BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20240101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020504
CREATED:20250312T224043Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072540Z
UID:87844-1740979800-1740979800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “Japan’s Territorial Disputes and their Management”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Arnab Dasgupta\, Research Analyst\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “Japan’s Territorial Disputes and their Management” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 03 March 2025. The session was chaired by Ms. Simran Walia\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA. Scholars of the Institute attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nThe session provided a comprehensive analysis of Japan’s three key territorial disputes: the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands with China\, Takeshima/Dokdo with South Korea\, and the Northern Territories with Russia\, which are critical to regional security and international relations. These disputes not only shape Japan’s foreign policy but also influence military dynamics\, diplomatic negotiations\, and economic interactions in the Indo-Pacific. \nDetailed report\nIn her opening remarks\, Ms. Simran Walia provided a historical overview of territorial disputes between Japan and its neighbours\, examining their implications for the parties involved. She highlighted how these territorial disputes have contributed to increased military deployments and the securitisation of the region\, thereby intensifying geopolitical tensions and strategic competition. \nDr. Arnab Dasgupta opened his presentation with a historical analysis of the three primary territorial disputes Japan has with its neighbours. The three primary territorial disputes are the Senkaku/Diaoyu islands disputes between Japan and China\, the Takeshima/Dokdo island dispute between Japan and South Korea and the Northern Territories dispute between Japan and Russia. Japan’s territorial claims over the Senkaku Islands\, Takeshima/Dokdo\, and the Northern Territories are rooted in historical assertions and post-war treaty negotiations. Japan occupied the Senkaku Islands in 1895\, citing a lack of prior ownership\, and later regained control in 1972 following their use as a US test range in the immediate aftermath of the Second World War. Tokyo attributes renewed Chinese and Taiwanese claims to the 1969 Economic Commission for Asia and the Far East (ECAFE) report\, which highlighted potential resources in the region. Similarly\, Japan maintains that Takeshima/Dokdo was historically mapped in the late 16th century and disputes Korean records\, asserting that it was legally incorporated into Japanese territory in 1905. Despite US and UK support for Japan’s claim post-WWII\, Japan argues that South Korea’s occupation in 1952\, following the unilateral imposition of the Syngman Rhee Line\, was illegal. Meanwhile\, Japan views the Northern Territories as part of Hokkaido’s historical development\, emphasising their settlement and economic significance before the Soviet occupation. \nIn the second segment of his presentation\, he examined the current state and characteristics of Japan’s three key territorial disputes: the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands\, Takeshima/Dokdo\, and the Northern Territories. These disputes differ in intensity\, legal standing\, and geopolitical complexity. The Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute remains the most militarised\, marked by increasing Chinese military presence\, frequent air and sea incursions\, and strategic infrastructure placement within Japan’s Exclusive Economic Zone. While the U.S. position had previously been ambiguous\, the US – Japan Summit held on 7 February 2025 reaffirmed Washington’s security commitments under Article 5 of the US-Japan Security Treaty\, solidifying its stance on defending the islands. Takeshima/Dokdo\, under firm South Korean control\, is heavily militarised and entangled in historical grievances from the colonial period\, with Seoul rejecting arbitration since 2012. Fishing disputes have led to firing incidents\, while the US remains ambiguous in its position. The Northern Territories dispute with Russia is in diplomatic deadlock\, exacerbated by the impact of the Ukraine conflict and sanctions. It is the only disputed territory with a historical record of permanent residence of Japanese citizens. Russia maintains heavy militarisation and a firm stance on retention through gradual replacement of Japanese residents with Russian residents. Despite US historical support for Japan’s claim\, the dispute remains intractable. \nIn the third segment of his presentation he discussed how Japan has managed these three disputes. Japan’s management of its territorial disputes varies in strategy and intensity across the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands\, Takeshima/Dokdo\, and the Northern Territories. In the Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute\, Japan maintains a strong armed presence\, with the   Japan Coast Guard (JCG)\, Japan Maritime Self-Defence Force (JMSDF) and Japan Air Self-Defence Force (JASDF) actively countering Chinese incursions. Diplomatically\, Japan asserts its position in international forums while restricting access to the islands. In contrast\, Japan’s approach to Takeshima/Dokdo is largely diplomatic\, with limited effect. Local advocacy efforts\, such as Takeshima Day and educational initiatives\, aim to sustain Japan’s claim\, though differences in commitment between national and regional authorities are noted. The Northern Territories dispute sees significant local activism\, including museums\, social media campaigns\, and past people-to-people exchanges with Russia\, which ceased in 2019. However\, the growing divergence between Japan and Russia\, coupled with military tensions\, complicates resolution efforts. \nDr. Dasgupta concluded his presentation with possible future developments in these disputes. Japan’s approach to territorial disputes is shaped by pragmatic considerations\, particularly its military limitations. While the United States plays a significant role in Japan’s security strategy\, there is considerable scope for Japanese strategic autonomy in managing the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands and the Northern Territories. The Senkaku/Diaoyu dispute is expected to remain a key flashpoint; however\, China has shown signs of accommodation in line with improving Japan-China relations. Additionally\, Japan’s emphasis on soft power and people-to-people exchanges\, particularly in the Northern Territories and to a limited extent in Takeshima/Dokdo\, offers valuable lessons for other nations. The Takeshima/Dokdo dispute exemplifies the importance of securing a ‘first-mover advantage’ in territorial claims. \nQuestions and Comments\nFollowing the presentation\, the floor was opened for questions and comments. Scholars raised inquiries regarding the implications of these disputes on regional stability. Ms. Simran Walia\, as the moderator\, inquired about the potential impact of international frameworks such as the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (Quad) on managing Japan’s territorial disputes and the role Japan plays within this framework. Group Captain (Dr.) R.K. Narang (Retd.) raised a question regarding the lessons India could draw from these geopolitical dynamics\, specifically comparing the approaches adopted by India and China in managing their disputes to those employed by Japan and China. Additionally\, Dr. Mayuri Banerjee enquired about the implications of the recent US commitment to the defence of the Senkaku Islands questioning its strategic significance in signaling to China. She further inquired why such an agreement was introduced at a time when relations between China and Japan appeared to be improving. \nDr. Arnab Dasgupta responded to the comments and the questions raised by MP-IDSA scholars as follows: The Senkaku Islands remain a critical component of the Indo-Pacific security architecture\, as they form a key part of the first island chain that regulates access to the Western Pacific and aligns with the core military interests of the United States. Regarding the role of the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (Quad) in territorial disputes\, it was noted that the Quad does not have a direct role in such matters due to its primary focus on providing public goods\, including maritime domain awareness\, open land networks\, healthcare\, and connectivity. Given its current framework\, the Quad does not engage in bilateral territorial disputes. \nIn the cases of the Takeshima and Northern Islands disputes\, public engagement through people-to-people exchanges and social media has played a significant role. Since Japan has limited political manoeuvrability on these issues\, it has opted to bring them into the public domain. This approach presents a potential strategy for India to consider\, as raising public awareness and encouraging civic involvement in territorial disputes could facilitate constructive engagement and possible resolutions. Furthermore\, while there have been occasional backchannel discussions\, formal mechanisms remain lacking due to periodic communication breakdowns between Japan and China. This starkly contrasts with the India-China dispute management approach. \nAdditionally\, the recent commitment by the US is perceived as a strategic signal to both Beijing and Tokyo\, emphasising the necessity of operating within defined geopolitical limits. The timing of this aligns with Trump’s broader strategy of encouraging US allies to assume a greater share of their security responsibilities. This shift indicates an expectation for Japan to take a more proactive role in the defence of the Senkaku Islands. \nThe report was prepared by Ms. Alvina A. Almeida\, Intern\, East Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-japans-territorial-disputes-and-their-management
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250303T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020504
CREATED:20250318T065026Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072413Z
UID:89047-1740979800-1740979800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of talk by Shri Rajiv Malhotra on 3 March 2025 at MP-IDSA
DESCRIPTION:Shri Rajiv Malhotra\, a prominent Indian-American author\, public intellectual\, and founder of Infinity Foundation\, who has significantly influenced discussions on India-US relations and Indian culture in the global context\, spoke on ‘Trump and India’ at the talk held on 03 March 2025. The session was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA. Scholars of the Institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nShri Rajiv Malhotra characterised the Trump administration as strategically focused on dismantling the “deep state” and DEI initiatives while implementing corporate-style efficiency in government operations. He anticipated an “America First” approach that may include a pragmatic power-sharing arrangement with China and a strategic realignment with Russia. For India\, he identified critical challenges: the country must transition from “renting out” tech talent to building indigenous technological capabilities\, assert regional leadership more effectively\, and strategically leverage its geography and Russia relationship in negotiations with the U.S. \nDetailed Report\nAmbassador Chinoy introduced the speaker Shri Rajiv Malhotra and highlighted his expertise on India-U.S. relations and the evolving global order\, noting his background in technology and commitment to indigenous strategic thought. \nAmb. Chinoy discussed how India has historically been interpreted through Western lenses for hundreds of years\, particularly during colonisation\, and emphasised the importance of now viewing India through its own cultural and strategic perspectives. He shared a personal anecdote about how Western scholars refused to provide endorsements for books focused on India’s strategic autonomy and Vedic foundations of Indian strategic thought\, which challenged Western academic norms. \nShri Malhotra began by sharing his background as a computer scientist with early studies in artificial intelligence during the 1970s when the field was largely theoretical. After working as a technical expert in the industry with approximately 20 companies\, he transitioned to working with a foundation focused on simulation spaces in the early 1990s. \nThe speaker discussed his observations from being granted access to Trump’s transition team in Washington during the days before the presidential inauguration. He characterised the Trump administration as strategic rather than chaotic\, populated by young\, sophisticated\, and tech-savvy professionals who are likely to remain influential beyond a single term. He suggested that this could represent a 12-year political wave rather than a temporary shift\, indicating that young people in Trump’s team who have already faced primaries\, would contest future elections\, and are very likely to win. \nA central focus of the Trump administration\, according to the speaker\, was dismantling what they call the “deep state” and challenging diversity\, equity\, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives that he believed have undermined American competitiveness. He suggested that under Trump\, with mass firings and implementation of corporate efficiency practices through the “Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE)” would lead to significant restructuring of government agencies. \nThe speaker predicted increased reliance on technology in governance\, with formerly anti-Trump tech figures now aligning with the administration. They anticipate a government that is “smarter\, more tech-driven” but potentially “less human\,” with algorithms replacing human decision-making in many areas. \nRegarding international relations\, the speaker predicted an “America First” approach would lead to a strategic rebalancing where Russia might be approached differently than during previous administrations. Drawing historical parallels to the Nixon-Kissinger strategy of decoupling China from the USSR\, he speculated that Trump might attempt to separate Russia from its alliance with China. He considered various scenarios for U.S.-China relations\, including potential conflict but also the possibility of a pragmatic power-sharing arrangement where the two countries divide global influence. He suggested that Trump\, as a “deal maker\,” might be open to a duopoly agreement with China rather than sustained confrontation. \nIn terms of implications for India\, the speaker identified several challenges and opportunities in this new landscape. He critiqued India’s approach of “renting out” its tech talent through outsourcing rather than building its own technological products and infrastructure. He suggested India should position its engineering workforce as a strategic asset in competition with China rather than merely seeking H-1B visas. \nThe speaker advised India to identify specific strategic “cards” it can bring to negotiations with the U.S.\, including potential influence in Bangladesh and other regional matters. He warned that India will likely face pressure to lower tariffs on American goods\, which could disrupt local industries\, and may experience pressure to purchase American weapons systems instead of Russian ones. \nThe speaker also noted that Christian right influences in the Trump administration might create tensions around religious missionary activities in India. He further mentioned that the aerospace sector will likely be prioritised\, with potential opportunities for collaboration. \nIn the domain of technology and labour markets\, the speaker raised concerns about rapid technological change causing labour market disruptions globally. He suggested that automation and Artificial Intelligence advancements are happening so quickly that job displacement and creation are occurring within 5-10 years rather than over generations\, potentially leading to significant social disruption. He speculated this might even lead to arguments for depopulation as technological efficiency reduces the need for large human workforces. \nThroughout the talk\, he emphasised the need for strategic thinking about the intersection of technology\, governance\, and international relations in a rapidly changing global landscape. \nQ&A Session\nThe Q&A session began with questions about Shri Malhotra’s characterisation of the “deep state” and its relationship to the Trump administration. Shri Malhotra clarified that every country needs a “deep state” as the infrastructure of machines\, administration\, and institutions that survive surface government changes. However\, he argued that the current American deep state has evolved beyond government entities to include NGOs\, universities\, and organisations like Planned Parenthood that promote specific ideological agendas. According to him\, the deep state has been the subject of criticism for many years\, with opposition gradually building over time rather than suddenly emerging under Trump. \nWhen questioned about how current DEI policies differ from previous affirmative action initiatives\, the speaker distinguished between individual-level and group-level approaches to diversity. He explained that earlier forms of affirmative action\, supported by figures like Martin Luther King Jr.\, emphasised individual equality rather than group-based rights. The speaker characterised modern DEI as a “collective bargaining medium” influenced by critical race theory\, which they described as a new manifestation of Marxism that categorises people by race\, sexual orientation\, and religion rather than solely by economic class. This shift\, he argued\, creates dangerous group-level divisions in society. \nRegarding free speech concerns\, the speaker clarified that the current battle for free speech is primarily focused within the United States rather than being imposed internationally. He described how certain ideological positions claim that those categorised as “oppressors” should be denied free speech through mechanisms like “cancel culture\,” preventing certain voices from being heard in academic and public settings. The speaker presented this as a destructive approach to speech that the Trump administration is opposing\, but noted this is primarily a domestic American issue. \nThe Q&A explored potential scenarios for U.S.-China relations\, with the speaker suggesting that while they may not become friends\, they might develop a pragmatic arrangement dividing global spheres of influence. Drawing historical parallels to how France and Britain competed while also collaborating\, the speaker proposed that both China and the U.S. are pragmatic powers that might negotiate spheres of influence with continued competition in “grey areas.” This arrangement could affect India’s position in the global order\, with the speaker questioning whether India truly qualifies as a “tier one power” with a seat at the decision-making table. \nSeveral questions focused on India’s strategic position and assets in negotiations with the United States. The speaker emphasised that India’s geography is a significant card but noted that India has failed to assert regional leadership in its neighbourhood\, pointing to situations in Bangladesh\, Nepal\, and Myanmar where India did not effectively establish itself as the dominant regional power. He cited India’s continued relationship with Russia despite international pressure as a valuable strategic asset. The speaker also reiterated his critique of India’s approach to technical talent\, arguing that by sending skilled workers to American companies only to later license back the resulting technologies\, India is failing to develop its own technological infrastructure and intellectual property. \nThe discussion further highlighted differences between India’s and China’s approaches to technology development. While both countries initially leveraged inexpensive labour (China in manufacturing\, India in services)\, the speaker suggested that China strategically reinvested profits into developing proprietary technologies and future capabilities. He noted that China’s government directed companies to invest significant portions of their earnings in R&D\, whereas India allowed short-term profit-taking without similar requirements for reinvestment. The speaker suggested that even with India’s different political system\, the government could have implemented policies such as taxes on exported talent to fund domestic R&D or created a more robust equivalent to the American DARPA (Defence Advanced Research Projects Agency)\, which has successfully developed numerous transformative technologies. \nThroughout the Q&A\, the speaker maintained that understanding these dynamics is crucial for India to strategically position itself in a changing global order\, where technological capability increasingly determines national power and influence. \nReport prepared by Ms. Khyati Singh\, Research Analyst\, North America and Strategic Technologies Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-talk-by-shri-rajiv-malhotra-on-3-march-2025-at-mp-idsa
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250304T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250304T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020505
CREATED:20250528T223651Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072341Z
UID:92555-1741066200-1741066200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report on talk by Ms. Britta Peterson\, Regional Director for South Asia\, the Rosa-Luxemburg-Stiftung
DESCRIPTION:The Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised a talk on “The German Election” by Ms. Britta Peterson\, Regional Director for South Asia\, the Rosa-Luxemburg-Stiftung on 4 March 2025. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, chaired the event. The Institute’s scholars were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nThe German election could impact Germany’s domestic situation and have implications for Europe.  The main focus would be on who forms the government and what kind of impact the rise of the AfD party would have. Questions on how the new leadership would tackle the relationship with Russia will arise. The recent situation surrounding the Ukraine War also has a long-term impact on the overall European security architecture and the relationship of the European Union with the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation. \nDetailed Report\nThe Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, delivered his Opening Remarks\, in which he discussed the recent German election results and the political shifts in the leadership post election. He highlighted the recent success of the Alternative fur Deutschland (AfD) and how the party occupying second-place in the election gives a message about how right wing parties across Europe are emerging. He brought out how the debate on immigration has been seen across Europe. \nAccording to the Director General\, the new government in Germany has to contend with both internal issues and challenges\, as well as the possibility of spending even more to support Ukraine’s war or pay for post-war reconstruction. The other challenge is external\, which is the great fissure that is appearing in the transatlantic partnership. Questions arise as to what the future of NATO holds and also the future of the EU. \nMs. Britta Peterson began by analysing the recent preliminary results\, focusing on the data and the share of vote that each party received. She then focused on how a coalition is needed to form the government and the options that can be considered to form the said coalition. She emphasised on the record voter turnout and how the electorate voted across the political parties in Germany. She said that though Chancellor Friedrich Merz was the favourite in a popularity poll to ascertain who among the leaders could lead the nation\, he won only with a small majority. She said among the relevant issues that determined the voters’ choice; illegal immigration\, development\, domestic security\, economic growth\, environment and climate\, peace\, and global security were dominant.  She also shared election data to reflect on how various age groups and genders voted and the multiple divisions among the voters based on region. She highlighted the recent news that there is discussion to form a coalition between the Christian Democrats and the Social Democrats. \nMs. Peterson then highlighted the uniqueness of Friedrich Merz who won the election and is likely to be the Chancellor. He has never held political office and comes from an elite background\, yet he received the support of the people\, in spite of German politics being a strong bastion of the middle class. Ms. Peterson emphasised on how during his campaign\, he was oscillating between a traditional value-based conservative ideological standing and then being critical of the Greens and the Social Democrats on election day. According to Ms. Peterson\, he is an unpredictable leader. She said that there is a chance of a coalition government by Easter. Once a coalition is formed\, there could be negotiations on the budget by August or even before\, based on the urgency. Recently\, Merz said that he wanted to develop a special budget of about 900 billion Euros\, of which he wanted to spend one-half on German infrastructure and the other half on defence. According to Ms. Peterson\, the idea of this special budget was a bit controversial\, given that the last German coalition collapsed due to the system of German debt brake. \nOne of the reasons why German infrastructure has been neglected is because investments into infrastructure are not coming because of this debt brake. Especially parties on the left\, the Social Democrats\, the Greens\, but also the Left Party\, have been demanding for a long time that this debt brake that puts restrictions on spending needs to go\, but it can be only reversed with a two-third majority in parliament. Parties on the left are not in favour of going for special budgets anymore\, because they want to remove the debt brake so as to give the government more flexibility in the changing geopolitical situation. \nMs. Peterson also talked about the recent meeting of the Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in the White House and controversy surrounding the meeting. She said that Germany and Europe are well aware of the recent geopolitical tectonic shifts. She mentioned how Americans have been pursuing a campaign focused on Asia\, which began with former United States President Obama’s “Pivot to Asia” speech. According to Ms. Peterson\, it was clear that America wanted the Europeans to focus on its defence and take more responsibility\, and now that has become a reality. She feels Europe needs to build its defence capacities and streamline the defence production market. She gave the example of the Airbus industry and how it can inspire the defence sector. \nThe Speaker stated that Europeans need a clearer political understanding since their opinions are fragmented regarding their approach to Russia. She then discussed the rise of the far right in Europe and how it has impacted European politics. She concluded that Europe needs to grow into an independent pole in the emerging world order that includes Russia\, China\, the United States and India. \nQuestions and Comments\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, complimented the speaker on her presentation. He highlighted the defence spending budget of the Europeans and the United States with reference to the NATO. He then brought up the role of China in the world order. He asked about the possibility of the United States reducing its troops in Europe\, particularly in Germany\, and how it would impact NATO. He also asked if Germany would spend much more on defence? What would Europe’s reaction be if the German military-industrial complex expands? Lastly\, when Germany and Europe as a whole are grappling with fascism and non-democratic impulses\, does it dampen European proclivity to counsel others about democracy and backsliding? \nMs. Saman Ayesha Kidwai asked about the rise of the far right in Germany\, the victory of the AfD\, how the media has been viewing the rise of the AfD\, and the state of German democracy. Secondly\, she also asked how Germany looks at the ‘Coalition of the Willing’ announced by the British Prime Minister. \nDr. Jason Wahlang asked about the rise of the far right\, particularly in Eastern Germany. \nDr. Rajorshi Roy questioned the United States and its role in Europe. He also asked if Europe could support Ukraine without the United States’ support. \nMs. Shruti Pandalai asked about the future of European security and wanted to know about Europe’s relations with China. \nDr. Arnab Dasgupta asked about gender trends and the support of the far right in the recent German election and whether Elon Musk’s support for the far right impacted the polls. \nDr. Smruti Pattanaik asked about terror attacks in Gemany and whether they impact anti-immigration debates. \nMs. Britta Peterson gave detailed explanations to all the questions and comments raised\, and the talk ended with a big round of applause from the audience. \nReport Prepared by Dr. Jason Wahlang\, Research Analyst\, Europe and Eurasia Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-on-talk-by-ms-britta-peterson-regional-director-for-south-asia-the-rosa-luxemburg-stiftung
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250310T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250310T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020505
CREATED:20250411T063015Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072136Z
UID:91529-1741584600-1741584600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of the Monday Morning Meeting on\, “The Shifting Dynamics of Major Powers in Southeast Asia”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Temjenmeren Ao\, Associate Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute of Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on\, ‘The Shifting Dynamics of Major Powers in Southeast Asia” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 10 March 2025. Ms. Shruti Pandalai\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA moderated the meeting. The scholars of MP-IDSA participated in the discussion. \nExecutive Summary \nSoutheast Asia is strategically important due to its geographic location\, economic potential\, and role in global trade. The presentation focused on the shifting dynamics in Southeast Asia and how they reflect a complex interaction of geopolitical interests\, economic aspirations\, and security concerns. As China’s power continues to rise\, other major powers like the U.S.\, Japan and Russia are recalibrating their strategies to safeguard their interests and maintain a balance of power. The region is increasingly becoming a focal point for global competition\, with Southeast Asian countries playing an essential role in navigating these shifts. \nDetailed Report \nThe session began with opening remarks by the moderator\, Ms. Shruti Pandalai regarding the current geopolitical dynamics playing out in the global arena under Trump’s Presidency.  She argued that the muscle memory of Trump 1.0 would trigger many Southeast Asian nations to assume that while they thought of Trump as inconvenient and transactional in the first term\, they did think he was manageable. However\,  Trump’s current geopolitics with a reset of Russia relations\, the Ukraine vote\, the rupture of the Transatlantic alliance\, Trade Wars and increasing strategic competition with China\, signal that Washington no longer guarantees to underwrite the global order. Ms Pandalai argued that there is a view that the Trump administration team views relations with Southeast Asia largely as a subset of its approach to great-power competition with China. So on the one hand in the first few days of the administration\, US prioritised maritime security\, focusing on the South China Sea during discussions with Quad partners\, doubled down regional defence alliances including a multilateral activity helmed by the U.S. Coast Guard with the Philippines\, Indonesia\, and Vietnam on maritime security. Yet on the other hand\, Trump pressed Taiwan to increase defence spending\, accused it of “stealing” the US semiconductor industry\, and called the security alliance with Japan as non-reciprocal\, are all moves that would make Southeast Asian nations anxious about the trajectory of global geopolitics and their ability to grapple with all these uncertainties and navigate great power competition \nFollowing this\, Dr. Temjenmeren Ao began his presentation and talk. He began by giving a brief overview of the importance of Southeast Asia as it remains geographically critical. He mentioned four major powers in Southeast Asia: the US\, China\, Japan and Russia. The two major powers with the most influence in Southeast Asia are the United States and China. He further explained that since the Cold War to post-Cold War\, the U.S. with its military and economic power is a major external power in Southeast Asia. \nDr. Ao explained how the ongoing U.S.-China rivalry is being played out in the two potential geopolitical hotspots of the Indo-Pacific; the South China Sea and the Taiwan Straits. Thus\, creating a volatile environment that is also pushing Southeast Asian countries towards diversifying their engagements beyond the U.S. and China. The U.S. has been attempting to regain its lost ground in Southeast Asia as a consequence of its escalating competition with China. The U.S. policy in Southeast Asia views multilateralism as fundamental towards complementing the alliances and partnerships it sought to build in the region. Under President Biden\, the U.S. intensified its diplomatic outreach but reinforcing old alliances and establishing new partnerships including new minilaterals such as AUKUS and initiatives such as the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework (IPEF). Dr. Ao went on to explain that the U.S. has strong security interests and commitments in Southeast Asia and that how Trump’s Presidency would view Southeast Asia in his second term remains to be seen. \nThe speaker then spoke about China’s increasing influence in Southeast Asia. China’s geographical proximity and the presence of extensive Chinese ethnic minorities provide Beijing with an enormous and unique advantage in the region. Dr. Ao remarked that since the Asian Financial crisis of 1997\, China with its timely economic outreach enabled it to become the largest trading partner of all the ten ASEAN countries. It has intensified its engagement in the region through programmes including infrastructure investments under China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Southeast Asian countries are faced with the challenge of managing these complex dynamics—balancing cooperation with China while also maintaining their relationships with other major powers like the U.S. and Japan. \nDr. Ao went on to explain how Japan has been strengthening its ties with Southeast Asia amidst the current geopolitical shifts and its own security complexities. The Fukuda Doctrine came out in 1977 and laid down the core for the building of Japan’s Southeast Asia policy\, based on the principle of an equal partnership to promote peace and prosperity in the region. Japan became one of the most important economic and development partners in Southeast Asia. Dr. Ao also remarked that Japan’s National Security Strategy 2022\, recognises Southeast Asia as a linchpin in its Indo-Pacific strategy\, emphasising expanding defence cooperation with like-minded partners. He mentioned that in recent years\, Japan has increased its engagement and security partnerships with Southeast Asian countries such as Vietnam\, the Philippines and Indonesia amidst Sino-Russian naval activities around its southwestern islands\, along with Moscow’s overtures with Pyongyang. Amidst uncertainty over U.S. commitments to the region\, Japan seeks to broaden its security footprints in the region providing the ASEAN nations with an alternative\, both in the economic and security spheres. \nDr. Ao explained how Russia has reinforced its great power status in Southeast Asia. The collapse of the Soviet Union\, and the growing American and Western influence\, perceived to threaten Russian national security made Moscow reassess its engagement with Southeast Asia. Russia began to deepen its defence cooperation while also establishing trade deals with ASEAN countries\, mainly focused on energy exports and arms sales. He remarked that Russia projects itself as a great power focused on promoting a multi-polar world order through strengthening its bilateral relations along with intensifying its engagements in ASEAN-led mechanisms. Dr. Ao concluded his presentation by mentioning that Russia’s engagement in the region is still very limited in comparison to other major powers. While the U.S. and China are the primary major powers in Southeast Asia\, countries like Japan and Russia are also expanding their geopolitical presence\, providing strong alternatives to the region. \nThe session concluded after an insightful exchange of views between scholars during the Q&A session which widely ranged from how France too is a major player in Southeast Asia and ASEAN’s role in terms of ASEAN identity and ASEAN functioning. \nReport has been prepared by Ms. Simran Walia\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-the-monday-morning-meeting-on-the-shifting-dynamics-of-major-powers-in-southeast-asia
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250312T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250312T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020505
CREATED:20250601T224209Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072037Z
UID:92562-1741757400-1741757400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report on Roundtable Discussion to Celebrate Commemoration of the 350th Anniversary of the Grand Coronation of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj
DESCRIPTION:Professor Shraddha Kumbhojkar\, Department of History\, Pune University and Professor Aniruddh Deshpande\, Department of History\, Delhi University visited the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) on 12 March 2025 for a Roundtable Discussion to celebrate commemoration of the 350th anniversary of the grand coronation of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj. \nProf. Kumbhojkar spoke on ‘Maratha Patshah – The Uniqueness of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj as Head of State’\, and Prof. Deshpande spoke on ‘Salient Features of Shivaji’s Military Strategy and Campaign Tactics – A Contextual View’. \nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, chaired the discussion. The scholars of MP-IDSA were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nThe roundtable discussion on Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj brought together experts to analyse his enduring legacy\, strategic leadership\, and military strategy. The discussion provided valuable insights into Shivaji Maharaj’s life\, governance and relevance. \nDetailed Report\nAmb. Sujan R. Chinoy made Introductory Remarks. Prof. Shraddha Kumbhojkar highlighted that Sabhasad Bakhar is the first biography of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj\, representing an indigenous way of recording history. While several historical accounts exist\, this one is considered closest to his life history. The author of Sabhasad Bakhar referred to Shivaji as “Maratha Patshah\,” a unique and rare designation. The term Patshah has Islamic origins\, yet it was used for a Hindu king in this context\, reflecting the fusion of Sultanate traditions with Maratha rule and showcasing a distinctive political and cultural identity. Shivaji Maharaj issued two coins—Shivraee\, a copper coin\, and a gold commemorative coin – which are important primary sources. Additionally\, public memory serves as a valuable historical source. \nWhile not strictly academic\, secondary sources are essential for those unfamiliar with historical scripts. The tradition of writing about Shivaji Maharaj has continued since 1826. Jyotirao Phule\, for instance\, interpreted Shivaji as a king of the Kunbi (agrarian) community\, presenting him as a ruler of the people rather than one from a Brahminical tradition. Dr Kumbhojkar mentioned several documents shedding light on Shivaji’s personality. One document on land tax and interest by Patangrao provides insights into his governance. Another account narrates that when Rajaram was born as a breech baby\, Shivaji remarked that he would “turn Delhi upside down”\, showcasing his pragmatic nature and dismissing superstitious beliefs. \nIn 1697\, discussions on forming a naval force included individuals like Darya Sarang and Mainak Bhandari from seafaring communities\, underscoring Shivaji’s practical approach. However\, after Shivaji’s time\, when the Marathas fought the British\, the Peshwas could not sustain the naval force\, leading to its eventual decline. Prof. Kumbhojkar pointed out that while modern terms like “secularism” and “nation” do not apply to 17th-century India\, the western coast had 27 different powers at the time\, with Shivaji being one of them. A document even records Shivaji granting land to a dancing woman who sought his help\, reflecting his inclusive governance. \nShivaji’s administrative policies also prioritised language reform. The Rajya Vyavhar Kosh mentions that many Persian-origin terms were used in governance\, and Shivaji had instructed Raghunath Pandit to refine the language by replacing them with indigenous words. However\, it remains unclear whether this glossary was ever finalised. Shivaji’s governance also reflected concern for public welfare. A letter from Shivaji to his military officers\, still cited today\, instructs soldiers to care for their horses before themselves. He also commanded that troops must not forcibly seize food and resources from civilians. Another letter rebukes a Brahmin Subedar for negligence\, asserting that caste would not grant anyone immunity from accountability\, showcasing his commitment to professional governance. \nOn identity\, Prof. Kumbhojkar noted that Shivaji maintained cordial relations with the Qutub Shahi dynasty of Golconda. A document records that the Qutub Shah personally welcomed Shivaji\, breaking protocol. Shivaji\, in turn\, called for all Maratha Jaati to unite with Qutub Shah—not in a caste-based sense\, but as a geographical and linguistic identity. This Deccani or Dakshini identity was emerging as a counterforce to the northern Mughal influence\, with Shivaji asserting that the Deccan should remain under its own people’s rule. Finally\, Prof. Kumbhojkar emphasised that Shivaji’s legacy is complex and must be viewed in its 17th-century context. While some of his values are timeless\, modern interpretations sometimes impose contemporary ideals onto his image. He has consistently been revered as Rayatecha Raja—the King of the People. As historian Ibn Khaldun noted\, history is deeply connected to the philosophy of its time\, and Shivaji’s legacy must be understood within that framework. \nProf. Aniruddh Deshpande emphasised that history is a subject of philosophy and hermeneutics. History is often interpreted based on contemporary concerns rather than objective facts. Govind Pansare’s book Shivaji Kaun Hota? (1988)\, built upon Jyotirao Phule’s perspective\, portrayed Shivaji as Kulwadi Kulabhushana\, a title signifying him as the crown jewel of the lower castes. Pansare applied the class analysis framework to re-imagine Shivaji as a proponent of Bahujan concerns and essentially as a leader of the subaltern classes. This interpretation\, he clarified\, was not anti-Brahmin but rather anti-Brahmanical\, a distinction that is often misunderstood. He also pointed out that India lacks a strong theoretical tradition in history and strategic studies\, affecting how historical figures like Shivaji are analysed. Shivaji’s political and strategic views should be contextually studied rather than applying a modern framework. \nShivaji’s military strategy was shaped by his constraints and the necessity of asymmetric warfare. Unlike the Mughals\, who drew vast revenue from Bengal and Punjab to sustain a large military machine\, Shivaji operated within a relatively smaller territory with limited resources. Recognising this challenge\, he adopted guerrilla warfare\, or Ganimi Kava\, which emphasised deception\, rapid movement\, surprise attacks\, and strategic retreats to fight another day. He focused on mobility rather than heavy equipment\, so his forces relied on light cavalry and infantry. The cavalry was composed mainly of locally available horses\, but heavier shock troops’ horses were procured from Arabs and Kathiawadi merchants. Forts played a crucial role in his administration and were strategically located along trade routes\, serving as governance and revenue collection centres. Unlike the commonly used terms Rajya or Rashtra today\, Desh and Deccan were the prevailing geographical terminologies of that era. \nTactically\, Shivaji never fought a set-piece battle. Stealth and secrecy were key tools in Shivaji’s battle tactics. As a master strategist\, he exploited the local knowledge and debunked superstitions\, including non-adherence to the religious calendar\, to plan battles. He maintained strict secrecy in planning military movements\, ensuring his enemy never detected his approach. His forces would converge from multiple directions at a distance from the target before launching brutal raids\, after which they would withdraw swiftly to avoid prolonged engagements. Although these attacks were ruthless\, plundering wealth and resources\, Shivaji’s forces strictly refrained from harming women\, children\, the elderly\, or religious objects. Unlike many rulers of his time\, he enforced strict discipline within his army\, forbidding concubines\, prostitutes\, and entertainers in military camps. Any soldier found violating these rules faced execution. \nThe structure of Shivaji’s army was well-organised and meritocratic. He maintained a balance between Shiledars\, who owned their horses\, and Bargis\, who were allotted horses by the state\, thereby ensuring individual responsibility and state control. The Pindari force served as scouts and spies\, crucial in gathering intelligence. Over time\, the Bargi system led to greater dependence on the government\, ensuring discipline and loyalty among soldiers. Shivaji promoted people based on merit rather than identity\, giving equal opportunities to capable individuals regardless of their social background. Additionally\, he provided pensions to widows of fallen soldiers and ensured that the grievances of his troops were heard and addressed promptly. Corrupt officials were severely punished\, reinforcing a governance system based on accountability. Similarly\, while Shivaji initiated the formation of a naval force\, it was not a full-scale navy. His maritime strategy relied on local seafarers and materials\, and leaders like Tukoji Angre and Kanhoji Angre later carried forward this legacy. Some historians today refer to Shivaji as the “father of the Indian Navy\,” but Deshpande argued that this characterisation oversimplifies history. \nThe identity of Maharashtra Desh was shaped by his rule\, along with the growing influence of the Marathi language and the Bhakti movement. His legacy\, however\, must be understood within the context of his time. He was not attempting to build a modern nation-state\, but he maximised his potential within the constraints he faced. His ability to adapt to challenges\, focus on survival rather than reckless heroism\, and build a disciplined and inclusive military made him an exemplary strategist whose influence continues to shape discussions on Indian history today. \nQuestions and Comments\nDr. Ajey Lele asked about Shivaji’s lineage\, whether he belonged to the Sisodia clan\, and the confusion surrounding his date of birth. Mr. Arvind Khare referred to historian Irfan Habib’s claim that Shivaji was secular and questioned whether modern historians imposed contemporary concepts onto him. Cmde. Abhay Singh sought insights into the role of the Maratha Navy. Dr. Saurabh Mishra questioned why Shivaji had a grand coronation despite opposition and how this was linked to his foreign policy\, particularly the collection of Chauth. Ms. Khyati asked about the evolution of relations between Brahmins and the Marathas after Shivaji’s coronation and whether any principles from Angre’s navy could be applied to contemporary naval strategy. Col. Dharmendra Yadav asked why the Marathas\, who initially excelled in guerrilla warfare under Shivaji\, later transitioned to conventional warfare. Lastly\, Dr. Arnab Dasgupta asked whether Shivaji had any explicit doctrine advocating using terror as a military strategy. \nBoth the speakers responded to all comments and questions from the Director General\, Deputy Director General and MP-IDSA scholars. \nReport was prepared by Mr. Rahul Wankhede\, Research Analyst\, Defence Economics and Industry Centre and Dr. Hirak Jyoti Das\, Research Analyst\, West Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-on-roundtable-discussion-to-celebrate-commemoration-of-the-350th-anniversary-of-the-grand-coronation-of-chhatrapati-shivaji-maharaj
CATEGORIES:ROUND TABLES / WORKSHOPS,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020505
CREATED:20250411T063759Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T061759Z
UID:91532-1742189400-1742189400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of Monday Morning Meeting on Reassessing AUKUS in Trump 2.0
DESCRIPTION:Cmde. Abhay Kumar Singh (Retd.)\, Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) spoke on “Reassessing AUKUS in Trump 2.0” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 17 March 2025 at 1000h in Seminar Hall I. Dr. R. Vignesh\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA chaired the session. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, along with scholars of the institute attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nThe session analysed AUKUS’s progress\, focusing on submarine acquisition\, industrial challenges\, and strategic imperatives amid rising U.S.-China tensions. Key discussions included Virginia-class submarine transfers\, maintenance backlogs\, production constraints\, and bipartisan U.S. support. Potential political uncertainties\, including a Trump 2.0 presidency\, were examined. While AUKUS has achieved legislative and strategic milestones\, sustaining momentum requires long-term investment\, industrial capacity-building\, and policy alignment to strengthen deterrence and ensure regional stability. \nDetailed Report\nDr. R.Vignesh commenced the meeting by highlighting that since the beginning AUKUS has had strong bipartisan support of the two dominant political parties in the US\, UK and Australia. He brought out that after the re-election of Donald Trump as US President\, there have been considerable concerns. He stated that the reversal of the US stance on the Ukraine War has ostensibly given rise to apprehensions in Australia’s political discourse and public perceptions regarding the reliability of the US as a security partner. Dr. Vignesh highlighted that due to the US’s centrality in this trilateral security agreement\, there are concerns that Trump’s Presidency may steer AUKUS into troubled waters. Hence\, it is important to understand as to what extent Trump’s Presidency can influence and impact AUKUS. With these opening remarks\, he invited Cmde. Abhay Singh to make his presentation. \nCmde. Abhay Singh began his presentation by highlighting British Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s visit to the White House on 27 February 2025. During this meeting President Trump was asked by a reporter about discussions with the United Kingdom regarding AUKUS. In response\, President Trump appeared unfamiliar with the acronym\, asking\, “What does this mean?” The remark\, widely noted in diplomatic and security circles\, raised fresh concerns about the future of AUKUS\, particularly in light of broader uncertainties surrounding U.S. foreign policy under a potential second Trump Presidency. Additionally\, the U.S. stance reversal on military aid to Ukraine has fueled apprehensions within Australian political discourse and public perception regarding Washington’s reliability as a security partner. Against this backdrop\, the role of AUKUS in securing long-term regional stability and ensuring continued commitment from all three partners has become a pressing concern. \nCmde. Singh provided a structured breakdown of its two pillars of AUKUS. Pillar One deals with the development and deployment of nuclear-powered submarines for Australia. He elaborated on the phased approach involving the training of Australian personnel\, rotational deployment of U.S. and U.K. submarines\, and eventual acquisition of SSN-AUKUS submarines. He detailed the San Diego Summit’s key decisions\, including initial indications for the transfer of Virginia-class submarines\, the new SSN-AUKUS submarine design\, and the role of the U.K.’s Astute-class SSNs and Australia’s Collins-class SSNs in the transition phase. He also highlighted that training programs have already commenced in the U.S. for Australian naval personnel\, although restrictions on the transfer of critical technology pose challenges to implementation. \nPillar Two\, as Cmde. Singh detailed\, expands AUKUS beyond submarines to incorporate advanced defence technologies. These include artificial intelligence\, quantum technologies\, cyber warfare\, undersea capabilities\, and hypersonic weapons. He emphasised that Pillar Two is vital for sustaining long-term technological superiority and interoperability among the three partners. The agreement for cooperation in Naval Nuclear Propulsion (NNP) was also discussed\, along with its impact on industrial development and strategic deterrence. \nCmde. Singh outlined the structure of AUKUS oversight\, mentioning the establishment of three steering groups to coordinate different aspects of the partnership. He also discussed the role of shipbuilders\, including ASC Pty Ltd and BAE Systems\, under the supervision of the Australian Submarine Agency (ASA). He stressed that investment assurance is critical for the SSN program\, requiring financial commitments from all three nations to ensure long-term sustainability. Australia’s AUKUS submarine strategy was examined in terms of creating demand clarity\, skilling manpower\, and ensuring continuity in strategic alignment. \nIn terms of strategic imperatives\, Cmde. Singh noted that AUKUS aligns with broader deterrence efforts in response to the perceived threat from the People’s Republic of China (PRC). He highlighted the importance of bipartisan consensus in ensuring policy continuity\, particularly in the context of a potential Trump 2.0 Presidency\, which may bring a more transactional approach to alliances. The growing influence of China hawks in Washington\, assertive manoeuvres by the PLA Navy\, and the linkage between AUKUS and the Royal Navy’s Astute-class replacement program were also discussed as critical factors shaping the agreement’s trajectory. Furthermore\, he noted that all three nations will need to expand their naval infrastructure\, as post-Cold War workforce retirements in the U.S. have led to a significant reduction in available submarine designers and maintainers. \nCmde. Singh also addressed potential impediments to AUKUS implementation. He highlighted serious maintenance backlogs in the U.S. submarine fleet\, which have led to a decline in the number of ready submarines from 40 to 32. The transfer of Virginia-class SSNs to Australia is constrained by the declining U.S. SSN inventory and existing bottlenecks in Virginia-class production. The Virginia-class payload module\, intended to enhance deterrence capabilities\, may face delays\, impacting the overall effectiveness of AUKUS. He further explored how the transfer of submarines to Australia might affect the U.S. Navy’s deterrence posture in the Indo-Pacific. \nThe discussion also touched upon broader U.S.-China dynamics and the potential for a G-2 redux under a different U.S. administration. The impact of a Trump 2.0 Presidency on Indo-Pacific security was examined\, including the risks of a transactional approach to alliances\, potential tariff escalations\, and shifts in U.S. strategic priorities. \nIn his concluding remarks\, Cmde. Abhay Kumar Singh reiterated that AUKUS has largely maintained its course\, with tangible progress seen in legislative approvals and collaborative frameworks. However\, he noted that AUKUS is at a critical inflexion point\, requiring sustained political commitment and industrial capacity-building. The upcoming U.S. National Defense Authorisation Act (NDAA) for FY 2025-26 will be a key factor in determining the future of AUKUS. He stressed that maintaining a balance between military preparedness and diplomatic engagement will be crucial for ensuring that AUKUS contributes positively to regional stability. The discussion provided a comprehensive understanding of how AUKUS is shaping global security and what steps are necessary to sustain its strategic momentum in the Indo-Pacific. \nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy in his remarks addressed concerns regarding AUKUS and highlighted the dominant role of the United States in the partnership. He emphasised that AUKUS is essentially an extension of U.S. foreign policy\, with its future trajectory closely tied to American strategic interests. He noted that it is logical for the U.S. to maintain a rotational presence in the region\, reinforcing its security posture. Additionally\, he pointed out that Australia has already made substantial investments in hosting U.S. personnel and has committed further resources to support this security arrangement. \nThe session concluded after an insightful exchange of views between scholars during the Q&A session. \nThe Report was prepared by Ms. Brahmshakti\, Intern\, Defence Economics and Industry Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-monday-morning-meeting-on-reassessing-aukus-in-trump-2-0
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250317T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020505
CREATED:20250523T034637Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20260707T072229Z
UID:92500-1742189400-1742189400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report on Emerging Arctic Security Dynamics
DESCRIPTION:MP-IDSA hosted a talk on Emerging Arctic Security Dynamics featuring Dr. Andreas Østhagen\, Senior Research Fellow at the Fridtjof Nansen Institute\, Oslo\, and Dr. Andreas Raspotnik\, Director at the High North Center for Business and Governance\, Nord University\, Bodø\, Norway. The event took place on 17 March 2025. The discussion was moderated by Dr. Uttam Kumar Sinha\, Senior Fellow and Coordinator NTS Centre. \nDetailed Report\nDr. Sinha opened the session by introducing the speakers and highlighting key aspects of the ongoing geopolitical shifts in the Arctic. In his opening remarks\, he emphasised MP-IDSA’s pivotal role in shaping India’s Arctic Policy\, noting the Institute’s longstanding commitment to Arctic research. He recalled that in 2012\, MP-IDSA published the first-ever ‘Special Issue’ on the Arctic in its flagship journal\, Strategic Analysis\, featuring contributions from renowned global experts. He further highlighted that\, after more than a decade\, the Institute released another ‘Special Issue’ on the Arctic in December 2024\, now available online. Dr. Sinha acknowledged the valuable contributions of Arctic scholars from the Fridtjof Nansen Institute (FNI) to this latest publication. Stressing the importance of continued collaboration\, he underscored the need to strengthen ties between FNI and MP-IDSA to advance Arctic research further. \nFollowing these remarks\, Dr. Sinha invited Dr. Østhagen to begin his presentation. \nDr. Andreas Østhagen\, began his presentation with a geographical overview of the Arctic\, setting the stage for a discussion on its evolving landscape. He pointed out scientific projections indicating that the Arctic could become ice-free by 2050\, a development that brings both opportunities and challenges with far-reaching implications for global geopolitics and state relations. Turning to India’s Arctic interests\, Dr. Østhagen highlighted the six pillars of India’s Arctic policy\, emphasising the vast potential for India-Norway cooperation in the region. He underscored how these policy pillars could serve as a framework for strengthening bilateral engagement\, particularly in areas such as climate research\, sustainable development\, and strategic partnerships. \nIn the second part of his presentation\, Dr. Østhagen underscored the crucial role of geography in shaping both economic opportunities and emerging challenges in the Arctic. He stressed that any discussion on resource exploitation\, sea routes\, or extended continental shelf claims must begin with a fundamental question: “Which part of the Arctic are we referring to?” He illustrated this point by highlighting the stark contrasts within the region. The Russian Arctic\, he noted\, is vastly different from the Norwegian Arctic\, just as the Arctic territories of Canada\, the US\, and Europe each have distinct geographical characteristics. These variations\, in turn\, translate into unique challenges and opportunities—from resource distribution to shipping lanes and broader geopolitical implications. \nBy emphasising these regional differences\, Dr. Østhagen reinforced the idea that a one-size-fits-all approach to Arctic policymaking is neither practical nor effective. Instead\, he advocated for a more nuanced\, region-specific understanding to navigate the complexities of this rapidly evolving frontier. \nDelving into the geopolitical flashpoints of the Arctic\, Dr. Østhagen highlighted that the risk of real geopolitical tensions\, conflicts\, or contestations is significantly higher in the European Arctic compared to the North Pacific Arctic. He attributed this to several critical factors\, including: \n\nRussia-NATO strategic posturing in the GIUK gap (Greenland-Iceland-UK)\, a key maritime chokepoint.\nThe heavy militarisation of the region\, with 50–60% of Russia’s nuclear arsenal stationed in the Arctic.\nAn escalating arms race\, as both Russia and NATO ramp up the scale and frequency of military exercises in the region.\n\nDr. Østhagen further warned that Russia’s actions in the Arctic cannot be taken at face value. He pointed to Moscow’s growing cooperation with Beijing\, arguing that this evolving Russia-China nexus adds another layer of complexity to European security. The recent joint naval patrols by Russian and Chinese vessels near Alaska\, as well as their coordinated air patrols\, have set off alarm bells among NATO allies operating in the region. For Norway\, these developments present heightened security challenges making closer cooperation with NATO partners not just important\, but essential for ensuring stability in the Arctic. \nTouching on the ongoing debate surrounding Greenland\, Dr. Østhagen pointed out that while the US already maintains a military base there\, Greenland holds little strategic significance from a shipping perspective. He emphasised that much of the discourse around Greenland’s geopolitical importance tends to be overstated when viewed through the lens of Arctic trade routes. \nAs he wrapped up his presentation\, Dr. Østhagen shifted focus to Norway’s unique position in the Arctic. With a 200-kilometer-long border with Russia\, Norway has historically engaged in active cooperation with Moscow on various regional issues. Despite the current geopolitical climate\, he noted that some functional cooperation continues\, particularly in areas like fish stock management and Svalbard governance. While most Western nations have suspended formal collaborations with Russia\, Dr. Østhagen stressed the importance of maintaining a working relationship with Moscow in the Arctic\, recognising that regional stability requires ongoing dialogue. \nHe concluded by expressing optimism about India’s growing role in Arctic affairs and underscored the potential for deeper research collaborations between MP-IDSA and FNI. As India continues to expand its Arctic engagement\, he emphasised that fostering academic and policy-driven partnerships would be mutually beneficial. \nDr. Andreas Raspotnik began his presentation by echoing several key arguments made by his colleague\, emphasising that geography remains central to understanding the Arctic. He stressed that for Arctic scholars\, it is crucial not only to analyse how non-Arctic states perceive the region but also to examine how Arctic nations themselves view it from their southern capitals—such as Oslo\, Helsinki\, and Stockholm\, which\, despite belonging to Arctic states\, are geographically removed from the Arctic itself. \nWhile security and geopolitics dominate global discussions on the Arctic\, Dr. Raspotnik argued that economic development\, demographic shifts\, and societal challenges must not be overlooked. These factors\, he noted\, are equally critical in shaping the Arctic’s future. \nBuilding on his colleague’s points\, he highlighted the importance of understanding how the Arctic impacts the Global South\, particularly India. One recurring theme in Arctic discourse\, he noted\, is its link to climate change—a phenomenon with far-reaching consequences for regions far beyond the Arctic itself. If climate change in the Arctic is indeed affecting the Global South\, what tangible actions are being taken—either in the Arctic or in the Global South—to address these challenges? This\, he emphasised\, is a question that demands greater scrutiny. \nIn the second part of his talk\, Dr. Raspotnik examined the decline of ‘Arctic exceptionalism’\, the idea that the Arctic had remained insulated from global geopolitical tensions. He argued that this notion has faded significantly since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine\, as cooperation within the Arctic Council has largely stalled. \nLooking ahead\, he suggested that the future of the Arctic will be shaped by geopolitical developments far beyond its borders. He underscored the importance of understanding how non-Arctic states\, like India\, perceive the ongoing power shifts and strategic alignments in the region. \nDr. Raspotnik also pointed to Finland and Sweden’s accession to NATO\, which has further complicated the Arctic’s security landscape. This shift\, he noted\, has introduced new dynamics that will influence the region’s strategic calculus for years to come. \nConcluding his remarks\, Dr. Raspotnik highlighted India’s growing role on the global stage\, arguing that its relationships with Russia\, its observer status in the Arctic Council\, and its leadership in international affairs make India’s future involvement in the Arctic more significant than ever before. As the Arctic undergoes profound geopolitical\, economic\, and environmental transformations\, India’s perspective and engagement will be crucial in shaping the region’s trajectory. \nQuestions and Comments\nDuring the Q&A session\, Mr. Arvind Khare invited the speakers to delve deeper into the social and demographic aspects of Arctic indigenous communities in the Norwegian Arctic\, highlighting the importance of understanding their evolving challenges and resilience in a rapidly changing environment. \nCapt. Anurag Bisen from the Vivekananda International Foundation posed a thought-provoking question on the ‘Norwegianisation of Svalbard\,’ seeking insights into the political and governance dynamics shaping the archipelago. He further inquired whether the Antarctic Treaty Consultative Meeting (ATCM) model could be applied to Svalbard to regulate research and governance in the region. \nIn response\, Dr. Østhagen and Dr. Raspotnik provided in-depth perspectives\, addressing the complexities of indigenous identity\, governance structures\, and international legal frameworks influencing the Arctic. \nThe session concluded with a concise summary by the chair\, encapsulating the key discussions and insights shared. \nReport prepared by Dr. Bipandeep Sharma\, Research Analyst\, Non-Traditional Security Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-on-emerging-arctic-security-dynamics
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250325T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20250326T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T020505
CREATED:20250504T232923Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250526T060058Z
UID:92280-1742880600-1742967000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Event Report: 5th India-Africa Strategic Dialogue on India And Africa: Partnership In The Next Decade
DESCRIPTION:Opening Remarks by Amb Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi\, India \nSpecial Address by H E Amb Anil Sooklal\, High Commissioner of Republic of South Africa to India \nKeynote Address by Shri Dammu Ravi\, Secretary (Economic Relations)\, Ministry of External Affairs\, Government of India\, New Delhi\, India \nSession 1: Framework for Cooperation\nChair: Amb Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi\, India \nSpeakers:\nDr Sharkdam Wapmuk\, Associate Professor and Head\, Dept of Defence and Security Studies\, Nigerian Defence Academy\, Nigeria \nDr Folashadé Soulé\, Senior Research Associate\, Blavatnik School of Government\, University of Oxford\, UK \nProf David Monyae\, Associate Professor of Political Science and IR\, Co-Director University of Johannesburg Confucius Institute and Centre for Africa China Studies\, South Africa \nMs Ruchita Beri\, Senior Fellow\, Vivekananda International Foundation\, New Delhi\, India \nSession II: Partnership for Deepening Trade and Investment Ties\nChair: Amb Gurjit Singh\, Former Indian Ambassador to Germany\, Indonesia\, Ethiopia\, ASEAN and the African Union\, Hon. Professor\, IIT Indore\, New Delhi\, India \nSpeakers:\nProf Stephen Onyeiwu\, Professor of Economics and former Chair of Dept\, Allegheny College\, US \nMr Kwame Owino\, Chief Executive Officer\, Institute of Economic Affairs\, Kenya \nProf Hebatallah Adam\, Professor and Associate Dean for Academic Affairs\, Jindal School of International Affairs\, India \nSession III: Partnership in Multilateral Forum and Global Governance Reforms \nChair: Prof Ajay Dubey\, Professor\, School of International Studies\, JNU\, India \nSpeakers:\nAmb Ruchira Kamboj\, Former Permanent Representative of India to the United Nations in New York and former Indian High \nCommissioner to South Africa \nMr Aly Verjee\, Senior Associate\, Amani Africa and Researcher at University of Gothenburg\, Sweden \nDr Kwaku Danso\, Dean\, Faculty of Academic Affairs\, Kofi Annan International Peacekeeping Training Center\, Ghana \nSession IV: Defence Cooperation and Maritime Security\nChair: VAdm Shekhar Sinha (Retd)\, Chairman\, Board of Trustees\, India Foundation\, New Delhi \nSpeakers:\nMr Raj Mohabeer\, Officer in Charge\, Indian Ocean Commission\, Mauritius \nCapt Sarabjeet S Parmar (Retd)\, Distinguished Fellow\, Council for Defence and Strategic Research\, New Delhi\, India \nDr Nicodemus M Minde\, Researcher\, Institute for Security Studies\, Nairobi\, Kenya \nSession V: Partnership in Critical Minerals and Energy Security \nChair: Dr Shailly Kedia\, Senior Fellow and Associate Director\, The Energy and Resources Institute\, New Delhi\, India \nSpeakers:\nDr Annika Bose Styczynski\, Associate Professor and Associate Dean\, Research & International Collaboration\, Jindal School of Government and Public Policy\, O.P. Jindal Global University\, Haryana\, India \nDr Sanjay Kumar Pradhan\, Associate Professor and Head of the Department of International Relations\, Pandit Deendayal Energy University\, Gujarat\, India \nDr Sandipani Dash\, Assistant Professor\, Department of African Studies\, University of Delhi\, India \nVote of Thanks: Dr Abhishek Mishra\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi\, India \nEXEUTIVE SUMMARY\nThe 5th IASD (25-26 March 2025) hosted by the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) underscored the importance of India-Africa partnership and proposed new areas of cooperation that can be further explored to strengthen their ties. MP-IDSA undertook this initiative in the wake of the African Union’s (AU) inclusion as a permanent member in the G20 under Indian G20 Presidency in 2023 and in the run up to a possible fourth India-Africa Forum Summit (IAFS) to be held later in the year. The opening remarks stressed that India and Africa’s relation will continue to be anchored on the principles of equality\, mutual respect and mutually beneficial partnerships which are centred on Africa’s priorities. The special remarks called upon the African diplomatic corps in India to have sustained and regular interactions with their Indian counterparts and highlighted the role of think tanks\, universities\, and academic research in strengthening the India-Africa partnership. The special remarks called for greater involvement of the Indian private sector in areas like agriculture\, pharmaceuticals\, energy transition\, education and skills development and digital public infrastructure. \nSession I highlighted the bilateral dimension of India-Africa partnership and noted that as India has emerged as an important partner at a time when African nations are pursuing strategic autonomy through diversification of international partnerships. From a steady and incremental approach\, the partnership has now evolved into a dynamic one with greater diplomatic engagement. Session II examined how India can maximise trade and investment relations with Africa and called for Indian private companies to set up manufacturing hubs and Special Economic Zones (SEZ) in Africa and work together with African partners to create an alternative global value chain under the opportunities offered by the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA). Session III emphasised the unfair distribution of power in the current global governance system and the need to reform multilateral institutions. Participants highlighted India’s consistent support for encouraging greater African representation and voices in institutions of global governance if the world is to truly become inclusive. Session IV discussed defence and security ties and underscored that Africa occupies a central position in both of India’s primary and secondary areas of maritime interest. Participants discussed the evolution of India’s maritime outlook in the Indian Ocean from SAGAR to MAHASAGAR and the importance of enhancing maritime domain awareness\, capacity building programmes\, and building on new initiatives like the Africa India Key Maritime Engagement (AIKEYME 2025). Session V examined how India and African countries can partner together in the field of strategic minerals and how India can enhance its renewable energy footprint while supporting Africa’s energy transition and provide clean\, affordable and accessible energy. In exploiting critical mineral resources\, India and African countries must consider the corporate social responsibility diligently. \nInaugural Session\nOpening Remarks by Amb Sujan R Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi\, India \n\nThe India-Africa Dialogue (IASD) hosted by the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) is a useful platform to discuss the various aspects of a rapidly and deeply evolving partnership. It aids India’s policy and helps to redefine and transform relations with countries in the African continent.\nThe presence of a large Indian diaspora\, along with Mahatma Gandhi’s ideals which shaped the struggles of the people of South Africa\, provided the foundations for India’s linkages with Africa.\nMore recently\, India facilitated the entry of the African Union (AU) into the G20 during its Presidency in 2023. Today\, as part of the Global South\, there is a need to work together to address challenges such as climate change\, natural disasters\, food and energy security and the adverse impact of rapidly evolving technologies such as Artificial Intelligence (AI) and data colonization on developing countries.\nGeo-politics and geo-economics are increasingly interlinked and India’s future is intertwined with the evolving dynamics of the Indo-Pacific. With the eastern coast of Africa being an integral part of this region\, developments there are of interest and concern to India. In the midst of current global disruptions\, India and Africa must work together to build a value-based future and lead the world in a better direction.\nAfrica remains a priority for Prime Minister Modi in his third term. The outreach and engagement of the last decade is set to gain new momentum. India is ready to work with Africa as an equal partner\, with opportunities to deepen engagement in the security sector through anti-piracy patrols and counter-terrorism exercises.\nThe MAHASAGAR initiative recently announced by the Indian Prime Minister adds further value and scope and therefore the role of scholars become critical in taking it to the next level.\nThe India-Africa partnership is anchored on the principles of equality\, mutual respect and mutually beneficial partnerships which are centred on Africa’s priorities. The concept of a free and open Indo-Pacific is further strengthening relations\, where individual priorities and interests are being reflected in this dynamic space.\n\nSpecial Remarks by H E Anil Sooklal\, High Commissioner of Republic of South Africa to India \n\nThe Bandung Conference of 1955 set the template for a close and strategic partnership between Asia and Africa. The role played by India during the conference provided the foundation upon which India and Africa’s ties rest. The Ten Principles for India-Africa Engagement elaborated by PM Modi in 2018 are an important template for the future partnership as it has various synergies with the African Union’s Agenda 2063.\nWhile there have been setbacks in advancing Agenda 2063\, the establishment of the continental wide African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) on May 30\, 2019 is expected to accelerate intra-African trade by 25% by 2035\, requiring strong partnerships.\nOver the decades there has been a proliferation of partnerships with the African continent\, which is a good sign. However\, there are questions on whether these partnerships are working towards advancing Africa’s goals and priorities.\nIndia is a trusted friend for Africa without any political baggage and no intent to disturb or influence the sovereignty and autonomy of any African nation. India must seek to leverage its tremendous goodwill across the continent. In this regard\, all sectors of the society need to step up with private businesses having a critical role to play in driving this process. The large number of Indian private sector companies operating across the continent is a clear indication that India views Africa as an important partner for mutual benefit and addressing shared economic challenges.\nThink tanks\, universities and academic scholars have a vital role in shaping this partnership. By studying the various aspects of the partnership\, policy-makers\, practitioners and officials could be better informed and help them make the right choices.\nThere is a need to re-organise the Africa Group (diplomatic corps) in India in order to fully leverage the opportunities in addition to having more regular and sustained interactions between the African Ambassadors and India’s Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) officials to discuss key issues of mutual interest.\n\nKeynote Address by Shri Dammu Ravi\, Secretary (ER)\, Ministry of External Affairs\, Government of India\, New Delhi\n\nThe geo-political shift from the Trans-Atlantic to the Indo-Pacific makes only the eastern part of Africa relevant in terms of the strategic thinking\, the India-Africa partnership has to become more inclusive by also having an Indo-Atlantic dimension.\nTwo narratives are emerging as the world is become more multilateral: development for Africa and development by Africa and Africans. From emerging as an aid recipient continent to driving its own growth agenda\, the African continent is shaping its own destiny. The current multilateral institutions set up in the post-Second World War period through the Washington consensus seeking structural changes in developing countries has not delivered\, particularly in promoting growth in Africa which continues to face health and education challenges.\nToday\, the G20 is enriched following the inclusion of the African Union. The task of making it credible and relevant requires the need to harness the talents towards shaping the future development and growth.\nThe concept of development and security are interlinked more closely than ever. The African continent is facing numerous challenges in maintaining peace and stability. The challenges have further broadened to energy security\, food security\, health security\, and education. With the widening in the scope of security and development\, the future partnerships that Africa would forge should include these new parameters.\nThe India-Africa partnership\, while on the right trajectory\, needs to grow in a number of areas. This includes in the area of trade\, one reason for this being the unavailability of hot currencies which could be addressed by doing trade in local currencies\, introducing fin-tech solutions\, and barter trade. This requires enabling greater investments through Public Private Partnerships and addressing the existing knowledge gaps for doing business in Africa.\nIndian entrepreneurship needs to collaborate with Africa in areas like education and skill formation\, energy transition\, and agricultural production\, and development. These gaps could be filled by entrepreneurs’\, not through grants but through commercial partnerships tailored to local needs of African people. India would be a good partner for collaboration in developing a digital public infrastructure which would be key towards reducing the developmental gaps\, through the application of new technologies.\n\nKey Takeaways:\n\nThe African Union needs to be the anchor of all partnerships to ensure the overall development and growth of Africa\, this collective action will provide better leverage than working individually.\nThere is a need to consciously work on reducing the knowledge gap in terms of business policies through greater interaction on various platforms.\nIndia is a net food exporting country\, while Africa despite having a large land mass\, and remains a net importer of food. The defining aspect of this partnership would be how India can help Africa move from being a net importer to achieving food self-sufficiency\, through the application of new technologies.\nThe one ocean concept would be the key towards dealing with the shared challenges being confronted especially in the security front.\nIndia proposes to host the next India-Africa Forum Summit in the second half of 2025.\nAfrica needs many partners with each bringing their individual expertise in which India can help\, especially in the area of education and skill development which is a critical area for its future growth.\nDespite our shared historical relations and vision of a multi-polar world order that reflects the current realities\, the future strength of the partnership would be shaped by deeper people-to-people interaction which would help reduce the existing knowledge gap and enhance engagements.\nThere are major positives in terms of the strategic partnership but much needs to be done on the part of Africa through deeper engagements and undertaking collaborations with private India businesses.\n\nReport prepared by Dr Temjenmeren Ao \nSession – I: Framework for Cooperation\nThe first session examined how the present framework of India and Africa’s engagement is progressing. Speakers deliberated on the main priorities and challenges which shape and impact India’s relationship with African countries. \nThe chair set the tone for the discussions by highlighting the importance India attaches to developing its partnership with Africa which became evident in India facilitating the African Union’s membership into the G20 under the Indian Presidency. The chair highlighted that India has now become Africa’s third-largest trading partner\, after China and the European Union\, with trade volume reaching US$ 83.34 billion in 2023-2024 and cumulative Indian investments in Africa worth to be estimated around US$ 75 billion. \nChair:  Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi\, India \nSpeakers: \n\nDr Sharkdam Wapmuk\, Associate Professor and Head\, Dept of Defence and Security Studies\, Nigerian Defence Academy\, Nigeria on Nigeria and India as Strategic Partners in Africa: A Springboard for Deepening Indo-Africa Relations\nDr Folashadé Soulé\, Senior Research Associate\, Blavatnik School of Government\, University of Oxford\, UK on India-Africa Relations: Towards a Strategic Alignment of Interests?\nProf David Monyae\, Associate Professor of Political Science and IR\, Co-Director University of Johannesburg Confucius Institute and Centre for Africa China Studies\, South Africa on Africa-India Relations in Changing Geopolitics\nMs Ruchita Beri\, Senior Fellow\, Vivekananda International Foundation\, New Delhi\, India on India-Africa Partnership: Priorities and Prospects\n\nDr Sharkdam Wapmuk \n\nRecalled India’s first Prime Minister\, Jawaharlal Nehru’s visit to Nigeria in 1962 and highlighted why it was important to resonate with the vision of leaders who played a crucial role in setting the foundations of India-Africa engagement as we look ahead to ‘A Decade of Progress in India-Africa relations’.\nNigeria’s strategic position in West Africa and its maritime access (through major ports in Lagos\, Port Harcourt\, Calabar\, and Lekki deep sea port) makes it a logistics hub and potentially a gateway for India’s entry into West Africa\, both at the sub regional and continental level.\nDuring former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s visit to Nigeria in 2007\, the Abuja Declaration elevated India-Nigeria ties to a ‘Strategic Partnership’ level.\nPrime Minister Modi’s address to the Ugandan parliament in 2018 (known as Kampala principles) stressed on a relationship between India and Africa based on an equal footing. His visit to Nigeria in November 2024 during which he received the country’s second-highest civilian award\, served as a strategic signal to various audiences\, including investors.\nEconomic cooperation remains a key pillar of bilateral ties and has increased following the COVID-19 pandemic. Previously\, palm oil and crude oil constituted a major part of bilateral trade\, and the balance of trade favoured Nigeria. However\, the trade imbalance remains an issue\, as India’s exports are primarily manufacturing goods\, while imports from Nigeria are raw materials.\nSince the 1961 visit of the Nigerian national security advisor Nuhu Ribadu to Delhi calling for Indian assistance in setting up the country’s strategic institutions and India’s role in establishing the Nigerian Defence Academy\, Command and Staff College in the 1960s and Naval College in 1980\, security and defence collaboration has remained a key pillar of ties.\nIndia and Nigeria have engaged in intelligence sharing and military and technical collaboration in recent years through defence missions\, peacekeeping\, counterterrorism\, and maritime security cooperation.\nPartnerships in the health sector and medical tourism are also pillars of bilateral ties. It is important to address bureaucratic and policy hurdles in order to strengthen bilateral ties. Gaps in ease of travel\, visa procedures\, and identity perceptions between the two sides have a negative bearing on people-to-people ties.\n\nDr Folashadé Soulé \n\nThere has been a rapid expansion of India’s diplomatic engagement with Africa since the 2000s\, including the 2015 India-Africa Forum Summit (IAFS)\, ‘The Ten Guiding Principles for India-Africa Engagement’ in 2018\, the opening of 16 new missions and e-visa facilities extended to 33 African countries. This has helped overcome the longstanding criticism that governmental engagement lacked depth and was not sufficiently sustained.\nHistorical elements and a shared past in anti-colonial resistance and the Non Aligned Movement (NAM) – provided the foundations of India’s ties with Africa. By increasing engagement with other strategic partners such as India\, African countries are seeking to move beyond the US-China rivalry.\nIn present times\, African countries and their leaders are exercising greater agency in the ‘Age of Choices’ through trade\, security\, and investment partnerships. Attracting investment is a common priority for African countries\, and with the multiplication of ‘Africa+1’ summit platforms\, they are competing among themselves to be attractive Foreign Direct Investment destinations.\nAfrican countries are pursuing strategic autonomy through diversification of international partnerships.\nAs African countries deepen their economic integration through the AfCFTA\, they have taken centre stage in the global investment agenda. They are interested in pushing their strategic priorities\, such as non-reciprocal duty-free market access.\nIndia and Africa have moved from a steady and incremental approach in ties to a dynamic partnership\, as demonstrated by India facilitating the entry of the African Union into the G20 in 2023.\nAlongside long-standing cooperation in health\, and digital infrastructure\, especially the possibility of replicating India’s success in ‘India Stack’ and biometric identification by African countries\, is now receiving attention for leapfrogging the development stages.\nA key security challenge is the threat of terrorism in the Sahel region and its spillover to coastal countries. India’s security cooperation with African countries in areas like defence training\, intelligence and information sharing\, and arms sales will be important.\nIndia and its African partners need to scale up their communication and visibility strategies\, utilising media\, social media reports\, and high-level visits.\n\nProf. David Monyae \n\nThe India-Africa relationship is much deeper today than in previous decades. The scope of interactions covers a large canvas of various fields including politics\, culture\, health\, and agriculture.\nIndia led the campaign to include the African Union in G20\, which is a testament to the importance India attaches to strengthening its partnership with Africa.\nAfrica is important to India\, including its Africa’s role today in the global economy\, presence of critical mineral resources like lithium\, platinum and cobalt\, a growing and vibrant market\, and most importantly\, Africa’s ability to provide valuable diplomatic support as a bloc of 54 countries at various multilateral fora.\nOn India-Africa economic cooperation\, it is seen that since the 1960s\, India has engaged with Africa through initiatives such as Indian Technical Economic Cooperation (ITEC) and Special Commonwealth Africa Assistance Plan (SCAAP). These initiatives are part of India’s development cooperation model with Africa through scholarships\, information technology and healthcare.\nThe launch of the India-Africa Forum Summit (IAFS) process in 2008 expedited cooperation on multilateral platforms. The initiative resulted in significant growth in trade and investment. Today\, India has not only emerged as the fourth largest trading partner of Africa but also has a cumulative investment of US$ 70 billion in Africa which the Confederation of Indian Industries aims to increase to US$ 150 billion by 2030.\nIndia through its SAGAR policy intends to increase its footprint in Africa’s maritime zone. In 2015\, it signed agreements with Mauritius and Seychelles to develop infrastructure on the islands of Agalega and Assumption. Several MoUs including defence cooperation and two Lines of Credit worth US$ 60 million\, were singed during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Kenya in July 2016.\nThe Indian Navy collaborates with African countries in the Indian Ocean for anti-piracy\, surveillance\, and disaster relief operations. It was the first international partner to respond during cyclones in Mozambique in 2019 and Madagascar in 2020. African navies actively participated in Indian Navy’s MILAN biennial exercises. Besides\, new initiatives like the Africa-India Field Training Exercise (AFINDEX) and the India-Africa Defence Ministers’ Conclave in 2020 have been launched with the aim of exploring avenues for defence cooperation.\nIndia’s role in UN Peacekeeping Operations (UNPKOs) in Africa must be highlighted. There is scope for expansion of people-to-people relations and sustained and regular engagement between India and Africa in the future.\n\nMs. Ruchita Beri \n\nIndia attaches immense importance to its relationship with Africa.\nIndia views Africa positively and refers to it as a continent of hope. At least four to five African economies are part of the ten fastest-growing economies of the world. India’s partnership with Africa is based on the demand and priorities of Africa and is intended to enhance local capabilities\, and open new diplomatic missions.\nWhen it comes to priorities\, these are decided in consultation with African countries. There are a number of projects initiated under the Line of Credit offered by India. The two sides have a number of shared concerns in the fields of health\, food and infrastructure. During Covid-19 pandemic\, India stepped up its efforts to help the African countries deal with the crisis. India played a vital role through its ‘Vaccine Maitri’ initiative.\nIndia intends to help Africa deal with issues related to food security. Africa has 65% of the world’s arable land but continues to suffer from food shortages. India can offer its expertise in the field of food security and become self-sufficient.\nDigital infrastructure is another priority area where digital infrastructure such as Unified Payments Interface (UPI) and the India Stack could be shared.\nIndia and Africa must organise the fourth IAFS at the earliest possible date. While facilitating private engagement\, India must ensure that building local capabilities in Africa gets requisite attention and importance.\n\nReport prepared by Dr. Deepika Saraswat and Dr. Ashish Shukla \nSession – II: Partnership for Deepening Trade and Investment Ties\nThe second session examined how India could maximise trade and investment relations with Africa by leveraging the existing frameworks. It discussed strategic ideas to enhance economic partnership and promote sustainable prosperity between India and African nations. \nThe session was chaired by Amb. Gurjit Singh\, who in his opening remarks noted that the African continent provides various trade and infrastructure opportunities to its international partners at a time when the world has become more transactional. He emphasised the importance of India and Africa working together to build a mutually beneficial relationship. He highlighted several components of India-Africa relations including trade\, development cooperation\, Duty-Free Tariff Preference (DFTP) and Information Technology (IT). \nHe recalled that investments in Africa since 2008 have helped India gain economic credit and garner diplomatic influence. He suggested that a trade and investment-led model of bilateral ties does not follow political dictates but looks at the sheer possibility of profit and development. On the other hand\, FDI-led investment provides opportunities to access regional markets and expand economic influence. He emphasised the role of academia\, governments\, business and Indian diaspora in strengthening trade and investment ties with Africa and also added that the Indian government should seek to encourage more investment in Africa by the Indian private sector. \nChair: Amb Gurjit Singh\, former Indian Ambassador to Germany\, Indonesia\, Ethiopia\, ASEAN and the African Union\, Hon. Professor\, IIT Indore\, New Delhi\, India. \nSpeakers: \n\nProf Stephen Onyeiwu\, Professor of Economics and former Chair of Dept\, Allegheny College\, US on Strengthening India-Africa Strategic Trade and Investment Partnerships in Frontier Industries\nMr Kwame Owino\, Chief Executive Officer\, Institute of Economic Affairs\, Kenya on India and Africa: Exploring the Path Towards a Free Trade Area\nProf Hebatallah Adam\, Professor and Associate Dean for Academic Affairs\, Jindal School of International Affairs\, India on Enhancing India-Africa Trade and Investment: Leveraging AfCFTA and DFTP Programs for Mutual Growth and Economic Integration\n\nProf Stephen Onyeiwu \n\nIndia and Africa’s trade and investment ties are on solid footing and both sides need to strengthen it further. India and Africa trade figures are increasing year-on-year reaching US$ 83 billion in 2023. One of the key drivers of bilateral trade is India’s import of oil resources from the continent. That has resulted in India becoming Africa’s fourth-largest trading partner.\nIndia should seek to export high-quality manufacturing goods. At present India is exporting goods to African nations in sectors like textiles\, pharmaceuticals\, and automobiles but must seek to diversify its export basket to the continent by selling hi-tech products.\nAt present\, most of India’s investments are for huge projects from bigger businesses such as Adani\, Ambani\, Tata\, Mahindra & Mahindra\, etc.\, overlooking the informal sectors. The focus of investment must shift to the 80% of informal sectors in Africa that empowers more people.\nAfrica and India should emphasise cooperating on new and emerging technologies such as AI\, robotics and digital public infrastructures in order not to fall behind. These frontier technologies are going to create a huge market all over the world which is very likely to be exploited by the US and China in the near future.\nFood and agro-processing sectors are important areas for targeting Indian investments due to Africa’s constant challenge of dealing with food insecurity. Investments in agro-processing can create jobs\, especially for rural women of the continent. He also suggested that India and Africa should create an alternative global value chain (GVC).\nThe Chair noted India’s investment in Africa is difficult to monitor and calculate accurately because many big Indian investments comes from foreign lands. For example\, Airtel’s investment in Africa is an Indian investment that comes from the Netherlands\, and the Indian company Godrej’s investment in Nigeria comes from Singapore.\n\nKwame Owino \n\nIndia-Africa trade patterns have witnessed significant shifts\, including trade diversification\, strategic partnerships and geographical expansion. The trade basket has expanded\, leading to increased volumes and mutual economic benefits.\nThere is great scope for engagement with one-third of land-locked countries in Africa who are dependent on open trade regimes.\nThere has been an eight-fold increase in trade volumes between India and Africa from 2000 to 2010. The bilateral trade has further diversified with the evolution of the IT sector.\nIndia-Africa trade ties have revived since the Covid-19 pandemic resulting in the recognition of the vitality in strengthening value chains in critical sectors at a time when there is a freeze in multilateral advancement.\nLastly\, the importance of the Indo Pacific region for Africa must be underlined\, in which significant number of global activities are concentrated. This region provides immense potential for Africa and India to collaborate.\n\nProf. Hebatallah Adam \n\nTrade and investment partnership between India and Africa has experienced substantial expansion\, with bilateral trade reaching US$ 83.34 billion in 2023-24 and India’s cumulative investments in Africa reaching US$ 75 billion. This partnership is set for further growth with the implementation of the AfCFTA\, which presents a consolidated market of 1.3 billion people\, and India’s DFTP program\, which grants preferred access for African products to enter the Indian market.\nSignificant potential exists in terms of expanding trade portfolios\, improving infrastructure\, and digital connectivity\, promoting value addition in African companies\, and engaging in sectors such as renewable energy\, healthcare\, and agriculture.\nChallenges like regulatory barriers\, infrastructure deficiencies\, and political uncertainties must be resolved to realise the complete potential of India -Africa cooperation. By aligning with the objectives of the AfCFTA and using the DFTP program\, India can enhance Africa’s integration into global value chains\, facilitate Africa’s industrialisation\, and establish a mutually beneficial partnership for both regions.\nIndia and Africa’s ties are based upon South-South cooperation\, mutual trust\, Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and two-way collaborations. Potential sectors for collaboration are energy\, security\, peacekeeping\, trade and investments.\nIndia’s model of engagement with Africa is more transformational than transactional and aimed at people’s development. Progressing together encompasses the motto of India and Africa’s ties. .\nIndia is already providing technical training to African students in various IT programs. Many Africans have benefitted from the Pan African e-Network Project (PAeNP) under which India set up a fibre-optic network to provide satellite connectivity\, tele-medicine and tele-education to university students and medical practitioners based in Africa.\nIndia should look to invest in Africa’s education\, technology\, capacity building\, and enhance trade and investment. India must diversify beyond traditional sectors such as IT\, renewable energy\, and agro engineering. India should manufacture in Africa to export value added products\, and build Africa’s manufacturing and transportation infrastructure which the continent lacks.\nIndia should share its experiences in agro processing\, renewable energy and pharmaceutical. These sectors will create jobs in Africa that will empower the people. India should invest more to cater to Africa’s huge market and explore possibility of setting up Special Economic Zones. India should also consider Africa for investment because the continent has rich natural resources\, high percentage of youth population\, and growing middle class.\nThe chair remarked that Africa can grab the opportunity of exporting lentil pulses to India (only Tanzania and Mozambique presently does) and cited the example of Myanmar that exports lentils to India of worth US$ 1 billion a year. India has made a progress by investing in lentils in Africa and have also set up processing centre.\n\nKey Takeaways:\n\nIndia should follow a new structure of trade in Africa dealing with high-quality manufacturing goods.\nIndia’s investments must cover Africa’s 80% of informal sectors.\nFood and agro sector are significant field for Indian investment in Africa.\nAfrica can find new opportunities in the Indo-Pacific region because of the increasing global activities in the region.\nIndia must diversify beyond traditional sectors such as emerging technologies\, IT\, renewable energy\, agro engineering that can empower the Africans.\nIndia should work together with Africa in creating an alternative global value chain.\nIndia should set up manufacturing hubs and SEZs in Africa.\n\nReport prepared by Dr. Abhishek Kumar Darbey \nSession–III: Partnership in Multilateral Forum and Global Governance Reforms\nThe third session discussed the issues of weakening of the multilateral institutions which were created in the post-World War II period\, the uneven distribution of power in the international order\, and the partnership between Africa and India for the democratisation of the global governance system. \nChair: Prof Ajay Dubey\, Professor\, School of International Studies\, Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU)\, India \nSpeakers: \n\nAmb Ruchira Kamboj\, Former Permanent Representative of India to the United Nations in New York and former Indian High Commissioner to South Africa\, on India’s advocacy for the inclusion of the African Union in the G20\nMr Aly Verjee\, Senior Associate\, Amani Africa and Researcher at University of Gothenburg\, Sweden on Approaching Multilateral Forums and Global Governance Reforms during the Decline of Multilateralism and Global Governance\nDr Kwaku Danso\, Dean\, Faculty of Academic Affairs\, Kofi Annan International Peacekeeping Training Center\, Ghana on From Objects to Subjects of Global Governance: Partnering to Center Africa and India in a Changing World Order\n\nAmb Ruchira Kamboj\, Former Permanent Representative of India to the United Nations in New York and former Indian High Commissioner to South Africa\, made a presentation on “India’s advocacy for the inclusion of the African Union in the G20”. \n\nIn her presentation\, Amb Kamboj discussed about India’s relations with the African continent. She referred to the historical injustices done to Africa and issues that have brought India and Africa closer.\nThe inclusion of the African Union in G20 in September 2023 was a historic moment which reflected New Delhi’s efforts to elevate the international position of Africa and make the multilateral institution and system more inclusive.\nIndia has committed to give priorities to the interests of the African countries and those of the Global South. From the Indian perspective\, the multilateral intuitions are important and they need to be reformed to make them democratic and reflective of the global challenges confronted by the world today.\nAmb Kamboj emphasised that the African nations applauded India’s role in facilitating the participation of the African Union in the G20.\n\nMr Aly Verjee\, Senior Associate\, Amani Africa and Researcher at University of Gothenburg\, Sweden presented his paper online on “Approaching Multilateral Forums and Global Governance Reforms during the Decline of Multilateralism and Global Governance”. \n\nMr Verjee in his presentation describing the ongoing chaos in the multilateral institutions. The exit of the United States from the World Health Organisation (WHO) and Washington’s withdrawal of aid and assistance to the developing countries under President Donal Trump’s second term would be detrimental for African nations.\nThe speaker highlighted that the response from India and Africa would be significant in meeting the challenges posed by ongoing developments in the global order. In this regard\, the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi in India has been supportive of greater participation of Africa in forums of global governance.\nMr Verjee discussed the cooperation between India and the African countries to meet the challenges posed by the shifting global order\, and the damages caused to the multilateral institutions due to the advent of second Donald Trump administration in the United States.\nAccording to Mr Verjee\, greater participation in the multilateral institutions by the African countries may not be beneficial for the latter if the former lose influence and power. For\, example Africa’s or India’s participation in the G20 or the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) would have less impact if the powerful nations do not cooperate among themselves.\n\nDr Kwaku Danso\, Dean\, Faculty of Academic Affairs\, Kofi Annan International Peacekeeping Training Center\, Ghana presented his paper on “From Objects to Subjects of Global Governance: Partnering to Center Africa and India in a Changing World Order”. \n\nDr Danso in his presentation critiqued the present global governance system which was established after the end of the World War II. The inherent “double standards” in the current international order has led to the dominance of the Global North and marginalisation of the Global South.\nHe asserted that the need to reform and “decolonise” the institutions of global governance in order to make them suitable in the current global circumstances and mitigate the existing disparities in the international system.\nIn this regard\, Africa and India could make significant efforts to bring a desirable shift in democratising the global and multilateral institutions\, and establish a fair distribution of power in the world.\nDr. Danso concluded by remarking that the level of collaboration between Africa and India would be important in making them either the “subjects” or the “objects” of the international order in the coming times.\n\nKey Takeaways\n\nThe papers presented in this session largely emphasised on the unfair distribution of power in the current global governance system\, and the need to reform the multilateral institutions.\nThe papers also asserted the need for closer engagement between the African countries and India to overcome the challenges posed by the weakening of the global institutions\, and to democratise the international system.\nIndia’s commitment to make the multilateral intuitions more inclusive has been significant in developing India-Africa partnership.\nDespite closer engagement between India and the African countries\, the cooperation of the powerful nations would be essential to maintain the viability of the multilateral institutions.\n\nReport prepared by Dr Ranjit Kumar Dhawan \nSession IV – Defence Cooperation and Maritime Cooperation\nThe fourth session examined how African nations in recent years have made greater efforts towards evolving a common vision for dealing with the continent’s maritime challenges for sustainable development. The participants discussed the scope for India to enhance maritime security cooperation with African countries and the common maritime challenges that are faced by both India and Africa. \nVice Admiral Shekhar Sinha\, in his opening remarks\, highlighted the growing uncertainty in the international system following the election of Donald Trump as the US President. He stated that these uncertainties will create new alignments and alter the dynamics of international cooperation\, particularly in the maritime domain. VAdm Sinha pointed out that the Indian Ocean Region (IOR) is bound to become a centre for geopolitical competitions and territorial contestations. He highlighted the need for India to foster greater collaboration with other IOR littoral nations\, including countries in the East African Coast\, to address common maritime security challenges. \nChair: VAdm Shekhar Sinha (Retd)\, Chairman\, Board of Trustees\, India Foundation\, New Delhi \nSpeakers: \n\nMr Raj Mohabeer\, Officer in Charge\, Indian Ocean Commission\, Mauritius on Scope for enhancing India-Africa cooperation to address maritime security challenges in the Western Indian Ocean\nCapt Sarabjeet S. Parmar (Retd)\, Distinguished Fellow\, Council for Defence and Strategic Research\, New Delhi\, India on India and Africa: Enhancing Defence Cooperation and Maritime Security\nDr Nicodemus M Minde\, Researcher\, Institute for Security Studies\, Nairobi\, Kenya on India-Africa Defence Cooperation and Maritime Security: The Case of Kenya\n Abyssinia Abay Mengistu\, India Africa Security Fellow\, MP-IDSA and Lecturer in International Law and Organizations\, Bahir Dar University\, Ethiopia on Assessing the Impact of AfINDEX 2023 on India’s Security role in Africa\n\nMr Raj Mohabeer \n\nThere is a need to enhance the India-Africa cooperation to address maritime security challenges\, particularly in the Western Indian Ocean (WIOR). Intergovernmental organisations such as the Indian Ocean Commission (IOC) have a key role in promoting security and stability in the WIOR. Drug trafficking\, arms smuggling\, human trafficking and Illegal\, Unreported\, and Unregulated (IUU) fishing are the major maritime security challenges faced by WIOR nations. In this context\, the following recommendations are made to enhance India-Africa Cooperation for jointly addressing the maritime security challenges of the WIOR:\nPromoting Regional Institutions and Mechanisms: It is impossible for a single nation to ensure the security and stability of vast maritime regions such as the WIOR. Hence\, it is important to foster greater regional and international cooperation particularly on issues such as piracy off the coast of Somalia. Promoting regional institutions can lead to stronger cooperation between India and the WIOR Nations on maritime security issues. The creation of regional conventions and enforcement mechanisms for implementing joint efforts to address security challenges in the WIOR is vital. This will also lead to the streamlining of capacity-building efforts jointly undertaken by India and African nations at a bilateral level.\nGreater Focus on Maritime Domain Awareness (MDA): One of the key challenges of the WIOR is the lack of MDA. Hence\, there is an urgent need to adopt an intelligence- based focus for tracking the movement of vessels and other activities on the high seas of the WIOR.\nReorientation of National Perspective on Maritime Security Issues: As the national security perspective of most WIOR nations has been shaped by colonial heritage\, there is considerable sea-blindness. This has led to an inadequate national framework among WIOR nations for addressing maritime security challenges. Due to this\, independent maritime security agencies in the WIOR nations often work in silos\, leading to a lack of coordination. India as an observer of IOC can play a vital role in guiding the security discourse of the WIOR.\n\nCapt Sarabjeet S. Parmar (Retd.) \n\nAfrica occupies a central position in both of India’s primary and secondary areas of maritime interest. Maritime threats in the region are fundamentally hybrid in nature with challenges like piracy\, terrorism\, natural disaster and pandemics. Apart from these threats\, there is the looming threat to submarine cables in the IOR\, which are economic lifelines of the entire region. In this context\, the following recommendations for enhancing synergy between India and Africa to address this range of maritime security issues is given below:\nEnvisaging a Strategic Framework for Collaboration: India’s Maritime Outlook based on Security and Growth for All in the Region (SAGAR) and Mutual and Holistic Advancement for SAGAR (MAHASAGAR) can serve as a broad template for envisaging a strategic framework required for guiding collaboration between India and Africa on maritime security issues. Apart from that\, the Gandhinagar Declaration made in 2020 during the India Africa Defence Dialogue (IADD) can provide a holistic roadmap for tangibly enhancing collaboration between India and Africa.\nCooperation in Capacity Building Programmes: Joint training programmes between the Indian Navy and the navies of Africa can be a critical component for maritime capacity building and capability enhancement. This will particularly help African navies to conduct maritime security operations\, both independently and in coordination with other maritime forces in the region. Joint exercises can enable both Indian and African Navies to share best practices\, procedures and doctrinal learnings with each other. Exercises like the Africa-India Key Maritime Engagement (AIKEYME)\, Indian Ocean Ship (IOS) Sagar\, and India-Mozambique Tanzania Trilateral Exercise (IMT-TRILAT) can play a crucial role in this endeavour.\nJoint Deployment in the High Seas: Policing the High Risk Areas (HRA) of the WIOR requires the pooling of resources between India and African navies. Hence\, envisaging frameworks for enabling joint deployment of the assets of the Indian and the African navies in common areas of interest can play a crucial role in shaping a favourable maritime environment.\nCollaboration in Enhancing MDA and Underwater Domain Awareness (UDA): There must be collaborative efforts between India and Africa to enhance MDA and UDA in the WIOR. This is particularly important for securing the Sea Lines of Communication and undersea infrastructure which are critical for the economy of the region.\n\nDr. Nicodemus M Minde \n\nMaritime security\, defence cooperation and regional stability have always been the key areas of focus in India-Kenya bilateral relations. Kenya as a gateway to East Africa and the IOR is fully aligned with India’s SAGAR initiative. Both nations have a long history of joint military training\, naval exchanges and technological assistance. Both India and Kenya view piracy\, maritime terrorism and IUU fishing as common maritime threats. In this context\, the following challenges and opportunities for maritime cooperation between India and Kenya are elucidated below:\nKenya’s Consonance with India’s SAGAR Initiative – Kenya’s Blue Economy goals are strongly aligned with India’s SAGAR initiative. The Indian Navy has safely escorted over 3\,500 vessels in the region since 2008. As a result of this Kenya’s fish exports have increased by 20% to US$ 100 million in 2023.\nKenya’s Preference of India as a Security Partner – The Indian Navy’s soft power outreach to Kenya through training\, goodwill visits and technological aid has been a great success. India’s US$ 250 million aid to Kenya in 2024 has been very well received. As a result\, Kenya rejected the Chinese naval base proposal in 2019\, favouring India’s non-hegemonic approach.\nIndia’s Limitation and Constraints: The potential of India’s security assistance to Kenya is constrained by India’s US$ 73 billion defence budget as opposed to China’s US$ 230 billion. Also\, there have been maintenance issues with the patrol vessels donated by India to Kenya. This has undermined Kenya’s ability to counter Al-Shabaab in their territorial waters.\nExploring the Avenues of Defence Cooperation: The proposed US$ 20 million India-Kenya joint naval task force has the potential to cut piracy and terrorism response times by 50%. Also India can consider increasing the officer training slots for Kenyan military personnel to 100 annually by 2025. India can contribute to advanced MDA cooperation with Kenya by a US$ 5 million investment in drones and satellite systems by 2027 to reduce IUU fishing losses by 50 percent.\n\nMr. Abyssinia Abay Mengistu \nThe following challenges regarding India-Africa cooperation on maritime security were highlighted: \n\nPrioritisation of Domestic Politics over Maritime Security Issues: Cooperation between India and Africa in defence and maritime security is deeply interwoven or interlinked with domestic political dynamics which prioritises regional survival than national survival. Due to this\, national security is deprioritised in a sense that leaders divert resources away from the maritime security initiatives to maintain political power. Reports from the African Union regional bodies also highlighted how domestic politics often overshadow strategic maritime concerns.\nDetrimental Role of Regional Power Rivalry: Cooperation in the maritime domain is further undermined by regional power rivalries. For instance\, rivalries between these regional nations such as South Africa\, Nigeria\, Ethiopia versus Egypt issues. These rivalries eventually lead to fragmented efforts in addressing collective maritime security challenges.\nAdapting Engagement Policy: India’s reputation of non-interference in the internal affairs of other nations is a major asset to foster greater collaboration with the African nations. India could still adopt a more adaptive engagement strategy that would allow for informal support and capacity building\, focusing on local government structures. India can adopt community-based maritime security initiatives that would engage local populations and governance structures.\n\nReport prepared by Dr. R. Vignesh \nSession – V: Partnership in Critical Minerals and Energy Security\nThe fifth session examined how India and African countries can partner together in the field of strategic minerals and how India can enhance its renewable energy footprint while supporting Africa’s energy transition and provide clean\, affordable and accessible energy. \nThe session was chaired by Dr. Shailly Kedia who set the tone of discussion by highlighting the growing importance of critical minerals in the world and in particular to India’s growing demand of critical minerals to meet renewable energy source. She underscored that although African countries remained the backbone for critical mineral resources\, yet the mineral sector continues to remain trapped in the bottom of value chain\, where the African region are lacking in processing and manufacturing technologies. Due to domination of mineral industries by China\, African countries are finding it difficult and challenging to fully realize the development of its economy. \nChair: Dr. Shailly Kedia\, Senior Fellow and Associate Director\, The Energy and Resources Institute\, New Delhi. \nSpeakers: \n\n Annika Bose Styczynski\, Associate Professor and Associate Dean\, Research & International Collaboration\, Jindal School of Government and Public Policy\, O.P. Jindal Global University\, Haryana\, India on Getting Real About Low-Carbon Energy Technologies: Partnerships in Critical Minerals for Energy Security\n Sanjay Kumar Pradhan\, Associate Professor and Head of the Department of International Relations\, Pandit Deendayal Energy University\, Gujarat\, India on India\, Africa and Energy Transition: Partnership for Critical Minerals\n Sandipani Dash\, Assistant Professor\, Department of African Studies\, University of Delhi on Bharat-Africa Partnership: Progress and Possibility in Sub-Soil Resource Sector\n\nDr. Annika Bose Styczynski   \n\nExplained the importance of critical minerals and their applications through presentation on\, “Getting Real about Low-Carbon Energy Technologies: Partnerships in Critical Minerals for Energy Security.” India needs to collaborate with other states in order to counter Chinese hegemony in mineral sector.\nEnergy is vital for the economic development of society. Though coal and petroleum still dominate the energy sector\, in recent times critical minerals have become increasingly imperative due to transition of energy resources to clean energy in order to mitigate the Impact of climate change.\nCritical minerals are a subset of minerals that are essential for the manufacturing and technological applications. Various countries have identified several minerals as critical minerals. However\, minerals like nickel\, manganese\, lithium\, and copper have been designated as critical minerals by most countries. Each critical mineral has its own specific purpose or usage. For instance\, light rare earth elements are used for generators and motors for wind power and electric vehicles and lithium is used in batteries.\nIn the critical minerals sector\, China continues to dominate in terms of raw material extraction and processing as well as in producing goods. It is only in recent years that India and other Western countries have started taking steps to proactively pursue critical minerals.\nChina is the dominant player in the African market\, including in mining as well as in terms of investment and consumption of critical minerals. One of the key features of China’s policy is based on extending easy credit to the companies through state-sponsored entities.\nIn spite of Chinese domination in African region in critical minerals sectors\, there are concerns about the transparency of Chinese mining operations\, environmental impact and labour practices. There are also reports that local communities are not benefiting in terms of economic development like adequate employment opportunities.\nIndia largely depends on the import of critical minerals\, with nearly 80% of Lithium being imported from China. In order to counter China’s domination in critical minerals sector\, one key element is for India to establish collaborations with African countries. India’s signing of an MoU in October 2024 on critical minerals with the United States and the launch of ‘National Critical Mineral Missions’ in January 2025 will also help streamline the supply chain of critical minerals and reduce China’s monopoly in this sector.\nCooperation on critical mineral sectors between India and Africa has emerged recently. However there are fundamental issues\, which need to be addressed\, i.e.\, transparency\, regulations\, human rights issue and environmental degradation. Every stakeholder needs to remember the UN Sustainable Development Goals as most African countries are lagging behind. Hence\, in exploiting critical mineral resources\, India and African countries must consider the corporate social responsibility diligently.\n\nDr. Sanjay Kumar Pradhan \n\nMitigating climate change is one of the fundamental factors driving the world’s search for critical minerals. Several minerals such as nickel\, manganese\, PGM\, cobalt\, lithium\, silica and tantalum fall under the category of critical minerals.\nAs India is one of the largest emitters of carbon dioxide\, achieving the Paris agreements remain crucial. Hence\, transition to clean energy becomes necessary. Yet\, India largely depends on imports of several critical minerals to support clean energy. Report indicates that by 2030\, the demand for lithium will increase to 20\,845 tonnes and the demand for cobalt to 5\,914 tonnes.\nThe African region possesses about 30% of global critical minerals. Hence\, cooperation with African countries is vital. Currently\, India imports a large percentage of critical minerals from South Africa\, Gabon\, Madagascar\, Zambia and Tanzania. Meanwhile\, 10 MoUs have been signed for geological surveys\, access\, and processing of critical minerals. The Indian Government has also initiated for getting a block (where?) on priority basis\, assisting Indian private companies and in 2021 launched the Supply Chain Resilience Initiative with Japan and Australia.\nThough\, in recent years the African Union has adopted several mechanisms for the sustainable development of mineral resources\, i.e.\, African Mining Vision\, African Minerals Governance Framework\, several challenges including transparency in the mineral sector continues to remain.\nThere is a need for India and Africa to maintain a win-win situation in the mineral sector particularly by exploring joint ventures with foreign companies and developing an ecosystem for refining and processing critical minerals. Establishment of a critical minerals fund\, recovery of critical metals through recycling\, and the establishment of national institute to conduct research on critical mineral resources and empower training skills to the African mining practitioners is imperative.\n\nDr. Sandipani Dash \n\nElaborating on the topic “Bharat-Africa Partnership: Progress and Possibility in Sub-Soil Resource Sector”\, the speaker explored the common shared values between India and African countries\, the policy frameworks that have been implemented over the years and the practical approach in relations to natural resources.\nOn the shared value\, the concept of ‘mother earth’ was underscored where both India and African have deep-rooted belief and reverence of nature. In other words\, communities in India and Africa have deep respect for nature from where food and water resources are derived for the prosperity of human civilization. Such reverence of nature is evident in numerous philosophical literatures as well as archaeological sources. Evidence indicates that communities in India and African region worship nature for prosperity.\nFrom the late 18th century\, however\, such traditional beliefs and reverence of nature has change into an object of control\, particularly unleashed by the European colonial powers. Consequently\, slavery system and industrial revolution managed to flourish in England and in other European imperialist empire. Hence\, in the name of resources capture\, conflict and wars were regular feature in the African region and in India.\nFollowing decolonization\, both the African region and India have witnessed a common policies orientation by opening up their market to the outside world for pursuing development. Indeed\, economic liberalization led to market drive-export growth. Meanwhile\, in international forum both India and African region had common agenda for inclusive development. Such principle implies that both India and African have shifted from the scramble for resources to pursuing inclusive\, sustainable development.\n\nKey Takeaways:\n\nCollaborations between India and African countries in critical minerals is vital for win-win situation. However in the backdrop of signing MoUs for accessing critical minerals\, stakeholders need to ensure sustainable development.\nFormulation of sound policies\, especially for critical mineral resources is crucial. Hence\, setting up national institute for conducting research critically is indispensable\, where it will aid policymakers to implement strategy effectively.\n\nReport prepared by Dr. Opangmeren Jamir
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/event-report-5th-india-africa-strategic-dialogue-on-india-and-africa-partnership-in-the-next-decade
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT,ANNUAL CONFERENCES
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR