BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20240101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T021843
CREATED:20250312T224043Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072540Z
UID:87844-1740979800-1740979800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “Japan’s Territorial Disputes and their Management”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Arnab Dasgupta\, Research Analyst\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “Japan’s Territorial Disputes and their Management” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 03 March 2025. The session was chaired by Ms. Simran Walia\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA. Scholars of the Institute attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nThe session provided a comprehensive analysis of Japan’s three key territorial disputes: the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands with China\, Takeshima/Dokdo with South Korea\, and the Northern Territories with Russia\, which are critical to regional security and international relations. These disputes not only shape Japan’s foreign policy but also influence military dynamics\, diplomatic negotiations\, and economic interactions in the Indo-Pacific. \nDetailed report\nIn her opening remarks\, Ms. Simran Walia provided a historical overview of territorial disputes between Japan and its neighbours\, examining their implications for the parties involved. She highlighted how these territorial disputes have contributed to increased military deployments and the securitisation of the region\, thereby intensifying geopolitical tensions and strategic competition. \nDr. Arnab Dasgupta opened his presentation with a historical analysis of the three primary territorial disputes Japan has with its neighbours. The three primary territorial disputes are the Senkaku/Diaoyu islands disputes between Japan and China\, the Takeshima/Dokdo island dispute between Japan and South Korea and the Northern Territories dispute between Japan and Russia. Japan’s territorial claims over the Senkaku Islands\, Takeshima/Dokdo\, and the Northern Territories are rooted in historical assertions and post-war treaty negotiations. Japan occupied the Senkaku Islands in 1895\, citing a lack of prior ownership\, and later regained control in 1972 following their use as a US test range in the immediate aftermath of the Second World War. Tokyo attributes renewed Chinese and Taiwanese claims to the 1969 Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East (ECAFE) report\, which highlighted potential resources in the region. Similarly\, Japan maintains that Takeshima/Dokdo was historically mapped in the late 16th century and disputes Korean records\, asserting that it was legally incorporated into Japanese territory in 1905. Despite US and UK support for Japan’s claim post-WWII\, Japan argues that South Korea’s occupation in 1952\, following the unilateral imposition of the Syngman Rhee Line\, was illegal. Meanwhile\, Japan views the Northern Territories as part of Hokkaido’s historical development\, emphasising their settlement and economic significance before the Soviet occupation. \nIn the second segment of his presentation\, he examined the current state and characteristics of Japan’s three key territorial disputes: the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands\, Takeshima/Dokdo\, and the Northern Territories. These disputes differ in intensity\, legal standing\, and geopolitical complexity. The Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute remains the most militarised\, marked by increasing Chinese military presence\, frequent air and sea incursions\, and strategic infrastructure placement within Japan’s Exclusive Economic Zone. While the U.S. position had previously been ambiguous\, the US – Japan Summit held on 7 February 2025 reaffirmed Washington’s security commitments under Article 5 of the US-Japan Security Treaty\, solidifying its stance on defending the islands. Takeshima/Dokdo\, under firm South Korean control\, is heavily militarised and entangled in historical grievances from the colonial period\, with Seoul rejecting arbitration since 2012. Fishing disputes have led to firing incidents\, while the US remains ambiguous in its position. The Northern Territories dispute with Russia is in diplomatic deadlock\, exacerbated by the impact of the Ukraine conflict and sanctions. It is the only disputed territory with a historical record of permanent residence of Japanese citizens. Russia maintains heavy militarisation and a firm stance on retention through gradual replacement of Japanese residents with Russian residents. Despite US historical support for Japan’s claim\, the dispute remains intractable. \nIn the third segment of his presentation he discussed how Japan has managed these three disputes. Japan’s management of its territorial disputes varies in strategy and intensity across the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands\, Takeshima/Dokdo\, and the Northern Territories. In the Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute\, Japan maintains a strong armed presence\, with the   Japan Coast Guard (JCG)\, Japan Maritime Self-Defence Force (JMSDF) and Japan Air Self-Defence Force (JASDF) actively countering Chinese incursions. Diplomatically\, Japan asserts its position in international forums while restricting access to the islands. In contrast\, Japan’s approach to Takeshima/Dokdo is largely diplomatic\, with limited effect. Local advocacy efforts\, such as Takeshima Day and educational initiatives\, aim to sustain Japan’s claim\, though differences in commitment between national and regional authorities are noted. The Northern Territories dispute sees significant local activism\, including museums\, social media campaigns\, and past people-to-people exchanges with Russia\, which ceased in 2019. However\, the growing divergence between Japan and Russia\, coupled with military tensions\, complicates resolution efforts. \nDr. Dasgupta concluded his presentation with possible future developments in these disputes. Japan’s approach to territorial disputes is shaped by pragmatic considerations\, particularly its military limitations. While the United States plays a significant role in Japan’s security strategy\, there is considerable scope for Japanese strategic autonomy in managing the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands and the Northern Territories. The Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute is expected to remain a key flashpoint; however\, China has shown signs of accommodation in line with improving Japan-China relations. Additionally\, Japan’s emphasis on soft power and people-to-people exchanges\, particularly in the Northern Territories and to a limited extent in Takeshima/Dokdo\, offers valuable lessons for other nations. The Takeshima/Dokdo dispute exemplifies the importance of securing a ‘first-mover advantage’ in territorial claims. \nQuestions and Comments\nFollowing the presentation\, the floor was opened for questions and comments. Scholars raised inquiries regarding the implications of these disputes on regional stability. Ms. Simran Walia\, as the moderator\, inquired about the potential impact of international frameworks such as the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (Quad) on managing Japan’s territorial disputes and the role Japan plays within this framework. Group Captain (Dr.) R.K. Narang (Retd.) raised a question regarding the lessons India could draw from these geopolitical dynamics\, specifically comparing the approaches adopted by India and China in managing their disputes to those employed by Japan and China. Additionally\, Dr. Mayuri Banerjee enquired about the implications of the recent US commitment to the defence of the Senkaku Islands questioning its strategic significance in signaling to China. She further inquired why such an agreement was introduced at a time when relations between China and Japan appeared to be improving. \nDr. Arnab Dasgupta responded to the comments and the questions raised by MP-IDSA scholars as follows: The Senkaku Islands remain a critical component of the Indo-Pacific security architecture\, as they form a key part of the first island chain that regulates access to the Western Pacific and aligns with the core military interests of the United States. Regarding the role of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (Quad) in territorial disputes\, it was noted that the Quad does not have a direct role in such matters due to its primary focus on providing public goods\, including maritime domain awareness\, open land networks\, healthcare\, and connectivity. Given its current framework\, the Quad does not engage in bilateral territorial disputes. \nIn the cases of the Takeshima and Northern Islands disputes\, public engagement through people-to-people exchanges and social media has played a significant role. Since Japan has limited political manoeuvrability on these issues\, it has opted to bring them into the public domain. This approach presents a potential strategy for India to consider\, as raising public awareness and encouraging civic involvement in territorial disputes could facilitate constructive engagement and possible resolutions. Furthermore\, while there have been occasional backchannel discussions\, formal mechanisms remain lacking due to periodic communication breakdowns between Japan and China. This starkly contrasts with the India-China dispute management approach. \nAdditionally\, the recent commitment by the US is perceived as a strategic signal to both Beijing and Tokyo\, emphasising the necessity of operating within defined geopolitical limits. The timing of this aligns with Trump’s broader strategy of encouraging US allies to assume a greater share of their security responsibilities. This shift indicates an expectation for Japan to take a more proactive role in the defence of the Senkaku Islands. \nThe report was prepared by Ms. Alvina A. Almeida\, Intern\, East Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-japans-territorial-disputes-and-their-management
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T021843
CREATED:20250318T065026Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072413Z
UID:89047-1740979800-1740979800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of talk by Shri Rajiv Malhotra on 3 March 2025 at MP-IDSA
DESCRIPTION:Shri Rajiv Malhotra\, a prominent Indian-American author\, public intellectual\, and founder of Infinity Foundation\, who has significantly influenced discussions on India-US relations and Indian culture in the global context\, spoke on ‘Trump and India’ at the talk held on 03 March 2025. The session was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA. Scholars of the Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nShri Rajiv Malhotra characterised the Trump administration as strategically focused on dismantling the “deep state” and DEI initiatives while implementing corporate-style efficiency in government operations. He anticipated an “America First” approach that may include a pragmatic power-sharing arrangement with China and a strategic realignment with Russia. For India\, he identified critical challenges: the country must transition from “renting out” tech talent to building indigenous technological capabilities\, assert regional leadership more effectively\, and strategically leverage its geography and Russia relationship in negotiations with the U.S. \nDetailed Report\nAmbassador Chinoy introduced the speaker Shri Rajiv Malhotra and highlighted his expertise on India-U.S. relations and the evolving global order\, noting his background in technology and commitment to indigenous strategic thought. \nAmb. Chinoy discussed how India has historically been interpreted through Western lenses for hundreds of years\, particularly during colonisation\, and emphasised the importance of now viewing India through its own cultural and strategic perspectives. He shared a personal anecdote about how Western scholars refused to provide endorsements for books focused on India’s strategic autonomy and Vedic foundations of Indian strategic thought\, which challenged Western academic norms. \nShri Malhotra began by sharing his background as a computer scientist with early studies in artificial intelligence during the 1970s when the field was largely theoretical. After working as a technical expert in the industry with approximately 20 companies\, he transitioned to working with a foundation focused on simulation spaces in the early 1990s. \nThe speaker discussed his observations from being granted access to Trump’s transition team in Washington during the days before the presidential inauguration. He characterised the Trump administration as strategic rather than chaotic\, populated by young\, sophisticated\, and tech-savvy professionals who are likely to remain influential beyond a single term. He suggested that this could represent a 12-year political wave rather than a temporary shift\, indicating that young people in Trump’s team who have already faced primaries\, would contest future elections\, and are very likely to win. \nA central focus of the Trump administration\, according to the speaker\, was dismantling what they call the “deep state” and challenging diversity\, equity\, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives that he believed have undermined American competitiveness. He suggested that under Trump\, with mass firings and implementation of corporate efficiency practices through the “Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE)” would lead to significant restructuring of government agencies. \nThe speaker predicted increased reliance on technology in governance\, with formerly anti-Trump tech figures now aligning with the administration. They anticipate a government that is “smarter\, more tech-driven” but potentially “less human\,” with algorithms replacing human decision-making in many areas. \nRegarding international relations\, the speaker predicted an “America First” approach would lead to a strategic rebalancing where Russia might be approached differently than during previous administrations. Drawing historical parallels to the Nixon-Kissinger strategy of decoupling China from the USSR\, he speculated that Trump might attempt to separate Russia from its alliance with China. He considered various scenarios for U.S.-China relations\, including potential conflict but also the possibility of a pragmatic power-sharing arrangement where the two countries divide global influence. He suggested that Trump\, as a “deal maker\,” might be open to a duopoly agreement with China rather than sustained confrontation. \nIn terms of implications for India\, the speaker identified several challenges and opportunities in this new landscape. He critiqued India’s approach of “renting out” its tech talent through outsourcing rather than building its own technological products and infrastructure. He suggested India should position its engineering workforce as a strategic asset in competition with China rather than merely seeking H-1B visas. \nThe speaker advised India to identify specific strategic “cards” it can bring to negotiations with the U.S.\, including potential influence in Bangladesh and other regional matters. He warned that India will likely face pressure to lower tariffs on American goods\, which could disrupt local industries\, and may experience pressure to purchase American weapons systems instead of Russian ones. \nThe speaker also noted that Christian right influences in the Trump administration might create tensions around religious missionary activities in India. He further mentioned that the aerospace sector will likely be prioritised\, with potential opportunities for collaboration. \nIn the domain of technology and labour markets\, the speaker raised concerns about rapid technological change causing labour market disruptions globally. He suggested that automation and Artificial Intelligence advancements are happening so quickly that job displacement and creation are occurring within 5-10 years rather than over generations\, potentially leading to significant social disruption. He speculated this might even lead to arguments for depopulation as technological efficiency reduces the need for large human workforces. \nThroughout the talk\, he emphasised the need for strategic thinking about the intersection of technology\, governance\, and international relations in a rapidly changing global landscape. \nQ&A Session\nThe Q&A session began with questions about Shri Malhotra’s characterisation of the “deep state” and its relationship to the Trump administration. Shri Malhotra clarified that every country needs a “deep state” as the infrastructure of machines\, administration\, and institutions that survive surface government changes. However\, he argued that the current American deep state has evolved beyond government entities to include NGOs\, universities\, and organisations like Planned Parenthood that promote specific ideological agendas. According to him\, the deep state has been the subject of criticism for many years\, with opposition gradually building over time rather than suddenly emerging under Trump. \nWhen questioned about how current DEI policies differ from previous affirmative action initiatives\, the speaker distinguished between individual-level and group-level approaches to diversity. He explained that earlier forms of affirmative action\, supported by figures like Martin Luther King Jr.\, emphasised individual equality rather than group-based rights. The speaker characterised modern DEI as a “collective bargaining medium” influenced by critical race theory\, which they described as a new manifestation of Marxism that categorises people by race\, sexual orientation\, and religion rather than solely by economic class. This shift\, he argued\, creates dangerous group-level divisions in society. \nRegarding free speech concerns\, the speaker clarified that the current battle for free speech is primarily focused within the United States rather than being imposed internationally. He described how certain ideological positions claim that those categorised as “oppressors” should be denied free speech through mechanisms like “cancel culture\,” preventing certain voices from being heard in academic and public settings. The speaker presented this as a destructive approach to speech that the Trump administration is opposing\, but noted this is primarily a domestic American issue. \nThe Q&A explored potential scenarios for U.S.-China relations\, with the speaker suggesting that while they may not become friends\, they might develop a pragmatic arrangement dividing global spheres of influence. Drawing historical parallels to how France and Britain competed while also collaborating\, the speaker proposed that both China and the U.S. are pragmatic powers that might negotiate spheres of influence with continued competition in “grey areas.” This arrangement could affect India’s position in the global order\, with the speaker questioning whether India truly qualifies as a “tier one power” with a seat at the decision-making table. \nSeveral questions focused on India’s strategic position and assets in negotiations with the United States. The speaker emphasised that India’s geography is a significant card but noted that India has failed to assert regional leadership in its neighbourhood\, pointing to situations in Bangladesh\, Nepal\, and Myanmar where India did not effectively establish itself as the dominant regional power. He cited India’s continued relationship with Russia despite international pressure as a valuable strategic asset. The speaker also reiterated his critique of India’s approach to technical talent\, arguing that by sending skilled workers to American companies only to later license back the resulting technologies\, India is failing to develop its own technological infrastructure and intellectual property. \nThe discussion further highlighted differences between India’s and China’s approaches to technology development. While both countries initially leveraged inexpensive labour (China in manufacturing\, India in services)\, the speaker suggested that China strategically reinvested profits into developing proprietary technologies and future capabilities. He noted that China’s government directed companies to invest significant portions of their earnings in R&D\, whereas India allowed short-term profit-taking without similar requirements for reinvestment. The speaker suggested that even with India’s different political system\, the government could have implemented policies such as taxes on exported talent to fund domestic R&D or created a more robust equivalent to the American DARPA (Defence Advanced Research Projects Agency)\, which has successfully developed numerous transformative technologies. \nThroughout the Q&A\, the speaker maintained that understanding these dynamics is crucial for India to strategically position itself in a changing global order\, where technological capability increasingly determines national power and influence. \nReport prepared by Ms. Khyati Singh\, Research Analyst\, North America and Strategic Technologies Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-talk-by-shri-rajiv-malhotra-on-3-march-2025-at-mp-idsa
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR