BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20230101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20241007T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20241007T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T031128
CREATED:20241101T052447Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20241101T052447Z
UID:83171-1728279000-1728279000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting Report: ‘The Evolving Development and Security Agenda in the QUAD’
DESCRIPTION:Ms. Shruti Pandalai\, Associate Fellow at the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analysis\, made a presentation on “The Evolving Development and Security Agenda in the QUAD” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 07 Oct 2024. Dr.. Temjenmeren Ao\, Associate Fellow at MP-IDSA\, moderated the session. The Director General and scholars of MP-IDSA attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nDr. Temjenmeren Ao started with opening remarks and some historical briefs about the Quad. He stated that the revival of Quad in recent years has been associated with a change in its objectives. Quad which brought together four nations in response to the humanitarian crisis in 2004\, today is a platform for partnership in diverse areas which is key towards the promotion of a free and open Indo-Pacific region. He also emphasised the successive summits and the key initiatives in new areas from climate change to vaccines under its health partnership\, AI and emerging technologies\, infrastructure\, that reinforce Quad as a global force for good to other countries in the region which is capable of stepping up towards delivering public goods. He emphasised how Quad in advancing deeper bilateral and multilateral cooperation such as AUKUS\, SQUAD\, IPEF\, etc. is shaping the security cooperation network in the Indo-Pacific region. He also emphasised that Quad is not a monolithic group by any means\, and there is divergence amongst the Quad members about how they perceive security challenges. However\, their shared values\, and concerns via-vis China are anchoring the partnership. After that\, he requested Ms. Pandalai to make her presentation. \nDetailed Report\nDr. Shruti Pandalai started with an introduction of the Quad and explained why it is valuable in the plethora of key US led initiatives. She expanded on how the Quad which is an assemblage of like-minded countries in the Indo-Pacific region\, was anchoring cooperation in the important geography\, and how it would be worthwhile to analyse the evolution of the Quad\, its developments and rebirth\, key agendas\, prospects\, challenges\, and the relevance of the Quad.   \nNext\, she explained the importance of Quad in maintaining regional stability\, deterring economic and maritime coercion\, and balancing major power relations amidst the rise of an assertive China. \nMs. Pandalai delved into the shaping of the strategic vision of the Quad when it was revived in 2017 and up until 2019 and talked about the expansion and operationalisation of the public goods agenda between 2020 and 2022. One of her key arguments included that while the development and security agenda of the Quad go hand in hand\, it would be incorrect to dismiss the security cooperation within the Quad as insignificant. Increasingly the security agenda includes the Indo Pacific Maritime Domain awareness (IPDM)\, intelligence sharing\, joint exercises like Malabar aimed at enhancing interoperability among the Quad nations\, countering regional threats through strategic and operational coordination\, and strengthening of Quad. \nShe also mentioned the impacts of election cycles on the revival of the Quad\, and the developments in the Quad in 2023 and 2024. The Quad’s working groups spanning vaccines to climate change\, infrastructure\, security initiatives\, cybersecurity partnerships\, and health security initiatives have become the key markers for the Quad’s socialisation. \nMs. Pandalai further discussed recent developments within the Quad\, such as joint training\, capacity building\, 2+2 foreign and security dialogues\, collective maritime capacity and capability building\, cybersecurity\, cooperation on undersea cable connectivity and resilience etc. While talking about the importance of Quad for India\, she discussed how it had become the major platform for channelling India’s vision for the Indo-Pacific and outreach on key sectors and initiatives. She argued that it also reflected the transformation of India’s ties with each of the participating nations within the Quad. For India\, the agendas overlap in bilateral\, trilateral\, and multilateral forums with these partner countries and helps building relationships within bureaucracies\, military\, industries\, and technological ecosystems. \nMs Pandalai then addressed the criticism of Quad\, especially on hard security. She argued that the motivation of the four countries will remain to balance the security and development agenda of the Quad and provide viable alternatives to regional requirements focussed on cutting-edge tech collaboration. \nConcluding her presentation\, she mentioned there is no current interest among the members for the expansion of the Quad\, cooperation with other partners will continue on issue based agendas and approaches. \nQuestions and Comments\nThe Director General\, Amb. Chinoy made insightful comments on the Quad. The scholars at MP-IDSA posed a diverse range of questions\, including on the expansion of Quad membership and Quad security cooperation. Ms. Shruti Pandalai appreciated the insights from the attendees and answered the questions posed to her.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-report-the-evolving-development-and-security-agenda-in-the-quad
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20241023T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20241023T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T031128
CREATED:20241023T012210Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20241227T005409Z
UID:83112-1729661400-1729661400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting Report on “Peace Agreements in Assam”
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Pushpita Das\,  Research Fellow\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses  (MP-IDSA)\, spoke on “Peace Agreements in Assam” at the Monday Morning Meeting  held on 14 October 2024. The session was moderated by Col. DPK Pillay (Retd.)\,  Research Fellow\, MP-IDSA. The scholars of the institute were in attendance and  participated in the discussion.  \nExecutive  Summary\nThe presentation focused on discussing various peace agreements in  Assam\, highlighting the significance of recent peace accords between the Indian  Government and various insurgent groups in the region. These agreements mark a  substantial decline in violence and indicate progress towards lasting peace.  Five major peace agreements were signed between 2020 and 2023 with different  ethnic insurgent groups in Assam\, particularly focusing on the Bodo\, Karbi\, and  Dimasa insurgencies. The agreements aim to balance tribal political aspirations  and Assam’s territorial integrity\, while also addressing socio-cultural and  developmental needs. However\, unresolved demands for separate statehood and  ethnic tensions among smaller tribes pose ongoing challenges to sustained  peace. \nDetailed Report\nCol. DPK Pillay (Retd.)  began the meeting with a brief introduction of Dr. Pushpita Das and the topic  that she was to present at the meeting. Dr. Pushpita Das began her presentation  by setting the context for the peace agreements\, which have played a pivotal  role in reducing violence in Assam. She explained that the region has long been  troubled by insurgent groups with political goals ranging from demands for  political autonomy to full secession. These groups\, formed by ethnic tribes in  Assam\, have waged armed struggles over the years\, seeking to safeguard their  customs\, traditions\, and territorial rights. She further informed the scholars  that the violence associated with these movements has placed Assam in a cycle  of despair for decades. However\, the last five years have seen a series of  peace agreements signed between the Indian Government\, both at the state and  union levels\, and various insurgent factions. Dr. Das noted that these  agreements have significantly reduced the frequency of violent incidents\, as a  growing number of militants have surrendered and chosen to negotiate with the  government\, bringing a much-needed sense of peace and hope to the people of  Assam. \nDr. Das proceeded to  discuss the timeline of the peace agreements\, highlighting five major accords  that were signed between 2020 and 2023. The first major peace agreement\, signed  on 27 January 2020\, involved four factions of the National Democratic Front of  Bodoland (NDFB). This tripartite agreement marked a critical moment in the  history of Assam’s insurgent movements. The NDFB\, one of the most prominent  insurgent groups in the region\, had been involved in violent activities for  decades\, primarily in pursuit of a separate Bodo state. Over time\, however\, the  group fractured into several factions: NDFB Progressive\, NDFB Dhirendra Bodo\,  NDFB Ranjan Daimary\, and NDFB Saoraigwra. NDFB-P had surrendered as early as  2005\, and by January 2020\, NDFB-S followed suit. The signing of the agreement  led to the disbanding of various Bodo insurgent groups\, significantly reducing  violence in the region. \nThe second peace  agreement was signed on 4 September 2021 and involved various Karbi insurgent  groups that had been active in the districts of Karbi Anglong. Dr. Das  explained that these groups\, like the Bodo factions\, had long demanded a  separate state. However\, after years of armed struggle\, over 1\,000 Karbi  insurgents surrendered following the signing of the peace agreement. This  marked another significant step toward peace in Assam\, particularly in the  Karbi Anglong region\, which had been a hotbed of insurgent activity for many  years. \nOn 15 September 2022\,  the third peace agreement was signed between the Union Government and several  Adivasi insurgent groups. Dr. Das noted that the Adivasi militants had  initially surrendered in 2012\, and peace talks with them had begun in 2016.  However\, it was not until 2022 that a comprehensive agreement was reached.  Following the signing of this agreement\, more than 1\,000 Adivasi militants  surrendered. \n  The fourth peace  agreement was signed on 23 April 2023 between the State Government\, the union  government\, and Dimasa insurgent groups\, including their political wing\, the  Dimasa People’s Supreme Council. This group had suspended its operations on 28  October 2021\, and after the agreement\, 281 Dimasa cadres surrendered\,  effectively ending the insurgency in the Dimasa-dominated areas of Assam. \nThe final peace  agreement that Dr. Das discussed was signed between the ULFA (Pro-Talk) faction  and the Union Government on 20 December 2023. The United Liberation Front of  Assam (ULFA) had been one of the most prominent and violent insurgent groups in  Assam\, with its demands centred on the creation of an independent Assam.  However\, over time\, the pro-talk faction of ULFA entered into negotiations with  the government\, and the December 2023 agreement represented a significant  achievement in resolving the ULFA insurgency. The Indian Government agreed to  consider the ULFA (Pro-Talk) demands in a time-bound manner\, and following the  agreement\, the militant group was officially disbanded on 23 January 2024. \nDr. Das highlighted that  these peace agreements\, particularly those with the Bodo\, Karbi\, and Dimasa  insurgents\, were all rooted in the long-standing demand for separate states.  She traced the origins of these movements back to the time of Indian  independence when tribal political elites expressed concerns about merging with  the Union Government. These elites feared that such a merger would jeopardize  their customs\, traditions\, and land rights. To address these concerns\, the  Indian Government agreed to establish a decentralised self-governance system\,  creating Autonomous District Councils (ADCs) in undivided Assam. Two of these  councils\, Karbi Anglong (established in 1951) and North Cachar Hills  (established in 1952)\, became the focal points of the Karbi and Dimasa  movements\, respectively. \nDr. Das explained that  the demand for separate states from the Karbi and Dimasa tribes did not  initially gain momentum. However\, after the Assam Reorganisation Act was passed  in 1971\, tribal leaders began to renew their demands for statehood. In 1979\,  following the Assam Agitation\, the demand intensified. In the 1980s and 1990s\,  this discontent turned into violence\, with militant groups like the United  People’s Democratic Solidarity (UPDS) in Karbi Anglong and the Dimasa Halam  Daogah (DHD) emerging to lead the armed struggle. In 2011\, the government  signed a peace agreement with the UPDS\, and in 2012\, a similar agreement was  reached with the DHD. These agreements upgraded the district councils into territorial  councils\, granting them greater powers and financial resources for development.  However\, dissatisfaction persisted\, and in 2021\, the remaining insurgent groups  surrendered\, leading to the peace agreements signed between 2021 and 2023. \nDr. Das further asserted  that the Bodos\, unlike the Karbi and Dimasa tribes\, had been demanding a  separate state even before India’s independence. Their demands intensified in  1967 when the Assamese language was made the official language of Assam\,  prompting the Bodos to form two organisations: the Plains Tribal Council of  Assam (PTCA) and the All Bodo Student Union (ABSU). In 1993\, a tripartite  agreement was signed between the Government and the Bodos\, granting them a  separate autonomous council called the Bodoland Autonomous Council (BAC).  However\, new militant groups like the National Democratic Front of Bodoland  (NDFB) and the Bodo Liberation Tigers (BLT) emerged in the 1990s\, leading to  further violence. In 2003\, a ceasefire agreement was signed with BLT\, and the BAC  was upgraded to the Bodoland Territorial Council (BTC). However\, the NDFB\,  which had been excluded from the peace talks\, continued its insurgent  activities until 2020\, when all its factions surrendered\, culminating in the  peace agreement of January 2020. \nDr. Das identified  several salient features of the peace agreements. First\, they ensured the  territorial and administrative integrity of Assam\, rejecting demands for  separate states. Second\, the agreements empowered the autonomous councils by  increasing legislative seats\, transferring additional subjects from the state  list to the councils\, and providing more financial resources for infrastructure  and economic development. Third\, the agreements included provisions to protect  and promote the socio-cultural identity of the tribes\, including the  recognition of Bodo\, Karbi\, and Dimasa languages as official languages in their  respective regions. Finally\, the agreements laid out measures for the  sustainable development of council areas\, including the rehabilitation of  surrendered militants and the announcement of special economic packages. \nDespite these successes\, Dr. Das warned that several challenges  remain. Most notably\, the agreements do not address the core demand for  separate statehood\, which could lead to tensions in future. Moreover\, granting  autonomous councils to major tribes like the Bodos\, Karbis\, and Dimasas could  lead to similar demands from smaller ethnic groups like the Kukis and Hmars\,  creating new sources of conflict. Additionally\, the inclusion of villages in  council areas with predominant populations of major tribes had resulted in ethnic cleansing of  non-tribal communities earlier\, and therefore\, continues to be a source of  concern. \n  In her concluding  remarks\, Dr. Das emphasised that while the peace agreements have brought  relative peace in Assam\, future stability will depend on addressing the  unresolved demands for statehood and managing the ethnic diversity of the  region. \nQuestions  and Comments\nFollowing Dr. Das’s  presentation\, a lively discussion ensued  among the scholars\, focusing on the implications of these agreements for Assam  and the broader Northeastern region of India. The session underscored both the  progress made and the challenges that lie ahead in securing lasting peace in  Assam.  \n  Dr. Pushpita Das responded  to the comments and questions of the scholars of MP-IDSA. \nThe report was prepared by Ms. Puspa Kumari\, Intern\, South Asia  Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/83112
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20241021T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20241021T053000
DTSTAMP:20261121T031128
CREATED:20241021T003759Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250108T032349Z
UID:83958-1729488600-1729488600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Imaging Kautilya: Popular and the Real
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Saurabh Mishra\, Research Fellow\, spoke on “Imaging Kautilya: Popular and the Real” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 21 October 2024. The session was moderated by Col. Vivek Chadha (Retd.)\, Senior Fellow\, and was followed by insightful remarks by the Director General of MP-IDSA\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, and other scholars. \nExecutive Summary\nDr. Saurabh Mishra offered an in-depth exploration of Kautilya’s Arthashastra by unravelling its complexities and addressing its misinterpretations. The session delved into the philosophical\, historical\, and strategic dimensions of the ancient text while examining its relevance in contemporary global discourse. \nDetailed Report:\nThe session commenced with remarks by Col. Vivek Chadha (Retd.)\, who emphasised the significance of the topic. Col. Chadha reflected on the complexities surrounding ancient Indian texts\, pointing out how misconceptions\, criticism\, and oversimplifications often cloud their true essence. He noted the Western appropriation of ancient Indian ideas\, such as the reductive comparison of Kautilya to Machiavelli which fails to capture the depth of the Arthashastra. \nDr. Saurabh Mishra began the session by identifying the wide gap between the popular perception and the historical and philosophical reality of Kautilya’s Arthashastra. He emphasised that the text is often oversimplified\, reduced to a mere realist manual\, and inaccurately compared to Machiavelli’s works. These comparisons\, he argued\, fail to capture the richness of the Arthashastra’s philosophical roots\, its scientific methodology\, and its comprehensive approach to governance and strategy. \nDr. Mishra noted that popular interpretations often caricature Kautilya as a Machiavellian figure\, focused solely on deceit and manipulation. He highlighted how text like Mudrarakshasa have contributed to this image\, with their portrayal of Kautilya as a cunning strategist devoid of moral considerations. However\, such depictions neglect the ethical and philosophical dimensions of the Arthashastra. The text’s emphasis on balance between ethics\, material well-being\, and strategic interests shows Kautilya’s deep understanding of governance as a multifaceted discipline. He also critiqued Western academic stereotyping\, which tends to pigeonhole Kautilya as an amoral realist\, ignoring the broader philosophical underpinnings of his work. \nDr. Mishra outlined the two major phases in the study of the Arthashastra: \n\nFirst Phase (1905–1992): The discovery of the Arthashastra in 1905 marked the beginning of its consolidation as a foundational text in Indian thought. During this phase\, scholars focused on the nationalist dimensions of the text\, highlighting its value as evidence of India’s ancient tradition of strategic and political thinking. This period was also marked by efforts to translate and compile the text\, with major contributions by scholars like R.P. Kangle.\nSecond Phase (Post-1992): This phase saw a shift toward exploring the Arthashastra’s relevance in modern strategic studies. With the rise of global interest in indigenous knowledge systems\, the text became central to discussions on decolonising intellectual discourse. Scholars began to examine its strategic insights\, particularly in the context of international relations\, warfare\, and statecraft.\n\nMoreover\, Dr. Saurabh Mishra emphasised that the text is deeply grounded in Indian philosophical traditions\, particularly Sankhya\, Yoga\, and Lokayata (materialist) systems. These traditions inform the Arthashastra’s empirical and scientific approach\, enabling it to address the practical realities of governance while maintaining a philosophical foundation. The integration of Sankhya’s dualist perspective\, Yoga’s harmonizing practices\, and Lokayata’s materialist outlook creates a holistic framework that balances ethics\, material well-being\, and political strategy. This synthesis\, according to Dr. Mishra\, makes the Arthashastra unique in its approach to governance and statecraft. \nWhile transitioning to its strategic relevance\, Dr. Mishra highlighted several strategic insights from the Arthashastra: \n\nMandala Theory: Kautilya’s nuanced understanding of state relations categorised neighbouring states as allies\, adversaries\, or vassals based on their behaviour and interests. Contrary to popular misconceptions\, Kautilya did not see all neighbours as enemies but recognised the potential for alliances and cooperation.\nPriority of Intellect: Dr. Saurabh emphasised Kautilya’s preference for intellectual and diplomatic strategies (Mantra Shakti) over brute force (Danda). This approach underscores the value of wisdom and planning in achieving political objectives.\nEthical Governance: The Arthashastra advocates for governance that prioritises the well-being of subjects\, asserting that the happiness of the people is central to the ruler’s success. This ethical dimension challenges the notion of Kautilya as a purely utilitarian thinker.\n\nWhile explaining contemporary implications\, Dr. Mishra dwelt upon global intellectual contributions. He argued for the integration of Kautilyan thought into global academic discourse. The Arthashastra offers valuable insights into governance\, strategy\, and ethics that are relevant in today’s multipolar world. Its emphasis on balance and pragmatism provides a counterpoint to Eurocentric theories in international relations. Moreover\, he highlighted ongoing efforts by Indian scholars to position the Arthashastra within post-Western theoretical frameworks. By engaging with global intellectual history and decolonising knowledge systems\, these efforts aim to expand the text’s influence in international academic circles. \nIn terms of managing perceptions in the neighbourhood\, he elaborated that Kautilya’s principles offer practical guidance for managing relations with smaller neighbouring states. Dr. Mishra emphasised the need for India to address regional perceptions through consistent diplomacy and gestures of goodwill. By applying Kautilyan strategies\, India can reassure its neighbours of its non-expansionist intentions and foster trust. \nFinally\, while explaining the challenges and opportunities\, Dr. Mishra addressed the challenges of engaging with the Arthashastra in contemporary contexts. Decolonising strategic studies requires overcoming entrenched stereotypes and resistance from both Western and Indian academic traditions. However\, these challenges also present opportunities for India to lead in the development of inclusive and indigenous frameworks for global discourse. He concluded by emphasising the enduring relevance of Kautilya’s Arthashastra. Far from being a relic of the past\, the text offers valuable lessons for modern governance\, strategy\, and international relations. By addressing misconceptions and integrating the Arthashastra into global discourse\, India can not only reclaim its intellectual heritage but also contribute to a more inclusive and balanced understanding of global strategy. \nFollowing the Presentation\, Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director-General\, MP-IDSA\, observed that it is intriguing that the discovery of an ancient text remained unnoticed by foreign scholars\, including missionaries\, Arabs\, and Chinese\, despite their extensive explorations in India. He observed that strategic thought has been increasingly dominated by China\, with institutions like the U.S. Army War College focusing heavily on Sun Tzu\, while Indian strategic traditions remain underrepresented. He emphasised the need for India to promote its strategic heritage globally\, especially given the historical advocacy of Chinese contributions by Westerners like Edgar Snow. Lastly\, he pointed out Pakistan’s growing acknowledgment of figures like Kautilya\, suggesting that India must proactively assert its heritage to prevent appropriation\, as recently seen with Pakistan’s narrative on Buddhism. \nQ & A Session:\nDuring the Q & A session\, a range of questions were posed on various themes\, including the discovery of the Arthashastra in 1905 and its subsequent recognition\, emphasising its delayed integration into academic and public discourse. Moreover\, questions were raised about why foreign scholars overlooked this text in earlier periods despite its foundational significance. The discussion delved into how India’s neighbours perceive its strategic posture\, with references to Kautilya’s Matsya Nyaya (law of the fish) and the management of relations through diplomacy and assurances against expansionist intentions. The Arthashastra’s perspectives on neighbouring states—classified as friendly\, vassal\, or hostile—were examined in the context of modern regional dynamics. \nThe session also addressed the presence of democracy in ancient Indian texts\, noting that while the Arthashastra references oligarchies and early forms of democracy in Himalayan and Ganges regions\, it does not align with modern democratic concepts. However\, Kautilya did not oppose democratic structures but viewed centralised monarchy as more effective for building empires. Questions were also raised about India’s engagement with its own knowledge systems\, particularly in the global academic context. It was acknowledged that while American scholars actively study the Arthashastra\, India needs to further assert its intellectual heritage. The discussion also critiqued how disciplines like history and science often overshadow India’s strategic contributions. \nThe session was concluded by Col. Chadha\, with encouragement for deeper academic engagement with ancient Indian texts and their relevance to modern strategic\, political\, and cultural debates. Participants were urged to explore these works to better understand India’s historical and intellectual legacy. \nThe Report was prepared by Mr. Mohana Sakthivel J. Research Analyst\, ALACUN Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-imaging-kautilya
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20261121T031128
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20261121T031128
DTSTAMP:20261121T031128
CREATED:20241209T012932Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20241209T012932Z
UID:83479-1795230688-1795230688@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of Monday Morning Meeting on “ISIS: An Enduring Threat”
DESCRIPTION:Ms. Saman Ayesha Kidwai\, Research Analyst\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) spoke on “ISIS: An Enduring Threat” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 28 October 2024. The session was chaired by Dr. Jason Wahlang\, Research Analyst\, MP-IDSA. MP-IDSA scholars participated in the discussion. \nExecutive Summary\nISIS has remained an enduring security threat due to its adaptability\, exploitation of regional and global instability\, and media propaganda.  \nDetailed Report\nThe session commenced with opening remarks from Dr. Jason Wahlang\, who provided an insightful overview of the persistent threat the Islamic State (IS) posed despite its waning influence in recent years. The Islamic State\, alongside its various vilayets\, continues to leverage instability in regions worldwide\, exploiting global security shifts for resurgence. \n Dr. Wahlang highlighted the worrying escalation of IS activities in previously unaffected areas\, including the attack in Azerbaijan’s Qusar district in September 2024 and the assault on a Shia Mosque in Oman. He stressed that the current complex geopolitical climate and the focus of major powers on their security imperatives\, especially with the Russia-Ukraine War and the broader West Asian instability\, has carved out space for a potential ISIS revival. \nMs. Kidwai explained that since its physical defeat in March 2019\, ISIS has effectively preserved its global threat profile through the evolution of operational tactics\, sustained ideological appeal\, and the exploitation of geopolitical conflicts. This adaptability\, combined with sophisticated media-driven propaganda\, has allowed ISIS to mobilise a diverse array of fighters\, including lone wolves\, enabled individuals\, and trained operatives\, all contributing to the perpetuation of the group’s agenda. \nMs. Kidwai also highlighted how high-profile international sporting events\, such as the Paris Olympics and Euro Games\, remain vulnerable to exploitation by ISIS\, as these “soft targets” provide terrorist groups visibility and an opportunity to inflict substantial impact. Moreover\, recent incidents\, including the Solingen knife assault and threats against the U.S. Capitol\, underscore the ongoing resilience of ISIS and its capacity to execute attacks on a global scale. These trends highlight the urgent need for a comprehensive and coordinated counterterrorism strategy to effectively address this enduring threat. \nFurthermore\, Ms. Kidwai noted that the 2024 Global Terrorism Index (GTI) reaffirms ISIS’s status as the world’s deadliest terrorist organisation\, attributing 470 attacks and 1\,636 deaths to the group in the preceding year. Ongoing regional and international conflicts\, exacerbated by socio-political disparities\, provide fertile ground for ISIS’s recruitment and radicalisation efforts. The group’s sustained strategy to inspire violence through multilingual propaganda has ensured that its influence extends beyond physical borders\, reinforcing its long-term goals as both an ideological force and a security challenge across nations. \nMs. Kidwai explained that ISIS has leveraged various networks across Africa\, such as the Maktab Al-Karrar’s global financing network\, which oversees regions including the Democratic Republic of Congo\, Mozambique\, and Somalia. This network has played a crucial role in coordinating terror financing and attacks on a global scale\, notably funding the 2021 Kabul airport attack perpetrated by Islamic State in Khorasan Province (ISKP). \nFurthermore\, the terrorist group employs both conventional and unconventional financing methods\, including hawala networks\, cryptocurrency\, and extortion schemes through social media platforms like Tinder\, specifically targeting South African citizens. These activities have intensified in South Africa\, where established economic structures\, combined with corruption and complacency\, have facilitated ISIS’s financing and logistical operations. \nAccording to Ms. Kidwai\, globally\, ISIS has proven its capacity to strike in unexpected locations\, as demonstrated by the first ISIS-claimed assault in Oman on 15 July 2024\, where an attack on a Shia Mosque resulted in numerous casualties. In Russia\, a resurgence of ISIS activity has been observed\, with deadly attacks in Moscow and Dagestan\, along with coordinated prison break attempts. In Syria and Iraq\, where the group initially established its caliphate\, ISIS has exploited the challenges brought by the COVID-19 pandemic and governmental unrest\, enabling it to regroup and renew its attacks. \nMs. Kidwai underscored that ISIS continues to exploit destabilised and poorly regulated regions\, particularly near the Iraq-Syria border and within the Kurdish autonomous region\, to smuggle weapons\, move fighters\, and establish sleeper cells. This threat endures despite repeated joint raids by Iraqi and American forces. \nIn Syria\, detention camps like al-Hol have become breeding grounds for new extremism\, exacerbated by inadequate oversight\, where indoctrination continues unabated. \nSimultaneously\, ISIS’s global reach and propaganda mechanisms have evolved\, becoming increasingly sophisticated. ISKP has utilised major propaganda outlets like Al-Azaim Foundation to disseminate its extremist ideology and target regimes in Central Asia. ISKP’s media strategies\, which include AI-generated content and dissemination of propaganda through platforms such as TikTok and Telegram\, have significantly broadened its audience\, allowing for the creation of visually compelling propaganda. \nISIS has also employed outlets like Al-Naba to denounce other groups\, notably branding Hamas as an apostate organisation and accusing Iran of betraying Hamas leaders. Recent developments\, such as the arrest of Islamic State in Hind Province’s leader Haris Farooqi and his aide Rehan in India\, further illustrate ISIS’s attempts to extend its influence in South Asia. However\, its reach within India has been limited. \nDuring her concluding remarks\, Ms. Kidwai added that global conflicts and polarisation have hindered a unified counter-terrorism response to deal with the ISIS threat. Looking forward\, ISIS is expected to exploit emerging socio-political grievances and leverage sophisticated propaganda techniques to sustain its presence within global extremist networks. Finally\, these developments call for a robust\, multifaceted counter-terrorism approach\, addressing both the immediate and evolving threats posed by ISIS and its affiliates to ensure a comprehensive global response. \nQ&A Session\nThe presentation was followed by a Q&A Session. Several key dynamics were addressed\, revealing the multifaceted nature of contemporary terrorism\, the speculation surrounding external influences in ISIS’s formation\, its digital transition post-territorial loss and its decentralised structure. \nMs. Kidwai provided insightful responses to the comments and questions raised.  \nThis report was prepared by Ms. Dalvi Sethi\, Intern\, Europe & Eurasia Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-monday-morning-meeting-on-isis-an-enduring-threat
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR