BEGIN:VCALENDAR
VERSION:2.0
PRODID:-//MP-IDSA - ECPv6.15.12.2//NONSGML v1.0//EN
CALSCALE:GREGORIAN
METHOD:PUBLISH
X-WR-CALNAME:MP-IDSA
X-ORIGINAL-URL:https://idsa.in
X-WR-CALDESC:Events for MP-IDSA
REFRESH-INTERVAL;VALUE=DURATION:PT1H
X-Robots-Tag:noindex
X-PUBLISHED-TTL:PT1H
BEGIN:VTIMEZONE
TZID:Asia/Kolkata
BEGIN:STANDARD
TZOFFSETFROM:+0530
TZOFFSETTO:+0530
TZNAME:IST
DTSTART:20230101T000000
END:STANDARD
END:VTIMEZONE
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240502T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240502T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240528T231735Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240528T231849Z
UID:81409-1714627800-1714627800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Lecture on Disaster Risk Management in 21st Century
DESCRIPTION:Shri Kamal Kishore\, Member Secretary of the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) visited the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, New Delhi\, on 2 May 2024 and delivered a lecture on “Disaster Risk Management in 21st Century “. The Session was chaired by the Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy. The Deputy Director General\, Gp.Capt. (Dr.) Ajey Lele (Retd.) and scholars of the Institute participated in the discussion. \nExecutive Summary\nShri. Kamal Kishore in his lecture talked about three global trends in Disaster Risk Management and five implications of these on India from India’s development\, strategic perspectives. In his lecture he emphasised that along with India’s development story\, there is a need to prioritise Disaster Risk Management in the country. \nDetailed Report\nThe Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy introduced Shri Kamal Kishore to the gathering and mentioned that Shri Kamal Kishore had worked on disaster risk reduction and recovery issues for over 22 years at the local\, national\, regional and global levels. He mentioned that prior to joining the National Disaster Management Authority\, Shri Kishore worked with the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) for nearly 13 years in New Delhi\, Geneva and New York. He further highlighted that at UNDP headquarters Shri Kishore has led global advocacy campaigns to address disaster risk reduction concerns in the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals and the post-2015 development agenda. Amb. Chinoy also congratulated Shri Kamal Kishore on his recent appointment as the Assistant Secretary General and Special Representative to the UN Secretary General for Disaster Risk Reduction. \nAfter introducing the Speaker\, Amb. Chinoy highlighted in his opening remarks the importance of Disaster Risk Management in India. He mentioned that as climate change is leading to a greater risk of disasters\, there is a need to develop suitable mechanisms to reduce the impacts of disasters. He mentioned that all this is also linked to larger salient initiatives of Prime Minister Modi’s Vision that include creating Pro-Planet People and initiatives such as LiFE (Lifestyle for Environment). He mentioned that all these reveal a deep sense of urgency even at the political level. Amb. Chinoy mentioned that despite all these ongoing initiatives in place\, there is a need to develop more ‘Disaster Resilient Infrastructures’ around the country\, which\, in future\, could be greatly beneficial in mitigating risks associated with disasters. With these initial remarks Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy\, invited Shri Kamal Kishore to deliver his talk. \nShri Kamal Kishore thanked Amb. Chinoy for his kind introduction. He highlighted that his lecture would focus on three global trends in Disaster Risk Management and five implications these have on India from India’s development and strategic perspectives. He mentioned that the first trend in global disaster risk management focuses on ‘disaster-related death’ over the last 60 years. Shri Kishore mentioned that if one analyses ‘the global total’ data over all these years\, it can be concluded that there has been a significant decline in the total number of people (Global Total) dying from disasters. Shri Kishore mentioned that over the years India has done a tremendous job in handling disasters related from Cyclones. He mentioned that in last year’s cyclone ‘Biparjoy’ in Gujarat\, India for the first time was able to achieve Zero mortality rate.  \nShri Kishore mentioned that the second trend in Disaster Risk Management suggests that in the 21st century\, people dying from a single disaster-related event is exceptionally high (more than 100\,000 people dying in a single event). Giving an example of the 2004 Indian Ocean Tsunami\, Shri Kishore mentioned that it affected a total of 13 countries out of which 5 countries were very badly impacted and the total number of people that died as a result of this was very high. He mentioned that in the 2008 Cyclone Nargis\, the 2005 Earthquake in Kashmir and Pakistan Occupied Kashmir and the 2023 Earthquake in Türkiye\, the number of people who died in each of these events was extremely high. He therefore concluded that while there is a global trend of decline in mortality due to disasters\, there still exist pockets in parts of the world which have high concentration of risks due to disasters. \nThe third trend highlighted by Shri Kishore was related to the ‘Economic Cost’ associated with the disasters. He mentioned that the overall economic losses as a result of disasters are increasing tremendously. Shri Kishore stressed that though states have become successful in reducing the mortality rate from disasters\, the economic losses suffered by people as a result of these disasters in terms of their housing\, livelihood\, assets etc. have been huge. Shri Kishore mentioned that if India has to achieve its dream of ‘Viksit Bharat’ disaster risk management remains most important. \nIn the second part of his lecture\, Shri Kishore highlighted the 5 implications of rising disaster risks for India. He first discussed the ‘Strategic Aspect’ in which he mentioned that due to different geographical terrains in India\, it becomes difficult to predict disasters. Giving an example of a disaster event in Sikkim\, Shri Kishore mentioned that there is a need to enhance our abilities in predicting the effects of disasters in these areas. He further said that extra emphasis is needed to be given to those infrastructural development projects in such regions that are of strategic importance to India. Shri Kishore highlighted that similarly\, the issue of rising sea levels is of great concern. He mentioned that any disaster occurring as a result of rising sea levels could have implications for India’s Naval strategic infrastructures. He highlighted that disasters occurring from rising sea levels in the future could also have implications for the functioning of India’s Naval forces. He then mentioned that climate change and increasing annual temperatures could have implications for transboundary river systems within India and the entire South Asia region. Any fluctuations in the flow of rivers to our neighbouring states could have strategic and geopolitical challenges in the future. He also emphasised that increasing heat waves have the potential to impact India’s agricultural outputs in the future which could have negative implications for the county’s food and economic security. \nShri Kishore mentioned that the second implication is related to the ‘development of India’s own communities and people’. He explained this by giving the example of annual average losses emanating from disasters. He mentioned that the annual estimated losses as a result of disasters stand annually at an average of USD 3.8 billion. He mentioned that this comes to around 1 per cent of India’s GDP. He further emphasised that if we plan to spend 10 per cent of the GDP on developing infrastructures\, roughly around 1 per cent is lost to disasters. \nShri Kishore pointed out that the third aspect of Disaster Risk Management relates to ‘International Disaster Diplomacy’. He pointed out that India has performed significantly well as compared to other global states in its pursuits of International Disaster Diplomacy. He mentioned that India was the first responder in the 2023 Türkiye earthquake. India sent 3 teams of the National Disaster Response Force. Shri Kishore highlighted the important role played by the ‘60 Para Field Hospital’ from Agra (a unit of the Indian Army) in setting up the field hospital and treating the injured people. He highlighted that the Indian medical team also consisted of enough women staff of doctors and nurses who played a crucial role in treating women and children affected due to the earthquake. He mentioned this initiative attained global appreciation for India and the country is presently known for its credible role in international disaster diplomacy. Shri Kishore pointed out that there is a need to further systematise our efforts and approach in this direction. \nThe fourth aspect highlighted by Shri Kishore relates to ‘Managing Risk’. He stressed that in order to manage risks associated with disasters\, Indian institutions need to be agile and quick in terms of responding to disasters. He mentioned that this aspect requires deep thinking on which scholars at MP-IDSA can work on and contribute in the near future. \nLastly\, Shri Kishore mentioned that the fifth aspect of Disaster Risk Management relates to ‘Implications for India’s’ Infrastructures’ as a result of disasters. Shri Kishore pointed out that in the last 10 years\, the length of the Metro in India has increased 6 times of its existing networks and the National Highways in the country have increased 1.5 times. He mentioned that all these infrastructures remain exposed to disasters. Shri Kishore mentioned that India’s developing infrastructure needs to be built disaster-resilient. \nQuestions and Comments\nThe Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy complimented the Speaker for his detailed talk on the subject. He asked the Speaker if NDMA brings out a Handbook of the technologies used in each of these disaster situations. He sought the Speaker’s response\, particularly with regard to technologies used in making disaster resilient infrastructures. He further asked if such a handbook is available for the use of the common man. Secondly\, Amb. Chinoy asked the Speaker to clarify whether NDMA also uses some kind of traditional construction technologies that the Indian ancient civilization used in the past to mitigate future natural disasters. \nThe Deputy Director General\, Gp. Capt. (Dr.) Ajey Lele (Retd.) asked the Speaker about India’s capabilities and NDMA’s practices in prevention and management of forest fires in India. \nComdt. Manoranjan Srivastava asked the Speaker regarding the long-term perspective plans of NDMA with regard to future challenges like emerging cyclones and sea-level rise along the Indian coast. He also asked the Speaker to comment on the issue of climate migration (both internal and external) as a result of these challenges. \nDr. Gulbin Sultana asked the Speaker about flood management and developing of flood resilient infrastructures in Assam. She further asked the Speaker to comment on the management of people in shelters during flood situations\, with regard to their basic issues of food\, water and sanitation.  \nMr. Arvind Khare while referring to India’s role in international disaster diplomacy\, asked the Speaker if India’s economic and technological capacities and capabilities are as per international standards. \nMr. D.S. Murugan Yadav\, asked about the creation of State Disaster Response Forces. He asked the Speaker regarding the various types of agencies that would be pooled in for creation of such State Disaster Response Forces. \nShri Kamal Kishore gave a detailed explanation to all the questions and the comments raised and the talk ended with the Director General thanking Shri Kishore for the opportunity to interact with him. \nReport prepared by Mr. Bipandeep Sharma\, Research Analyst\, NTS Centre\, MP-IDSA\, New Delhi.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/lecture-on-disaster-risk-management-in-21st-century
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240506T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240506T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240506T222936Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20250828T053313Z
UID:81015-1714973400-1714973400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:MP-IDSA Fellow’s Seminar on Evolution of African Maritime Security: Imperatives\, Governance and Challenges
DESCRIPTION:The MP-IDSA Fellow’s Seminar presentation by Dr. Abhishek Mishra\, Associate Fellow\, MP-IDSA\, on “Evolution of African Maritime Security: Imperatives\, Governance and Challenges” was held on 29 February 2024. It was chaired by Vice Admiral Satish Kumar Namdeo Ghormade\, PVSM\, AVSM\, NM (Retd.)\, former Vice Chief of Naval Staff. The External Discussants for the paper were Commander Abhijit Singh\, Head\, Maritime Policy Initiative\, Observer Research Foundation (ORF)\, and Dr. Pooja Bhatt\, Consultant\, Ministry of External Affairs and Researcher on Maritime Security and Governance. The Internal Discussants were Ms. Ruchita Beri\, Consultant\, Africa\, Latin America\, Caribbean\, & UN (ALACUN) Centre\, MP-IDSA\, and Cmde. Abhay K. Singh\, Research Fellow & Coordinator\, Southeast Asia and Oceania Centre\, MP-IDSA. \nExecutive Summary\nThe development of a maritime security agenda for African countries has been relatively new\, despite the continent being completely surrounded by water. Following the emergence of the scourge of piracy off the coast of Somalia\, African countries and international actors started to pay due attention to ensuring maritime security. Although armed robbery at sea has sensitised the countries of Africa and the international community to the threats in the African maritime domain (AMD)\, an overemphasis on piracy and armed robbery has skewed perceptions about the African maritime landscape. The challenges today are much broader\, and the resultant strategies employed by African countries go beyond tackling piracy. Thus\, in the present time\, African maritime strategies tend to focus on the common interests of wealth creation and sustainable governance. \nDetailed Report\nDr. Mishra’s research explored the potential of the “blue economy” or “blue growth” approach in mitigating maritime crime in African waters. He also examined the evolution of maritime security within the African context over the past two decades. \nPreviously neglected\, Dr. Mishra argued that Africa’s colonial past fostered a “sea blindness\,” hindering a focus on maritime security. He emphasised the ambiguity of the term “maritime security\,” highlighting the varying interpretations by Till (2018) with hard and soft security distinctions\, Bueger’s (2015) constructivist approach with the Maritime Security Matrix\, and Siebels’ (2020) “Tale of Two Regions” incorporating positive and negative definitions. \nHe further underscored the criticality of Africa’s maritime sector. Firstly\, 38 out of 54 African territories are island nations or coastal states. Secondly\, Africa boasts a vast coastline exceeding 26\,000 nautical miles. Finally\, the number and capabilities of actors threatening the African Maritime Domain (AMD) are continuously rising. These factors necessitate a commensurate response at national\, regional\, and continental levels. \nMoreover\, while explaining the threats and vulnerabilities of the African Maritime Domain (AMD)\, he categorised them into three main areas. Governance issues encompass illicit fishing\, marine pollution\, illegal oil bunkering\, and crude oil theft. Security concerns include armed robbery\, piracy\, and trafficking in weapons\, drugs\, and wildlife. Finally\, humanitarian assistance needs encompass Search and Rescue (SAR)\, Humanitarian Assistance/Disaster Relief (HA/DR)\, and out-of-area emergencies. \nHe then highlighted the Stable Seas Maritime Security Index\, which ranks nations based on nine criteria relevant to Africa\, including global cooperation\, legality\, maritime safety\, coastal well-being\, the blue economy\, fishing practices\, piracy\, illegal trade\, and mixed migration via sea. \nHowever\, Dr. Mishra acknowledged the ongoing debate surrounding maritime security (MS) in Africa. He said that scholars grapple with a unified definition within the African context. Since 2005\, the African Union (AU)\, Regional Economic Communities (RECs)\, and the African Union Commission (AUC) have actively discussed the African Maritime Domain (AMD) primarily in relation to piracy. The initial discourse revealed diverse interests and a complex web of African-international relationships. Notably\, African RECs have collaborated with the United Nations\, International Maritime Organization\, and other nations. \nHe further emphasised Africa’s pre-existing engagement in maritime governance. By 2000\, 37 African nations were already members of the International Maritime Organization (IMO)\, and the continent had a maritime transit charter established in 1993. Additionally\, African countries ratified key agreements like the 1974 SOLAS Convention (safety of life at sea) and the 2004 ISPS Code (security of ships and port facilities). \nThe 2000 International Convention on Maritime Search and Rescue (SAR) provided the foundation for the first pan-African initiatives to bolster SAR capabilities. Between 2007 and 2011\, five Maritime Rescue Coordination Centers (MRCCs) and twenty-six sub-centers were established in strategic locations like Mombasa\, Cape Town\, Lagos\, Monrovia\, and Rabat. \nDr. Mishra also highlighted the significance of informal gatherings and conferences fostering maritime cooperation since 2005. These include the IMO-sponsored Sea Power for Africa Symposium (SPAS)\, the U.S. Naval Command’s East Africa and Southwest Indian Ocean Maritime Security Conference (EASWIO)\, and the Indian Navy’s Indian Ocean Naval Symposium (IONS)\, alongside regional meetings in Sana’a\, Muscat\, and Dar es Salaam. The establishment of the Djibouti Code of Conduct (DCoC) in January 2009 marked a further step towards regional cooperation. \nMoreover\, Dr. Mishra made a distinction between the Yaoundé Code of Conduct (YCoC) and the Djibouti Code of Conduct (DCoC). Adopted in January 2009\, the DCoC focuses on piracy and armed robbery suppression in the Western Indian Ocean and Gulf of Aden. Its core objective is to facilitate international cooperation through information sharing\, training nitiatives\, national legislation updates\, and counter-piracy measures. The DCoC+\, established through the 2017 Jeddah Amendment\, addresses additional threats like illegal\, unreported\, and unregulated (IUU) fishing and human trafficking. \nOn the other hand\, the YCoC\, ratified in 2013 by 25 West and Central African nations\, targets a broader range of illicit maritime activities in the Gulf of Guinea\, including piracy\, armed robbery\, and IUU fishing. Information sharing is a central pillar\, achieved through two regional centers: (i) Regional Centre for Maritime Security in Central Africa (CRESMAC) under the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) and (ii) the West Africa Regional Maritime Security Centre (CRESMAO) under the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS). \nDr. Mishra highlighted key differences. The DCoC\, designed from the outset to combat piracy on the high seas\, actively seeks international assistance. Conversely\, the YCoC prioritizes preserving signatory sovereignty. Additionally\, the YCoC incorporates measures absent from the DCoC\, such as seizing assets linked to illicit activities\, mitigating IUU fishing\, and addressing pollution prevention (a broader maritime concern beyond traditional security). Finally\, the YCoC uses the term “signatories\,” while the DCoC uses “participants.” \nHe moved on to explain Africa’s Integrated Maritime Strategy (AIM 2050) as a unified effort to revitalize the maritime sector for the continent’s development. AIM 2050 aims to leverage Africa’s waterways and oceans for the benefit of its maritime industries. Additionally\, the African Union (AU) is fostering a maritime security community tailored to Africa’s unique needs\, experiences\, and practices. \nHe discussed the Lomé Charter\, formally known as the African Charter on Maritime Security\, Safety\, and Development in Africa\, signed in October 2016. It builds upon the AIM 2050 Strategy by transitioning maritime security in Africa from a “soft law” approach (non-binding guidelines) to a “hard law” approach with a legally binding treaty. This shift is in contrast to earlier instruments like the DCoC or AIM 2050. Notably\, while 25 nations signed the Lomé Charter\, only Benin\, Senegal\, and Togo have ratified it thus far. \nIn addition to that\, he emphasised the AU’s focus on promoting sustainable utilization of Africa’s ocean resources. He terms the Blue Economy (BE) as the “new frontier for Africa’s renaissance\,” highlighting its significance. The 2018 Sustainable Blue Economy Conference in Nairobi\, Kenya\, served as a key platform to discuss the applicability of the Blue Economy concept in Africa. \nIn conclusion\, Dr. Abhishek acknowledged the mixed success of various community-based and government-led Blue Economy initiatives in Africa. He argued that social equity and ecological sustainability haven’t received the same level of attention as economic benefits. He emphasized that people are the foundation of any successful Blue Economy endeavour. For Africa’s Blue Economy development to thrive\, it must prioritise social fairness\, environmental preservation\, and a robust institutional governance framework. \nThis was followed by Comments from the External Discussants. \nComments and Questions\nFollowing Dr. Mishra’s presentation\, the discussion shifted\, with Cdr. Abhijit Singh emphasizing the value of the “sea blindness” concept in academic and policy circles. He linked national security postures to global commons management\, highlighting how a state’s sea blindness or sea consciousness can impact its ability to address global maritime challenges. He argued that fragmented perspectives and challenges to coordination among African nations hinder effective action. He identified poverty and poor governance (extending to maritime domains) as key issues. He also mentioned CRESMAC and CRESMAO as maritime information centers focused on West and Central Africa. He made the case that we have to identify the challenges facing Africa’s marine sector and provide a targeted set of solutions. He stated that the lack of an Indian policy perspective in the study is the sole area of concern. Lastly\, he said it is essential to assess each of the instruments mentioned above closely. \nDr. Pooja Bhatt then offered insights on Africa’s evolving maritime approach. She noted a shift from the basic needs (food\, security\, and resources) to complex issues like trade\, the security of traditional and non-traditional rights\, and the intricate legal and technical aspects of addressing these challenges. Moreover\, she emphasised the importance of definitions in maritime security. Clear definitions help identify stakeholders and goals\, facilitating collaboration. However\, excessive focus on definitions can hinder progress. She commended the AU’s approach as a valuable model for regional cooperation on maritime security. Dr. Bhatt concluded by urging India to take a leadership role in establishing a dedicated maritime security office within the United Nations\, advocating a collective vision from the Global South on maritime security. \nThis was followed by Comments from the Internal Discussants. \nMs. Ruchita Beri highlighted the historical perception of land as a place to reside and the sea as a passage. This perspective shapes how power and security are traditionally viewed\, often neglecting the maritime domain. She pointed to the Berlin Conference’s impact on Africa\, where colonial powers focused on land wealth and used the seas for resource extraction\, neglecting maritime security concerns. She went on to point out the various narratives developed in maritime security\, shaped by African think tanks and academics. She urged Dr. Mishra to delve into questions pertaining to the root causes of the conduct of the African nations and the persistence of the problems in the region. \nCmde. Abhay Kumar Singh cautioned against a singular view of African maritime security. He identified two key schools of thought within Africa and argued that security is not solely about laws and standards. Power\, strategy\, and wealth are crucial elements for effective maritime security\, and Africa’s challenges in these areas contribute to its maritime insecurity. He asked Dr. Mishra to elaborate on a postmodernist viewpoint\, focusing on the rationale for the existence of this information and the reasons behind the state of affairs. \nThis was followed by Comments from the Floor. \nDirector General\, Amb. Sujan R. Chinoy stated that the whole issue is being explored without delving into the essential question of what it is about Africa’s economic growth that genuinely shapes its marine environment. There is undoubtedly substantial economic hardship that exists in the littoral regions\, which extends to the marine environment and vice versa. Furthermore\, as an Indian researcher studying the topic\, he asked Dr. Mishra to consider the Marine Biodiversity of Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction (BBNJ) and expand on what specific aspect of the G20 proclamation seems to have been tailored specifically for today’s theme. \nWhen the house was opened for questions\, a question regarding Africa’s opposition to Western-led security formations was raised. The panelists responded by highlighting China’s growing role in African security\, noting the 2023 China-Africa Security Forum as a point of geopolitical interest to India. \nVice Admiral Satishkumar Namdeo Ghormade concluded the discussion by emphasising the strategic significance of Africa’s resources and location. He attributed the continent’s vulnerability to a lack of technology\, defensive forces\, and the multitude of challenges it faces. \nThe Report was prepared by Ms. Anusha Khurana\, Intern\, ALACUN Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/mp-idsa-fellows-seminar-on-evolution-of-african-maritime-security-imperatives-governance-and-challenges
CATEGORIES:FELLOW'S SEMINAR,EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240513T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240513T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240528T232152Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240528T232152Z
UID:81412-1715578200-1715578200@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Report of Monday Morning Meeting on ‘iDEX: The Future of Defence Startups’
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Shayesta Nishat Ahmed\, Research Analyst\, Defence Economics and Industry Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA)\, delivered a presentation on “iDEX: The Future of Defence Startups” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 13 May 2024. Mr. Arvind Khare\, IDAS\, Senior Fellow\, Defence Economics and Industry Centre\, MP-IDSA\, moderated the session. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Gp. Capt. (Dr.) Ajey V. Lele (Retd.)\, Deputy Director General and the scholars of MP-IDSA attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nInnovation for Defence Excellence (iDEX)\, is a flagship programme of Department of Defence Production (DDP) under the Ministry of Defence (MoD)\, in collaboration with Start Up India and Atal Innovation Mission (AIM)\, unveiled by Prime Minister Narendra Modi in April 2018. The objective of iDEX is to further self-reliance and Atmanirbharta in Defence and Aerospace Sector by way of extending financial support to Startups and individual innovators for indigenous innovations in relation to technology projections and existing technology gaps. \nDetailed Report\nMr. Arvind Khare\, IDAS\, Senior Fellow\, initiated the meeting by providing a brief outline of iDEX. Dr. Shayesta Nishat Ahmed\, Research Analyst\, began her presentation by providing an introduction of what exactly iDEX is\, as a Scheme for granting funds\, its aim\, the existing procedure and its performance so far. iDEX initiative aims at promoting India’s defence indigenisation and self-reliance by rapidly incorporating innovations in weapon technologies and systems procurement by startups and individual innovators. She brought out the rationale behind the quest for achieving indigenisation in the defence sector is reducing import dependency and achieving strategic autonomy. The iDEX framework was developed in collaboration with Start Up India\, Atal Innovation Mission (AIM)\, and Make in India programs. \nApart from the objectives of iDEX\, the presentation also included the modus operandi of iDEX functioning to facilitate granting funds from the Defence Innovation Fund (DIF) for innovations. iDEX aims to foster the fast development of indigenous but innovative technologies for defence and aerospace by engaging with competent startups\, and to empower a culture of technology co-creation and co-innovation in the Defence R&D ecosystem. \nThe presentation highlighted the institutionalised structure of Defence Innovation Organization (DIO)\, which is a Section 8 company executing the iDEX scheme. The process of identification of a technology gap area\, selection of competent startups\, granting necessary funds\, monitoring the execution of projects and assessment of fund utilisations by the startups under the iDEX scheme was elaborated. The presentation also covered the provisions of Defence Acquisition Programme (DAP) 2020 regarding iDEX and the Technology Development Fund (TDF) scheme of the Defence Research & Development Organisation (DRDO)\, and their differences in structure\, budgeting\, execution & monitoring of the projects and their funding mechanisms. Following that\, Dr. Shayesta delineated the ‘Support for Prototype and Research Kickstart’ (SPARK) framework\, through which iDEX provides grants to startups and MSMEs to develop functional prototypes for the required technologies. Various programmes that run under the iDEX set up such as the DISC Challenges\, iDEX4Fauj\, iDEX Prime (Space) for Mission DefSpace\, iDEX Prime (Sprint) for Indian Navy\, etc. and the amount of grants per project under different variants of iDEX were also discussed. \nRecent developments under iDEX umbrella\, viz. INDUS–X and ADITI were also discussed. India-United States Defence Acceleration Ecosystem (INDUS-X) was launched in Washington DC\, USA on 21 June 2023\, in an event co-organised by iDEX (Ministry of Defence\, Government of India) and US Department of Defense\, and hosted by US-India Business Council (USIBC)\, for co-development and co-production of advanced technologies by Indian and US Startups by developing suitable mechanisms for future collaboration across industries\, academia\, and investors. ADITI (Acing Development of Innovative Technologies with iDEX) is an encouraging endeavour of iDEX\, DIO\, DDP for extending financial supports up to Rs. 25 Cr. per project relating to innovation in critical and strategic deep-tech technologies. \nDr. Shayesta spoke on the role of partner incubators in iDEX\, which provide mentorship and support to iDEX winners\, and of the iDEX Investors Hub\, which aims to accelerate the growth of the defence ecosystem by providing access to interested investors. The process of prototype development\, commercial solicitation\, and IPR management under iDEX was also discussed. She also highlighted in her presentation\, challenges of the iDEX initiative\, including difficulties in monitoring the development of critical defence technologies\, lack of user involvement\, less commercial proliferation of the developed technologies\, IPR issues\, accountability aspects\, etc. \nQuestions & Comments\nBefore opening the floor for a Q&A session\, Mr. Arvind Khare\, IDAS noted that the concept of iDEX\, i.e. involving small & focused teams for getting rapid technological solutions in the form of startups under a government funding mechanism\, is not something new in the defence innovation ecosystem worldwide. He quoted the examples of the establishment of MIT Rad Lab by the US Department of Defense in the 1940s and the establishment of Defence Innovation Unit Experimental (DIUx) in 2015\, to involve the startups in defence innovations. He also mentioned the Maf’at\, a joint administrative body of the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) & Israel’s Ministry of Defence and touched on other similar frameworks in Israel such as ‘Yozma’\, ‘Lotem’\, ’Unit 8200’ of Israel. He also referred to the ‘European Defence Fund’ having sharp focus on engagement with and investment in SMEs\, startups and midcaps for the defence industry. \nThe Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy began his comments by complimenting Dr. Shayesta for a comprehensive presentation. He mentioned that during the 1950s the focus was on heavy industries in India and also there was reduction in defence budget. Later\, there was a realisation within the country about the significance of prioritising defence R&D and innovation especially in critical supply chains\, in order to attain strategic autonomy. Moreover\, since defence production was solely dependent upon Defence Public Sector Undertakings (DPSUs) and due to lack of investment & interest in the Private Sector for R&D in the defence sector\, there was a serious necessity for government funding to the private sector\, particularly to MSMEs and Startups for encouraging them for innovations and R&D. Now the time has come where schemes like iDEX and TDF are doing wonderful work for involving MSMEs and Startups to become part of the defence supply chain. However\, Amb. Chinoy also emphasised that more systemic and robust changes are required to make these funding schemes more accountable\, responsible\, target-oriented and business-focussed; and elaborated upon the need for removing bureaucratic hurdles and red-tapism in implementation of such initiatives. Amb. Chinoy also expressed the need for formation of a Technology Commission for steering futuristic technological developments involving all stakeholders like Armed Forces\, DRDO\, DPSUs\, private industries (MSMEs & Startups) and strategic collaborations with foreign partners. \nDuring discussions\, the issue of IPR\, possibility of certain companies with inimical interests attempting to acquire startups\, absence of any regulatory mechanisms for monitoring the performance of startups under iDEX funding\, ways & approaches to enhance the participation and engagement of competent startups\, and lack of information about cancellation of projects due to non-fulfilment of quality requirements and about lack of transparency in identification of incubation centres\, along with the contributions of the project directors in the technology development milieu\, were also discussed. \nThe Report was prepared by Mr. D.S. Murugan Yadav\, Intern\, Military Affairs Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/report-of-monday-morning-meeting-on-idex-the-future-of-defence-startups
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240516T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240516T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240528T235508Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240528T235519Z
UID:81414-1715837400-1715837400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “Understanding Nepal’s Coalition Shift: Implications for Domestic Governance and India’s Interests”
DESCRIPTION:Ms. Sneha M\, Research Analyst\, Manohar Parrikar IDSA (MP-IDSA)\, made a presentation on “Understanding Nepal’s Coalition Shift: Implications for Domestic Governance and India’s Interests” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 6 May 2024. The session was moderated by Dr. Ashok Behuria\, Senior Fellow\, MP-IDSA. Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA and scholars of the Institute attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nDr. Ashok Behuria\, in his opening remarks\, provided a brief and insightful overview of Nepal’s political landscape\, highlighting the frequent changes in the administration and the challenges leading to the failure of the previous coalition governments. He discussed Nepal’s two electoral methods – First Past the Post (FPTP) and Proportional Representation (PR) system. After giving a short overview of the 2022 Parliamentary Elections\, he noted that no government has ever lasted in power for a full term\, which indicates the instability in the Nepalese political system. He drew attention to the diversity in Nepal with almost 135 spoken languages and high representation level of Members of Parliament (MPs)\, with one MP representing a population of only one lakh. He further highlighted that with the increase in bilateral engagements between China and Nepal\, there are concerns regarding China’s growing influence in the region. \nDetailed Report\nMs. Sneha M. commenced her presentation with a comprehensive overview of Nepal’s tumultuous political history\, marred by divisions in the successive governments. She traced Nepal’s trajectory towards democracy from the time of Absolute Monarchy in 1846 to the adoption of a new constitution in 2015\, highlighting significant events such as the Partyless Panchayat system in 1960 and emergence of multiparty democracy in 1990. She highlighted the challenges posed by the emergence of the Maoist insurgency in 1996 which was largely driven by grievances related to poverty\, inequality and corruption\, and the subsequent transition to a Federal Democratic Republic in 2006-2008. \nWhile giving an overview of the 2022 Parliamentary Elections\, Ms. Sneha noted that the Nepali Congress (NC) emerged as the single largest party. Due to differences among leaders for the post of Prime Minister\, Pushpa Kamal Dahal\, popularly known as “Prachanda”\, of the Communist Party of Nepal-Maoist Centre (CPN-MC) broke the coalition and joined hands with the Communist Party of Nepal-Unified Marxist Leninist (CPN-UML) resulting in him becoming the Prime Minister. However\, the coalition collapsed within two months\, causing further instability in the country. Ms. Sneha pointed out the political shift in March 2024\, when Prachanda formed a new coalition with “CPN-UML”\, Rashtriya Swatantra Party (RSP) and Janata Samajwadi Party (JSP) after terminating the alliance with the Nepali Congress. She also noted that a country with such a small population of almost 3 crores\, has 109 registered political parties due to the ease of securing just 3 per cent of the total vote share to achieve a PR seat and become a national party. \nThrowing light on the instability in the government alliances\, she assessed some key factors which led to the fall of the coalition including clash of opinions between Prime Minister Dahal and NC Finance Minister\, Prakash Sharan Mahat\, personal interests of leaders\, and external pressures. She emphasised how the coalition dynamics have been impacted by Nepal’s complex electoral system and the proliferation of political parties. She also analysed the implications on domestic governance\, citing Nepal’s GDP growth having an average of about 4.2 per cent since 2008 which falls short of 7 per cent to qualify as an emerging economy. She elaborated on the escalation of the trade deficit from 14 per cent to over 50 per cent of the GDP since 2008. As a result\, she observed that a significant number of young people have been departing the country in search of better opportunities abroad\, citing the limited job prospects within Nepal. \nAssessing implications for India\, Ms. Sneha acknowledged the robust ties between the two countries across economic\, security\, cultural and strategic domains. India has always engaged with Nepal over mutual interest irrespective of the party in power. She emphasised that China would any day prefer a left party rule in Nepal for its own political benefits. Highlighting recent developments\, she emphasised that Nepal’s balance is shifting towards China\, which is evident in the increased bilateral exchanges and investments. \nFurthermore\, she stated that the inclination of the current administration towards China is unlikely to impact the bilateral relationship between Kathmandu and New Delhi given that India is still the largest trade partner of Nepal\, comprising two-third of Nepal’s merchandise trade and about one-third of trade in services. India is also the largest source of foreign investments in Nepal. However\, she analysed that India might lose smooth cooperation with Nepal and experience delays in implementation of projects that India has invested in and funded\, in the near future. \nQuestions and Comments\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, commended Ms. Sneha for her comprehensive and engaging presentation. He pointed out the significance of the India-Nepal relationship and emphasised on adopting a strategy of aligning with Nepal on issues of mutual interests. Amb. Chinoy stated that allowing local dynamics to shape Nepal’s domestic politics is a better approach for India.  However\, he recognised the importance of closely observing regional developments and responding appropriately\, as porous borders might be exploited by adversaries to undermine India’s security landscape. \nScholars raised pertinent points such as Nepal’s decision to print NPR 100 currency incorporating disputed territories and how it impacts Indo-Nepal relations\, the relevance of anti-Indian sentiments propagated by political parties\, the role of culture in International Relations. Additionally\, concerns related to Nepal’s reconciliation with India’s Agniveer Scheme and the recruitment of Nepalese in the Gorkha regiment were also raised. Commenting on the same\, Amb. Chinoy stated that there are enough Indian Gorkhas who could be recruited to continue the legacy of the Gorkha regiment. \nMs. Sneha M. responded to the comments made by the Director General and the questions raised by MP-IDSA scholars. \n\nReport prepared by Ms. Puspa Kumari\, Intern\, South Asia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-understanding-nepals-coalition-shift-implications-for-domestic-governance-and-indias-interests
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240520T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240520T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240618T021421Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240618T021421Z
UID:81513-1716183000-1716183000@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on “Debates on US-China Science and Technology Agreement”
DESCRIPTION:On 20 May 2024\, Dr. Opangmeren Jamir of the East Asia Centre delivered a talk during the Monday Morning Meeting on “Debates on US-China Science and Technology Agreement.” The meeting was moderated by Commodore Abhay Singh (Retd)\, Research Fellow at MP-IDSA. Scholars of the institute were in attendance. \nExecutive Summary\nThe United States-China relationship has gone through several ups and downs during the twentieth and twenty-first centuries\, impacted variously by the legacies of imperialism\, world war and superpower competition between the Soviet Union and the US at a global scale. As China now emerges as a peer competitor of the US and attempts to surpass the latter in the field of science and technology (S&T)\, it is important to understand the historical and cognitive foundations underlying the Chinese conception of science\, its application to collaboration with the US commencing from the 1970s and its continued relevance today under the rule of Xi Jinping. Dr. Opangmeren Jamir’s presentation attempts to address just such a lacuna in the understanding of China’s push to unleash the ‘new productive forces’ of science and technology so that it may outstrip the US in the quest to provide an alternative technology hub for emerging economies. \nDetailed Report\nThe meeting was called to order by Cmde. Abhay Singh (Retd.)\, who introduced the Speaker and delivered short introductory remarks on the topic under discussion. He laid the groundwork for the Speaker’s remarks by articulating the challenge posed by China’s growth in technological prowess\, and the apprehensions this has caused in Western strategic circles. He pointed out several pessimistic findings from Institutions of repute such as the Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI)\, whose work he cited to highlight how the Western powers face an imminent loss of their competitive edge in 33 of 44 key sectors where China already has or will have a strong lead in the near future. He also noted that in the current context\, technological advancement in the form of an ‘innovation marathon’ will determine the course of our global future. He also briefly introduced the US-China Science and Technology Agreement of 1979\, and outlined its current status. He then invited the Speaker to commence his remarks. \nDr. Jamir began his talk by providing a background of the current state of the US-China Science and Technology Agreement\, namely\, that it has been extended for a short term of six months\, so that the agreement is in force while negotiations continue\, though a formal declaration of extension is pending. He then outlined the key features of his presentation\, stating that the intention would be to focus on historical and technical background of US-China collaboration in S&T. He then took the audience through a theoretical overview of various normative understandings of S&T as a form of national power. In particular\, he cited Adam Smith’s conception of a ‘division of labour’\, Joseph Schumpeter’s conception of ‘creative destruction’ of industries and innovation and Susan Strange’s idea of ‘scientific knowledge as power’ whereby states with robust research and development (R&D) capacities are deemed to have the most power. \nFollowing this theoretical exposition\, Dr. Jamir introduced the audience to the history of science policy in China before the takeover of the country by the Communist Party of China (CPC) in 1949. Here he discussed in some detail the 1911 Revolution which toppled the declining Qing Empire\, as well as the May Fourth Movement of 1919\, which aimed to reform China into a modern\, prosperous and democratic state free of the harmful impacts of Western imperialism. In order to achieve these goals\, the leaders of the May Fourth Movement looked broadly to both ‘Mr. Democracy’ as well as ‘Mr. Science’ as fundamental pillars on which a strong China would be built. This led in 1928 to the formation of the setting up of premier academic societies such as the Academica Sinica\, as well as the reform of the education system according to American models\, as the Republic of China attempted to execute nation-building projects. He thus highlighted that the Chinese have always conceived of science instrumentally\, that is\, as a means to achieve a strong state\, rather than as a noble pursuit in and of itself. \nAs China fell to the Communists in 1949\, this background led the CPC to proclaim that only science could ‘save China’. Dr. Jamir pointed to two pivotal events which shaped science policy after the CPC’s takeover\, until the late 1970s: the replacement of the Soviet Union with the US as the preferred model of educational emulation\, and the scars left by the Cultural Revolution (1966-1976) when the regime itself unleashed a wave of suspicion and mistrust against scientific authorities. He spoke at length on the impact of Mao’s Cultural Revolution and the irreparable harm it caused to scientific progress in China for over two decades\, as first he and then the Gang of Four encouraged students to revolt against their Western-educated teachers\, condemned and persecuted them as ‘rightists’ and ‘capitalist roaders’ and fostered an environment of hostility against all practitioners of science.  \nIt was only after 1978 that the context for US-China scientific cooperation became clear\, as Deng Xiaoping channelled China’s energies into the ‘Four Modernisations’\, which removed Soviet influences from Chinese scientific education and restored the normative significance of Western models. The signing of the US-China Science and Technology Cooperation Agreement in 1979 thus marked a sea change in China’s scientific progress\, as it firmly established the importance of science as an article of faith within the CPC’s worldview. Driven by a desire to not repeat the mistakes of the Cultural Revolution\, Deng and his successors up to and including Xi Jinping continued to encourage scientific cooperation with US in order to develop China into the powerhouse it is today. \nDr. Jamir concluded his lecture by pondering the question of whether the US and China would be better off collaborating or competing\, especially as their trade frictions continue to intensify and cautious delinking seems the order of the day. In this regard\, he cited Wang Huning\, who in a 1992 publication pointed out that the US could only be ‘defeated’ by being surpassed in S&T. Thus\, there is a need to be wary of sharing dual use\, critical and emerging technologies\, while maintaining robust cooperation on pressing issues such as climate change mitigation\, space exploration and knowledge production. \nQuestions and Answers\nBefore opening the floor to the audience for Q&A\, Cmde. Singh asked Dr. Jamir to elucidate the drivers of change in China’s S&T policy post-Cultural Revolution\, and whether a specific point could be identified when imitation of Western models shifted to indigenous innovation. Dr. Jamir answered that the seeds of reform were already present in the late Qing empire\, almost seven decades prior to the Cultural Revolution’s termination\, but the cumulative effects of the ‘century of humiliation’ by Western powers as well as the disastrous policies adopted in the initial years of the People’s Republic led to a thorough rethinking of S&T policy. \nDr. Swasti Rao asked about the sectors where the US-China Agreement currently being negotiated is deadlocked\, and whether Xi Jinping’s leadership plays a role. Dr. Jamir answered that areas of deadlock were mainly confined to emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence and quantum computing. As for Xi’s role\, Dr. Jamir noted that each leader of China after Deng has attempted to put their own imprimatur on S&T policy\, and Xi’s contribution\, the ‘New Prosperity Theory’\, essentially sets entrepreneurs free to innovate indigenously in order to break the deadlock faced due to geopolitical headwinds. \nThis report was prepared by Dr. Arnab Dasgupta\, Research Analyst\, East Asia Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-debates-on-us-china-science-and-technology-agreement
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240522T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240522T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240712T035654Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240712T035654Z
UID:81866-1716355800-1716355800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Lecture by H. E. Dr Philipp Ackermann\, Ambassador of the Embassy of the Federal Republic of Germany on “Challenges in Europe and Indo-German Partnership”
DESCRIPTION:On 22 May 2024\, the Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised a lecture by His Excellency Dr. Philipp Ackermann\, Ambassador of the Embassy of the Federal Republic of Germany\, under the Eminent Persons Lecture Series. The topic of the lecture was “Challenges in Europe and Indo-German Partnership”. The event was chaired by the Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R Chinoy. \nExecutive Summary\nThe conflict in Ukraine has impacted the European continent including Germany. Germany has attempted to diversify its partners\, which has ensured a reduction of its dependence on Russia. When it comes to India\, Germany’s relationship with India has gained prominence\, and it will continue to grow in the long term. \nDetailed Report\nThe session began with the opening remarks from the Director General\, MP-IDSA\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy who underscored the pivotal role of Germany as a critical player in the European Union and one of India’s most important strategic partners. He highlighted the various high-level dialogues that have taken place\, including the visits of India’s Prime Minister to Germany in 2022 and the German Chancellor’s reciprocal visit in 2023\, which have significantly bolstered bilateral ties. There has been a rise in trade and investment between the two nations. Germany’s foreign policy towards China was mentioned with a particular focus on the term de-risking\, which is the recent focal point of the policy regarding China in Europe. Amb. Chinoy said that Germany is concerned about issues such as climate change\, and illegal immigration and asked about the perspectives of the various political parties and ideologies. \nAmbassador Dr. Philipp Ackermann began his talk by proposing that he would present a few key messages and five points regarding the topic. The first key point is that Europe faces challenges but in the last couple of years has shown resolve to overcome them. On the migration challenge\, he stated that Europe is very popular among migrants\, and migration is encouraged\, but illegal migration from various nations is an issue. This has led to certain insecurities and ensured that a rise of the far right has become possible\, which would be visible in the results of the upcoming European elections. Germany has an ageing population\, so there is a need for migration. Germany has also signed a migration partnership with India and with the consent of the state and centre\, is recruiting skilled labour for Germany from India. He emphasised the need to legalise and channel legal migration while ensuring that illegal migration is brought down. \nThe second challenge is the economic shock Germany suffered in the last two years due to the war in Europe. This support has been costly but it is a price that needs to be paid to support Ukraine. Ukraine is close to Germany\, and the war has changed the texture of the European security structure and affected the cohesion of the European Union. Germany thought that any security structure in Europe could not be possible without Russia. Various avenues have been set up to deal with Russia\, including the Russia-NATO Council. Russia’s reactions at present and its approach in 2014 have changed the mindset within Europe\, and now the focus is on building a resilient security structure against Russia. The main reason for this is to ensure that Russia does not invade any other countries in Europe. Russia has a clear appetite to have more territory. \nThe second key point of concern is the Russia-Ukraine war. If Russia is not shown the limits of its actions\, it will continue. Russian President Vladimir Putin has an expansionist mentality. NATO’s eastern front is not very strong and its deeper integration into the larger security structure is required to prevent any other aggression. Putin has miscalculated the unity of Europe\, and Ukraine cannot be left alone\, and its territory allowed to be taken away by Russia. The war has impacted the world\, particularly in the energy sector. Germany paid the price since 50 per cent of its gas came from Russia\, but now\, after diversification\, no gas comes from Russia. India has felt the impact of the war on various sectors\, including fertilisers\, gas\, and oil. \nThe third key point is the India-Germany Partnership. India has gained a new weight in Germany’s foreign policy. India’s position is much higher\, and the German Government has seen a need for like-minded partners. India’s democratic ethos and non-expansionist character are similar to what Germany feels. India and Germany have a sound strategic partnership\, and the two nations can focus on all the areas of cooperation. Certain avenues include start-ups\, academic research\, and energy (hydrogen); the governments also want to intensify this cooperation. The inter-governmental consultations\, which will happen in October 2024\, would further strengthen the collaboration. Germany and India have cooperated in the sustainability of smart cities\, biodiversity and trade. Already there are 2200 Indo-German companies who have invested in both the countries and there is hope for more investments. \nThe fourth key point is based on defence cooperation. There has been evident growth and a step forward in this area. Progress has been made in delivering military equipment\, systems\, arms\, and supplying of aircraft. Joint exercises\, capacity building\, and information sharing have increased. In August 2024\, for the first time\, fighter jets would be sent by Germany to participate in Tarang Shakti Phase 1 exercise in Coimbatore. In October 2024\, a German frigate would come to Goa and exercise with the Indian Navy. The two defence ministries share a strong relationship. This was underscored by the visit of the German Defence Minister in June 2023 and the signing of various tenders during that visit. \nThe fifth key point is focused on the Indian Ocean. Protecting international borders and oceans for free navigation is essential. We must keep the lines of communication in the open seas as safe as possible. Germany wants to promote a rules-based order protecting free and open trade. Germany and India can try to minimise the security challenges in the Indian Ocean together. China’s aggressive behaviour in the Indian Ocean concerns how China is attempting to expand its influence. For Germany\, China is a partner and a competitor; when it comes to politics\, it is considered a systemic rival. \nQuestions and Comments\nDirector General\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy inquired about Chinese Influence Operations in Europe\, including Germany. Secondly\, he asked whether Germany sees China as a long-term or immediate threat? Lastly\, he asked whether Germany’s understanding of the rules-based order collides with their experience with China’s approach to a rules based order. \nAmbassador Dr. Phillip Ackermann replied that China has firmly pushed its policy in academic institutions in recent years. This is done to shape and form an understanding of how China functions. In the case of a policymaker influenced by China\, he gave an example of an individual who was a Chief of Staff of a Member of Parliament. Therefore\, it shows how strongly China has influenced decision-making and policy-making. When it comes to cyberspace\, the Russians participate more actively. For Germany\, China and Russia are a threat as influence operators. \nDr. Swasti Rao asked if Germany believes in a de-risking policy vis-a-vis China and\, if so\, what steps should be taken. The Speaker answered that de-risking means encouraging and recommending the private sectors to de-risk. Germany cannot force them to not go to China; this was done with Russia\, but it was easier since Russia is not an important economy. German companies have diversified and have begun focusing on the Asian arena\, including India. Many German companies want to set up shop in India. German companies see India more as a brain than a muscle; therefore\, the focus is more on investing in Rand D\, technology and development sector. \nGrp. Capt. (Dr.) Ajey Lele asked about German investments in the technology and space arena. \nThe Speaker emphasised that Germany is lagging behind in space\, and the French are ahead. India needs to cooperate in this sector. \nDr. Rajorshi Roy asked about the European assessments of a scenario of a defeated Russia and its impact on regional security and stability. \nThe Speaker focused on the possibility that a period of frozen conflict would arise if the war did end\, and he felt it wouldn’t end very soon. They would still need to deal with Russia. Russia did attack a sovereign country\, and Russia did take 20 per cent of the land; this act cannot be accepted. The history of the First World War shows that humiliation was not a good option for better relations after the war ended. The priority is to support Ukraine in its legitimate fight to protect its territorial integrity. \nMs. Anandita Bhada enquired about how Germany plans to reduce dependence on China in the renewable energy sector. Secondly\, with Germany’s attempts at energy diversification\, whether Germany is looking at other energy partnerships soon? \nThe Speaker answered that we are much more diversified in the energy sector in the current period\, and Germany is not dependent only on one source of energy. Germany gets its gas from Norway\, the Gulf\, etc. It has become a mixed basket. \nDr. Jason Wahlang asked how Germany sees the rise of the right-wing in the European Parliament. Secondly\, how much influence does the Alternative for Germany party have in the Western side of Germany when it comes to immigration debates? \nThe Speaker stated that there will be a rise of right-wing parties in the European Parliament for many reasons. The far right is not as powerful as it seems; its percentage is about 15-16 percent. On the immigration question\, Germany does not think immigration is a bad thing; they do not want illegal immigration. Twenty percent of German individuals have at least one non-German parent. \nDr. Rajiv Nayan enquired about the different perceptions of terrorism in India and Europe. \nOn the topic of terrorism\, the Speaker explained that India has its own experience and Germany has its own. In this globalised world\, there is a need to compare whether\, for example\, the Khalistan issue is taken more seriously only in India or other nations as well. Intelligence sharing is important\, and there is a need to find ways to cooperate. \nMs. Shruti Pandalai asked whether China’s relationship with Germany limits its national policy in the Indo-Pacific. Secondly\, how could a change in the White House’s leadership impact the future of the Trans-Atlantic alliance? \nThe Speaker opined that Germany was considered the least popular country in Europe in the first tenure of the Trump leadership. With any change in leadership in the United States of America\, Germany would still find a way to work and function with this relationship. \nDr. Prashant Singh enquired about the perceived disunity between the United States and Europe regarding trade and investment with China. \nThe Speaker stated that Europe and Germany are wholly localised economies compared to the United States of America. It would appear that the de-risking has reduced German engagement with China. \nCaptain Sunil Tyagi\, Centre for Air Power Studies\, asked whether Russia would shift its attention to Georgia and Moldova after the Ukraine War. \nAmbassador Dr. Philip Ackerman stated that Russia has\, in a way\, played with Georgia and Moldova. He feels that both countries can be seen as candidates for membership in the European Union\, but their conflicts are very different. \nThe report has been prepared by Dr. Jason Wahlang\, Research Analyst\, Europe and Eurasia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/lecture-by-h-e-dr-philipp-ackermann-ambassador-of-the-embassy-of-the-federal-republic-of-germany-on-challenges-in-europe-and-indo-german-partnership
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240527T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240527T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240701T230136Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240701T231002Z
UID:81738-1716787800-1716787800@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Monday Morning Meeting on Security and Defence Cooperation between India and Poland
DESCRIPTION:Dr. Patryk Kugiel\, Senior Analyst for South Asia at the Polish Institute of International Affairs (PISM)\, Warsaw\, made a presentation on “Security and Defence Cooperation between India and Poland” at the Monday Morning Meeting held on 27 May 2024. The Session was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director-General\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA). Scholars of the Institute participated in the discussion. \nExecutive Summary\nThe people of India and Poland have shared cordial relations since historical times. In 1942\, Maharaja Digvijaysinhji Ranjitsinhji Jadeja established the Polish Children’s Camp in Jamnagar-Balachadi\, offering refuge to Polish children. During World War II\, Polish and Indian soldiers fought together in various battles\, prominent among which was the Battle of Monte Cassino. Not only do both the countries have a history in defence cooperation over the last 70 years\, but also have a shared future in the defence sector. \nDetailed Report\nDr. Patryk Kugiel commenced his presentation by highlighting the glorious past of Poland-India relations in the defence sector. During the Cold War era\, Poland was the seventh largest supplier of arms to India and India was the second largest market for Polish arms export\, showcasing very intensive cooperation between both the countries. In 1989\, Poland entered into a complex transition in political\, economic and strategic dimensions. This led to the rearrangement of Poland’s foreign policy from East to the West\, in turn bringing about change in its strategic defence partners. The Polish defence sector and heavy industries underwent remarkable restructuring and privatisation as well. These developments transitioned Poland from an arms exporter (of Soviet equipment) to arms importer (from the West). Dr. Kugiel highlighted that from 1991\, the Indian economy also started to transition and so did its defence sector. During this time India remained heavily dependent on Russia for arms supply\, but in the subsequent years\, India has also started to diversify its imports\, by opening markets to supplies from USA\, France and Israel\, among others. \nDr. Kugiel highlighted that during the last three decades there have been many attempts to revive defence cooperation. For instance\, in 1998 India bought 22 TS-11 Iskra jet trainers and 44 WZT- 3 Armoured Recovery Vehicles (ARVs); in 2002\, 88 WZT (ARVs) and fire control DRAWA-T systems. Furthermore\, in 2003 the countries signed a Defence Cooperation Agreement and in 2004 a Joint Working Group (JWG) on defence cooperation was established. Moreover\, the Defence Wing of the Indian Embassy in Warsaw was reopened on 8 May 2024\, with Brigadier Satish Trivedi’s accreditation to Poland’s Ministry of National Defence. \nDr. Kugiel emphasised that the war in Ukraine has complicated relations\, but can also be seen as a new opportunity in India-Polish cooperation in the defence sector. He highlighted the changes that have taken place in the Polish defence sector since the war i.e.\, urgent replacement of Russian military equipment\, modernisation of armed forces (through a spike in defence budget and investment in domestic industry) and increased international cooperation. There have also been changes in the political dimensions\, as Poland has now become a frontline state and is a key member of NATO. He also stressed on the Weimar Triangle between France\, Germany and Poland emerging as a new engine for European cooperation and integration. \nRegarding India’s defence sector\, Dr. Kugiel raised the following strategic questions. Is Russia a reliable supplier? Is Russian equipment the best? Is the Russia-China axis emerging? Is the overdependence on Russia in sync with India’s strategic economy? He also highlighted the following strategic implications for India i.e.\, replacement of Russian/post-Soviet equipment which might impact the modernisation and development of the domestic defence industry in India. \nDr. Kugiel emphasised that both countries have potential for cooperation in the defence sector\, mainly in three areas – modernisation of post-Soviet equipment\, experience of ready-made products (such as Krab howitzer\, Piorun and Grom man-portable air-defense systems\, Grot rifles)\, and co-development and co-production of new weapons system (Borsuk Amphibious Infantry Fighting Vehicle). However\, according to Dr. Kugiel\, this cooperation between Poland and India faces the challenge of lack of trust and mutual understanding. There is lack of clear understanding on the requirement\, rules and procedures of procurement. Additionally\, there is uncertainty about whether the existing resources and technologies are sufficient for the mass-production of weapons required in current times. \nIn his concluding remarks\, Dr. Kugiel provided recommendations to meet these challenges and obstacles. For the rebuilding of mutual trust and understanding in defence cooperation he suggested that there is a great need for dialogue between the policymakers such as the National Security Advisors (NSA)\, the countries should focus on the revival of the JWG on defence\, match major arms producing companies for co-production projects and find solutions to the issues in the Bumar contract. He stressed on the need to address the existing knowledge gap between the procedures of procurement in both the countries\, suggesting detailed studies to examine the potential of joint projects. This would help in strengthening military dialogues with the exchange visits of military personnel and academicians. There is also a need to revive joint bilateral and multilateral military exercises. He emphasised on the need for maximisation of resources to address these deficiencies together and intensify partnership in major arms fairs. \nComments and Questions\nAmb. Sujan Chinoy thanked Dr. Kugiel for his recommendations on advancing the bilateral relationship and defence cooperation between India and Poland. He stressed the need to encourage Polish companies to participate in Indian trade fairs and also the Indian defence industrial corridors. He also emphasised the possibilities of investing in the Indian defence sector as it has been opened for 100 per cent foreign direct investment (FDI)\, stating the example of ‘Saab’ – becoming the first global defence company to secure an approval for a 100 per cent FDI project in the defence corridor in Uttar Pradesh to manufacture the Carl-Gustaf rocket systems. Amb. Chinoy agreed on the need for increased dialogue at different levels. Regarding overdependence on Russia\, he pointed out that Indian imports from Russia have come down from 70 per cent to about 36 per cent and that overdependence is a thing of the past. Commenting on the Russia-China axis\, Amb. Chinoy said that the two countries are coming closer against the primacy of the West in the current international order in terms of agenda setting and not against India. \nGp. Capt. (Dr.) R.K. Narang (Retd.)\, commented on the changing landscape of the Indian defence industry in the last decade and the development of niche technologies by Indian companies. \nDr. Swasti Rao\, enquired about how India could improve its exports to Poland\, and asked the Speaker to share his views on the geopolitical development of the Weimar Triangle and its role in Ukraine’s and Europe’s security at large. \nDr. Rajorshi Roy\, questioned about NATO’s overtures to India\, and Dr. Kugiel’s assessment on how India would react to these overtures. \nDr. Rajiv Nayan\, enquired about Poland’s import of military equipment from South Korea. \nDr. Samuel C. Rajiv\, enquired about Polish and European export efforts post the war in Ukraine. \nDr. Patryk Kugiel responded to the comments and the questions raised by the MP-IDSA Scholars. \nReport has been prepared by Ms. Anusua Ganguly\, Intern\, Europe and Eurasia Centre\, MP-IDSA.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/monday-morning-meeting-on-security-and-defence-cooperation-between-india-and-poland
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240529T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240529T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240618T021658Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240618T021658Z
UID:81515-1716960600-1716960600@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Growing India-Denmark Ties
DESCRIPTION:Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses (MP-IDSA) organised a lecture by H.E. Ambassador Freddy Svane\, Ambassador of Denmark to India under the Eminent Persons Lecture Series on “Growing India-Denmark Ties” on29 May 2024. The interaction was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA and attended by the Institute’s scholars. \nExecutive Summary\nThe event provided a comprehensive overview of the India-Denmark Green Strategic Partnership. It delved into bilateral ties of the two nations while also analysing the future prospects to further develop this strategic partnership. Ambassador Sujan Chinoy highlighted his shared diplomatic experiences with Ambassador Freddy Svane in Japan and India. He praised Amb. Svane’s understanding of India and India’s partnership with Denmark\, emphasising the significance of their bilateral ties. Amb. Svane discussed the historical relations between India and Denmark\, the 75-year milestone of their partnership\, and the importance of strategic autonomy for India. He elaborated on the 5Ss of their partnership: scale\, skills\, strength\, speed\, and sustainability\, also mentioning the potential for collaboration in areas beyond the green partnership\, such as defense and the Arctic. He also highlighted Denmark’s defense posture post-Russia-Ukraine crises and expressed willingness to collaborate with India. The Q&A session covered aspects including Denmark’s wind energy sector\, defence collaboration\, the Russia-Ukraine crises\, possibility of limestone trade\, deep-sea fishing\, and the future of data\, minerals\, and green transitions. \nDetailed Report\nAmbassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA delivered the opening remarks. He began by welcoming Ambassador Freddy Svane to MP-IDSA and fondly recalled their common tenure in Tokyo from 2015-2018 as Ambassador of India to Japan and Ambassador of Denmark to Japan\, respectively. Amb. Svane is the only ambassador to have held two tenures as Danish Ambassador to India (2010-2015 and 2019- current) as well as to Japan (2005-2008 and 2015-2019). Amb. Chinoy spoke about Amb Svane’s familiarity with India. He mentioned Indian Prime Minister Modi’s 3S formula and said that skill\, scale and speed should define India- Denmark relations. \nAmb. Chinoy also highlighted the improvement witnessed in India- Denmark bilateral relations in recent years and requested him to share his views on bilateral ties\, Green Strategic Partnership\, and emerging scenarios in the Arctic region amongst others. He said that the Green Strategic Partnership has emerged as a crucial aspect in India- Denmark relations and this has been evident from various high level visits in the recent past. The trade and investment statistics seem to suggest that the full potential has yet to be realised. He expressed hope that this would pick up pace in coming times. With this he invited Amb. Svane to deliver the lecture. \n H.E. Amb. Freddy Svane commenced the lecture by mentioning the biggest diplomatic victory- the India Denmark Green Strategic Partnership. He quoted Denmark’s current demographic figures and the advent of Danish people 400 years ago to what is now called Tamil Nadu in November 1620 as traders\, not colonisers. He mentioned the historical fabric trade between the two regions and a recent event in Denmark to commemorate that. In 2024 India-Danish partnership has reached the milestone of 75 years\, which had started with building strategies to manage trade ties with India. \nAmb. Svane recalled his last posting in India when he was invited by a private company to inaugurate an industrial plant in Gujarat and how he met the then Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi in 2011. He credits that particular bilateral meeting as the starting point of India’s green partnership with Denmark. He also highlighted the west’s pattern of dictating to other countries what to do but reiterated that Denmark has no such intentions vis-a-vis India or the west. It does not want to teach or preach to others. He mentioned the increasing investments coming to India and that India is not only the largest market in terms of size but also a democratic country with its own rights and sovereignty. Giving the Danish perspective Amb. Svane said that it is best if India exercises its strategic autonomy rather than join a specific camp and tow that line. \nAmb. Svane underscored that the green strategic partnership is based on the 5Ss of scale\, skills\, strength\, speed and sustainability. India has the Scale which is reflected in its capacity and capability; Denmark has the necessary technological Skills; Strength of this partnership comes from affordability and resilience\, which are unique to the Indian developmental agenda; Speed is required in achieving the goals laid out for climate change and SDGs; and lastly\, Sustainability is crucial\, which is why Copenhagen would be willing for joint collaborations beyond the green partnership to include sectors like defence\, Arctic and critical minerals. Science is the sixth S which will be added in the next meeting as innovation is the key to Indo-Danish relations. \nAmb Svane mentioned what comprises the Kingdom of Denmark- Denmark\, Greenland\, and Faroe Islands- where foreign policy and defence is managed by the capital seat in Copenhagen. Greenland is approximately ¾ the size of the Indian subcontinent but inhabits a small population of around 60 thousand. It caught global attention when the vast ice sheets across the island began to melt\, giving rise to unexplored reserves of resources\, critical minerals\, and trade routes. Since Denmark is a founding member of the Arctic Council\, its vision is greatly defined by the values dear to Danish people. Amb. Svane went on to mention the critical role played by Denmark in ensuring India’s addition as an observer state to the Arctic Council in 2013 and how the then Deputy NSA of India discussed India’s arctic vision with him. The conversation revolved around resources and critical minerals found in Greenland but India was very much interested in scientific engagement at that time. It was involved in ice cold drilling\, R&D and other procedures. Amb. Svane emphasised that Denmark wants to give India as much role in Arctic as possible owing to the reality of climate change. \nOn the defence front Amb. Svane recognised that historically Denmark has fought many wars and lost them all. Post cold war\, it chose to close down the military installation in Greenland. The naval base there was put up for auction and its biggest bidder was an Australian company. This was very surprising as Australia is geographically distant from Greenland but it was later discovered that this firm had some Chinese connections. Similarly\, Chinese involvement has recently increased in tenders for building airports and critical infrastructure too. \nConcluding his remarks\, Amb. Svane commented on Indian interests in Denmark\, which are evident from several visits of its new Ambassador to Greenland and Faroe Islands. Deep sea fishing and mining are significant issues that India has to deal with. As of now there are no fish left in the strait separating India from Sri Lanka. Denmark has the required technology for it and Faroe Islands have the experience of dealing with issues like deep sea fishing. Cooperation in such fields could prove useful for both the parties. Democratic dialogue in India is strong. There is no yardstick to measure democracy but each country has its own set of issues and situations. \nQ&A Session\nAmb. Chinoy thanked Amb. Svane for his insightful remarks and opened the floor for questions. Scholars of MP-IDSA asked diverse questions ranging from Denmark’s promising wind energy sector\, India-Denmark defence collaboration\, the Ambassador’s views on Russia-Ukraine crises\, high limestone reserves in Denmark and its possible trade with trade\, and the kind of collaboration possible with India over deep sea fishing. \nAmb. Svane answered the questions\, commencing with the one on renewable energy. He mentioned the oil crises of 1970s and how the governments were left to fend for alternate sources of energy. Denmark had researchers and scientists working on the R&D needed for this. Denmark had the first mover’s advantage amongst the European nations\, especially in wind energy. Today 75 per cent of its electricity comes from renewables. For the critical minerals required in wind turbines\, Denmark relies on China\, which is known for mining and processing these critical minerals. The current Danish Government having stopped mining as it is environmentally degrading\, leaves the question of mineral procurement unanswered. What can be done to access certain minerals if their mining is under the monopoly of one country? In fact\, in India too most of the work related to wind turbines is being done by China and not surprisingly these installations are mostly India’s near critical infrastructure. Last 7 GW of commissioned turbines were given to Chinese companies. What most people do not realise is that those managing the software in these systems also have access to the data that the software constantly collects. This is one of the reasons why US has become vary of China’s inroads in the cyber and technology sector and has put in place certain legislations to minimise that damage. \nAnswering the question on defence procurement\, Amb. Svane said that Denmark is re-arming itself post the Russia Ukraine crises\, in accordance to the NATO norms. It would be great to collaborate with allies like India in this regard. Copenhagen is open to all kinds of possibilities to re-build its defence industry. With regard to Russia-Ukraine crises\, Amb. Svane reiterated that he does not want to preach or teach anybody. He mentioned that Denmark is sending F-16 fighter jets to Ukraine alongside helping them out in aid and other matters. India’s stand on the crises was a tough one for Amb. Svane to explain to the west but he referred to the 1962 India – China war when India was left to fend for itself as no help from the west arrived when India needed it. According to Amb. Svane\, Denmark understands the reasons for Indian dependence on Russian arms and ammunitions and would be happy to help India diversify in this sector. He even praised the recent increase in India-Russia oil trade and how this helped keep market prices of oil under control. The real threat recognised in the region was China. If India could somehow keep China under control\, Denmark would do all that it can to help India diversify its supply chains which are currently dependent on China. \nConcluding the Q&A round\, Amb. Svane responded to the query on limestone trade by mentioning that the top most traded item from Europe to India is waste. It is indeed a sad state of affairs that India buys tonnes of scrap metal and e-waste from Europe but if this can be replaced by other items including limestone\, that would be beneficial for both the parties. Lastly the issue of deep sea fishing was addressed. The Danish Ambassador said that Faroe Islands have proven capabilities and knowledge on this matter as well as on the issue of deep sea mining. The future is about data\, minerals and green transitions\, all of which are sensitive aspects of critical development\, especially for certain sectors like defence\, cyber\, and IT amongst others. \nAfter concluding the Q&A session\, Amb Chinoy thanked H.E. Amb. Freddy Svane\, Ambassador of Denmark to India and the audience for a fruitful engagement. \nReport has been prepared by Ms. Anandita Bhada\, Research Analyst\, Europe and Eurasia Centre\, Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/growing-india-denmark-ties
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
BEGIN:VEVENT
DTSTART;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240531T053000
DTEND;TZID=Asia/Kolkata:20240531T053000
DTSTAMP:20261122T045200
CREATED:20240618T021837Z
LAST-MODIFIED:20240618T021837Z
UID:81514-1717133400-1717133400@idsa.in
SUMMARY:Lecture by Ambassador Harsh Shringla on “Developmental Priorities and India’s Neighbourhood: View from Darjeeling”
DESCRIPTION:Under MP-IDSA’s Eminent Persons Lecture Series\, Ambassador Harsh Shringla delivered his lecture on “Developmental Priorities and India’s Neighbourhood: Views from Darjeeling” on 31 May 2024. The Session was chaired by Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy\, Director General\, MP-IDSA. Scholars of the MP-IDSA attended the meeting. \nExecutive Summary\nThe lecture highlighted the evolving global landscape\, characterised by shifting power dynamics and the limitations of existing global institutions in addressing modern challenges effectively. It underscored India’s emerging role as an advocate for the Global South\, drawing from the Speaker’s extensive experience in the Ministry of External Affairs. The discussion emphasised the importance of adopting a comprehensive foreign policy approach that balances regional development with international diplomacy\, considering the intricate interplay between local and global factors. \nDetailed Report\nIn his opening remarks\, the Director General\, Ambassador Sujan R. Chinoy welcomed Ambassador Harsh Shringla to MP-IDSA. He highlighted Amb. Shringla’s diplomatic career including as the Chief Coordinator for India’s G20 Presidency. He invited Amb. Shringla to share his perspectives on regional developmental challenges\, the future of India’s neighbourhood and India’s emergence as a voice for the Global South\, particularly in the context of India’s G20 Presidency.  \nAmb. Harsh Shringla began by expressing gratitude for being invited to share his insights. He acknowledged the importance of engaging in discussions on foreign policy and developmental challenges. He emphasised that the world is navigating through very uncertain times\, which necessitates a thoughtful consideration of significant shifts in global leadership and influence. He added that these shifts contribute to rebalancing of economic growth and manufacturing power\, with countries like China rising in prominence and altering the traditional global power dynamics away from the United States and Europe. \nAmb. Shringla also discussed the implications of this rebalancing on global governance\, questioning the ability of existing institutions like the United Nations and global financial organisations to effectively address the challenges of the 21st century. He highlighted the lack of effectiveness in global governance\, attributing it to a lack of diversity and equity within key institutions. For instance\, he noted the deadlock in the United Nations Security Council and the limited capabilities of the World Bank\, which lacks the resources and military backing to address issues effectively. He added that the developing countries often find themselves disproportionately affected by these global shifts\, facing high prices for essential goods\, increasing economic disparity\, and severe impacts of climate change. \nAmb. Shringla further highlighted the evolution of India’s foreign policy over the past 20-30 years. India has transitioned from primarily responding to global initiatives to leading and devising solutions based on its own ideas and traditions. He emphasised the success of UPI under the Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) initiative\, noting that 40 percent of global digital transactions take place in India. Additionally\, India administered over 2 billion COVID-19 vaccines worldwide\, starting with its neighbours\, through both grants (Vaccine Maitri) and commercial schemes. \nThe Speaker also touched upon the importance of maintaining peace and stability in global conflicts. He highlighted India’s balanced approach\, avoiding direct involvement in wars while promoting diplomatic resolutions. He cited Prime Minister Modi’s stance on global cooperation\, underscoring the principle of “Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam” (the world is one family) as a guiding philosophy for India’s foreign policy. He discussed India’s strategic approach during the recent global conflicts and crises. According to Amb. Shringla\, India has consistently preferred a multipolar world order\, projecting itself as a pole rather than aligning with any so-called bipolar or unipolar order. He underlined that purchasing discounted Russian oil helped stabilise domestic prices and contributed to global market stability. This action demonstrated India’s ability to navigate complex international situations while adhering to sanctions and maintaining economic stability\, he added. \nWhile expressing the need to move towards renewable energy\, Amb. Shringla stated that India has the potential to meet 80% of its energy requirements through renewable sources. He underscored that this shift would benefit both the economy and environment\, positioning India as a leader in global climate mitigation efforts. He stressed the importance of voluntary and individual lifestyle changes to achieve environmental sustainability\, advocating policies that promote modest and efficient utilisation of resources. Amb. Shringla highlighted that India’s proactive foreign policy has evolved to focus on global initiatives and solutions. \nThe discussion highlighted the development challenges in West Bengal due to the contested dynamics between the TMC-led State Government and the BJP-led Central Government. Despite the central government’s intentions\, state-level politics and demographic shifts hinder effective development. This scenario emphasises the need to reconcile regional aspirations for autonomy with the central goal of fostering development. He underlined that the security situation in the Northeast remains complex\, with unresolved grievances and the influence of neighbouring countries like Myanmar and Bangladesh\, directly impacting India’s border states and complicating regional stability and development. He concluded by stating that India’s Foreign Policy must address these cross-border influences\, as the conflict in Myanmar and instability in Bangladesh have significant repercussions within India. Collaborating closely with regional authorities and considering local sentiments for autonomy and development is crucial. \nQuestions and Comments\nThe Director General\, Amb. Chinoy thanked Ambassador Shringla for his remarks. \nThe Q&A session offered an in-depth look at India’s strategic priorities\, touching on the intricacies of India-US relations\, India’s firm pursuit of its national interest\, as well as regional security and economic development. He also observed that there is a systemic imbalance at the global level\, contributing to conflicts and unrest in the Middle East\, Ukraine\, and other parts of the world. Therefore\, equilibrium is required in the international system. \nAmb. Shringla provided responses to all the questions. The session emphasised the need for pragmatic diplomacy to navigate the global landscape\, uphold India’s strategic autonomy\, and promote multipolarity. The interaction concluded with a formal Vote of Thanks to the Speaker by the Director General. \nThe Report has been prepared by Ms. Sneha M.\, Research Analyst\, South Asia Centre.
URL:https://idsa.in/idsa-event/lecture-by-ambassador-harsh-shringla-on-developmental-priorities-and-indias-neighbourhood-view-from-darjeeling
CATEGORIES:EVENT REPORT
ATTACH;FMTTYPE=image/jpeg:https://idsa.in/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/no_photo-200x150-2.jpg
END:VEVENT
END:VCALENDAR