BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20240101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T021831
CREATED:20250411T063759Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T061759Z
UID:91532-1742189400-1742189400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of Monday Morning Meeting on Reassessing AUKUS in Trump 2.0
DESCRIPTION:Cmde. Abhay Kumar Singh (Retd.)\, Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) spoke on “Reassessing AUKUS in Trump 2.0” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 17 March 2025 at 1000h in Seminar Hall I. Dr. R. Vignesh\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA chaired the session. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, along with scholars of the institute attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nThe session analysed AUKUS’s progress\, focusing on submarine acquisition\, industrial challenges\, and strategic imperatives amid rising U.S.-China tensions. Key discussions included Virginia-class submarine transfers\, maintenance backlogs\, production constraints\, and bipartisan U.S. support. Potential political uncertainties\, including a Trump 2.0 presidency\, were examined. While AUKUS has achieved legislative and strategic milestones\, sustaining momentum requires long-term investment\, industrial capacity-building\, and policy alignment to strengthen deterrence and ensure regional stability. \nDetailed Report\nDr. R.Vignesh commenced the meeting by highlighting that since the beginning AUKUS has had strong bipartisan support of the two dominant political parties in the US\, UK and Australia. He brought out that after the re-election of Donald Trump as US President\, there have been considerable concerns. He stated that the reversal of the US stance on the Ukraine War has ostensibly given rise to apprehensions in Australia’s political discourse and public perceptions regarding the reliability of the US as a security partner. Dr. Vignesh highlighted that due to the US’s centrality in this trilateral security agreement\, there are concerns that Trump’s Presidency may steer AUKUS into troubled waters. Hence\, it is important to understand as to what extent Trump’s Presidency can influence and impact AUKUS. With these opening remarks\, he invited Cmde. Abhay Singh to make his presentation. \nCmde. Abhay Singh began his presentation by highlighting British Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s visit to the White House on 27 February 2025. During this meeting President Trump was asked by a reporter about discussions with the United Kingdom regarding AUKUS. In response\, President Trump appeared unfamiliar with the acronym\, asking\, “What does this mean?” The remark\, widely noted in diplomatic and security circles\, raised fresh concerns about the future of AUKUS\, particularly in light of broader uncertainties surrounding U.S. foreign policy under a potential second Trump Presidency. Additionally\, the U.S. stance reversal on military aid to Ukraine has fueled apprehensions within Australian political discourse and public perception regarding Washington’s reliability as a security partner. Against this backdrop\, the role of AUKUS in securing long-term regional stability and ensuring continued commitment from all three partners has become a pressing concern. \nCmde. Singh provided a structured breakdown of its two pillars of AUKUS. Pillar One deals with the development and deployment of nuclear-powered submarines for Australia. He elaborated on the phased approach involving the training of Australian personnel\, rotational deployment of U.S. and U.K. submarines\, and eventual acquisition of SSN-AUKUS submarines. He detailed the San Diego Summit’s key decisions\, including initial indications for the transfer of Virginia-class submarines\, the new SSN-AUKUS submarine design\, and the role of the U.K.’s Astute-class SSNs and Australia’s Collins-class SSNs in the transition phase. He also highlighted that training programs have already commenced in the U.S. for Australian naval personnel\, although restrictions on the transfer of critical technology pose challenges to implementation. \nPillar Two\, as Cmde. Singh detailed\, expands AUKUS beyond submarines to incorporate advanced defence technologies. These include artificial intelligence\, quantum technologies\, cyber warfare\, undersea capabilities\, and hypersonic weapons. He emphasised that Pillar Two is vital for sustaining long-term technological superiority and interoperability among the three partners. The agreement for cooperation in Naval Nuclear Propulsion (NNP) was also discussed\, along with its impact on industrial development and strategic deterrence. \nCmde. Singh outlined the structure of AUKUS oversight\, mentioning the establishment of three steering groups to coordinate different aspects of the partnership. He also discussed the role of shipbuilders\, including ASC Pty Ltd and BAE Systems\, under the supervision of the Australian Submarine Agency (ASA). He stressed that investment assurance is critical for the SSN program\, requiring financial commitments from all three nations to ensure long-term sustainability. Australia’s AUKUS submarine strategy was examined in terms of creating demand clarity\, skilling manpower\, and ensuring continuity in strategic alignment. \nIn terms of strategic imperatives\, Cmde. Singh noted that AUKUS aligns with broader deterrence efforts in response to the perceived threat from the People’s Republic of China (PRC). He highlighted the importance of bipartisan consensus in ensuring policy continuity\, particularly in the context of a potential Trump 2.0 Presidency\, which may bring a more transactional approach to alliances. The growing influence of China hawks in Washington\, assertive manoeuvres by the PLA Navy\, and the linkage between AUKUS and the Royal Navy’s Astute-class replacement program were also discussed as critical factors shaping the agreement’s trajectory. Furthermore\, he noted that all three nations will need to expand their naval infrastructure\, as post-Cold War workforce retirements in the U.S. have led to a significant reduction in available submarine designers and maintainers. \nCmde. Singh also addressed potential impediments to AUKUS implementation. He highlighted serious maintenance backlogs in the U.S. submarine fleet\, which have led to a decline in the number of ready submarines from 40 to 32. The transfer of Virginia-class SSNs to Australia is constrained by the declining U.S. SSN inventory and existing bottlenecks in Virginia-class production. The Virginia-class payload module\, intended to enhance deterrence capabilities\, may face delays\, impacting the overall effectiveness of AUKUS. He further explored how the transfer of submarines to Australia might affect the U.S. Navy’s deterrence posture in the Indo-Pacific. \nThe discussion also touched upon broader U.S.-China dynamics and the potential for a G-2 redux under a different U.S. administration. The impact of a Trump 2.0 Presidency on Indo-Pacific security was examined\, including the risks of a transactional approach to alliances\, potential tariff escalations\, and shifts in U.S. strategic priorities. \nIn his concluding remarks\, Cmde. Abhay Kumar Singh reiterated that AUKUS has largely maintained its course\, with tangible progress seen in legislative approvals and collaborative frameworks. However\, he noted that AUKUS is at a critical inflexion point\, requiring sustained political commitment and industrial capacity-building. The upcoming U.S. National Defense Authorisation Act (NDAA) for FY 2025-26 will be a key factor in determining the future of AUKUS. He stressed that maintaining a balance between military preparedness and diplomatic engagement will be crucial for ensuring that AUKUS contributes positively to regional stability. The discussion provided a comprehensive understanding of how AUKUS is shaping global security and what steps are necessary to sustain its strategic momentum in the Indo-Pacific. \nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy in his remarks addressed concerns regarding AUKUS and highlighted the dominant role of the United States in the partnership. He emphasised that AUKUS is essentially an extension of U.S. foreign policy\, with its future trajectory closely tied to American strategic interests. He noted that it is logical for the U.S. to maintain a rotational presence in the region\, reinforcing its security posture. Additionally\, he pointed out that Australia has already made substantial investments in hosting U.S. personnel and has committed further resources to support this security arrangement. \nThe session concluded after an insightful exchange of views between scholars during the Q&A session. \nThe Report was prepared by Ms. Brahmshakti\, Intern\, Defence Economics and Industry Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-monday-morning-meeting-on-reassessing-aukus-in-trump-2-0
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T021831
CREATED:20250523T034637Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072229Z
UID:92500-1742189400-1742189400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report on Emerging Arctic Security Dynamics
DESCRIPTION:MP-IDSA hosted a talk on Emerging Arctic Security Dynamics featuring Dr. Andreas Østhagen\, Senior Research Fellow at the Fridtjof Nansen Institute\, Oslo\, and Dr. Andreas Raspotnik\, Director at the High North Center for Business and Governance\, Nord University\, Bodø\, Norway. The event took place on 17 March 2025. The discussion was moderated by Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\, Senior Fellow and Coordinator NTS Centre. \nDetailed Report\nDr. Sinha opened the session by introducing the speakers and highlighting key aspects of the ongoing geopolitical shifts in the Arctic. In his opening remarks\, he emphasised MP-IDSA’s pivotal role in shaping India’s Arctic Policy\, noting the Institute’s longstanding commitment to Arctic research. He recalled that in 2012\, MP-IDSA published the first-ever ‘Special Issue’ on the Arctic in its flagship journal\, Strategic Analysis\, featuring contributions from renowned global experts. He further highlighted that\, after more than a decade\, the Institute released another ‘Special Issue’ on the Arctic in December 2024\, now available online. Dr. Sinha acknowledged the valuable contributions of Arctic scholars from the Fridtjof Nansen Institute (FNI) to this latest publication. Stressing the importance of continued collaboration\, he underscored the need to strengthen ties between FNI and MP-IDSA to advance Arctic research further. \nFollowing these remarks\, Dr. Sinha invited Dr. Østhagen to begin his presentation. \nDr. Andreas Østhagen\, began his presentation with a geographical overview of the Arctic\, setting the stage for a discussion on its evolving landscape. He pointed out scientific projections indicating that the Arctic could become ice-free by 2050\, a development that brings both opportunities and challenges with far-reaching implications for global geopolitics and state relations. Turning to India’s Arctic interests\, Dr. Østhagen highlighted the six pillars of India’s Arctic policy\, emphasising the vast potential for India-Norway cooperation in the region. He underscored how these policy pillars could serve as a framework for strengthening bilateral engagement\, particularly in areas such as climate research\, sustainable development\, and strategic partnerships. \nIn the second part of his presentation\, Dr. Østhagen underscored the crucial role of geography in shaping both economic opportunities and emerging challenges in the Arctic. He stressed that any discussion on resource exploitation\, sea routes\, or extended continental shelf claims must begin with a fundamental question: “Which part of the Arctic are we referring to?” He illustrated this point by highlighting the stark contrasts within the region. The Russian Arctic\, he noted\, is vastly different from the Norwegian Arctic\, just as the Arctic territories of Canada\, the US\, and Europe each have distinct geographical characteristics. These variations\, in turn\, translate into unique challenges and opportunities—from resource distribution to shipping lanes and broader geopolitical implications. \nBy emphasising these regional differences\, Dr. Østhagen reinforced the idea that a one-size-fits-all approach to Arctic policymaking is neither practical nor effective. Instead\, he advocated for a more nuanced\, region-specific understanding to navigate the complexities of this rapidly evolving frontier. \nDelving into the geopolitical flashpoints of the Arctic\, Dr. Østhagen highlighted that the risk of real geopolitical tensions\, conflicts\, or contestations is significantly higher in the European Arctic compared to the North Pacific Arctic. He attributed this to several critical factors\, including: \n\nRussia-NATO strategic posturing in the GIUK gap (Greenland-Iceland-UK)\, a key maritime chokepoint.\nThe heavy militarisation of the region\, with 50–60% of Russia’s nuclear arsenal stationed in the Arctic.\nAn escalating arms race\, as both Russia and NATO ramp up the scale and frequency of military exercises in the region.\n\nDr. Østhagen further warned that Russia’s actions in the Arctic cannot be taken at face value. He pointed to Moscow’s growing cooperation with Beijing\, arguing that this evolving Russia-China nexus adds another layer of complexity to European security. The recent joint naval patrols by Russian and Chinese vessels near Alaska\, as well as their coordinated air patrols\, have set off alarm bells among NATO allies operating in the region. For Norway\, these developments present heightened security challenges making closer cooperation with NATO partners not just important\, but essential for ensuring stability in the Arctic. \nTouching on the ongoing debate surrounding Greenland\, Dr. Østhagen pointed out that while the US already maintains a military base there\, Greenland holds little strategic significance from a shipping perspective. He emphasised that much of the discourse around Greenland’s geopolitical importance tends to be overstated when viewed through the lens of Arctic trade routes. \nAs he wrapped up his presentation\, Dr. Østhagen shifted focus to Norway’s unique position in the Arctic. With a 200-kilometer-long border with Russia\, Norway has historically engaged in active cooperation with Moscow on various regional issues. Despite the current geopolitical climate\, he noted that some functional cooperation continues\, particularly in areas like fish stock management and Svalbard governance. While most Western nations have suspended formal collaborations with Russia\, Dr. Østhagen stressed the importance of maintaining a working relationship with Moscow in the Arctic\, recognising that regional stability requires ongoing dialogue. \nHe concluded by expressing optimism about India’s growing role in Arctic affairs and underscored the potential for deeper research collaborations between MP-IDSA and FNI. As India continues to expand its Arctic engagement\, he emphasised that fostering academic and policy-driven partnerships would be mutually beneficial. \nDr. Andreas Raspotnik began his presentation by echoing several key arguments made by his colleague\, emphasising that geography remains central to understanding the Arctic. He stressed that for Arctic scholars\, it is crucial not only to analyse how non-Arctic states perceive the region but also to examine how Arctic nations themselves view it from their southern capitals—such as Oslo\, Helsinki\, and Stockholm\, which\, despite belonging to Arctic states\, are geographically removed from the Arctic itself. \nWhile security and geopolitics dominate global discussions on the Arctic\, Dr. Raspotnik argued that economic development\, demographic shifts\, and societal challenges must not be overlooked. These factors\, he noted\, are equally critical in shaping the Arctic’s future. \nBuilding on his colleague’s points\, he highlighted the importance of understanding how the Arctic impacts the Global South\, particularly India. One recurring theme in Arctic discourse\, he noted\, is its link to climate change—a phenomenon with far-reaching consequences for regions far beyond the Arctic itself. If climate change in the Arctic is indeed affecting the Global South\, what tangible actions are being taken—either in the Arctic or in the Global South—to address these challenges? This\, he emphasised\, is a question that demands greater scrutiny. \nIn the second part of his talk\, Dr. Raspotnik examined the decline of ‘Arctic exceptionalism’\, the idea that the Arctic had remained insulated from global geopolitical tensions. He argued that this notion has faded significantly since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine\, as cooperation within the Arctic Council has largely stalled. \nLooking ahead\, he suggested that the future of the Arctic will be shaped by geopolitical developments far beyond its borders. He underscored the importance of understanding how non-Arctic states\, like India\, perceive the ongoing power shifts and strategic alignments in the region. \nDr. Raspotnik also pointed to Finland and Sweden’s accession to NATO\, which has further complicated the Arctic’s security landscape. This shift\, he noted\, has introduced new dynamics that will influence the region’s strategic calculus for years to come. \nConcluding his remarks\, Dr. Raspotnik highlighted India’s growing role on the global stage\, arguing that its relationships with Russia\, its observer status in the Arctic Council\, and its leadership in international affairs make India’s future involvement in the Arctic more significant than ever before. As the Arctic undergoes profound geopolitical\, economic\, and environmental transformations\, India’s perspective and engagement will be crucial in shaping the region’s trajectory. \nQuestions and Comments\nDuring the Q&A session\, Mr. Arvind Khare invited the speakers to delve deeper into the social and demographic aspects of Arctic indigenous communities in the Norwegian Arctic\, highlighting the importance of understanding their evolving challenges and resilience in a rapidly changing environment. \nCapt. Anurag Bisen from the Vivekananda International Foundation posed a thought-provoking question on the ‘Norwegianisation of Svalbard\,’ seeking insights into the political and governance dynamics shaping the archipelago. He further inquired whether the Antarctic Treaty Consultative Meeting (ATCM) model could be applied to Svalbard to regulate research and governance in the region. \nIn response\, Dr. Østhagen and Dr. Raspotnik provided in-depth perspectives\, addressing the complexities of indigenous identity\, governance structures\, and international legal frameworks influencing the Arctic. \nThe session concluded with a concise summary by the chair\, encapsulating the key discussions and insights shared. \nReport prepared by Dr. Bipandeep Sharma\, Research Analyst\, Non-Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-on-emerging-arctic-security-dynamics
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR