisms to decide the host for the COP summit.   \nMs. Mayuri Banerjee made a query about  whether there is a link  between  terrorism and climate change and the existing discourse on the challenges faced  by the two \nThe discussion  ended with a Vote of Thanks by Dr. Uttam K. Sinha.  \nThe report has been prepared by Ms. Richa Kumaria\, Intern\, Non-  Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-cop27-an-assessment
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221118T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221118T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131448Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T125558Z
UID:62968-1668749400-1668749400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Talk by H.E. Dr. Fayssal Mekdad\, Minister of Foreign Affairs and Expatriates Syrian Arab Republic
DESCRIPTION:The  Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies & Analyses (MP-IDSA)  organised a Talk by H.E. Dr. Fayssal Mekdad\, Minister of Foreign Affairs and  Expatriates\, Syrian Arab Republic\, on “Developments in Syria and the Region\, &  India-Syria Relations” on 18 November 2022. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director  General MP-IDSA\, delivered the welcome remarks and moderated the session.  \nExecutive Summary\nH.E. Dr. Fayssal Mekdad  offered a brief review of the present situation in Syria\, highlighting the  challenges posed by terrorist groups and the constraints faced by the present government.  He also spoke at length about ways Western interference has destabilised the  region and how unilateral Western sanctions continue to undermine Syria’s  reconstruction efforts today. He concluded his talk by suggesting deeper  cooperation with India to combat terrorism and urged the international  community to unify efforts to fight the menace of terrorism. \nDetailed Report \nThe  session began with Amb. Chinoy extending a warm welcome to H.E. Dr. Fayssal Mekdad  and other participants who joined the event. In his welcome remarks\, Amb.  Chinoy made observations on Syria’s rich civilisational and cultural heritage and  the deep historical linkages between India and Syria. He stated that over the  years\, ties between the two countries have been nurtured through regular  high-level visits and India has been one of Syria’s key developmental partners.  Further\, India hopes to do more with Syria\, especially in capacity building  projects. Highlighting some of India’s recent endeavours in the field of  humanitarian assistance to Syria\, Amb. Chinoy informed that New Delhi has  played a crucial role in helping Syria to meet its food\, health and  developmental needs during the period of crisis. Also\, India has extended  support towards Syria’s human resource development by providing educational scholarships  to students and providing training to Syrian diplomats. He stated that Syria’s  devastation is a reminder to the rest of the international community of the need  to respect national boundaries and sovereignty\, and the dangers posed by  radical ideologies and terrorist organisations. He added that India hopes to  see a peaceful and comprehensive resolution of the decade-long conflict through  a Syrian-owned dialogue\, involving all the parties to the conflict.  \nDrawing  attention to the larger international situation\, Amb. Chinoy stated that the  past few years have witnessed major changes in the global strategic landscape.  The effects of the COVID-19 pandemic have been compounded by great power  competition and major power rivalry which is spilling over to diverse areas  from trade\, technology to ideology. He highlighted that as India takes on the  presidency of the G20\, New Delhi will endeavour to work together to address the  security challenges faced by the international community and India is committed  to striving for the benefit of the Global South. Amb. Chinoy ended his address  by emphasising on the dangers of conflict and the need to recommit to  strengthening diplomacy and resolving disputes through peaceful dialogue and  negotiations.  \nDr.  Mekdad stated that the situation in Syria is improving and the victory is not  only for Syria against terrorism but for all humanity. However\, if the  destructive force of terrorism succeeds again in Syria\, the entire international  community will suffer. Linking the Syrian conflict to the Arab Spring\, he  contended that the violence and the political instability caused by the Arab  Spring were planned by the Muslim Brotherhood\, certain Western countries and  Turkey. Contrary to Western media propaganda of the Arab Spring being the  solution to the problems faced by the Arab world\, the event was a geopolitical  change effected by the West to achieve its political needs. He elaborated that  the West mislead Arab people and the international community with promises of  democracy and freedom\, however\, the US and its allies have not been able to stabilise  the countries where they engineered regime change.  \nWith  regard to the Syrian conflict\, Dr. Mekdad stated that while terrorists and  insurgents infiltrated into the country through Turkey\, the US and Europe  accused Syria of human rights violations and blocked the Syrian Government’s  access to the international media. They also falsely accused Syria of using  chemical weapons against its own population. Moreover\, at present\, parts of  Syria are occupied by Turkey and Western forces who are not only fuelling  separatism but also stealing Syria’s natural resources like oil and natural  gas. He expressed the view that although the West has made significant  contributions towards developing the ideas of democracy and human rights\, they  are now politicising these principles for their own interests. Highlighting the  crippling impact of Western sanctions on the Syrian economy and society\, Dr.  Mekdad suggested that the US was committing human rights violations by denying  Syrian people access to basic food and health amenities.  \nHe  concluded his talk by appreciating India’s past humanitarian assistance and continuing  efforts towards supporting Syria. He offered Syrian cooperation to India for  combating terrorism. He emphasised that terrorism is an international threat  which should never be tolerated. As an essential measure towards combating terrorism\,  Dr. Mekdad suggested that civil institutions should be empowered to play a more  influential role.  \nFollowing  Dr. Mekdad’s speech\, Amb. Chinoy highlighted two key takeaways from his address.  He observed that the international community needs to unite in the fight  against terrorism by rising above the divisive politics and ideologies of the  day; and secondly\, the world needs a big dose of humanity and a moral compass  to guide it into the future.  \nThe  Talk was followed by a lively Q&A session. Responding to a question on the  phase of reconstruction in Syria and the feasibility of the infrastructure  project connecting Iranian ports to Syrian and Lebanese ports on the  Mediterranean\, Dr. Mekdad affirmed that the three countries are working  together to strengthen economic cooperation\, however\, the US presence in the south  of Syria is thwarting infrastructure development that could benefit Syria and  the neighbouring countries. Another participant made a query about the Syrian Government’s  plans to counter the spread of radical ideologies within Syria. Dr. Mekdad stated  that Syria is trying to combat it by promoting education in schools and universities  and empowering civil institutions in the country. To a question on the status  of the Astana process\, Dr. Mekdad responded by stating that the Astana process  has taken the negotiations in a good direction and it will confer again with  Russia\, Iran\, Turkey\, the Syrian delegation and observer countries meeting for  negotiations. \nThe session ended with a Vote of Thanks by the Deputy Director General\, MP-IDSA\,  Maj. Gen. (Dr.) Bipin Bakshi (Retd).  \nReport prepared by Ms. Mayuri  Banerjee\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/talk-by-h-e-dr-fayssal-mekdad-minister-of-foreign-affairs-and-expatriates-syrian-arab-republic
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221116T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20221116T053000
DTSTAMP:20261120T233219
CREATED:20231223T131448Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20231224T130737Z
UID:62969-1668576600-1668576600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report on Roundtable Discussion on Dangers of Tactical Nuclear Weapons
DESCRIPTION:Manohar Parrikar Institute for  Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) and the Indian Pugwash Society (IPS) jointly  organised an in-person roundtable discussion on “Dangers of Tactical Nuclear  Weapons” as part of the Nuclear Roundtable Series on 16 November 2022 at  1500 hrs in Room Number 005. Ambassador  Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA and Convener\, IPS chaired the  session. Air Marshal Rajesh Kumar\,  PVSM\, AVSM\, VM\, ADC\, (Retd.)\, Former Commander-in-Chief\, Strategic Forces  Command; Dr. G. Balachandran\,  Independent Scholar; and Dr. Rajiv Nayan\,  Senior Research Associate and Centre Coordinator\, Nuclear and Arms Control  Centre\, MP-IDSA participated in the discussion as panellists.  \nExecutive Summary\nBrainstorming was done at the roundtable discussion on the implications of the use of Tactical Nuclear Weapons (TNW)s in  the Russia-Ukraine war as well as in the various theatres of the world. The speakers  brought out various factors related to TNWs right from its definition\, the  issue of command and control\, nuclear doctrines\, the demonstrative role of TNWs\,  and factors related to radiation among others. Also\, that there was the least  possibility of Russia using TNWs against Ukraine. In the India-Pakistan  context\, Pakistan’s threat to use TNWs was bluff and bluster and India needs to  enforce deterrence through actions such as the Balakot strikes.  \nDetailed Report\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy set  the ball rolling by providing a brief background to the topic. He reminded the  audience about the P-5 Joint Statement at the beginning of 2022\, that abjured  the use of nuclear weapons. But just a few weeks later\, Russia put its nuclear  forces on alert amidst the Ukraine crisis. However\, the United States (US) did  not react with a similar counter-action. Broadening the scope of the topic\, Ambassador  Chinoy spoke about the risks of escalation\, retaliation and miscalculation with  the TNWs being in the action. The New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New  START) Treaty was drawing to an end and new negotiations were yet to begin.  China is loathe to get involved in any nuclear arms control treaty. Russia\,  even today\, contains a large number of TNWs. However\, the lack of consensus on  the definition of TNWs adds to the problem of putting TNWs in meaningful arms  control negotiations. With these initial remarks\, the Chair invited Air Marshal  Rajesh Kumar to speak on the topic. \nAir Marshal Rajesh Kumar began by  stating that the TNWs are weapons meant to be used on the battlefield. Their  yield varies from 1 – 50 Kilotons. Tactical weapons should be judged based on  size\, range and doctrine. There were so many TNWs before the advent of the  START treaty but over a period of time\, their numbers have been reduced.  However\, there is no treaty limiting TNWs. The US has drawn down tactical  nuclear weapons because of the advent of precision weapons. However\, the  Russian Doctrine requires TNWs to have escalation control in the event of war as  Russia doesn’t match up to the combined might of the NATO forces. For Russia\,  TNWs can be used to return the aggression\, prevent conflict from expanding\,  pre-empt damaging strikes that pose an existential threat to Russia and  terminate hostility. They have a strategy of escalating to deescalate.  The US had a similar strategy when the Warsaw  Pact was alive. Air Marshal Rajesh Kumar mentioned the Kalibr and Iskander missiles  of Russia and the B61 air-delivered gravity bomb of the US. The US has not  developed TNWs because their doctrine says that the use of TNWs will escalate  the war in the nuclear ladder and there will be Mutually Assured Destruction  (MAD). In the case of MAD\, the US doctrine mandates to respond with strategic  weapons. Russian assertion on 2 November 2022 that the nuclear war should not  be fought has come out of a realisation that the nuclear war cannot be stopped  after firing a single tactical nuclear weapon. The war would inevitably  escalate. \nAccording to Air Marshal Rajesh  Kumar\, TNWs had limited utility when it came to achieving specific objectives  such as stopping the war or stopping the enemy’s advances. A study suggested  that Pakistan would require 35 TNWs of 1-2 Kilotons each to stop the advancing Indian  Armoured Division in its tracts by destroying at least fifty per cent of the  tanks in a hypothetical situation. Targeting is a big problem with TNWs which  is not the case with precision weapons. With the use of precision weapons\, the  objectives of TNWs can be achieved with conventional weapons. Later\, the speaker  highlighted the issue of command and control vis-à-vis TNWs. In the case of TNWs\,  command and control is delegated to the person on the ground unlike the case of  strategic weapons where Command and Control is in safe hands. Therefore\, there  is a big risk of miscalculation in the case of TNWs. After dwelling on the  theoretical issues related to tactical weapons\, the speaker put forth his  thoughts on the Russia-Ukraine war. Moscow’s action of putting nuclear forces  on alert was a warning to the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) to not  get involved. Surfacing of the Ohio-class Sub-surface Ballistic Nuclear Submarine  (SSBN) in the Arabian Sea and the port visit of another Ohio-class SSBN to  Gibraltar was a signal from the US to Russia. The US signalled that they would  respond to TNWs with strategic nuclear weapons. The speaker\, further\, contended  that the supporters of disarmament as well as those of deterrence were making  strong arguments according to their respective positions with TNWs in the news. \nAir Marshal Rajesh Kumar dwelled  on TNWs in various theatres across the world. He called out Pakistan’s threat to  use TNWs and asserted that it was just bluff and bluster. Pakistan knows that  if they use TNWs\, the war will certainly be escalated to a full-fledged nuclear  war. Additionally\, they have inadequate fissile material for the consequential  use of TNWs to meet their objectives. Therefore\, India should make its doctrine  of massive nuclear retaliation credible. According to the speaker\, TNWs will be  ineffective in the case of the Korean Peninsula. In the India-China context\,  both are No-First-Use states\, so the question of TNWs does not arise. In  conclusion\, Air Marshal Kumar said that TNWs do not work. There is an issue of  command and control. Any use of TNWs will lead to a full-fledged nuclear war. Therefore\,  any talk of normalisation of the use of nuclear weapons should be discouraged.  \nDr. G. Balachandran endorsed the  arguments of Air Marshal Rajesh Kumar. He said that a dispersed delegation of  command and control in the case of TNWs involves multiple actors. The more  actors involved\, the more the anarchy. He contended that distance became an  important factor in distinguishing between strategic and TNWs because of the  US-Russia dynamic. He defined strategic weapons as weapons that take out an opponent’s  retaliatory weapons. If there is a first strike then strategic weapons take out  the opponent’s strategic weapons. Whereas TNWs are used for tactical purposes.  Thus\, on average\, strategic nuclear weapons have a higher yield than TNWs. \nFurther\, the speaker stated that  if a nuclear weapon state uses TNWs against a non-nuclear weapon state\, then a non-nuclear  weapon state has to depend upon a nuclear-weapon state for retaliation. In the case  of the Russia-Ukraine conflict\, if Russia uses TNWs\, the command and control  would be vested only with the president rather than delegated to the local  commander. TNWs can either be used against a large enemy formation or to create  a radioactive barrier to slow down the advances of the enemy. Referring to  JASON advisory group’s report regarding the use of TNWs in the Vietnam War\, Dr.  Balachandran asserted that the study concluded that the use of TNWs would not  have been effective as conventional weapons could have achieved the same  objectives. Additionally\, the use of TNWs would have turned international and  domestic opinion against the state that was using it. The same logic could be  applied in the case of Russia today which is a rational state\, therefore it would  not use TNWs. However\, if TNWs are used\, it will be to send a strategic message  to the opponent. Coming back to the use of TNWs\, the speaker asserted that TNWs  used in massive quantities could be effective. Moreover\, they are effective in  erecting radioactive barriers for advancing opponent forces. But even then\, TNWs  of a specified yield have to be continuously used as the radiation level drops  after some time.  \nDr. Rajiv Nayan in his opening remarks stated that there was no universally accepted definition of TNWs. Broadly\,  missiles below a range of 550 km are considered tactical weapons. However\,  there was no limit to the yield of the weapon. Therefore\, even weapons with a yield  of 200 Kilotons could be termed as TNWs. In 2010\, the Treaty on the  Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) tried to reach a consensus regarding  the definition of TNWs but failed.  \nTalking about the Russia-Ukraine  conflict\, Dr. Nayan asserted that western media\, western think tanks\, research  institutes\, and western leadership had created hype about Russian TNWs. One-third  of Russian nuclear weapons are always on alert. So\, there is nothing unusual.  Rather Russian actions vis-à-vis nuclear weapons are according to their  doctrine. In the Ukraine crisis\, TNWs are not in the picture except maybe for  signalling. Russia has always denied the use of TNWs but the western strategic  community has projected the Russian threat of TNWs against Ukrainian  infrastructure and NATO forces.  \nDr. Nayan\, further\, spoke about the  implications of the use of TNWs after the Ukraine conflict. He foresaw a demand  for the deployment of TNWs in Europe. Although some European countries were not  in favour of the same\, the changed equations may lead to the redeployment of  the weapons. Then there is a possibility that nations will try to modernise their  respective TNWs. The Russian threat projection can be used for securing modernisation  funding by the US. Further\, the concept of graduated deterrence might come into  vogue. The speaker predicted that there could be a verification problem in  coming times. The world will have to grapple with how to deal with stored nuclear  weapons as they are likely to come into play. Unless there is overall  disarmament\, TNWs are unlikely to fade away. Nations are likely to take a fresh  look at the doctrines to make necessary changes. \nIn the ensuing discussion  including the question and answer session\, Ambassador Chinoy argued  compellingly that tactical and strategic nuclear weapons were conjoined. The use  of one would involve the other. There was no doctrine for TNWs. Taking over  from him\, Dr. Balachandran argued that if Russia were to use TNWs\, it won’t  face any counter-action from NATO. However\, the use of nuclear weapons would  certainly lead to the collapse of the international non-proliferation regime. Responding  to questions and comments\, Air Marshal Rajesh Kumar opined that India’s nuclear  doctrine is very well crafted. However\, it is not studied well by practitioners  and academicians. There is an air of secrecy about our strategic weapons.  Sometimes political and military leadership work in silos\, as a result\, they  speak differently as there is a difference in understanding of strategy and  doctrine by the two. Our programme does not appear to be credible because many  stakeholders speak at cross-purposes. We should set our narrative right so that  the world interprets it as we want. Further\, the cold-start doctrine is no  longer required. Rather Generals are worried about so many soldiers being  deployed on the border as there is a possibility of tiredness at the beginning  of the war. Bringing back the debate on the Russia-Ukraine crisis\, Dr. Nayan  drew the attention of the audience to the fact that Uranium can be accessed by  countries in indirect ways and Russians were not pondering using TNWs. In the  India-Pakistan context\, Dr. Nayan contended that India needs to take action  like at Balakot to achieve deterrence. If actions is not taken\, Pakistan will  get emboldened. In the end\, Ambassador Chinoy complimented the panel and the audience  for intense brainstorming. \nThe  report was prepared by Mr. Niranjan Chandrashekhar Oak\, Research Analyst\,  MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-on-roundtable-discussion-on-dangers-of-tactical-nuclear-weapons
CATEGORIES:ROUND TABLES / WORKSHOPS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR