BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20240101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250804T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250804T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T012011
CREATED:20250829T061849Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T053917Z
UID:93539-1754285400-1754285400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of the Monday Morning Meeting on “Nepal – The Making of an Inclusive Constitution: Demands\, Debates\, Dissents”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Nihar Ranjan Nayak\, Research Fellow at the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, presented his book Nepal – The Making of an Inclusive Constitution: Demands\, Debates\, Dissents\, Pentagon Press LLP\, 2025 during the Monday Morning Meeting held on 04 August 2025. The session was moderated by Ms. Sneha M\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA\, and Dr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, served as the Discussant. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA and scholars of the Institute attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nDespite the conclusion of a protracted political transition\, the 2015 Nepalese Constitution was criticised for failing to achieve true inclusivity. Using his book as a guide\, Dr. Nayak examined the development of Nepal’s Constitution\, the ongoing marginalisation of groups like the Madhesis and Janajatis\, and the interaction between internal politics and external forces. The presentation evaluated the nature and objectives of different socio-political movements\, the difficulties in integrating ethnic diversity\, and the structural flaws in the constitution-drafting process. It also assessed the geopolitical ramifications of Nepal’s constitutional discussions and the Maoist movement’s calculated outreach to underprivileged groups. The development of new dissident groups\, the partial success of Nepal’s peace process\, and the necessity of ongoing communication and inclusive governance to ensure long-term political stability\, were reflected upon.  \nDetailed Report\nDr. Nayak began his presentation by describing the political history of Nepal’s transition to a Federal Democratic Republic\, highlighting the seven-year process that resulted in the adoption of the 2015 Constitution and the election of the country’s second Constituent Assembly (CA-II). He acknowledged the important political turning points but maintained that the constitution was not truly inclusive\, especially when it came to meeting the demands of historically marginalised groups like Janajatis and the Madhesis. Based on his in-depth research\, Dr. Nayak clarified that the movements spearheaded by these communities were centred on calls for federal restructuring\, cultural recognition\, and proportional representation. He pointed out that during the civil war\, the Maoist movement had strategically allied itself with these organisations\, only to weaken its pledges once it entered the political mainstream. \nThe Speaker also delved into Nepal’s constitutional history\, pointing out the discriminatory clauses in previous versions and highlighting four significant movements that influenced the call for inclusivity: the Janajati movement\, the pro-democratic movement of Nepali Congress\, the Maoist movement\, and the Madhesi movement. He made it clear that his research does not address the six constitutions that came before it\, but only the 2015 Constitution\, its framework\, and the controversy surrounding its adoption. Press releases\, media reports\, stakeholder interviews\, and other primary and secondary sources are all incorporated into the book’s exploratory methodology. \nThe role of external actors was specifically highlighted. China’s measured involvement\, the United States (US)\, the European Union’s (EU) stances and India’s influence—shaped by proximity\, shared history\, and political engagement—were all discussed. The Speaker maintained that Nepal’s constitutional process was directly impacted by changes in the Indian Government in New Delhi\, particularly when it came to discussions on ethnic- federalism. He pointed out that a significant flaw\, which led to delays and deep-seated divisions\, was the lack of a reliable formal mediator during the drafting process. As presented by the Speaker\, the book’s thematic chapters explore the development of the Janajati and Madhesi movements\, the ethno-regional context of state discrimination\, the co-optation of marginalised leaders by dominant parties\, and the intricate relationship between identity politics and Maoist political tactics. It was highlighted that the process of drafting the constitution changed from reaching consensus to being a competitive process\, leading to a framework that left several grievances unresolved. \nWhile concluding his presentation\, Dr. Nayak stated that although Nepal’s peace process has made some progress\, important promises made in the Comprehensive Peace Agreement of 2006 have not been met. One possible destabilising factor was the resurgence of royalist organisations and other dissident forces. He concluded the session by urging continued political discourse\, inclusive governance and cautious handling of regional and ethnic ambitions in order to ensure the legitimacy and longevity of the constitution. \nDiscussant’s Remarks\nDr. Ashok K. Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, and Discussant\, began by highlighting Nepal’s complicated demographic makeup\, pointing out that the Janajatis and Paharis (hill upper caste groups) together make up almost 60 percent of the population and have long-standing political and economic power under the country’s constitution. He emphasised that genuine inclusivity is still elusive in Nepal despite its federal structure\, which consists of seven provinces\, 75 districts\, and several levels of government. Local governments only receive 25 percent of the national budget and 50 percent of tax revenues\, which restricts their ability to adequately meet local needs. In order to clarify how marginalised communities in Nepal frequently experience exacerbated disadvantages as a result of overlapping ethnic\, regional and caste identities\, Dr. Behuria expounded on the idea of intersectionality. He noted that although progressive concepts like intersectionality have been introduced by Nepal’s thriving intellectual community\, ruling elites frequently split these communities apart in order to keep political power. He also mentioned how Janajati leaders have frequently been co-opted into the political mainstream due to the influence of foreign organisations and political players. \nLater in the conversation\, Dr. Behuria also highlighted the need for more targeted studies on the effectiveness of Nepal’s federal system and the integration of marginal demands into governing frameworks. He emphasised that in order to guarantee accountability and effectiveness in governance\, ideas like the subsidiary principle—where decisions are made at the lowest competent level—are essential. \nQuestions and Comments\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, commended Dr. Nayak for his research and recommended that a comparative study between India and Nepal be included in subsequent editions of the work. He emphasised the connections between the Maoist movements in the two nations and pointed out that Nepal could learn a lot from India’s experience with inclusive development and decentralisation. Additionally\, Ambassador Chinoy noted that the two countries have structural parallels in caste\, religion\, and colonial legacies\, which make them ideal subjects for comparative political analysis. \nA research scholar in the audience asked how India’s military capabilities and bilateral relations with Nepal might be affected by the Indian Army’s decision to stop recruiting Gurkhas after the Agniveer scheme was implemented. In response\, Dr. Nayak pointed out that the Indian Army’s decision to stop hiring Gurkhas under the Agniveer program might have diplomatic and military ramifications. He emphasised that the Maoists in Nepal have long opposed Gurkha enlistment\, seeing it as exploitative\, and have included it in their 40-point demand since 1996. Especially during previous conflicts like the Kargil War\, when the deployment of Gurkha regiments sparked political debates in Kathmandu\, this opposition has fuelled anti-India sentiment in Nepal. Such actions could strain bilateral relations\, Dr. Nayak continued\, particularly given that India’s political engagement with various Nepali factions has frequently been uneven and occasionally seems to favour the Maoists over other parties like the Nepali Congress. \nGiven the administrative and economic difficulties federalism seems to be facing\, another research scholar posed a crucial question: is there a genuine chance for Nepal to further decentralise within its current federal system\, or would the nation be better off returning to a unitary structure? In response\, Dr. Nayak stated that although the Nepalese federal system has a number of operational issues\, going back to a unitary structure is neither practical nor wise. In order to meet the needs of Nepal’s diverse and historically marginalised communities\, he emphasised that federalism was a difficult political compromise. He maintained that in order to increase the effectiveness of federalism\, the emphasis should be on enhancing institutional capacity and true devolution of power rather than repealing it. \nAs the session came to an end\, Dr. Nayak emphasised that the Constitution of Nepal should not be viewed as a mere textual document but rather as a dynamic political tool that must change to reflect the will of the people. He emphasised that the ability of the Constitution to address the issues of all citizens\, particularly the marginalised\, is its true test. In light of Nepal’s complicated and frequently unstable political environment\, he emphasised the significance of inclusive governance and true implementation in order to guarantee that the Constitution acts as a responsive and unifying framework for the nation’s future. \nReport was prepared by Ms. Saanya Sidhra\, Intern\,\, South Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-the-monday-morning-meeting-on-nepal-the-making-of-an-inclusive-constitution-demands-debates-dissents
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250811T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250811T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T012011
CREATED:20250829T032416Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T053945Z
UID:93533-1754890200-1754890200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on recently published book "Mahabharata's Strategic Insights: Navigating the Dharmic Compass"
DESCRIPTION:On 11 August 2025\, at the Monday Morning Meeting Col. Vivek Chadha (Retd.)\, Senior Fellow\, Military Affairs Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute of Defence Studies and Analysis spoke on his recently published book Mahabharata’s Strategic Insights: Navigating the Dharmic Compass\, (Pentagon Press LLP\, 2025). Dr Ashok Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, South Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA moderated the session. Dr. Saurab Mishra\, Research Fellow\, Africa\, Latin America\, Caribbean\, & UN (ALACUN) Centre\, MP-IDSA was the discussant. \nDetailed Report\nIn his opening remarks\, Dr. Ashok Behuria described the Mahabharata as a dynamic text that evolved between 500 BCE and 400 CE\, integrating diverse literary and cultural influences. Initially composed as Jaya (8\,800 verses)\, it expanded to Bharata (24\,000 verses) and ultimately became the Mahabharata\, containing about 100\,000 verses across 18 books and 1\,356 chapters. He noted that compilers likely borrowed from multiple contemporary texts\, embedding sociocultural elements to reflect the ethos of different periods. \nDr. Behuria highlighted that among its vast contents\, the Bhagavad Gita emerged as the most influential section. Krishna’s teachings emphasise Dharma as context-specific rather than absolute\, adaptable to circumstances.  He concluded his opening remarks stating that Mahabharata’s philosophical relativism—where the same principle may be upheld in one context and rejected in another—offers layered ethical insights\, sustaining its relevance. \nCol. Vivek Chadha (Retd.) began his talk on his book\, Mahabharata Strategic Insights: Navigating the Dharmic Compass\, by highlighting how the epic’s multidimensional character— encompassing religious\, spiritual\, philosophical\, and strategic aspects—offer guidance for leadership and statecraft. He categorically stated that his work focused on principles rather than fixed solutions. \nThe Mahabharata\, according to Col. Chadha\, is a tool to guide future decision-making through its deep insights. It aligns with a renewed institutional and governmental interest in indigenous strategic thought. However\, he highlighted that MP-IDSA has conducted similar research for over 15 years\, with the Mahabharata offering a unique convergence of spirituality\, philosophy\, and strategic affairs. \nCol. Chadha highlighted that his primary source of the text is the English translation of the Critical Edition by Bibek Debroy (2010–2015) that is based on the Bhandarkar Oriental Research Institute’s Sanskrit edition (1919–1966). He stated that the study deliberately avoided multiple competing versions and focused on a single edition. The research focuses on the following core themes: \n\nDharma as a Strategic Foundation – Principles remain constant\, but their application is situational and subject to personal interpretation.\nKrishna’s Strategic Decision-making – Case studies reveal unmatched clarity and adaptability in strategic choices.\nApproach to War – Derives a framework for assessing war\, ways of war avoidance and its constituents for achieving victory. The book also presents a comparative analysis with the Arthashastra and Nitishastra demonstrating continuity in Indian strategic thought.\n\nHe explained that the Mahabharata reflects a five-stage decision cycle—threat identification\, evaluation of options\, choice\, action\, and review—which mirrors modern processes but derives its strength from the quality of evaluation and adherence to guiding principles. The talk also contrasted finite objectives with the Bhagavad Gita-inspired infinite approach\, which advocates pursuing long-term purposes with detached perseverance—particularly relevant in counter-terrorism and protracted conflicts. \nCol. Chadha outlined a strategic framework derived from the Mahabharata: \n\nObjective: Protection and prosperity.\nPreference: Avoid war where possible; if unavoidable\, prepare fully and aim to win.\nAlignment: Ancient strategic logic remains consistent with modern frameworks.\n\nThis framework is further explained through an Ends–Means–Ways correlation: \n\nEnds: Yogakshema (security and welfare).\nMeans: The seven resources available to the state (saptanga).\nWays: Execution during war and peace to ensure the effective application of resources towards objectives.\n\nOn the application of force\, Col. Chadha described it as a spectrum—from deterrence to decisive action—requiring careful calibration to context\, as both excess and insufficiency can undermine objectives. \nKey takeaways from his analysis include: \n\nStrategic thought is timeless; application must adapt to circumstances.\nDharma serves as a compass for personal and professional conduct.\nThe infinite approach fosters resilience and vision.\nProsperity and protection are complementary\, not competing\, goals.\nWar avoidance is ideal; preparedness is essential.\nDeterrence depends on demonstrable capability.\nAncient strategic logic parallels modern practice.\n\nFuture research avenues identified by Col. Chadha include tracing links between ancient\, medieval\, and modern Indian strategic thought; assessing continuity in strategic culture beyond the Mahabharata; and exploring the relevance of Dharma Yuddha to modern laws of armed conflict and rules of engagement. \nDr. Saurabh Mishra described the book authored by Col. Chadha as a timely contribution to indigenous strategic thought\, addressing a long-standing gap in linking the epic to modern decision-making. While previous works\, such as Strategic Choices\, Ethical Dilemmas: Stories from the Mahabharat by Aruna Narlikar\, Amitabh Mattoo and Amrita Narlikar touched on negotiations or moral dilemmas\, they remained introductory; this book offers a consolidated\, detailed framework. \nHe highlighted the infinite approach as the core conceptual innovation—advocating holistic\, long-term strategy over finite\, short-term actions\, contrasted with Western models through cases like Vietnam and Afghanistan. The book’s integration of Mahabharata narratives with contemporary issues\, including counter-terrorism\, was praised for clarity and relevance. \nEmphasising dharma as a strategic compass aligning intent and endeavour\, Dr. Mishra said the work provides a robust foundation for future research on the epic’s strategic dimensions and will serve as a bridge for subsequent scholarship. \nQ/A Session\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, asked about the practical relevance of the book to contemporary challenges and whether comparisons could be drawn with Oriental traditions like Confucianism and Taoism. Col. Chadha affirmed the continued relevance of the infinite approach—emphasising flexibility\, self-preservation\, and long-term vision. He noted similarities between ancient Chinese strategic thought and the Mahabharata\, suggesting that a comparative study of Oriental and Western approaches under different circumstances would be valuable. \nDr. Arnab Dasgupta\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA\, inquired whether the Mahabharata War led to a “dharmic world order” and if such principles could inform a modern global order. Col. Chadha explained that post-war\, there was no lasting ideal state; social decline was evident. Instead of replicating the post-war order\, the focus should be on applying principles from the text\, such as those in the Bhagavad Gita\, to governance and order today. \nDr. Adil Rasheed\, Research Fellow\, MP-IDSA asked about the influence of the Mahabharata and Gita on figures like Shivaji and Mahatma Gandhi\, and whether anti-state groups claiming moral legitimacy could be seen as acting under dharma. Col. Chadha agreed on the value of studying the epic’s influence on later leaders but rejected the analogy between dharma and violent extremist groups\, stating that genuine dharma is incompatible with terrorism. \nGp. Capt. (Dr.) R.K. Narang (Retd.)\, Senior Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, asked how these strategic insights could be made more accessible to policymakers. Col. Chadha said awareness is growing through publications and lectures\, but the gap between academic and public accessibility remains. Like the Panchatantra\, simplified formats are needed to bridge this gap. \nCol. (Dr.) Rajneesh Singh (Retd.) asked if the decision-making and force-application diagrams in the presentation were direct interpretations from the Mahabharata or modern constructs informed by it. Col. Chadha clarified that they are correlations\, not direct lifts\, intended to show that the essence of strategic thought existed in India and aligns with modern frameworks—countering claims that India lacks a strategic culture.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/mahabharatas-strategic-insights-navigating-the-dharmic-compass
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250818T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250818T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T012011
CREATED:20250917T224816Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T054021Z
UID:93724-1755495000-1755495000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “Headwinds in the Taiwan Strait: A View from Taipei”
DESCRIPTION:On 18 August 2025\, Dr. Prashant Kumar Singh\, Research Fellow and Coordinator of the East Asia Centre\, delivered a talk during the Monday Morning Meeting on “Headwinds in the Taiwan Strait: A View from Taipei”. The meeting was chaired by Dr. Abhishek K. Darbey\, Associate Fellow at MP-IDSA. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, and scholars of the Institute actively participated in the discussions. \nExecutive summary\nRelations between China and the self-ruled island of Taiwan have attracted much attention in international circles in recent years. While Chinese President Xi Jinping continues to espouse the inevitability of ‘peaceful reunification’\, Taiwan under its leader Lai Ching-te continues to take steps that China construes as provocative and leaning towards Taiwan’s ‘independence’. Dr. Prashant Kumar Singh undertook a survey of Taiwan’s current political and security landscape. He argued that Lai and his party\, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP)\, are engaged in a quest to redefine the island’s identity in a way that has attracted the ire of Beijing and that may not be without implications for its domestic politics and society. He noted that the recent internal political churn in Taipei has brought the general resilience of Taiwan’s democratic system under the scanner. He maintained that the political constellation in Taipei not only impacts cross-Strait ties but could have some impact for US-Taiwan ties as well. On the security front\, he showed that a section of Taiwanese analysts is pessimistic and views China deciding to take action for ‘reunification’ as a foregone conclusion\, though they do not agree on the timing. At the same time\, they differ from Western analysts by arguing for an all-out attack by Beijing’s forces.    \nDetailed report\nDr. Darbey commenced the meeting with a brief overview of the issues between China and Taiwan. Recounting the three Taiwan Strait Crises\, he noted that in recent times three interrelated factors have become relevant to the current state of affairs. The first factor is the continued emphasis by President Xi Jinping’s administration on a ‘peaceful reunification’ of Taiwan with China\, failing which all means at its disposal would be utilised. On the other hand\, the incumbent administration of Lai Ching-te and his party\, the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP)\, has in recent times taken actions that Beijing construes as leaning towards ‘independence’ of Taiwan. The final factor is the population of Taiwan\, which is caught between these two opposing forces but wants to maintain the status quo. These three factors\, according to Dr. Darbey\, interact to influence not only domestic politics\, but also Taiwan’s relations with the other superpower\, the United States of America. With this backdrop in mind\, he requested Dr. P.K. Singh to present his thoughts. \nAt the outset\, Dr. Singh explained that the content of his remarks would be based on his experience of Taiwanese society after a recent four-month stay there\, and that some of his arguments would revisit his published material concerning this period. He also noted that his remarks would also incorporate impressions gleaned during his field-trip and his interactions with local interlocutors. \nSurveying the recent state of cross-Strait relations\, Dr. Singh argued that until 2022\, tensions in the Taiwan Strait had by and large persisted at a low level. However\, then-US House of Representatives Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan in 2022 proved a turning point in cross-Strait relations\, as did the subsequent rise of Lai Ching-te in Taipei. At present\, the Speaker noted\, China is conducting a series of military exercises in the region surrounding Taiwan\, and grey zone activities (such as the severing of cables between Taiwan and the outlying island of Jinmen) have picked up pace. While business-to-business ties continue\, other forms of people-to-people contact\, particularly academic and cultural contacts\, have suffered. \nTurning to domestic policy changes\, Dr. Singh noted the transformative impact of Lai Ching-te by differentiating his approach from predecessors such as Chen Shui-bian and Tsai Ing-wen. Though they came from the same DPP that Lai belongs to\, which is widely perceived as having pro-‘independence’ proclivities\, they nevertheless engaged in the question of the nature of cross-Strait relations\, albeit in their own way. However\, Lai\, who has emerged out of the political rank-and-file of the DPP\, demonstrates a rigid stance on this issue. This is evident from his repeated references to ‘Taiwan’ in a way that purports to accentuate its separateness from Mainland China and parity with it\, coupled with expunging ‘Han Chinese’ as a distinct ethnic marker from the demographic profile of the Executive Yuan’s website. Such moves\, Dr. Singh noted\, may not resonate with the Taiwanese society. \nAccording to Dr. Singh\, another Lai-era policy initiative that has been viewed with some concern is his characterisation of China as a ‘hostile external threat’. The recent listing of 17 strategies to combat what it perceives as ‘red infiltration’ are\, according to Dr. Singh\, a sign of viewing the mainland through an exclusive security lens. Though he showed some understanding towards reasonable measures taken by Lai’s administration to clarify ‘citizenship’ requirements and maintain the sanctity and dignity of ‘citizenship’\, he nevertheless argued that the line between ‘permissible’ and ‘impermissible’ contacts with the mainland was difficult to clarify\, with ample scope for overreach. Thus\, apprehensions regarding the rule of law and freedom in Taiwan have a basis in fact\, especially given the ruling party’s aggressive approach towards the political opposition. \nDr. Singh then informed the audience that the opposition has taken up cudgels to protect itself. Tracing the roots of this confrontation to the January 2024 election of Lai\, he highlighted several key attempts by the opposition to undercut the administration’s quest for unanimity in its policy towards China. He related details of legislative moves by opposition parties\, who dominate the Legislative Yuan\, to criminalise contempt for its decisions\, an overreach that was swiftly overthrown by the judiciary. A later\, more successful\, move was the revision of three key laws governing judicial procedure\, budgetary allocation and election of public officials. \nIn response\, Dr. Singh revealed\, the DPP triggered the limited power available to it under Taiwan’s governing constitution. This would metamorphose into the ‘recall movement’\, whereby legislators from the opposition Kuomintang (KMT) would effectively be recalled by a public vote of no-confidence. However\, in a vote held on 26 July 2025\, 24 of 31 legislators slated for recall survived the challenge unscathed\, with a later round of voting for 7 legislators on 23 August expected to return the same results. Dr. Singh characterised these results as a vindication of Taiwan’s democratic resilience and as a sign of Taiwanese people’s preference for the status quo. \nGiving an overview of Taiwan’s defence preparedness\, the Speaker noted that the administration was motivated by a sense of ‘imminent threat’\, which a significant section of Taiwan’s population has given some support to. Briefly outlining steps such as the lengthening of conscription periods and the cultivation of whole-of-society resilience\, he informed the audience that during his recent visit a greater number of clearly-marked air defence shelters were visible\, which he interpreted as signs of preparedness. However\, he was sceptical about the effectiveness of increasing pools of reserve service persons. He also flagged the state of advancement in critical military technology like drone technology\, where Taiwan has a lot of ground to cover before it possessed effective drone capabilities. \nConcerning the probability of a Chinese invasion\, Dr. Singh assured the audience that the lion’s share of experts he had interacted with did not perceive an impending invasion\, though a section of them were quite pessimistic as to the long-term future of the island. These experts believe that while Taiwan could resist preliminary waves of the People’s Liberation Army (PLA)\, successive waves of attackers willing to accept high casualty rates would wear down Taiwan’s defences should the latter be deprived of external support. Others believe that China does not have the necessary capabilities to effect a forcible takeover and place faith in the deterrent effect of economic sanctions and political isolation to influence Chinese policymakers. He also shed light on an interesting fact\, namely\, that the Taiwanese do not subscribe to the much-touted ‘piecemeal’ escalation often propagated by Western sources. Instead\, they believe that any invasion attempt by Beijing would seek to capture the entire country in one go\, perhaps through the well-disguised ruse of a ‘military exercise’. \nOffering his views on US involvement\, the Speaker pointed out that continued US commitment to Taipei’s security remains the working assumption\, though scepticism regarding the intentions of President Donald Trump remains. Taiwanese analysts\, he related\, are quite bemused by President Trump’s treatment of traditional Asian allies. The US president’s ‘tariff war’ on Taiwanese exports has attracted concern\, especially as it is accompanied by a significantly-appreciated Taiwan Dollar. Meanwhile\, the increasing pressure on semiconductor manufacturers to ‘Make in America’ has also given rise to fears of a hollowing-out of Taiwan’s ‘Silicon Shield’\, which many in Taipei believe keeps them strategically relevant to Washington. It is also seen as the US’ desire to move strategic assets out of Taiwan. \nThe Speaker in his conclusion expressed uncertainty about whether China’s moves in the Taiwan Strait represented deterrence or compellence. He argued that Beijing had successfully restricted Taipei’s room for manoeuvre in the international space\, which has probably led the latter to fall into domestic ‘cacophony’. He apprehended that Taiwan’s increased internal political turbulence could unwittingly cause sections of the political forces there to violate China’s ‘red lines’ and trigger unwarranted Chinese intervention in unforeseen ways. US policy towards the region could also see a recalibration in the coming days\, which in turn could impact matters in the Strait. \nComments and questions\nExpressing his appreciation for the Speaker’s incisive presentation\, Dr. Darbey requested the Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, to deliver his remarks on the arguments presented. Amb. Chinoy\, congratulating the Speaker for his comprehensive presentation on the current state of Taiwanese politics and security\, noted that Beijing’s preference for the KMT seemed quite clear\, as the DPP’s actions presented a significant risk of rolling back gains made by the KMT in cross-Strait ties. As such\, it is only natural that public discontent is rising. Agreeing with the Speaker’s assessment Amb. Chinoy urged scholars to keep a close eye on the actions of the other superpower\, the US\, especially under President Trump. \nThough the failure to follow through on commitments to defend Taiwan from Chinese aggression would mark the end of a sustainable US posture in the Asia-Pacific and sow doubt regarding US intentions among long-standing allies such as Japan and South Korea\, Amb. Chinoy sought the Speaker’s opinion on the possibility that President Trump\, frustrated by the immovable obstacles facing his attempts to claim credit for resolving the Ukraine conflict and India-Pakistan tensions\, may choose to involve himself in dealmaking with China on the Taiwan issue. The Speaker concurred with this assessment\, adding that Taiwanese analysts too believe that US-China and US-Taiwan relations may witness changes in the times to come\, though they do not foresee US abandonment yet. China’s military moves primarily serve a deterrent purpose\, and if mutual accommodation between the US and China is reached\, along with a political change tolerable to Beijing within Taiwan in the coming years\, tensions in the Taiwan Strait may subside. \nAmb. Chinoy then queried whether Taiwan’s quest to seek membership of international organisations at a time when President Trump is mulling US withdrawal from the same would be conducive to the improvement of US-Taiwan relations. Dr. Singh replied that Taiwan’s presence is not expected to increase in the days to come\, but there may be limited acceptance by Beijing of some limited presence being retained by Taipei should forces more amenable to abiding by the 1992 Consensus\, in other words\, the “One China principle\, with respective interpretations”\, comes to power in Taipei. \nDr. Anand Kumar wished to understand the US interest in modulating cross-Strait relations\, especially given the context that Nancy Pelosi’s visit in 2022 may have been driven by personal political motives.  Dr. Singh replied that the US by and large would like that the level of tension in the Strait is manageable and does not spill over into open conflict. \nThis report was prepared by Dr. Arnab Dasgupta\, Research Analyst\, East Asia Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-headwinds-in-the-taiwan-strait-a-view-from-taipei
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250822T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250822T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T012012
CREATED:20250901T012234Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T054046Z
UID:93563-1755840600-1755840600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:MP-IDSA Fellows Seminar: Messianism – Concept\, Features and Geopolitical Manifestations
DESCRIPTION:The Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised a Fellows Seminar on 22 August 2025\, where Dr. Adil Rasheed\, Research Fellow\, presented his paper titled “Messianism: Concept\, Features and Geopolitical Manifestations.” The session was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA. Ambassador Talmiz Ahmad\, former Ambassador to Oman\, Saudi Arabia and the UAE\, and presently Distinguished Professor at Symbiosis International University\, Pune\, joined as the External Discussant. The Internal Discussant was Dr. Ashok Behuria\, Senior Fellow and Coordinator of the South Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA. \nExecutive Summary\nThe Seminar explored how the belief in a Messiah or a saviour figure at the end of times continues to shape politics\, societies\, and state behaviour. Dr. Rasheed argued that messianic ideas\, which include apocalyptic and utopian mythologies\, are not limited to religious beliefs but even influence modern nationalist\, ideological\, and secular movements. Drawing on examples from Iran\, Israel\, ISIS\, Pakistan\, US-based dispensationalists\, Russia\, and China\, he stressed that these narratives mobilise followers and leave a global geopolitical impact. The discussion highlighted the dangers of messianic myths when tied to power\, violence\, and geopolitics\, while also emphasising the need for careful analysis to distinguish between genuine theological traditions and opportunistic uses of such rhetoric. \nDetailed Report\nInitial Comments by the Chairperson \nAmbassador Sujan R.Chinoy \nIn his opening remarks\, Ambassador Chinoy explained that messianism is both a spiritual and a political force. While it inspires devotion\, history shows that it has also provoked wars and upheavals. He pointed out that the Abrahamic religions\, Judaism\, Christianity and Islam\, have been most associated with messianic traditions\, but these ideas have also influenced secular ideologies like Fascism\, Marxism\, and Neo-conservatism. He stated that Dr. Rasheed’s paper might help provide a framework to better understand how messianic themes might influence international geopolitics. \nPresentation by Dr. Adil Rasheed\nDr. Rasheed began by defining messianism as the belief in the arrival of a Messiah\, a redeemer who establishes justice and peace at the end of times. Though strongly present in the Abrahamic faiths\, he stressed that similar ideas have emerged across societies\, including secular thought. Movements such as Fascism and Marxism\, he argued\, drew on utopian and redemptive impulses that resemble religious salvation. \nDr. Rasheed explained how contemporary religious and political movements have woven messianic themes into their agendas. Examples include Salafi Jihadism\, Shia Mahdism\, Evangelical Dispensationalism\, Revisionist Zionism\, Neo-Conservatism and even Slavic nationalism. Once politicised\, these narratives do not remain abstract but influence state policy\, militant strategies\, and interstate relations. \nWest Asia\, he noted\, is one of the main theatres where such politics is visible. Iran’s former President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad invoked the Hidden Imam during his UN speech in 2005\, and Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei declared that Israel would not survive beyond 25 years. Tehran even installed a countdown clock in the capital to reinforce this message. While Iranian leaders claim to separate anti-Zionism from anti-Semitism\, the rhetoric still fuels fears of an eventual religious conflict. \nSunni groups also make use of such themes. ISIS portrayed itself as the beginning of a prophesied caliphate\, citing the Syrian town of Dabiq as the site of an end-time battle. By linking itself with apocalyptic prophecies\, the group tried to legitimise violence and attract recruits. \nDr. Rasheed then discussed how Jews\, despite being the originators of the messianic idea\, often became its greatest victims. He traced centuries of persecution\, from massacres in Alexandria in 38 CE\, to the Crusades\, expulsions from England\, France and Spain\, the Black Death pogroms\, the Spanish Inquisition\, Russian pogroms\, and ultimately the Holocaust. Even in modern Israel\, political leaders still draw on messianic themes. He mentioned Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s ties with Rabbi Menachem Schneerson\, who was revered as a messianic figure and had once predicted Netanyahu’s rise. Biblical references in Netanyahu’s speeches\, he said\, also illustrate how such narratives enter modern politics. \nDr. Rasheed further highlighted the role of Christian Zionism. In the United States\, many evangelicals believe support for Israel is essential for the fulfilment of prophecy and the Second Coming of Christ. This theological conviction has become politically influential\, shaping US foreign policy. Statements from leaders like US Senator Ted Cruz\, Dr. Rasheed argued\, reveal how messianic worldviews can translate into real political commitments. \nSouth Asia too is not free of these currents. In Pakistan\, both military and political elites have used religious prophecies such as Ghazwa-e-Hind to justify policies and rhetoric. General Asim Munir’s speech in April 2025\, shortly before the Pahalgam attack\, described Pakistan as a divinely ordained state\, which Dr. Rasheed said was evidence of messianic framing within its national identity. \nBeyond the region\, he also drew attention to Russia’s “Third Rome” idea\, neo-Nazi movements in Europe\, and aspects of Chinese strategic thought that sometimes present themselves in civilisational\, quasi-messianic terms. \nDr. Rasheed then explained the theological foundations of messianism in Judaism\, Christianity and Islam. For Jews\, the Messiah is a descendant of King David who will rebuild the Temple and restore Israel. For Christians\, Jesus Christ is already the Messiah\, whose Second Coming will bring the Kingdom of God. For Muslims\, Jesus is also the Messiah\, but his return will be preceded by the Mahdi. He briefly touched upon non-Abrahamic traditions too\, like the Hindu belief in the Kalki Avatar and the Buddhist expectation of Maitreya\, though he noted that these ideas have not yet taken militarised forms. \nHe drew on Anson Rabinbach’s typology of messianism\, restorative\, utopian\, apocalyptic and expectative. He contrasted quietist forms\, which wait for divine will\, with activist forms that seek to hasten the Messiah’s arrival through deliberate action\, even conflict. He concluded by noting that India must take these ideological undercurrents into account when dealing with states where such ideas shape political culture. \nComments by the External Discussant\nAmbassador Talmiz Ahmad \nAmbassador Ahmad began by recalling how his own study of messianism had grown out of research for his book Children of Abraham at War. He explained that he first turned to the subject while trying to understand why Judaism\, Christianity and Islam had been repeatedly caught in violent conflict. Through this\, he found the deep traditions of messianic expectation across all three. \nHe explained how Jewish messianic hopes were shaped by centuries of exile and persecution\, while European anti-Semitism\, from the Crusades to the Black Death\, fuelled repeated invocations of redemption. He then traced how Protestant premillennialism in the 19th Century laid the basis for Christian Zionism. For American evangelicals\, support for Israel became tied to their eschatological vision\, creating political alliances that were convenient for both sides. \nOn Islam\, he argued that messianism was historically less central but grew in importance after the Arab defeat in 1967. In times of despair\, he observed\, societies often turned to prophecy for hope. Still\, he stressed that groups like al-Qaeda were pragmatic and strategic rather than deeply messianic. Shia traditions around the Hidden Imam carried more weight\, but he warned against equating faith with politics. \nHe then offered a frank critique of the paper. He suggested that too many themes need not be grouped under messianism. Nationalism and racism\, he argued\, could not meaningfully be seen as messianic. He also felt that references to non-Abrahamic religions or leaders like Putin stretched the argument.  Instead\, he suggested\, the focus should remain on the Abrahamic core. \nHe further argued that messianism should not be overstated as the main driver of conflict. Geopolitics\, nationalism and identity are stronger forces\, with messianic rhetoric often serving as a tool rather than the cause. He gave examples such as George W. Bush’s religious imagery during the “War on Terror” and the selective use of scripture by Jewish extremists. \nIn conclusion\, he urged Dr. Rasheed to sharpen the framework\, distinguish clearly between theology and politics\, and avoid placing too many movements under one label. \nComments by the Internal Discussant\nDr. Ashok Behuria\nDr. Behuria\, began by emphasising that research in social sciences thrives on diverse perspectives rather than absolute truths. He praised Dr. Rasheed’s effort and argued that messianism should not be restricted to the Abrahamic religions alone. Non-Semitic traditions\, he noted\, also contain messianic themes. He pointed to the Bhagavad Gita\, where Lord Krishna promises to return in different eras to restore balance in favour of ‘Dharma’\, as an example. \nHe welcomed Dr. Rasheed’s reference to thinkers such as Carl Jung and Giorgio Agamben. Jung’s ideas of archetypes and the collective unconscious\, he noted\, offer a useful way to explain how symbols and myths continue to shape culture and politics. On Agamben\, he highlighted the distinction between “messianism” and “messianicity\,” as well as the notion of “inoperativity\,” which describes how existing structures can be suspended to allow new possibilities. \nAt the same time\, he advised that if the paper intends to go beyond Abrahamic cases\, then examples from Hinduism and Buddhism should be developed more fully\, rather than dealing with them briefly. He also noted that certain movements\, such as American Israel Public Affairs Committee (IPAC)\, were cited but not explained in detail. Expanding these\, he suggested\, would give the work a more balanced scope. \nHe concluded by describing the paper as a valuable primer on the subject and encouraged Dr. Rasheed to refine it further. \nQ & A Session\nDr. Rajiv Nayan praised the choice of topic but said the definition of messianism needed greater clarity. Was Dr. Rasheed restricting it to the Abrahamic faiths\, or taking it in a broader sense? He also urged that claims about its influence should be backed by data\, and asked whether messianic politics truly mobilises large groups today\, given declining religiosity in some societies. \nDr. Saurabh Mishra recommended a stronger methodology\, suggesting historical as well as contemporary analysis to show how messianic beliefs affect politics. He said exploring figures like Sri Krishnadevaraya could provide useful insights. \nDr. Arnab Dasgupta asked how a messianic leader or state might be identified in practice\, and how societies could move on after such leaders—a process he termed “demessianisation.” He also raised a question related to Pakistan\, pointing to General Asim Munir’s speeches after the Jaffar Express attack in March 2025\, where he used religious references.  He asked how such rhetoric should be situated within the broader framework of messianism. \nComments by the Chairperson \nThe Chairperson\, Ambassador Chinoy\, offered his reflections\, noting that while the paper should not become overextended\, parallels from history and ideology could be useful. He cited Donald Trump’s survival after an assassination attempt\, which he framed in religious language\, and the Spanish conquest of the Americas\, which carried strong messianic zeal. He contrasted this with the British Empire\, which avoided such religious fervour. He also referred to Marxism and Maoism as movements with utopian\, quasi-messianic claims. \nSharing further thoughts on the subject\, Ambassador Ahmad\, reminded the participants that religion has often been a tool of political mobilisation. He gave examples from the Crusades\, Nazi Germany\, Ahmadinejad’s presidency\, and Israel after 1967. He also drew parallels between Pakistan’s idea of itself as a “second Madina” and the Zionist project. He concluded that while messianic zeal persists\, it does not single-handedly drive global politics. \nDr. Rasheed responded to the questions and thanked the participants. \nReport was prepared by Mr. Harsh Yadav\, Intern\, West Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/mp-idsa-fellows-seminar-messianism-concept-features-and-geopolitical-manifestations
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250825T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250825T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T012012
CREATED:20250917T225546Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T054104Z
UID:93726-1756099800-1756099800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of the Monday Morning Meeting On “Locating Jordan in the Israel-Palestine Conflict”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Hirak Jyoti Das\, Research Analyst\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analysis (MP-IDSA)\, delivered a presentation on “Locating Jordan in the Israel-Palestine Conflict” during the Monday Morning Meeting held on 25 August 2025. Dr. Deepika Saraswat\, Associate Fellow at MP-IDSA\, moderated the session. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director-General of MP-IDSA\, attended the meeting\, along with scholars from the Institute. \nExecutive Summary\nThe presentation offered a detailed analysis of the role of Jordan in the Israel-Palestine dynamics and how it has navigated through the conflict. The discussion also covered the trends in Jordan’s Palestinian Policy\, ties with Israel\, position towards Hamas\, and its role in the Israel-Hamas War. The presentation also thoroughly covered Jordan’s concerns and its security cooperation with Israel. \nDetailed Report\nInitial Comments by the Moderator\nIn her opening remarks\, Dr. Deepika Saraswat noted that Jordan\, though often understudied\, has significant influence in West Asia. As one of the few monarchies outside the Gulf\, its strategic location gives it weight in regional affairs despite limited resources. She highlighted Jordan’s complex history with the Arab–Israeli conflict\, including its occupation of the West Bank from 1948 to 1967 and renunciation of claims in 1988\, while its custodianship of Islamic holy sites like the Al-Aqsa Mosque keeps it central to regional developments. Dr. Saraswat also noted Jordan’s security cooperation with Israel through the Peace Treaty\, while pointing out the challenge posed by the Israeli proposal\, supported by President Trump\, to displace Palestinians into Jordan. \nPresentation by Dr. Hirak Jyoti Das\nDr. Hirak Jyoti Das began his presentation by situating Jordan as a middle power with limited resources\, which has lacked a strong economic base\, with Jordan heavily relying on external support initially from Britain\, then from the United States (US). Despite being surrounded by powerful neighbours\, it has managed to protect its interests and ambitions beyond its capacity due to its pivotal role in Israel-Palestine dynamics and as a critical US ally. Jordan has maintained extensive ties and secret talks with Israel\, and it was the second Arab State after Egypt to sign a Peace Treaty with Israel in 1994. \nDr. Das explained that Jordan’s Palestinian policy has undergone key trends. After the 1948 Arab-Israel War\, Jordan integrated the West Bank\, including East Jerusalem\, granting citizenship to Palestinians to consolidate control. The loss of these territories in 1967 shifted policy toward preserving influence through custodianship of the Al-Aqsa Mosque\, constitutional claims\, and pro-Hashemite ties in the West Bank. The Palestinian Liberation Organisation (PLO)’s predominance in Palestinian affairs and anti-Jordanian sentiments during the 1987 Intifada led to disengagement from the West Bank in 1988. Jordan has preserved its influence in Israel-Palestine dynamics by focusing on safeguarding holy sites\, supporting the Palestinian Authority (PA)\, and advocating for a two-state solution. \nThe Speaker noted that Jordan’s ties with Israel have a long and complex history. King Abdullah I and the Hashemites maintained secret contacts with the Zionist movement\, sharing concerns over regional isolation and political vulnerability. After the 1948 war\, Jordan viewed Israel as a balance against Nasser’s Egypt and the spread of Pan-Arabism and Marxism\, which it saw as domestic threats\, while Israel trusted King Hussein as a partner and a useful buffer. Jordan and Israel signed a Peace Treaty in 1994\, leading to cooperation in security\, trade\, energy\, and water\, with trade rising from US$18 million to over US$300 million by 2024 and a 15-year energy deal signed in 2016. Nevertheless\, challenges persist over Israel’s attempts to weaken Jordan’s authority at Al-Aqsa Mosque and continuing diplomatic tussles. \nDr. Das opined that Jordan initially saw Hamas as a tool to counterbalance Fatah\, but the relationship soon worsened due to Hamas’ opposition to the Oslo Accords and Jordan’s Peace Treaty with Israel and use of violence to disrupt the peace process. After Hamas took Gaza in 2007\, Jordan’s engagement with the group remained limited. \nJordan’s role in the Israel-Hamas war\, reflects its delicate balancing act in the region. The country has consistently condemned violence and called for restraint. Dr. Das also mentioned the incident when Abdullah II\, King of Jordan\, was a vocal critic of Israel’s conduct and\, at the same time\, condemned the 7 October 2023 attack and kidnapping of Israelis. Jordan has undertaken diplomatic measures and humanitarian initiatives\, providing shelter\, medical aid\, and essential supplies to those affected\, often coordinating with international organisations. \nJordan’s key concern is the displacement of Palestinians\, backed by US President Donald Trump’s offer to rebuild Gaza. The conflict has led to an increase in radicalisation within Jordanian society\, boosting support for Hamas and armed resistance and political consolidation by the Islamic Action Front (IAF). \nDr. Das further noted that Jordan’s security cooperation with Israel is driven by its priority of state stability and the survival of the monarchy. Therefore\, Israel’s efforts to degrade Hamas’ military capabilities align with Jordan’s strategic interests. Jordan’s security\, trade\, and energy cooperation with Israel has remained intact during the ongoing war. Jordan values its peace treaty with Israel and has resisted calls to cancel it\, as this could weaken its stake in the Al-Aqsa Mosque\, reduce leverage in the West Bank\, limit its role in preventing displacement\, and threaten US$1.5 billion in US aid. \nQ/A Session\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General of MP-IDSA\, shared that Jordan’s influence declined after the 1920s when the Al Saud family took control of the Hijaz\, ending Hashemite authority over Mecca and Medina\, and was further limited by the Sykes-Picot Agreement\, though King Hussein Ben Ali’s sons briefly held wider regional influence. Today\, Jordan functions mainly as a buffer state\, balancing ties with the U.S.\, Britain\, Israel\, and the Palestinians\, while its large Palestinian-origin population and memories of Black September continue to shape internal policies. He highlighted Jordan’s role in regional security\, such as assisting in intercepting Iranian missiles aimed at Israel\, and stated that Jordan cannot act independently. It could serve in a supportive capacity to stabilise the region rather than leading solutions to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. \nMs. Saman Ayesha Kidwai\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA\, asked whether Jordan’s dual approach of supporting Palestinian rights while cooperating with Israel is becoming unsustainable amid rising domestic anger. She also asked if Hamas is genuinely committed to a two-state solution or focused on integrating Palestinians elsewhere. \nDr. Das made a note of the comments and replied to the questions. \nReport was prepared by Mr. Harsh Yadav\, Intern\, West Asia Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-the-monday-morning-meeting-on-locating-jordan-in-the-israel-palestine-conflict
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR